Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform has had its day

269 replies

Grumpybutfunny · 20/01/2023 20:33

Okay I'm northern like this poor kid, tho not that close to the Scottish border. Is it unreasonable to say, when schools start saying kids should wear an inappropriate coats, just because it is school uniform that its time for parents to fight back.

I've left for work at 7:30 and it has been minus 2-3 all week. When I'm scraping ice off the car, a kid shouldn't be walking to school in a summer fleece with a rain jacket over the top. I've been freezing in my duvet coat.

Uniforms were a great leveller, but in the age of social media they still see what kids are wearing outside of school or what car the parent does the school run in. Surely what's more important is that they are comfortable and warm.

www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/jesmond-park-academys-uniform-policy-26016890

OP posts:
Patineur · 21/01/2023 23:58

CecilyP · 21/01/2023 10:35

That would be interesting about a group of parents! I can’t see ofsted taking it on or giving requires improvement if other aspects of the school are good.

They would have to if that became a concrete part of their criteria and that were allowed no discretion on the matter. Schools couldn't logically object because it would be such an easy one to comply with.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 21/01/2023 22:30

Wear not were...

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 21/01/2023 22:27

I also think kids should were padded, light coloured coats in the winter as easier to see in the dark as well as warmer. DD coat is white and is much safer.

Magenta82 · 21/01/2023 22:25

Oldsu · 21/01/2023 17:10

So if the school jacket is too cold and a £20 supermarket jacket is better why did that father put his son in a £240 one, why didn't he buy the £20 jacket if warmth is the only reason for not wearing the school one? I stand by what I say the man is a hypocrite

Kids don't wear school coats on weekends, it was cold the kid went in wearing his weekend coat.

Are you suggesting he should have bought a third coat?

Babycakes6 · 21/01/2023 22:15

I agree with you OP!
I’m European, we never wore uniforms, it’s so old school.
Also, schools here are so strict about it.
My DD was required to wear a uniform to pre-school/ nursery. One day she decided to wear a princes dress instead. There was no way of getting her into uniform that day, she chucked the biggest tantrum. I think it’s unreasonable to force it on 3-year olds!

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 18:33

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 17:34

No just the worry about some nutter going to school with a gun. I'd rather deal with school uniform 'nonsense' any day.

Me too.

I don’t mind not having it in primary, it’s working well. But Ds has it in private which is fine by me and I prefer and sixth form Ds no uniform and he does spend money on clothes - which he earns.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 18:29

@OoooohMatron or you could have what you'd get in places like Germany and the Netherlands - no uniform and also not nutjobs with guns to worry about. Amazing, isn't it?

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 17:34

mathanxiety · 21/01/2023 14:51

YANBU.

I consider myself lucky to be living in the US and no longer stuck dealing with this kind of nonsense.

Even when my DCs were in a uniform wearing primary, weather considerations came first. They wore suitable jackets in whatever colour they wanted or came in, and the DDs wore fleece pajama pants under their skirts outdoors.

In high school, teens here wear appropriate clothes for the weather. There's precious little fuss about style.

No just the worry about some nutter going to school with a gun. I'd rather deal with school uniform 'nonsense' any day.

Oldsu · 21/01/2023 17:10

Grumpybutfunny · 21/01/2023 14:26

Sorry but that doesn't make sense are you saying you can't have empathy just because you can afford a £240 coat (Xmas present maybe). I read it as the school coat is too cold for the -2 temperature and is a struggle to afford at £56 for some parents. Better costs can be cheaper, his son has a better coat it just wasn't cheaper.

So if the school jacket is too cold and a £20 supermarket jacket is better why did that father put his son in a £240 one, why didn't he buy the £20 jacket if warmth is the only reason for not wearing the school one? I stand by what I say the man is a hypocrite

mathanxiety · 21/01/2023 14:51

YANBU.

I consider myself lucky to be living in the US and no longer stuck dealing with this kind of nonsense.

Even when my DCs were in a uniform wearing primary, weather considerations came first. They wore suitable jackets in whatever colour they wanted or came in, and the DDs wore fleece pajama pants under their skirts outdoors.

In high school, teens here wear appropriate clothes for the weather. There's precious little fuss about style.

Grumpybutfunny · 21/01/2023 14:26

Oldsu · 21/01/2023 13:00

There was a different version of this story reported in other media and if its true the Father is a fucking hypocrite, in the other versions the North face jacket the boy was wearing £240 looking at their website I can well believe it yet he has the cheek to pretend he has empathy with struggling parents, why if there are parents at the school who are struggling to to even afford the school one does he send his son to school wearing a jacket they have no hope of being able to afford, and if they should be able to buy a £20 warmer jacket from a supermarket why isn't his son wearing a £20 jacket. from a supermarket instead of such an expensive one.

Sorry but that doesn't make sense are you saying you can't have empathy just because you can afford a £240 coat (Xmas present maybe). I read it as the school coat is too cold for the -2 temperature and is a struggle to afford at £56 for some parents. Better costs can be cheaper, his son has a better coat it just wasn't cheaper.

OP posts:
Changingmynameyetagain · 21/01/2023 14:22

I absolutely hate school uniforms and I have no idea why we love them so much in the UK,
Cheap polyester clothing that will end up in landfills for the next 200 years.

I also don’t get the argument that kids who can’t afford designer clothes will be bullied, My DD is 16 and she and all her friends love shopping in charity shops. And honestly kids know who’s family is poorer than them regardless of what clothes they are wearing.
When DC high school has a non uniform day most kids wear a hoodie and jeans, you get the odd one in a ridiculous outfit but most of the kids opt for comfort.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 14:11

@Blip it all ties in with the argument that 'uniform prepares you for the world of work' Hmm

Firstly, workplace dress codes are changing and becoming more relaxed.
Secondly, if you work in a uniformed environment, your employer will usually provide the uniform.
Thirdly, are British kids really so stupid compared to their peers in other countries that they need to spend 12 years learning how to dress appropriately for a given situation? I don't think they are.

DDivaStar · 21/01/2023 14:09

School uniform isn't the issue. The issue is impractical uniform and strict rules.

Blip · 21/01/2023 14:03

I'm no fan of nasty and uncomfortable polyester clothing.

Deciding what to wear in the morning is a basic life skill that kids should be learning.

Highonpower · 21/01/2023 13:39

GnomeDePlume · 21/01/2023 13:09

I think the 12 years learning to wear uniform is actually 12 years of actively learning to dress badly. To follow a set of uniform rules without considering what is appropriate. To wear ill-fitting, poor quality clothes which just need to be present to meet the uniform requirements. To not look after clothes as the only rule is that the uniform items are present.

It is no wonder that a lot of young people entering work dont know what to wear to dress appropriately. They have never had to give it any thought. I have seen so many young new starters turn up either dressed for the weekend or dressed for school.

I remember turning up at a big 4 Christmas event - back in the day when they all wore suits. The standard of casual wear was truly awful - it’s a hard thing to get right and it takes more practice than wearing a suit. It’s hard to take pride in a school uniform that looks so badly made.
At the end of lockdown - our school were still insisting the year 13 students wore business suits for the last 2 weeks they were asked to come back - no excuses were acceptable, if your child had grown out of their suit you had to buy a new one or apply to the school’s hardship fund. Hardly a good use of resources, who wants to go cap in hand to the school to say you can’t afford to buy a suit for your child to wear for 2 weeks, it was such a waste of money - such a daft approach - I’m afraid by the time my kids left school I had lost all respect for the HT and their daft rules, there must be more important things to focus on.

hennylovespens · 21/01/2023 13:13

No child should miss out on education because of their clothes, shoes or hair. It's ludicrous.

No child should be dressed inappropriately for the weather.

My uniform included a £60 blazer that you weren't allowed to forget but you also weren't allowed to wear indoors and was so thick it was really hard get a coat over.
You weren't allowed jumpers or tracksuit bottoms for PE until it was decreed cold enough but often this didn't happen until January. Although the woman who made the decision always wore thermal layers and a tracksuit.

GnomeDePlume · 21/01/2023 13:09

Highonpower · 21/01/2023 12:27

I am really against uniform. Observed teachers getting at kids for their parent's choices. It seems to bring out the control freakery in teachers. It's expensive to have to buy your child clothes for school and clothes for home and they grow so quickly. It looks really horrible - all that poorly fitting polyester, I really don't understand the need to dress our kids like poorly paid office workers - even the teachers have a slacker dress code. And don't get me started on people thinking kids need to wear uniform for 12 years so they can learn how to wear uniform to work - really 12 years to learn something like that? How on earth do the kids in Europe and America manage it - brighter perhaps?

I think the 12 years learning to wear uniform is actually 12 years of actively learning to dress badly. To follow a set of uniform rules without considering what is appropriate. To wear ill-fitting, poor quality clothes which just need to be present to meet the uniform requirements. To not look after clothes as the only rule is that the uniform items are present.

It is no wonder that a lot of young people entering work dont know what to wear to dress appropriately. They have never had to give it any thought. I have seen so many young new starters turn up either dressed for the weekend or dressed for school.

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 13:04

Blip · 21/01/2023 12:51

Most countries don't have school uniform and I wish they would scrap it in the UK. School is not a military academy.

All the arguments made for school uniform are clearly false given that other countries are managing fine without them.

Yeah because a polo shirt and sweatshirt is exactly the same as a military uniform

Oldsu · 21/01/2023 13:00

There was a different version of this story reported in other media and if its true the Father is a fucking hypocrite, in the other versions the North face jacket the boy was wearing £240 looking at their website I can well believe it yet he has the cheek to pretend he has empathy with struggling parents, why if there are parents at the school who are struggling to to even afford the school one does he send his son to school wearing a jacket they have no hope of being able to afford, and if they should be able to buy a £20 warmer jacket from a supermarket why isn't his son wearing a £20 jacket. from a supermarket instead of such an expensive one.

SpongeBob2022 · 21/01/2023 12:54

I think a practical school uniform of trousers, a polo shirt and a sweatshirt at a reasonable price is fine. I like that it takes any thinking out of it in the morning.

Anything above this is excessive and not necessary IMO. Don't even get me started on blazers....

Blip · 21/01/2023 12:51

Most countries don't have school uniform and I wish they would scrap it in the UK. School is not a military academy.

All the arguments made for school uniform are clearly false given that other countries are managing fine without them.

Highonpower · 21/01/2023 12:27

I am really against uniform. Observed teachers getting at kids for their parent's choices. It seems to bring out the control freakery in teachers. It's expensive to have to buy your child clothes for school and clothes for home and they grow so quickly. It looks really horrible - all that poorly fitting polyester, I really don't understand the need to dress our kids like poorly paid office workers - even the teachers have a slacker dress code. And don't get me started on people thinking kids need to wear uniform for 12 years so they can learn how to wear uniform to work - really 12 years to learn something like that? How on earth do the kids in Europe and America manage it - brighter perhaps?

Copasetic · 21/01/2023 12:16

I like a sensible school uniform. I'm not a fan of blazers and the wanky rules surrounding them and this school has obviously gone a step further but there is nothing wrong with a sensible school uniform.

Boomboom22 · 21/01/2023 11:56

avamiah · 20/01/2023 22:34

My daughter is year 8 secondary school and attends a school in London were they wear uniform and I agree with the uniform policy.

However she can wear any coat she wishes as long as it is black to travel to and from school and she can wear a pair of wellies if she wants and a balaclava as long as she removes it before entering the school but it must be black .😬

See as a driver and teacher I think this is really dangerous unless the black coat has bright bits that are clear in headlights. It's OK again now but from November to last week kids will be travelling in the dark at least one way, where I live there are no pavements either.