Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the controversy over Canada expanding assisted dying for mental illness?

231 replies

janef001 · 20/01/2023 19:22

I’ve been reading online and watching videos regarding Canada expanding MAID for those with incurable mental illnesses in March of this year. It’s been getting a lot of backlash.

I understand that a lot of mental illnesses can cloud someones judgement but does that really make them inherently irrational? In almost every other case, an adult with depression/bipolar/schizophrenia would be considered competent in other aspects of life when it comes to signing a contract, purchasing a home. If they were to get in trouble with the criminal justice system, they'd be seldom shown any leniency and considered as responsible as someone without mental illness.
In an ideal world, mental disorders would be properly treated so that people wouldn’t resort to dying but the public resources (therapists, psychiatrists) are not easily accessible. Many meds prescribed also take too long to work, don’t work much/at all, or have unpleasant side effects.

It seems fair to allow death in certain cases even if the mental illness might not be terminal itself.

OP posts:
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 20/01/2023 23:23

Keyansier · 20/01/2023 23:17

What or where would be the shock and shame in your own suicide compared to doing exactly the same thing but with assistance? Genuine question. The result is the same. It's not the same when someone who is physically in excruciating daily pain and feel like they can't go on any more but do not have the physical strength, muscle or capability to do so themselves.

The difference is the rational decision made in the knowledge of others and accepted by others prior to the death.

Keyansier · 20/01/2023 23:17

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 20/01/2023 22:38

I think it’s brilliant. I‘d love to tell the few people who know me that I‘ve had enough and be able to leave without the shock and shame of suicide. I‘d do it line a shot tbh.

What or where would be the shock and shame in your own suicide compared to doing exactly the same thing but with assistance? Genuine question. The result is the same. It's not the same when someone who is physically in excruciating daily pain and feel like they can't go on any more but do not have the physical strength, muscle or capability to do so themselves.

HRTQueen · 20/01/2023 22:56

His is really concerning and shocking that this may be considered for children

treatment is often intense, long, not straight forward but many very unwell people take years with medication, often changes and years of talking therapies and support with every day skills, education until their lives improve

it’s so upsetting to think that some people (poor) won’t be considered worthy

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 22:47

DaughterofBrum · 20/01/2023 21:30

Reading quite a few of the posts on here, eg Userwoozer's, confirms my opinion that its actually the people who care least about actual people and suffering, who are the most concerned to preserve life in all circumstances and talk a lot about people being 'bullied' and 'guilt-tripped' into killing themselves. I'm not quite sure why this is- probably they are afraid for themselves for some reason? Those who have made subtler points regarding the eventual misuse of euthanasia by governments keen to cut healthcare and pension bills are more on the money. The legislation is going to expand, and the best safeguards will be via specific medical end-of-life training, but there's going to be abuse, full stop. It's also abusive to decree that people should die in pain regardless of circumstances because someone else is worried about being 'bullied' into euthanasia.

I certainly do care about actual people and their suffering. I just don't believe that there is any solution to this that will work. So you then have to weigh up the small number of people who 1) are in great suffering, 2) are very unlikely to recover 3) want to die, 4) are genuinely incapable of committing suicide, 5) don't have any family member or friend willing to run the small legal risk of helping them (courts are sympathetic in those cases), and 6) can't afford the trip to Switzerland, bearing in mind that they will never need money again. And balance that number against what I suspect would be a large and ever growing number of people who will be pushed into euthanasia in the interests of others.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 20/01/2023 22:38

I think it’s brilliant. I‘d love to tell the few people who know me that I‘ve had enough and be able to leave without the shock and shame of suicide. I‘d do it line a shot tbh.

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 22:37

musingsinmidlife · 20/01/2023 21:41

Physician assisted suicide has been legal in the Netherlands since 2002. That is 20 years of data that doesn't yet support the government seeing it as a way to cull the population, cut health care spending, or to abuse it for their own purposes.

How much confidence do you have in the current UK government? They weren't overly concerned about the impact of sending elderly people with Covid back into care homes, were they? How many died because of that?

MyGrandmaLizzie · 20/01/2023 22:10

Keyansier · 20/01/2023 19:42

Do you know, the more I hear about Canada (which I originally thought seemed like a great country), it seems like its main mission these days is Not Like America. Similar to Scotland's main mission of Not Like England.

This^^

underneaththeash · 20/01/2023 22:10

We’ll because it’s not terminal.

Workerbeep · 20/01/2023 21:49

@musingsinmidlife it has increased significantly though

‘until 2010 only a few cases were reported yearly. However, since 2011 there has been a remarkable increase, with 115 cases being recorded in 2021 - the most recent year for which figures are available (2).’

NooNooHead1981 · 20/01/2023 21:49

Ironically I have become a lot more negative and mentally unwell after being given psychotropic drugs to help with a severe breakdown after a head injury and post concussion syndrome.

The antipsychotic drug that was prescribed off label for severe anxiety and insomnia during this time gave me a permanent and untreatable neurological involuntary movement disorder called tardive dyskinesia that is horrible, and includes involuntary movements of my face, tongue, and most other body parts. Consequently having to live with this for the next 40 odd years doesn't fill me with much joy, surprisingly.

I would consider MAID if it was available. I know of several other people with these iatrogenic injuries like mine in Facebook support groups that have ended their lives in places like Switzerland, and the level of suffering mentally that accompanies these horrendous conditions means that people see assisted dying as their own control over a body that has been robbed of having control over by the medication designed to help them mentally.

I'm allowing these people their wishes to die if they wish to. If I didn't have children, I might be serious enough to think about it. Look up videos on YouTube about the movement disorders called akathisia, tardive dyskinesia, and tardive dystonia and I think you'll agree with me.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/01/2023 21:46

musingsinmidlife · 20/01/2023 21:41

Physician assisted suicide has been legal in the Netherlands since 2002. That is 20 years of data that doesn't yet support the government seeing it as a way to cull the population, cut health care spending, or to abuse it for their own purposes.

Compare access to MH services in Holland and Canada and you will soon see the issue. Plus Canada has a gaping wound of First Nations MH and trauma which must be addressed.

There is already a huge suicide epidemic going on.

JackieDaws · 20/01/2023 21:41

DaughterofBrum · 20/01/2023 21:30

Reading quite a few of the posts on here, eg Userwoozer's, confirms my opinion that its actually the people who care least about actual people and suffering, who are the most concerned to preserve life in all circumstances and talk a lot about people being 'bullied' and 'guilt-tripped' into killing themselves. I'm not quite sure why this is- probably they are afraid for themselves for some reason? Those who have made subtler points regarding the eventual misuse of euthanasia by governments keen to cut healthcare and pension bills are more on the money. The legislation is going to expand, and the best safeguards will be via specific medical end-of-life training, but there's going to be abuse, full stop. It's also abusive to decree that people should die in pain regardless of circumstances because someone else is worried about being 'bullied' into euthanasia.

Get back to us when your children and grandchildren are pressuring you to choose euthanasia quickly so they can get their hands on your property.

musingsinmidlife · 20/01/2023 21:41

Physician assisted suicide has been legal in the Netherlands since 2002. That is 20 years of data that doesn't yet support the government seeing it as a way to cull the population, cut health care spending, or to abuse it for their own purposes.

XenoBitch · 20/01/2023 21:37

x2boys · 20/01/2023 21:31

I don't disagree atall for people like your self ,who.are i n sound mind i have seen so many people destroyed by mental illness
I
I dI worry however for some peop!e whose illnesses fluctuate and many people's do n
How can we be certain they actually want to do this ?

it really does need to.be case by casev

Exactly. A lot of MH fluctuates. I have a lovely friend with bipolar, who even in her darkest times knows that she will eventually come out of it. But then there are those who feel like it will never end, even though it does.
Is why medical history needs to be taken. It is not a case of feeling down and having assisted suicide. At least, I would hope not.

x2boys · 20/01/2023 21:31

Jomummy1013 · 20/01/2023 20:07

@x2boys thank you for replying to my comment. Yes I agree it would have to be on a case by case basis, and not a decision to be taken lightly. Mental illness has been absolute torture for me, and has taken so much of my life away already. For me it's not about living in the here and now with these disorders, it's the prospect of living through this agony for the rest of my life. It's been such a long long time. I can't escape it. It's always there and even if I get to a better place it will always engulf me again. I am getting support and help but I have to say my heart lifted when I saw the title of this post, even though I don't live in Canada! I agree with assisted euthanasia for people who are severely unwell with other, physical illnesses as well. Why shouldn't we have this choice. X

I don't disagree atall for people like your self ,who.are i n sound mind i have seen so many people destroyed by mental illness
I
I dI worry however for some peop!e whose illnesses fluctuate and many people's do n
How can we be certain they actually want to do this ?

it really does need to.be case by casev

SomethingLikeThisNow · 20/01/2023 21:30

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 21:07

If this is brought in for terminally ill people, then the population will get used to the idea. The scheme will then be extended. And extended.

This.
And then it's one of a variety of options.
And vulnerable people will be 'helped' to 'choose' this option. Kind of like people could be pressured to include someone in their wills.

It could help some people but it will definitely have people dying who otherwise could live happy but inconvenient lives.

DaughterofBrum · 20/01/2023 21:30

Reading quite a few of the posts on here, eg Userwoozer's, confirms my opinion that its actually the people who care least about actual people and suffering, who are the most concerned to preserve life in all circumstances and talk a lot about people being 'bullied' and 'guilt-tripped' into killing themselves. I'm not quite sure why this is- probably they are afraid for themselves for some reason? Those who have made subtler points regarding the eventual misuse of euthanasia by governments keen to cut healthcare and pension bills are more on the money. The legislation is going to expand, and the best safeguards will be via specific medical end-of-life training, but there's going to be abuse, full stop. It's also abusive to decree that people should die in pain regardless of circumstances because someone else is worried about being 'bullied' into euthanasia.

Workerbeep · 20/01/2023 21:25

some may find this an interesting article concerning PAD for psychiatric disorders in The Netherlands.I haven’t read it all.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9251055/

DaughterofBrum · 20/01/2023 21:25

Userwoozer, that is probably because different people- even (gasp) different mentally ill people- have different opinions.

Thanks for refusing to spell out to me how to kill myself efficiently, btw. Pmsl. Doing that to someone who's already tried and failed several times just to prove a point is a really special kind of [wo]mansplaining.

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 21:24

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 21:22

This is completely contrary to what we've been told by another poster who has experience of attempting suicide and feels strongly that assisted dying would be a much easier option.

Sorry, that was in response to musinginmidlife.
There's a little bit of research here:
post.parliament.uk/research-briefings/post-pb-0047/#

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 21:22

This is completely contrary to what we've been told by another poster who has experience of attempting suicide and feels strongly that assisted dying would be a much easier option.

DaughterofBrum · 20/01/2023 21:22

I would put money on First Nations peoples being overrepresented. Social deprivation and exclusion are huge reasons for long term untreatable mental illness. As we all surely know by now, children born into socially excluded and deprived populations are far more vulnerable to abuse and neglect, and abuse and neglect are THE fundamental reasons for long-term untreatable mental suffering. And then of course it becomes a cost saving measure to allow those who are suffering the most an easy opt-out. I absolutely agree that the last bit is vile if it is a calculated attempt to cut Canadian benefit and healthcare bills, which it probably is.

Women will be overrepresented too as they suffer depression at twice the rate of men, but we can hardly expect that to improve in the future. It is great that people still want to try though (I'm too ill now but used to be a feminist firebrand when I had the energy).

musingsinmidlife · 20/01/2023 21:20

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 21:16

People can be bullied and pressurised and guilt tripped.

If they feel bullied, pressured or guilt tripped into dying, then suicide would be a much easier option. There is a lot of time and assessments and paperwork involved with MAiD. If your family / others want you dead and you agree - I doubt many would go through the MAiD process, they would just off themselves.

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 21:16

musingsinmidlife · 20/01/2023 21:15

So far almost everyone who has died of MAiD has been very close to death already, so it isn't saving much. In July the report on 2022 will be released so that will be another year of data to consider.

And only the person can initiate the process - this can't be done to someone.

People can be bullied and pressurised and guilt tripped.

Workerbeep · 20/01/2023 21:16

The Netherlands have had PAD (physician aided death) for those with psychiatric suffering since the 1990s. There must be information and data. Is it similar to Canada?

i don’t know enough about this to have an opinion yet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread