Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the controversy over Canada expanding assisted dying for mental illness?

231 replies

janef001 · 20/01/2023 19:22

I’ve been reading online and watching videos regarding Canada expanding MAID for those with incurable mental illnesses in March of this year. It’s been getting a lot of backlash.

I understand that a lot of mental illnesses can cloud someones judgement but does that really make them inherently irrational? In almost every other case, an adult with depression/bipolar/schizophrenia would be considered competent in other aspects of life when it comes to signing a contract, purchasing a home. If they were to get in trouble with the criminal justice system, they'd be seldom shown any leniency and considered as responsible as someone without mental illness.
In an ideal world, mental disorders would be properly treated so that people wouldn’t resort to dying but the public resources (therapists, psychiatrists) are not easily accessible. Many meds prescribed also take too long to work, don’t work much/at all, or have unpleasant side effects.

It seems fair to allow death in certain cases even if the mental illness might not be terminal itself.

OP posts:
QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 21/01/2023 10:41

No, this is morally reprehensible. We should have the infrastructure in 2023 to be able to sufficiently treat mental health issues and have the moral duty to support those that suffer.

For context, I suffered from severe mental health issues from young childhood into my 30s, I thought that was just life and constantly thought of suicide. I managed to pay for trauma therapy a few years ago and it changed my life, I am happy and thriving now. Would I have considered assisted dying in my 20s when I was at my lowest, absolutely, would it have been a good choice knowing that I am living an exceptionally happy life, no.

Are we all happy when someone dies by suicide? No, we are all horrified that they have been let down by society and the system. Why should state suicide be any different? It just gives an excuse to not help and support those who need it.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 21/01/2023 09:34

dollymixtured · 21/01/2023 09:24

Of course it should be available. Anyone should have the right to end their life in a dignified way at any point. It is the ultimate in bodily autonomy. The arrogance of anyone thinking that they are a better judge of the situation than the individual themselves is breathtaking. Many people object with the idea of impinging on women’s bodily air when it comes to abortion but are quick to remove the option of a dignified death. Death is not some enormous unknown it is the one absolute certainty for all of us.

100%

I want to be able to say „It’s been a blast folks but I want to get off now, not enjoying this any more“ and be able to get assistance to leave with dignity and prepared support for those who survive me. A process to make opting out viable. None of us opted in, at least let us opt out if life isn’t for us.

dollymixtured · 21/01/2023 09:24

Of course it should be available. Anyone should have the right to end their life in a dignified way at any point. It is the ultimate in bodily autonomy. The arrogance of anyone thinking that they are a better judge of the situation than the individual themselves is breathtaking. Many people object with the idea of impinging on women’s bodily air when it comes to abortion but are quick to remove the option of a dignified death. Death is not some enormous unknown it is the one absolute certainty for all of us.

musingsinmidlife · 21/01/2023 09:16

clairelouwho · 21/01/2023 08:21

It's quite hard to put into words how abhorrent and morally reprehensible MAID is so I'm going to illustrate it with a case that I've heard of recently.

A man in his 50s, chronically disabled with back issues but not terminal, applies to go on the MAID program. He's about to be made homeless due to extreme poverty. His doctor signs him off for the MAID program.The media in Canada gets a whiff of the story and publicises it. A fundraiser is set up and somewhere in the region of $60,000 is raised to help get this man back on his feet. The man on the program who only needed one more signature by the way-comes off it as his actual problem has been aided with help and support that he actually needed.

For all that claim that the checks are robust, impenetrable, are you sure? How did this man slip through the net then? Had he had one more signature, we might be looking at a completely different and tragic outcome. There was a similar case where the outcome was not positive at all.

This is what short-term compassion looks like and why rules and laws should never be based on compassion. For anyone that will say that I don't care about people suffering with terminal illnesses-I do-but we know from doctors and the hospice care field-that pain can be effectively managed. There's a reason why one of the leading hospice care associations in Canada are strongly and vocally opposed to MAID in all of its forms.

You best believe that this is a system ripe for abuse. Objectors to MAID and other forms of assisted suicide have warned how opening the door to it in any form-for cases of terminal illness-will naturally lead to people who are mentally ill wanting it and being allowed it and case in point-here it is. There's your slippery slope. They've plummeted down it at an alarmingly rate of speed.

There will be people who have been bullied and coerced by relatives and other "loved" ones into doing this as they're perceived to be a "burden." It may be dressed up as "Look at this wonderful, kind, compassionate solution to all of your issues," but it's still coercion. For all the will in the world, no doctor or human being will ever be able to weed out those who have been bullied and coerced.

Why are people so happy and willing to see life as something that's disposable? TLDR: I'm opposed to it in all of its forms.

Health care professionals represent a wide range of personal and professional views on death. So it is possible there are health care professionals who feel anyone should be allowed to die at any time and they would be prepared to risk their licenses and professions to not follow MAiD protocols and to sign off on people who don't meet critieria. There are always a small number of humans, even in helping professions, who don't follow the ethics of Do No Harm. The chances of finding two independent practitioners prepared to sign off for someone who doesn't meet eligibility would be very rare.

However you can't believe everything you read in the papers. This is a political and tense issue in Canada and there have been some activitist both inventing, embellishing and misrepresenting stories to try to make their cases and points. The start date for the inclusion of mental health has been postponed due to ongoing concerns by health care professionals about what their responsibilities would be. There have been a few reports trying to clarify this but none yet to the satisfaction of the physicians / psychiatrists / nurse practitioners who would be involved. For a non foreseeable a death, one of the assessments and sign offs has to come from someone with expertise in that specific condition (psychiatry) and to date psychiatrists as a group are pretty resistant to taking responsibility to assess and determine eligiblity of what constitutes greivious and irremdiable, what consitents the required decline, and what constitutes offering of services and consulations with those services. Based on this criteria - a lack of access or resource makes one ineligble unless the resource doesn't exist (versus being difficult to access to long waits or lack of practitioners). The next report is coming out in February.

To date most of the health care professionals involved have been palliative care professionals who are comfortable with their role in assessing and providing comfort measures or MAiD to a dying population. The inclusion of those with non forseeable deaths was not meant to originally be part of the legislation but was eventually legislated after a court order to do so. So far, that has been a minimally accessed route - and primarily for neurological disorders like Huntington's and Parkinson's. To expand this beyond palliative care is of great concern to many health care professionals as well who have responsibility in various ways within the legislation. Even for those who support MAiD, ensuring a process that supports the intended goals is critical.

Cherry35 · 21/01/2023 08:25

It's very immoral. With some mental health diseases there's a very fine line when someone is well and unwell. Meaning someone is very unwell, may look well to others even doctors and may take the decision to use Assisted Dying when they just needed a different therapy or more time in treatment. When people are in a depression or manic cycle they really can't take conscious decisions but others who don't know them (even doctors) may not realize it.

Only best friends, partners would recognize this type of behavior.

clairelouwho · 21/01/2023 08:21

It's quite hard to put into words how abhorrent and morally reprehensible MAID is so I'm going to illustrate it with a case that I've heard of recently.

A man in his 50s, chronically disabled with back issues but not terminal, applies to go on the MAID program. He's about to be made homeless due to extreme poverty. His doctor signs him off for the MAID program.The media in Canada gets a whiff of the story and publicises it. A fundraiser is set up and somewhere in the region of $60,000 is raised to help get this man back on his feet. The man on the program who only needed one more signature by the way-comes off it as his actual problem has been aided with help and support that he actually needed.

For all that claim that the checks are robust, impenetrable, are you sure? How did this man slip through the net then? Had he had one more signature, we might be looking at a completely different and tragic outcome. There was a similar case where the outcome was not positive at all.

This is what short-term compassion looks like and why rules and laws should never be based on compassion. For anyone that will say that I don't care about people suffering with terminal illnesses-I do-but we know from doctors and the hospice care field-that pain can be effectively managed. There's a reason why one of the leading hospice care associations in Canada are strongly and vocally opposed to MAID in all of its forms.

You best believe that this is a system ripe for abuse. Objectors to MAID and other forms of assisted suicide have warned how opening the door to it in any form-for cases of terminal illness-will naturally lead to people who are mentally ill wanting it and being allowed it and case in point-here it is. There's your slippery slope. They've plummeted down it at an alarmingly rate of speed.

There will be people who have been bullied and coerced by relatives and other "loved" ones into doing this as they're perceived to be a "burden." It may be dressed up as "Look at this wonderful, kind, compassionate solution to all of your issues," but it's still coercion. For all the will in the world, no doctor or human being will ever be able to weed out those who have been bullied and coerced.

Why are people so happy and willing to see life as something that's disposable? TLDR: I'm opposed to it in all of its forms.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 21/01/2023 07:48

The thing is, mental illness can fluctuate. I myself have severe OCD since i was 5, depression and PTSD from my mid-late teens.
10 years ago i was desperate to die, like a zombie in a world of never ending pain, i couldn't function, needed a full time carer. All i thought about was suicide how much i wished i was dead, i was crying in pure dispair, physical and mental pain almost 24/7. I would have jumped at the chance of medically assisted suicide where i wouldn't suffer or "fail" the attempt and be left with even more illness.Those bad patches can last weeks, months, sadly even years at a time, but you do get better periods too. I still need a carer, i still have physical disability, i have the same OCD and PTSD triggers, and still cannot work. BUT, i am content/happy with the good parts of my life, and i absolutely do NOT want to die! I am picturing the best future i've ever felt possible, and the thought of medically assisted suicide for myself right now horrifies me. I am very aware i could spiral back to the point i was at 10 years ago at any time, and its terrifying, but i don't think it should be anything other than an absolute last resort.

We need actual, functional, mental health support, intensive treatments and specialist inpatient centres with 24/7 care and support. Reasearch into better drug therapy regimens etc. I've been in the mental health system for almost 20 years now, and it has always been as shockingly underfunded and understaffed with months/years long wait lists, as the current NHS crisis for physical illness/dentistry etc. It's an area of healthcare thats been chronically failing patients which leaves them desperate enough to see assisted suicide as a vaild "treatment" option.

Goatinthegarden · 21/01/2023 07:04

Oh gosh, this is such a contentious issue. It is a huge concern that people who don’t have capacity could be coerced, or allowed, to make an irreversible decision.

However, I very desperately hope that euthanasia will be an option for me should I ever be in a position that I might need it. I’m a fit and healthy person in my thirties. I love life and have never had a suicidal thought…but I seriously fear ending up in a position where I didn’t have a choice to end my life peacefully and with dignity. I have watched several loved ones die over a prolonged period of time; some in pain and some in confusion or distress.

I’d happily create a legal document now, whilst I’m fit and well and of sound mind, to authorise euthanasia to be performed on me should I lose capacity to make such a decision. Surely we all deserve autonomy over our own lives, even if it’s a decision that makes others uncomfortable?

Weddi · 21/01/2023 06:58

I meant sound mind not mound, obviously. Tired.

Weddi · 21/01/2023 06:57

I hadn’t heard about this and I personally find it disturbing. I don’t think anyone suffering with a mental illness is of ‘sound mound’, that’s oxymoronic. If you are mentally ill, being suicidal may be part of the illness but it doesn’t mean that is something you should follow through with. You’re sick but not beyond saving.

Suicide is a permanent ‘cure’ for a temporary illness. Sure, some mental illnesses are lifelong but manageable with the right care. It goes beyond therapy and medication, you do have to implement self help sometimes too. I don’t think suicide is ever the solution in this instance.

TootHole · 21/01/2023 06:13

Keyansier · 20/01/2023 23:36

Suicide is suicide is suicide. Whether "signed off" or not. The result is the same. IMO.

It's not the same, at all.

Imagine spending your childhood through to adulthood, knowing your Dad was going to kill himself. Imagine living a life of apprehension everytime he was late from work, or when he took off during the really bad times, all that while, thinking, is this the time? Is this the day the police are knocking to tell me, he's been successful this time and they've found his body?

It would have been completely different for my family and I. Dad would have had a dignified death, and my life before and after, would have been a lot better to manage.

TootHole · 21/01/2023 06:06

If people want to do it, they will often find a way so it isn't really necessary to assist them.
Not necessary to help them? Why not? Because they've made the decision to end their life, that they don't deserve a more dignified way to go?

Like my Dad who had to suffocate to death on exhaust fumes? Or the countless people my husband has had to retrieve what's left of their bodies, after they've jumped in front of a train?

Why shouldn't people have assistance, after a thorough assessment?

People dying by suicide is a horrific way to go, and if you have never found a body after an act like that, that's a massive trauma to an innocent person.

Insaneinthemembraneee · 21/01/2023 04:32

Place marking.
😬

JudgeRinderonTinder · 21/01/2023 04:22

I don’t agree with it in the main but to be honest some people are so traumatised that they unfortunately cannot be helped, try as you might, and sometimes, for their sake and their quality of life, the liberation of death might be a good thing.

I suffer with depressive episodes that come and go and it’s so tiring fighting it until it passes. It’s SO tiring. People say to me, ‘’it’ll pass hang on’’ and it does and I get a few weeks/ months of feeling ok and happy enough. However, it’s no way to live, just waiting for a period when you feel okay/happy because being miserable keeps coming back and it’s exhausting.

I don’t think I could bring myself to do assisted suicide, but at the same time I don’t care about death, the thought of dying in an accident doesn’t scare me at all, even now, when I’m not feeling too bad because I know that darkness will come back and I’ll have to fight again! Not everyone lacks capacity when mentally Ill.

Judgyjudgy · 21/01/2023 01:07

Keyansier · 20/01/2023 19:26

I haven't heard about this but I'm learning to sit on my fingers until I know more about things rather than leaving comments straight away. Are you saying that in Canada, if someone says they are depressed and want to die, they may be able to get help with assisted suicide? If that's the case, that doesn't initially sit right with me. At all.

I think this in my heart, mainly because of suicide survivors who then go onto be happy.
If people want to do it, they will often find a way so it isn't really necessary to assist them.
😔

Notcontent · 21/01/2023 01:02

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 21:07

If this is brought in for terminally ill people, then the population will get used to the idea. The scheme will then be extended. And extended.

This is my concern. How we perceive things changes over time. Smoking is a good example - only a few decades ago smoked in offices, classrooms etc. That seemed very normal but now seems crazy. I can easily see a future where people who have addiction issues, are homeless, etc are offered this as the ultimate solution…

hadntbeen · 21/01/2023 00:05

I do think though that mental illness is an incredibly painful and scary thing to experience - never mind living with day in, day out and dare I say, I would rather be physically ill than mentally. I have had a few acute mental health crises during my life and they have honestly been horrific and will stay with me forever. I never forget the feeling of low I felt, and each time it takes me months to recover. I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. So yes, I think that people should be able to end their life when confronted with that however they must ensure that that person has capacity to make that decision.

hadntbeen · 21/01/2023 00:00

I don't know enough about this to comment yet but my dad has bipolar disorder. I know that he would quite happily choose to die when he is in his low mood (has tried many times) so I know if this was an option available to him he would take it when depressed. However, when he is manic, there is no way he would agree to that as life is (his perception) great and wonderful and he's energetic and happy.

So I think a person considering this would need extensive, intensive therapy and would have to be completely mentally stable for a period of time. I believe we all have the right to end our life when we choose, for whichever reason. But we need also be protected from doing things that we may not actually want to do but rather the illness is making us feel like we do.

Goodness for someone with no opinion on this I sure had a lot to say

BigGreen · 20/01/2023 23:57

I can't see how it's possible for the state to truly establish informed consent - too hard to know if someone is having an acute episode of their illness, if they're suffering social pressure.

DisenchantedOwl · 20/01/2023 23:56

As someone who has suffered from mental ill health almost my entire life OP I completely agree. Poor and unmanageable/untreatable mental health is an awful state to leave someone in and a person should be able to decide when enough is enough and have a dignified way out. As you say, poor mental health does not necessarily mean you lack capacity to make decisions.

I don't think that it should be presented as an option as an alternative to accessing appropriate treatment though.

9outof10cats · 20/01/2023 23:49

I think this solution should be the absolute last choice only if someone has a proven long history of mental illness and has exhausted all available treatments/therapies.

It should be up to the individual to decide whether their life is worth living, not casual bystanders who have never walked in their shoes. I speak as someone who has suffered mental illness their whole life.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 20/01/2023 23:37

Disagree. Prescribed opiates for pain vs illegal heroin for pleasure. One is sanctioned by society, the other is a taboo and source of shame.

Keyansier · 20/01/2023 23:36

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 20/01/2023 23:23

The difference is the rational decision made in the knowledge of others and accepted by others prior to the death.

Suicide is suicide is suicide. Whether "signed off" or not. The result is the same. IMO.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 20/01/2023 23:34

www.tiktok.com/@drjesstaylor/video/7166980634919980293