Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the controversy over Canada expanding assisted dying for mental illness?

231 replies

janef001 · 20/01/2023 19:22

I’ve been reading online and watching videos regarding Canada expanding MAID for those with incurable mental illnesses in March of this year. It’s been getting a lot of backlash.

I understand that a lot of mental illnesses can cloud someones judgement but does that really make them inherently irrational? In almost every other case, an adult with depression/bipolar/schizophrenia would be considered competent in other aspects of life when it comes to signing a contract, purchasing a home. If they were to get in trouble with the criminal justice system, they'd be seldom shown any leniency and considered as responsible as someone without mental illness.
In an ideal world, mental disorders would be properly treated so that people wouldn’t resort to dying but the public resources (therapists, psychiatrists) are not easily accessible. Many meds prescribed also take too long to work, don’t work much/at all, or have unpleasant side effects.

It seems fair to allow death in certain cases even if the mental illness might not be terminal itself.

OP posts:
erehj · 21/01/2023 12:31

Do you think what was done to that woman was OK?

Thelnebriati · 21/01/2023 12:30

If you've been researching MAIDS online, how have you never come across the problem cases? I am generally in favour of elective euthanasia, but the way MAIDS is being offered should concern anyone interested in human rights. there are some terrible cases from Canada, disabled people asking for help with medical issues or gadgets to assist living, and being offered MAIDS instead.

dollymixtured · 21/01/2023 12:28

erehj · 21/01/2023 12:23

I’d happily create a legal document now, whilst I’m fit and well and of sound mind, to authorise euthanasia to be performed on me should I lose capacity to make such a decision.

What if, when the doctors decided the time was right, you had actually changed your mind. Your life was fine for you, and you wanted to live? Would you want your family to hold you down and the doctor to inject you with lethal drugs whilst you were screaming and resisting and begging not to be killed? Because that's what happens in the Netherlands.

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/doctor-netherlands-lethal-injection-dementia-euthanasia-a7564061.html?amp

That article does not remotely say what you have posted. I also have to assume you have no knowledge or experience of working with patients with dementia..

dollymixtured · 21/01/2023 12:26

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:37

@dollymixtured

There is currently no way to guarantee a pain free death, even with many years of experimenting on unfortunate humans in other countries.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9270985/

That doesn’t mean for a moment it is beyond the wit of man to develop one.

erehj · 21/01/2023 12:23

I’d happily create a legal document now, whilst I’m fit and well and of sound mind, to authorise euthanasia to be performed on me should I lose capacity to make such a decision.

What if, when the doctors decided the time was right, you had actually changed your mind. Your life was fine for you, and you wanted to live? Would you want your family to hold you down and the doctor to inject you with lethal drugs whilst you were screaming and resisting and begging not to be killed? Because that's what happens in the Netherlands.

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/doctor-netherlands-lethal-injection-dementia-euthanasia-a7564061.html?amp

hadntbeen · 21/01/2023 12:12

Goatinthegarden · 21/01/2023 07:04

Oh gosh, this is such a contentious issue. It is a huge concern that people who don’t have capacity could be coerced, or allowed, to make an irreversible decision.

However, I very desperately hope that euthanasia will be an option for me should I ever be in a position that I might need it. I’m a fit and healthy person in my thirties. I love life and have never had a suicidal thought…but I seriously fear ending up in a position where I didn’t have a choice to end my life peacefully and with dignity. I have watched several loved ones die over a prolonged period of time; some in pain and some in confusion or distress.

I’d happily create a legal document now, whilst I’m fit and well and of sound mind, to authorise euthanasia to be performed on me should I lose capacity to make such a decision. Surely we all deserve autonomy over our own lives, even if it’s a decision that makes others uncomfortable?

Same

SleepingStandingUp · 21/01/2023 12:05

Ops argument seems to be "MH care is shot so its fine to help people kill themselves"

Imagine if this were cancer.

"Mr Smith you have cancer, its difficult to access care and its an expense we'd like to reduce frankly. Instead of petitioning for better treatment and survival, we'd instead like to offer you euthanasia. Think how much effort you'd be saving people"

WeepingSomnambulist · 21/01/2023 11:59

This already happens

www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/stories-45117163.amp

There are other cases as well. A recent one was a very young woman with PTSD.

Whosedogisitanyway · 21/01/2023 11:58

Workerbeep · 20/01/2023 21:16

The Netherlands have had PAD (physician aided death) for those with psychiatric suffering since the 1990s. There must be information and data. Is it similar to Canada?

i don’t know enough about this to have an opinion yet.

It is and I don't know why this keeps being ignored in this thread. This is and has been allowed in more than one European country for ages. You cannot just go to the doctor with a bout of depression and ask for some suicide pills.

I know I'm in the minority on here, but I'm in favour of assisted suicide and I have a positive experience with seeing a family member go through it. They were not a psychiatric patient, but they were not terminal. It was the best thing for them and a peaceful ending for everyone involved. I'm glad it was an option.

EwwSprouts · 21/01/2023 11:57

It's a big fat no from me. If people were 100% committed to end of life in these cases they would commit suicide. And we fight to stop people doing that because the majority with treatment can have a better life.

Read this and see how it has proliferated from being for those who are staring death in the face such as MND sufferers.
www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/no-other-options

Drivingmisspotty · 21/01/2023 11:55

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:37

@dollymixtured

There is currently no way to guarantee a pain free death, even with many years of experimenting on unfortunate humans in other countries.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9270985/

Thank you for sharing this. I have thought about the morals of assisted dying but had always pictured the actual death as peaceful and a gentle drifting off. It’s important to have this info.

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:54

The full ‘cocktail’ included two anti-nausea pills, an anti-seizure pill and 100 capsules of Secobarbital. It all had to be ingested within an hour... My attention turned to the kitchen table, where my husband and sister, wearing latex gloves, frantically scraped the powder from 100 capsules with toothpicks, trying to beat the clock... The mountain of powder we poured into more sugar syrup created a half-cup of sludge so bitter it literally burned my tongue. And my aunt, who could barely swallow water, had to drink all of it in <5 min to ‘ensure success.’... When we sat back down at the kitchen table, white powder everywhere, we all had to wonder, ‘Who the hell wrote this law?’ We had been forced to assist in the most bizarre fashion, jumping through seemingly random legal hoops and meeting arbitrary deadlines while my aunt suffered, and finally emptying capsules, making an elixir so vile I cried when I knew she had to drink it. This was death with dignity?

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:48

Drugs used for medical purposes are required to undergo a stringent approval process in order to assess efficacy and safety. But the drugs being used for ‘assisted dying’ have not undergone such process; the safety and effectiveness of previous and current combinations of lethal drugs is largely unknown. Canada’s MAiD protocol concedes this.

Darkdiamond · 21/01/2023 11:46

Yuck.

musingsinmidlife · 21/01/2023 11:43

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:37

@dollymixtured

There is currently no way to guarantee a pain free death, even with many years of experimenting on unfortunate humans in other countries.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9270985/

That is an interesting article and speaks to issues when the person is self administering without a health care professional though the oral route (swallowing pills or powders). It seems there should be clear guidelines for what medications to use. In one example the person had to swallow 100 pills and in the other, the person who had difficulty swallowing had to drink a large amount of fluid. These seem like oversights in the process.

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:37

@dollymixtured

There is currently no way to guarantee a pain free death, even with many years of experimenting on unfortunate humans in other countries.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9270985/

MolkosTeenageAngst · 21/01/2023 11:37

If someone is suffering they should be allowed to die. I have mental health issues and have attempted suicide in the past, obviously unsuccessfully. I’m not actively suicidal anymore but my life is pretty miserable without much joy, my life is pretty pointless and I don’t believe anybody would really miss me if I was gone. I don’t see why anybody should have to keep living beyond a point which they want to. One of the things that scares me most about attempting suicide again is that no method is 100% successful and that there is always the risk of ending up with a life changing injury and being reliant on care from others, if there was an option to end it legally and in a way which was guaranteed and where families didn’t feel the shame or guilt that, is often attached to suicide that would definitely bring me some relief and make the option of ending things feel more achievable. Why should anybody have to live in misery? My life doesn’t mean anything to anybody outside of myself, so why should the views of others stop me from being able to terminate it?

musingsinmidlife · 21/01/2023 11:30

The Canadian Association of MAiD Assessors and Providers recommends fixed dosing of midazolam (an anxiolytic), 10 mg; propofol (an anesthetic coma-inducing agent), 1000 mg; and rocuronium, 200 mg, or cisatracurium, 40 mg (neuromuscular blockers to stop respiration).

musingsinmidlife · 21/01/2023 11:28

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:22

Assisted suicide isn't necessarily pain- free or easy. There's evidence that it can be a horrendous and distressing way to die, with sensations of burning alive, vomiting, taking weeks to die.

What? Weeks to die? I don't think so - what is your evidence for this with MAiD?

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:28

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11322105/amp/How-assisted-suicide-23-year-old-woman-created-national-scandal-Belgium.html

A 23 year old woman in Belgium killed by doctors instead of being treated properly for PTSD.

If you do not want this to happen in the UK, then you must never allow any kind of euthanasia.

dollymixtured · 21/01/2023 11:24

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:22

Assisted suicide isn't necessarily pain- free or easy. There's evidence that it can be a horrendous and distressing way to die, with sensations of burning alive, vomiting, taking weeks to die.

Seriously do you think that it’s beyond science to find a painless way for people to end their lives?

erehj · 21/01/2023 11:22

Assisted suicide isn't necessarily pain- free or easy. There's evidence that it can be a horrendous and distressing way to die, with sensations of burning alive, vomiting, taking weeks to die.

musingsinmidlife · 21/01/2023 10:56

SlinkySienna · 21/01/2023 10:51

I think it's incredible that they'd sooner kill someone with a mental illness than fast track research into other therapies such as psychedelic therapies which are highly effective.

Canada has been advancing research on psychedelics and they can be accessed in 3 ways.

Clinical trials
Special Access Program
Individual subsection 56(1) exemptions from the CDSA

And no one is killing anyone else. That line just echoes around the echo chamber.

SlinkySienna · 21/01/2023 10:51

I think it's incredible that they'd sooner kill someone with a mental illness than fast track research into other therapies such as psychedelic therapies which are highly effective.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 21/01/2023 10:45

Saying all that, I'm not in opposition to assisted dying in terminal cases but I am not sure how to safeguard against possible abuse. We should allow dignified death but if that leads to governments and society being able to offer a way out rather than invest in making society a better place then no, I dont agree with it.