Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the controversy over Canada expanding assisted dying for mental illness?

231 replies

janef001 · 20/01/2023 19:22

I’ve been reading online and watching videos regarding Canada expanding MAID for those with incurable mental illnesses in March of this year. It’s been getting a lot of backlash.

I understand that a lot of mental illnesses can cloud someones judgement but does that really make them inherently irrational? In almost every other case, an adult with depression/bipolar/schizophrenia would be considered competent in other aspects of life when it comes to signing a contract, purchasing a home. If they were to get in trouble with the criminal justice system, they'd be seldom shown any leniency and considered as responsible as someone without mental illness.
In an ideal world, mental disorders would be properly treated so that people wouldn’t resort to dying but the public resources (therapists, psychiatrists) are not easily accessible. Many meds prescribed also take too long to work, don’t work much/at all, or have unpleasant side effects.

It seems fair to allow death in certain cases even if the mental illness might not be terminal itself.

OP posts:
SouperNoodle · 22/01/2023 20:18

TW - suicide and mental illness

In my personal opinion, I think it's a good idea.

I suffered severely with mental illnesses for many years and had to be cared for. I had weekly support workers, doctors visits, psychiatrists and psychologists.
I was on 24/7 suicide watch and was barely able to function as a person without help.
Thankfully I received significant help and was heavily sedated and medicated as my parents didn't want me sectioned.

I'm now mostly recovered and live a good life but it doesn't always work out that way for everyone. Had I not recovered, I 100% would've commit suic*de so humane euthanasia would've been a dream.
I could not have carried on that way for years.

Just because it's mental and not physical doesn't mean people should just have to suffer.

Felix01 · 22/01/2023 20:09

DrBlackbird · 22/01/2023 19:44

Agreed that it’d be a living hell to be bed bound with dysphagia, wasting and pain. Surely at that stage, most people with dementia would also be unable to even be asked a question, let alone answer it pretty coherently. However the wasting bed bound stage didn’t sound like it was the stage of the Dutch woman when she was euthanised.

There’s a lot of fear about getting dementia. I’m terrified. At the same time my MiL can joke, laugh, enjoy a party even if she no longer recognises her family. She may lack cognitive capacity but doesn’t lack capacity to enjoy herself. Does she warrant being euthanised? It feels a bit more complex to me.

They give it late stage now in Holland if they have signed an advanced directive. I'm talking about personally for me. I've looked after many people with dementia as a nurse and I know this will likely be my fate as a female. It's a roll of the dice how you will be with it , your MIL is lucky to be content , many many people with dementia are not happy , I've known many to cry constantly, be fearful , I can only give so much diazepam to try and ease the anxiety for them. I don't want to be sad and unhappy and I hope a kind HCP will be able to end my suffering if I'm like that when the time comes.

DrBlackbird · 22/01/2023 19:44

Agreed that it’d be a living hell to be bed bound with dysphagia, wasting and pain. Surely at that stage, most people with dementia would also be unable to even be asked a question, let alone answer it pretty coherently. However the wasting bed bound stage didn’t sound like it was the stage of the Dutch woman when she was euthanised.

There’s a lot of fear about getting dementia. I’m terrified. At the same time my MiL can joke, laugh, enjoy a party even if she no longer recognises her family. She may lack cognitive capacity but doesn’t lack capacity to enjoy herself. Does she warrant being euthanised? It feels a bit more complex to me.

Felix01 · 22/01/2023 18:57

DrBlackbird · 22/01/2023 17:53

@Felix01 do you not think this woman had capacity in the moment that she was being asked? Dementia affects memory. So whilst she may not remember the question asked, she would be entirely capable of saying in the moment that she wanted to live. And mean it. My MiL has severe dementia but is still capable of being perfectly lucid in the moment and certainly capable of enjoying life in the moment. That story of the Dutch woman is horrendous.

No she wouldn't have had capacity because she had severe late stage dementia. So cannot weigh up the information and make an informed judgment that's why the high court allowed it and keeps allowing it in Holland. She signed the contract when she had capacity, I've looked after many people with dementia 100s if not 1000s and I don't want my death to be like that bed bound with dysphagia, wasting and pain so I should have freedom of choice to not go through with it. I don't want to have to make the decision to kill myself whilst I still have capacity and some quality of life which is what will happen if they don't allow it.

I've required rapid tranquillisation before surgery, I remember being very happy , calm and then I fell asleep if I died during the operation then oh well it was a good death I felt no fear. We have the ability to give good deaths.

DrBlackbird · 22/01/2023 17:53

@Felix01 do you not think this woman had capacity in the moment that she was being asked? Dementia affects memory. So whilst she may not remember the question asked, she would be entirely capable of saying in the moment that she wanted to live. And mean it. My MiL has severe dementia but is still capable of being perfectly lucid in the moment and certainly capable of enjoying life in the moment. That story of the Dutch woman is horrendous.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 22/01/2023 16:29

Brrrrrrrrrr please know that there is help and support available. Please don't leave your children, you are worth saving and it will get better. Please believe that.

TootHole · 22/01/2023 12:59

Namechangerr1 · 22/01/2023 10:14

@TootHole your post is disgusting and I can only assume you have never felt suicidal.

You clearly haven't read any of my posts.
It was a flippant response to someone who thinks assisted suicide isn't needed, and there are plenty of ways to kill yourself if you really wanted to.

Felix01 · 22/01/2023 12:25

erehj · 21/01/2023 12:40

@dollymixtured here is some more detail

The patient in question suffered from Alzheimer's disease. When she was diagnosed in 2012, she requested the procedure occur at a time she deemed appropriate and before she was placed in a nursing home.
"I want to be able to decide (when to die) while still in my senses and when I think the time is right," she told the public broadcaster NOS, according to Courthouse News.
Four years later, the woman was admitted to a care home in The Hague, where she was placed under Arends' care.
A second specialist agreed that she was suffering unbearably. However, when Arends asked her directly if she wanted to die, the patient repeatedly responded, "Not yet."
"If you asked her: 'What would you think if I were to help you to die?', she looked bewildered and said: 'That's going a bit far!'" Arends told Nieuwsuur.
However, she contended, "I saw in her eyes that she didn't understand it any more."

Despite asking the patient three times, and receiving a negative reply each time, Arends went through with the euthanasia on April 22, 2016. She secretly put a sleeping drug in the patient's coffee. However, the patient woke up and appeared to recoil from the lethal infusion, and her daughter and husband had to restrain her while the procedure was completed.

www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/44875/dutch-doctor-who-euthanized-woman-without-final-consent-defends-decision

This is BS and I don't think you have any idea how Dementia works. She was in the latter stages of dementia and had lost capacity , probably if you asked her she would have forgotten 2 seconds later what the question was . She requested this when she had capacity and was sound of mind. The Dutch high court have approved late stage euthanasia for dementia for when you have lost capacity and I'm so grateful. Many people with dementia effectively starve to death as they forget to eat and swallow..
This is probably my fate as it will be the number 1 cause of death for women and I don't want my death to be like that.

I hope the law changes when I get elderly , when you take an animal to the vets they fight and don't want it but we still do it because it's in their best interests.

neurospicygal · 22/01/2023 11:20

Fladdermus · 20/01/2023 19:29

So helping ill people to kill themselves should be a valid alternative to actually giving them the treatment they need. That's all kinds of fucked up.

this

DrBlackbird · 22/01/2023 11:06

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr so sorry that you feel this way Flowers

DrBlackbird · 22/01/2023 11:03

erehj · 21/01/2023 22:30

Kevin Hines survived a suicide attempt and now teaches about his story of recovery. Some great resources on his website for anyone feeling hopeless today. His slogan is "Be here tomorrow." x

www.kevinhinesstory.com

This is an important message. I’ve been involved in the care of people who attempted suicide and were so so grateful that the attempt failed.

DrBlackbird · 22/01/2023 10:54

the second pathway is when the illness is considered by at least two health care professionals to be grievous and irremediable

This is misplaced faith in some magical and purely objective ability of ‘two healthcare professionals’ who are able to mythically understand the past and future of an individual.

Tainted blood? Maternity and newborn deaths? Thalidomide? Breast implants? Unnecessary surgery? The response to medical scandals is all too often a cover up. It is so surprising that 2/3rds of posters think this is okay. This will be another scandal brewing in 10 years time.

Healthcare scandals and the failings of doctors

healthcare scandals: crime and punishment

www.forbes.com/sites/robertpearl/2018/12/10/shame-scandal/

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 22/01/2023 10:39

MooseBreath · 22/01/2023 10:30

To be honest, I think people should be allowed to choose to die if their quality of life is poor. Mental illness definitely contributes to poor quality of life. If other avenues of help are readily available and don't work, this is a humane option.

We don't choose to be born. We are all going to die someday. Why force someone to live in pain when they don't want to?

100%

Why should we be forced to go on living ?

I was really down on New Years Eve with fireworks and celebrations and my kids dancing around going on about another year starting. I just felt like „oh god another year“ and was filled with sadness.

Would prefer not to have to do a shock suicide but to have support and a process and have that be an acceptable choice I can make.

Userwoozer · 22/01/2023 10:32

Lots of arguments for and against are looked at here:
www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/against/against_1.shtml

Userwoozer · 22/01/2023 10:30

"We concluded that it was virtually impossible to ensure that all acts of euthanasia were truly voluntary and that any liberalisation of the law in the United Kingdom could not be abused.
We were also concerned that vulnerable people - the elderly, lonely, sick or distressed - would feel pressure, whether real or imagined, to request early death."
Lord Walton, Chairman, House of Lords Select Committee on Medical Ethics looking into euthanasia, 1993

MooseBreath · 22/01/2023 10:30

To be honest, I think people should be allowed to choose to die if their quality of life is poor. Mental illness definitely contributes to poor quality of life. If other avenues of help are readily available and don't work, this is a humane option.

We don't choose to be born. We are all going to die someday. Why force someone to live in pain when they don't want to?

Userwoozer · 22/01/2023 10:26

With the government we have at the moment, it really isn't much of a stretch to imagine them pushing this. The Scottish government want to bring in assisted dying this year. It's so obviously beneficial to those in charge of the difficult practicalities of the care of the elderly, the disabled and those in ill health, post-Brexit (a lack of care workers) and with a growing elderly population. And remember that these people are in control of the money. If it's not spent on the care of the elderly, then it's easier for them to spend money on their own priorities or to divert it to their cronies (as happened in a very big way during Covid).
And it's so obvious that some individuals would be pressurised by their families to die early. Very elderly people who see no-one except their adult children and may completely depend on them. The same adult children who stand to inherit. Those at risk from this kind of law are those who are most vulnerable to this kind of pressure.

Namechangerr1 · 22/01/2023 10:15

There are no easy ways to kill yourself.

Namechangerr1 · 22/01/2023 10:14

@TootHole your post is disgusting and I can only assume you have never felt suicidal.

PoIIyPandemonium · 22/01/2023 09:12

The govt are not jumping in to kill people. Unless you are suggesting people are actually being given no choice and just being told they are going to have their life ended. Massive over exaggeration doesn’t help anyone in this debate.

Not offering support or alternative options to people to help them improve their lives does amount to no choice for vulnerable and desperate people imo.

DaveyJonesLocker · 22/01/2023 09:09

I guess the main problem is that people with mental health issues can be coerced more easily into saying they want to die if someone's wants to be rid of them. You don't want mental health facilities feeding this as an option either.

But. I think we all have the right to die if we choose to. And we shouldn't have to be alone and afraid and die painfully if there could be a kinder option.

dollymixtured · 22/01/2023 09:05

Ggggggoooo · 22/01/2023 09:00

You don’t think it’s exploitative that the government are jumping in to kill people because their life is difficult? There are people who have been offered MAID because they’re poor, or in a bad place in their life, or because their trans surgery went wrong.

Instead of being given help, they’re just offered death. What about when it’s your loved one? What about if they could have improved their life? I wanted to die when I was young, now I am pretty happy and glad I’m still here. Death doesn’t just affect the person whose died, it has ripple affects.

I’m all for humane euthanasia of terminally ill people with no quality of life or in extreme pain but expanding it in this way is beyond a slippery slope. Not to mention they’re looking to expand it to ‘mature minors’ without parental consent. Do you understand how dystopian and fucked up that is?

The govt are not jumping in to kill people. Unless you are suggesting people are actually being given no choice and just being told they are going to have their life ended. Massive over exaggeration doesn’t help anyone in this debate.

Untitledsquatboulder · 22/01/2023 09:05

@TootHole you see dignity, I see a government keen to find a cheap way to "solve" a complex health need.

Ggggggoooo · 22/01/2023 09:03

Namechangerr1 · 20/01/2023 19:33

I get the controversy but I do think it's fair. Personally I believe a person has a right to end their life at any point and for whatever reason, it's just so unfortunate that for the most part, people have to resort to painful and unreliable methods rather than being able to access a peaceful and dignified passing. Personally I welcome Canada's decision however I very much doubt the application process will be easy, and I imagine it's only for residents of the country.

There are some stories out there already. The application has been made easier than you think, much like some other things with long term consequences

Ggggggoooo · 22/01/2023 09:02

There are some stories out there already. The application has been made easier than you think, much like some other things with long term consequences