Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get the controversy over Canada expanding assisted dying for mental illness?

231 replies

janef001 · 20/01/2023 19:22

I’ve been reading online and watching videos regarding Canada expanding MAID for those with incurable mental illnesses in March of this year. It’s been getting a lot of backlash.

I understand that a lot of mental illnesses can cloud someones judgement but does that really make them inherently irrational? In almost every other case, an adult with depression/bipolar/schizophrenia would be considered competent in other aspects of life when it comes to signing a contract, purchasing a home. If they were to get in trouble with the criminal justice system, they'd be seldom shown any leniency and considered as responsible as someone without mental illness.
In an ideal world, mental disorders would be properly treated so that people wouldn’t resort to dying but the public resources (therapists, psychiatrists) are not easily accessible. Many meds prescribed also take too long to work, don’t work much/at all, or have unpleasant side effects.

It seems fair to allow death in certain cases even if the mental illness might not be terminal itself.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
erehj · 28/01/2023 08:53

Well I do wonder how they're going to ascertain that someone with suicidal ideation isn't in a severe depressive episode, given that suicidal ideation is actually a symptom of serious depression.

And if a person's depression has been alleviated, then I don't see how their illness can be termed "irremediable".

So these supposed safeguards are a nonsense in my opinion (as someone who has recovered from longstanding depression and suicidal ideation.)

musingsinmidlife · 27/01/2023 11:03

RumandSpinach · 26/01/2023 20:20

I would imagine that this wouldn't (or shouldn't) apply to bipolar disorder, which has a range of treatment options and if all else fails is episodic and will pass. Dor this reason I struggle to see that there would ever be a case where someone in a depressive phase of BPAD would be deemed to have capacity to end their life.

I think the comparison would be someone with a mental health problem which for whatever reason isn't treatable and is unrelenting in nature.

Mental pain can really hurt and there will be some people who won't want to live with it indefinitely without hope of change, just in the same way that people with chronic severe physical pain may want to die. It's a really difficult thing to say, and not a reality I personally want for anyone, but it doesn't feel right to assume all people with MH problems lack capacity - because they don't.

No one will sign off if the person is acutely unwell. If someone is manic or psychotic or in a severe depressive episode then their decision making will be clouded by their illness at that time and they would not meet criteria.

There are issues to overcome but there is a lot of information out there on the facts that people need to read to understand what MAid is or isn't.

LangClegsInSpace · 26/01/2023 20:21

@Felix01 'when you take an animal to the vets they fight and don't want it but we still do it because it's in their best interests.'

I only just noticed this. We have moved from 'consent' to 'best interests'.

If we take a relative to the doctor and they fight and don't want assisted dying, should we still do it because it's in their 'best interests'?

People really need to stop talking about their pets in this discussion. Animals do not have human rights. It's legal to kill animals just because they taste nice. The starting point for ethical pet euthanasia is in a completely different place.

RumandSpinach · 26/01/2023 20:20

Stressedmum2017 · 26/01/2023 20:01

As someone with bipolar who has attempted suicide twice I find this absolutely terrifying. At the depths of a depressive episode you are certainly not in your right mind and I wouldn't say I had capacity so how is this judged? That's before you even start thinking about psychosis possibly being a factor. Being at the height of an episode is like someone else has got in the driver seat of your brain whilst the real you is lying dormant somewhere so this I cant think how this is ethical at all.

I would imagine that this wouldn't (or shouldn't) apply to bipolar disorder, which has a range of treatment options and if all else fails is episodic and will pass. Dor this reason I struggle to see that there would ever be a case where someone in a depressive phase of BPAD would be deemed to have capacity to end their life.

I think the comparison would be someone with a mental health problem which for whatever reason isn't treatable and is unrelenting in nature.

Mental pain can really hurt and there will be some people who won't want to live with it indefinitely without hope of change, just in the same way that people with chronic severe physical pain may want to die. It's a really difficult thing to say, and not a reality I personally want for anyone, but it doesn't feel right to assume all people with MH problems lack capacity - because they don't.

Stressedmum2017 · 26/01/2023 20:01

As someone with bipolar who has attempted suicide twice I find this absolutely terrifying. At the depths of a depressive episode you are certainly not in your right mind and I wouldn't say I had capacity so how is this judged? That's before you even start thinking about psychosis possibly being a factor. Being at the height of an episode is like someone else has got in the driver seat of your brain whilst the real you is lying dormant somewhere so this I cant think how this is ethical at all.

LangClegsInSpace · 26/01/2023 19:51

Felix01 · 22/01/2023 12:25

This is BS and I don't think you have any idea how Dementia works. She was in the latter stages of dementia and had lost capacity , probably if you asked her she would have forgotten 2 seconds later what the question was . She requested this when she had capacity and was sound of mind. The Dutch high court have approved late stage euthanasia for dementia for when you have lost capacity and I'm so grateful. Many people with dementia effectively starve to death as they forget to eat and swallow..
This is probably my fate as it will be the number 1 cause of death for women and I don't want my death to be like that.

I hope the law changes when I get elderly , when you take an animal to the vets they fight and don't want it but we still do it because it's in their best interests.

"I want to be able to decide (when to die) while still in my senses and when I think the time is right,"

She was not 'in her senses' when a decision was made for her to die and she was repeatedly, assertively vocal that the time was not right.

People change their mind. This paper suggests around half of terminally ill people change their mind:

jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/193281

So why wouldn't half of people with dementia also change their mind? I don't see how advance directives can be made safe.

My understanding is that the doctor in this case was cleared because he acted in good faith and within the letter of the law. I think that was right. It's not fair to put moral responsibilities like this on individual clinicians, as long as they are following the law and guidance.

Nevertheless, this woman's life was deliberately and forcibly ended when she did not want to die. For her, the experience and outcome were indistinguishable from murder.

I know everyone's keen to talk about dignity and not prolonging suffering and what they would want for themself (or at least what they now think they would want), or what they would have wanted for their loved one, but the bottom line is that in any other circumstances deliberately ending someone's life is murder.

That is the status quo. That is the starting point from which to build safeguards for any assisted dying law.

100% cast iron consent at the time of death is the absolute minimum. If there is the slightest doubt that someone might not want to die then their life should not be ended.

pointythings · 26/01/2023 15:04

As fas as I know it is possible for doctors to opt out, which it should be, I also agree it is important to assess competence,

The case of Marc in the article does not move me at all. My mother suffered mental trauma as a result of her experiences in a camp and never recovered - it is not for Marc to decide his mother should have carried on living and suffering to appease his feelings. My mother had a mostly good life, but after my dad died her mental health fell off a cliff. She did not choose euthanasia, she drank herself to death instead, at a cost to my sister and me. She would not and could not help herself or be helped. We did not suggest anything to her, we supported her as best we could and made no demands, Marc should have done the same,

witheringrowan · 26/01/2023 13:51

I found this article pretty fair and balanced - and it talks about the impact having to make these decisions has on doctors or the members of the approval boards, which I think is an often overlooked element. www.theguardian.com/news/2019/jan/18/death-on-demand-has-euthanasia-gone-too-far-netherlands-assisted-dying

pointythings · 26/01/2023 13:38

@RumandSpinach it's an enormously complex area. I had a cousin who had psychosis - this was before the advent of modern antipsychotics. Despite trying everything that was available at the time, nothing worked and he took his own life in a particularly violent way, causing enormous distress not only to his wife and young children but also to the wider family and to members of the public who witnessed it. We mustn't forget that suicide is incredibly distressing to both the person themselves and the people around them, and that sometimes there is no 'good' outcome - only a less awful one.

RumandSpinach · 26/01/2023 13:27

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 22/01/2023 22:13

Rumandspinach is this due to their condition or lack of options of treatment? I'm just curious as to whether it is NHS not being able to afford certain treatments or that some people are so far gone with mental health issues that they cannot ever be cured? That's desperately sad if so.

Yes. Hospital is by far the most expensive option (£3-600 a day), so it's not a question of having funds. Sometimes people are so profoundly traumatised they can't engage in psychological treatment and so the crux of their treatment is to offer medicine to reduce their distress with them on essentially suicide watch for years.

I wouldn't be happy to see legislation to allow this group of people to die, but I don't think that for many we are offering much in the way of hope or quality if life. It can feel like we are prolonging life because withdrawing the nursing care/supervision feels uncomfortable to us as clinicians as opposed to what is genuinely in the person's best interests.

It's really hard.

pointythings · 26/01/2023 12:51

@TheInebriati I do agree with that, but in the cases highlighted in Belgium and the Netherlands, the people involved had been engaging with mental health services for years. In the case of the alcohol addicted man who requested and received euthanasia, it had been 30 years. There comes a point where the carrot of hope of recovery becomes a stick we beat people with. How long do you think someone living miserably with mental ill health should carry on?

Thelnebriati · 26/01/2023 11:49

I feel it is incredibly patronising to think that someone with a mental illness is therefore not capable of making an informed choice about ending their life.

I don't think people are saying that capacity is the problem; more that the mental health system offers a very limited range of help and that in some cases what's needed is not more of the same - more drugs, or more therapy - but something different.

pointythings · 26/01/2023 11:02

The Dutch have a thing called 'gedoogbeleid' which is basically monitoring something that is technically illegal during the period while the legislation catches up with events, which is what I suspect you are describing. It means that what was happening in the mid 90s was technically illegal but there were few prosecutions because the law was being developed which would make those instances of euthanasia legal. Personally I think it's a far more sensible approach than the British one, which seems to be to yell 'no, no, slippery slope' and bury one's head in the sand.

I would say the Dutch law works pretty well. There are instances where it goes wrong, for instance with the case around the lady with dementia who clearly withdrew her consent but was not heard - cases like that will hopefully lead to refinements in euthanasia law. Dementia is probably the most difficult area and personally I would want to see a withdrawal of consent after an advance direction taken at face value, with no further efforts at ending that person's life thereafter, even if the person asks, as no capacity for consent is present any more. It would be erring on the side of caution. My father was offered an advance directive when he was first diagnoses with Parkinson's dementia - he refused. Later on, when he was getting worse, he wanted to change his mind in his lucid periods but was deemed not to have consent any more. That to my mind was a tragic but fully correct application of the law,

In terms of euthanasia for mental health, I am in favour. Those people who have had euthanasia in Belium and the Netherlands have all suffered for many years before choosing to end their lives, and have had to jump through all the legal hoops. I feel it is incredibly patronising to think that someone with a mental illness is therefore not capable of making an informed choice about ending their life.

The Canada law seems to be drafted far more loosely than the Dutch one, which is why I feel it needs a lot more work before implementation.

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/01/2023 10:57

Userwoozer · 20/01/2023 20:01

The clue is in the word "terminal". The risk of the process being abused is obviously far far lower where someone only has a maximum of 6 months to live. The OP's post is an example of how quickly people can move from "life is sacred" to "the government can legitimately save money on healthcare by legalising and encouraging euthanasia."
The next move - saving money on social care by legalising and encouraging the euthanasia of healthy elderly people.
This is why I am against any form of legalised euthanasia.

Me too.

We've already seen Canada (link given earlier) suggest to a disabled person they might take that "option".

Like at least one other poster, the more I hear of what's going on in Canada, the more uncomfortable they make me feel.

Workerbeep · 26/01/2023 10:56

Perhaps a slow cautious approach would be prudent. In the Netherlands in the 1990s it was discussed and proclaimed it would be available, but was not enacted upon till 2001, even though 320 people had made requests in 1995.

I understand and am empathetic that this timescale for many people would not be best.

Workerbeep · 26/01/2023 10:47

@pointythings not wanting to come across as pendantic but have you read the scientific paper I linked to?

Does there seems to be conflicting information on internet?

who is wrong or right? We both are.

I said that PAD had been available not that an act had been passed or any procedure had been carried out.

Wikipedia cites that in the Netherlands there was a act passed in 2001 concerning euthanasia whereas the scientific paper I linked to, in its introduction, states that the Supreme Court in the Netherlands rules that PAD could be undertaken for psychiatric suffering then goes on to state that there had been 320 requests in 1995 for PAD for psychiatric suffering and 1100 requests in 2010. None had been carried out till 2001.

so, my point is whether you want take the Netherlands starting point as the 1990s or the early 2000s PAD for psychiatric suffering, it’s been available for 20 to 25 years.

How is this working out in the Netherlands?

pointythings · 26/01/2023 09:34

The Netherlands have had PAD (physician aided death) for those with psychiatric suffering since the 1990s. There must be information and data. Is it similar to Canada?

This is incorrect. The first euthanasia law in the Netherlands was passed in 2001. Because of the way the law was worded, it could include psychiatric patients. Criteria are far more stringent than the ones proposed in Canada.

Stylemyhairplease · 26/01/2023 09:01

Sorry - this documentary. A young woman with severe MH issues preparing for MAID in the Netherlands.

Stylemyhairplease · 26/01/2023 08:57

Workerbeep · 20/01/2023 21:16

The Netherlands have had PAD (physician aided death) for those with psychiatric suffering since the 1990s. There must be information and data. Is it similar to Canada?

i don’t know enough about this to have an opinion yet.

Indeed. I watched this documentary years ago and it stuck with me:

DrBlackbird · 23/01/2023 21:40

Is it really so different in Canada? I remember reading about very real health inequalities bw different groups. Is that really different for mental health?

At a time that Canada was ranked about 5th best country in the world (its dropped now), when the data was disaggregated, the First Nations peoples data (life expectancy, literacy, income etc) ranked about 112th… So, yes, very real health inequalities between groups. It’s naïve to think prejudices wouldn’t get played out in such decisions made by health professionals.

Untitledsquatboulder · 23/01/2023 08:26

Well I live in a country where people with terrible mental illnesses and/or trauma can be left without access to appropriate treatment and support for years and years. The thought of my government bring able to offer euthanasia to such people is terrifying. Is it really so different in Canada? I remember reading about very real health inequalities bw different groups. Is that really different for mental health?

Felix01 · 22/01/2023 23:33

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 22/01/2023 22:13

Rumandspinach is this due to their condition or lack of options of treatment? I'm just curious as to whether it is NHS not being able to afford certain treatments or that some people are so far gone with mental health issues that they cannot ever be cured? That's desperately sad if so.

I've worked within MH settings , the reality is some people can spend years in hospital. We have tried DBT, trauma based therapy , medications , positive risk taking. We have to keep people on constant observations even the toilet. We monitor all of their post , rooms can be stripped bare and some can't even have clothes and will wear a rip proof strong suit. As soon as they are taken off observations they go on to attempt suicide or serious self harm so they are put back on. They headbang so much they fracture their own skulls, they interfere with wounds. We have to physically restrain them to stop them hurting themselves.

We try our best to keep these people alive, it's so sad they are so distressed and it upsets me they have such a poor quality of life

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 22/01/2023 22:13

Rumandspinach is this due to their condition or lack of options of treatment? I'm just curious as to whether it is NHS not being able to afford certain treatments or that some people are so far gone with mental health issues that they cannot ever be cured? That's desperately sad if so.

RumandSpinach · 22/01/2023 20:50

I'm a mental health nurse. Something we aren't great at is acknowledging when treatment options have been exhausted. This can lead to people with complex trauma based diagnoses being essentially kept alive in hospital against their will for years, often in pretty horrendous and restricted circumstances, with no hope of change.

Some will definitely lack capacity to make a decision like this due to their illness, but some would do and I brlieve in very isolated cases the law should allow for this

CuteOrangeElephant · 22/01/2023 20:42

My grandma had late stage dementia. She spent years being severely unhappy, even if she didn't recognise it herself. The last time I saw her she couldn't even talk but she was crying. She was kept alive with countless interventions and pills.

I'm in Holland. When I turn 60 I will put everything in order so I can avoid this faith. Not sure if I would like direct euthanasia, but there were several opportunities that my grandma could have died a natural death, but she kept being patched up with antibiotics etc. I think I would want pain management only at that stage, no curative medicine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread