Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inviting others on a trip we paid for?

279 replies

Wantsummerback · 20/01/2023 19:09

Please tell me your thoughts on this, me and DH are so wound up about it. We have booked a trip for parents in law and they are inviting other people at our expense. I appreciate we have gifted it them and they can do what they want with it.

but it just feels such a slap in the face! We found such a lovely place for them to relax and now they aren’t even going together.

OP posts:
Airspice · 21/01/2023 23:11

LookItsMeAgain · 21/01/2023 19:35

At this point @Wantsummerback , what I would do is cancel this cabin.

Make up some excuse to PiL (especially MiL) saying that there has been an event at the lodge and they can't actually stay there after all and you'll do your very best to arrange an alternative location. Tell her you'll let her know the day before but to still be packed.

Book somewhere else. A hotel with a hot-tub or jacuzzi in the room or a hotel with a spa treatment and just don't tell her where. She'll have to break the news to SiL that her trip is off.
If you can, drive your PiL to the location so they can't tell anyone.
Make sure that their phones are off and that all types of tracking on the phone is turned off.
Deliver them to the posh hotel and tell them that they are to have fun - minus SiL!

This!!!!

Airspice · 21/01/2023 23:04

I’d be furious tbh, especially if SiL/BiL is renowned for being a sponging CF! This is a gift for your PiL, NOT for him/her. Especially after them deciding ‘no gifts’!
I know others are saying it’s their gift to do what they want with but no, you have paid for it for them, not for any freeloaders. I’d have to say something, either to the Pil or the freeloader themselves.

kateandme · 21/01/2023 23:00

but i bet you no exactly how to behave in order for you to get things your way with your parents. and so does your dh! we all have it in families. and if you parents keep doing it its not her fault. its theirs. they keep inviting her. they dont invite you or anyone else so its obvious they can say no and choose who to invite. and choose who they dont invite. she plays it up and they feel for her. but they very very easily can not invite her.
maybe its jealousy.but seeing what you all have as a family might make her so. you cant really blame her for seeing waht you have and being jealous if that is the life shed yearn for and cant have. if she cant afford holiday and cars etc it would be totally normal to feel how she does. thats human.
shes done what any kid does in life no matter their age.
if it was so hideos when she was with them your parents would say no or do their own "sly" way of not inviting her.
you really seem ot dislike her. but dont have her side of the story in all this.
you seem jealous that he keeps getting nice things in life.or bitter.

HamBone · 21/01/2023 22:44

JemimaTiggywinkles · 21/01/2023 22:11

He doesn’t like seeing his parents treated like that, IYSWIM.

Yes, but you cannot control your parents’ relationships with their other children. And I’m not sure you should try to, unless there’s abuse happening.

@JemimaTiggywinkles No, you can’t control other people’s relationships and my DH doesn’t attempt to.

He doesn’t dwell on it, it just upsets him sometimes when she asks them to drive 90 miles each way to help her out.
They’re in their 80’s ffs!

Although, they might be starting to realize that it’s not sustainable as a couple of weeks ago, they cancelled on her due to bad weather. DH was so relieved, he gets anxious every time they drive up to her.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 21/01/2023 22:11

He doesn’t like seeing his parents treated like that, IYSWIM.

Yes, but you cannot control your parents’ relationships with their other children. And I’m not sure you should try to, unless there’s abuse happening.

Dishwashersaurous · 21/01/2023 22:02

You've posted before about the odd family dynamics involving your SIL.

Given the history and how everyone reacts why did you buy a gift whereby there was even the option of her going?

If you wanted to get them an experience you could have got two theatre tickets.

This is the family dynamics. You can rail against it and get cross.

Or you can just accept it is how it will be, and adapt behavior accordingly

HamBone · 21/01/2023 22:00

PollyAmour · 21/01/2023 21:41

I don't understand the issue, to be honest. If PIL have invited her along, she's hardly muscling in, is she? You're just pissed off that she's getting a free holiday. Let go of the grudge you have against her, and try to understand that her parents love her and want to include her. You don't sound very kind.

I think it’s the principle of it, @PollyAmour . Her DH buys a thoughtful present for his parents and then his sister whines until she gets invited along. It’s not a great way to treat your parents.

Plus the OP says that her SIL has form for getting herself invited along on holidays at others’ expense.

It’s similar to one of my DH’s sisters, who cadges financial and practical help from his parents and it does annoys him, tbh. Yes, they always give in/offer to help her, but what irritates my DH is that his sister is even asking elderly people in their 80’s to help her out- at what point, will she start “giving back” or helping them out abit? He doesn’t like seeing his parents treated like that, IYSWIM. Same with the OP’s in-laws.

aloeleaf · 21/01/2023 21:52

PollyAmour · 21/01/2023 21:41

I don't understand the issue, to be honest. If PIL have invited her along, she's hardly muscling in, is she? You're just pissed off that she's getting a free holiday. Let go of the grudge you have against her, and try to understand that her parents love her and want to include her. You don't sound very kind.

Exactly this.

LoisLane66 · 21/01/2023 21:43

@aloeleaf
I couldn't do that. It would irritate me far too much, however, I take my hat off to you and others who might be of like mind.

PollyAmour · 21/01/2023 21:41

I don't understand the issue, to be honest. If PIL have invited her along, she's hardly muscling in, is she? You're just pissed off that she's getting a free holiday. Let go of the grudge you have against her, and try to understand that her parents love her and want to include her. You don't sound very kind.

LoisLane66 · 21/01/2023 21:40

ADVICE
Don't post if you've had a drink (or two) because we will have to ask you multiple questions to understand what exactly you meant. 😂

MichelleScarn · 21/01/2023 21:28

So you are paying for everything? Is booking fully in your name and deposit for cleaning/any damage chargeable to you then or inlaws?
This is what I'd be unhappy about!

Wonnle · 21/01/2023 21:26

canyoutellemehowtoget · 21/01/2023 21:23

This thread is ridiculously hard to follow.

You claimed early on that this was a male relative but now apparently it's your SIL and there's some other thread that everyone is supposed to know about?

Poor form, op.

Ask a question giving all the pertinent facts or don't ask at all.

Maybe the SIL was BIL at the start of the tread and has come out as trans !

canyoutellemehowtoget · 21/01/2023 21:23

This thread is ridiculously hard to follow.

You claimed early on that this was a male relative but now apparently it's your SIL and there's some other thread that everyone is supposed to know about?

Poor form, op.

Ask a question giving all the pertinent facts or don't ask at all.

Lialou · 21/01/2023 21:21

I dont see how any of it is your business. You can't attach your own rules and conditions to gifts!

HamBone · 21/01/2023 21:19

Your SIL does sound like a PITA but ultimately, it’s your PIL who aren’t setting boundaries and invited her on this trip. If they didn’t want her to come, they shouldn’t have invited her.

Just make sure that the chef is booked for only two people (an extra person will have to pay for themselves). We recently bought theatre tickets for DH’s parents and if someone else wants to come along, they’ll have to buy their own ticket!

Purpleauntie · 21/01/2023 21:09

If the extra person isn't costing you extra, just go with the flow. However, if an extra person WILL add to the expense, your in-laws can cover the cost. Make that clear. If the extra person becomes an irritant (i.e., tries to change the itinerary, complains about the accommodations/food/service, attempts to cross boundaries), take your in-laws aside and let them know that this is unacceptable, period, and they need to deal with it. Now. Once you get home, explain to them that this isn't the first time their friend has tried to score a free trip. Hopefully they will think twice about inviting them along in the future. Just my thoughts, for what they're worth (I can't stand mooches,either!)

Belmum84 · 21/01/2023 20:48

Slightly off topic, but... does this remind anyone of that episode of the Royale family when Anthony buys Jim and Barbara a caravan holiday. Then Denise and David tag along?

Justbefair · 21/01/2023 20:46

What a lovely gift and if they want to invite others at no expense to you, let them! You may have thought they would value it on their own but seems they would like company while also having time to themselves. Their decision, feel happy you have created this for them. X

T1Dmama · 21/01/2023 20:44

Text her and say you and husband are now going so she can’t! As you paid for the trip she can simply buggar off!
I think you need to tell in laws that
youre pissed off about it. You can’t expect them to just know

Glitteratitar · 21/01/2023 20:38

aloeleaf · 21/01/2023 20:29

Your sister in law is clearly struggling to live independently as an adult. Her parents obviously love her very much and are clearly happy for her to tag along free of charge. You and your husband resent his sister and her needy behaviour. Her behaviour is causing anger and resentment but to ameliorate these feelings why not instead focus on the pleasure your PIL will receive from your gift and feel sympathy for the rather sad lonely sister in law as she will never have the life that you enjoy.

This. As per your explanation on your other thread, she clearly has issues and the dynamics are complicated. Didn’t you say on your other thread you forced her to come out and she struggles to get into a relationship? She’s obviously needs support emotionally so it’s a bit more than her tagging along for a free holiday.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 21/01/2023 20:37

I remember your last post OP. It is a bit galling that your PIL have done this but its a gift and really they can do what they like with it. Best not to buy presents like this again.
Also, there is some reason for SIL's resentment. Why for example was she "dragged" out to come and admire your new car?
Don't put yourselves or her in that position again. If she gets fed up with the things you have and it makes her feel sad that she doesn't have those things- why expect her to be full of compliments and "happy" for you? Particularly if she's dragged out and expected to come out with pleasantries. I think thats actually quite unfair.
Just don't bring it up in conversation and this won't be an issue and tell MIL to stop the whole performance too.
It doesn't sound like you like her much, and she clearly knows it,
so step back, be neutral and leave her and MIL to sort themselves out and try not to get involved in this stuff in future and you'll find that eases the situation considerably.

Eastereggsboxedupready · 21/01/2023 20:33

Ils are enabling her to be a freeloader. You need to be as cunning to make sure this is the last time.

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 21/01/2023 20:32

Wantsummerback · 20/01/2023 19:35

Well we are going round to PIL tomorrow DH said he’s going to bring it up.

but I’ve just come here to ask whether we are being selfish knobs. But then as I said this person keeps doing this.

The other person needs to now pay half just phone them and tell them!!

aloeleaf · 21/01/2023 20:29

Your sister in law is clearly struggling to live independently as an adult. Her parents obviously love her very much and are clearly happy for her to tag along free of charge. You and your husband resent his sister and her needy behaviour. Her behaviour is causing anger and resentment but to ameliorate these feelings why not instead focus on the pleasure your PIL will receive from your gift and feel sympathy for the rather sad lonely sister in law as she will never have the life that you enjoy.