Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be dismayed by the lack of real effort men have to make - and they still manage to succeed

63 replies

thecatsmum12346 · 20/01/2023 17:16

Ok this should probably be on the feminist forum but interested to hear your thoughts here.
I was at a business breakfast this morning (Northern Ireland) aimed at helping SMEs gain funding. early start…
When we got there……
The Room was full of men (only about 2 other women there). All the speakers were men. The room smelt like it was full of men. Most of them were very mediocre speakers. Some couldn’t really be bothered dressing in a professional manner (covered in dandruff etc).
The food, organised by a man was sausage baps and bacon baps.
I asked for some bread without a sausage so I could put my banana in it was was told ‘no’, ‘take yer sausage out and give it to your husband to eat’!!!
The whole thing had hilarious David Brent vibes. At one stage my husband asked me if I had seen Fitchy around! (Of ‘while you’re down there love’ fame)
OK. So, Aibu to be dissatisfied with the fact that many men simply get away with making very little effort.? And still dominate the world of business? Or is this just a Northern Ireland thing? There loads of ‘women in business forums’ but it’s a pity women aren’t more involved ‘organically’ in all spheres of business at senior levels. A youngish woman came in after 9am (missing the baps!). She probably did the school run first.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EBearhug · 23/01/2023 07:29

Women shouldn't have to play the 'mediocre men games' to get ahead. The workplace shouldn't reward that. But it still does. Women dumb themselves down and have to waste energy trying to be 'likeable' to the mediocre men, so they are allowed in to play the mediocre man games, and have a chance to get ahead. Is that really what you want?

There's no point. Women are held to different standards. If you behave like a mediocre man, they will recognise the mediocrity, even while they ignore it in men.

donttellmehesalive · 23/01/2023 06:47

My profession is dominated by women and there are plenty of mediocre ones.

However, those few men we do have are more likely to be in senior roles. IME this is due to confidence and the fact that their careers aren't compromised by having children. They don't take breaks for maternity leave or take time off when their kids are sick or leave early to collect kids from nursery.

But you see it on mn all the time. Women who are SAHM or work pt because their dh's career is more important or pays more. Or they can't bear to return to work after maternity leave.

NineToFiveish · 23/01/2023 06:26

HashBrownandBeans · 21/01/2023 09:39

Well I currently work for two of the worst male managers I’ve ever had the misfortune to come across. No idea how they got there, it certainly wasn’t through hard work. They are rude, belligerent, lazy, unintelligent, they don’t communicate even the simplest information, mostly because they think it’s funny to watch people fuck up due to lack of insight. It’s been horrific. I’m getting out in ten days time!

This is so familiar I almost thought you were my colleague! But none of us are planning to leave; I'll definitely outlast manager.

DorisParchment · 23/01/2023 06:16

I hear you! I used to work in cybersecurity and was almost always the only woman. I was ignored, talked over, on one occasion handed an empty coffee cup as if I was the waitress. I used to speak at international conferences, almost always the only woman speaker. There were always more questions for me than any other speaker - not because my presentation was more interesting, but because the majority of the audience wanted to ask questions designed to trip me up. PhD students were the worst. And I knew they were PhD students because they always started their question with “I’m a PhD student at x university…”

FlamingoOfDoom · 23/01/2023 05:27

MademoiselleTrunchbull · 22/01/2023 20:22

If you're being repeatedly out manoeuvred by mediocre men then you might need to work on your social skills, OP. A lot of women are great at the academic bit but seem to realise that you need to be more than 'a brain'.

These men may seem 'mediocre' but they know how to play the game and they're doing it successfully. I think that's often a difference between the sexes. Women work hard for validation but men often don't give a monkeys as long as they get the fat paycheck. Obviously this is a generalisation.

It is a generalisation, but unfortunately your post also suggests a lifetime under the patriarchy and a lot of (unintentional) internalised misogyny.

Women shouldn't have to play the 'mediocre men games' to get ahead. The workplace shouldn't reward that. But it still does. Women dumb themselves down and have to waste energy trying to be 'likeable' to the mediocre men, so they are allowed in to play the mediocre man games, and have a chance to get ahead. Is that really what you want?

Bestcatmum · 22/01/2023 20:37

We had a senior manager who ate like an animal, worse actually, mouth open chomping, slurping, sucking, swapping fork for hands.
Everyone in the room was aghast. It was like watching a hyena tearing the guts out of some animal.
How do you get to manhood thinking this is ok. Oblivious to the stares and tuts.

MademoiselleTrunchbull · 22/01/2023 20:22

If you're being repeatedly out manoeuvred by mediocre men then you might need to work on your social skills, OP. A lot of women are great at the academic bit but seem to realise that you need to be more than 'a brain'.

These men may seem 'mediocre' but they know how to play the game and they're doing it successfully. I think that's often a difference between the sexes. Women work hard for validation but men often don't give a monkeys as long as they get the fat paycheck. Obviously this is a generalisation.

Andanotherone01 · 21/01/2023 09:44

Your OP is so full of stereotypes that I’ll take it with a shovel of salt

HashBrownandBeans · 21/01/2023 09:39

Well I currently work for two of the worst male managers I’ve ever had the misfortune to come across. No idea how they got there, it certainly wasn’t through hard work. They are rude, belligerent, lazy, unintelligent, they don’t communicate even the simplest information, mostly because they think it’s funny to watch people fuck up due to lack of insight. It’s been horrific. I’m getting out in ten days time!

Flumpaphone · 21/01/2023 09:36

I work in and around that sort of world and attend those sort of events as part of my job. I'm in the North.

I would say the picture you have painted was probably true 10 years ago but it is changing and has certainly moved since Covid.

There are still those sorts of men about I don't deny, but I see lots and lots of women at events and at a well run event everyone makes an effort. There is also an effort made with catering (if you even get catering these days as everything has become so expensive), the last event I was at had vegetarian, vegan and gluten free options.

There are some groups, where those attitudes do seem to prevail, the ones starting at 6.00 am, which tend to be more akin to a cult in my opinion but they are easy to avoid.

The ones who are very much dying out thank god are the old guard. The ones who were the pompous old farts who had wives at home running everything which allowed them to be still running meetings and puffing up their own importance at 7.00 in the evening. They were often worse.

SomeSix · 21/01/2023 09:19

10-12 years ago I was on a course with a quite senior civil servant from NI. I fully believed her reports of sexism in her office. The men assuming she was in the meeting to take the minutes or make the tea sort of thing.

lljkk · 21/01/2023 09:11

With you, BabyOnBoard90.

I'm the scruffiest female in the room typically, I suppose: quite scruffy.
Since I can't care about who is well-groomed, I will think about bad speakers. Can definitely think of some bad female speakers.

I barely know any vegans, they seem as often male as female, though, or maybe slightly more males (idealists).

I don't want people to be invested in my own child count so I don't have systematic info about who among senior colleagues has kids or not.

As ever, MNers track a lot of info about other people. I sure hope no one is tracking my info.

Iamthewombat · 21/01/2023 09:02

So you work in the nursery industry, which I assume encompasses medium sized manufacturing businesses, distribution companies and actual nursery operators, which are often small businesses? In what is probably the most provincial area of the U.K. (in my opinion, before anyone living in NI gets annoyed with me)?

And you know that most of these business breakfast type events are aimed at selling services, disguised as networking?

And that in most areas, this type of event usually attracts the same people every time? The type who can find time to go to multiple business breakfasts?

In which case,m you can see that you’d be at high risk of encountering the type of men you describe, right?

If your question is, would you see the type of men you describe at similar events in other parts of the country, the answer is maybe, where it’s an industry involving small to medium businesses in a relatively trad sector. But, you must see that they are not typical of the men dominating the world of business.

VogueDarling · 21/01/2023 09:01

I attend business breakfasts around 3/4x a year. I work in finance and we use these to get various clients together and share upcoming changes or any trends the clients may be seeing in service etc. Always well catered in lovely hotel settings and thankfully the chat is relevant and insightful

Also the male to female split has improved its now more 60/40 than 80/20

neverbeenskiing · 21/01/2023 08:59

It's not just business. I have always worked in the public sector, in Health and more recently Education. Women significantly outnumber men in both of these sectors but senior management is dominated by men.

Having spent the last few years working in schools it never ceases to amaze me how many likeable but incompetent men manage to not only keep hold of senior leadership roles, but also continue to climb the ladder. These men turn up to meetings unprepared, they miss deadlines and don't respond to emails, they shy away from making touch decisions or having difficult conversations because they want to be everyone's mate.

Women in SLT are consistently held to a higher standard in Education, and often expected to pick up the slack and repair the damage caused by their under-performing, over-promoted male colleagues. Then when they inevitably burn-out it is seen as a sign of weakness, that they obviously weren't cut out for senior management. Friends and colleagues who work in schools across different areas have noticed the same pattern. I'm sure its present in other sectors too.

In my current school, there are four women on the Senior Leadership Team. Not one of them has dependent children. The men on SLT? They all have dependent children, but also have wives at home who work very PT in highly flexible roles or not at all.

Aprilx · 21/01/2023 08:53

IDontWantToBeAPie · 21/01/2023 08:38

I mean the dandruff thing isn't really their fault they can't just stop producing it. The bread thing is bizarre but I've also never seen anyone wrap a banana in bread so they probably thought you were the weird one.

I work in a female dominated sector of a male dominated sector. They've learned to adapt to us pretty well. They've had to.

I didn’t like to say, but I also thought asking for bread to put a banana in at a catered business function was a bit weird and I felt embarrassed for OP. If you don’t want what is on offer then decline and eat your banana later.

LulusMiniEgg · 21/01/2023 08:47

@thecatsmum12346 ooh, I work in that industry too! But in the Uk. In the most part I love it, but there is still a lot of laddish behaviour that goes on! In fact, I think I can imagine one of the men you talk of…. One of the biggest distributors in Ireland?! I sat next to him at a meal in K&J and couldn’t believe how much the guy could drink and talk 😂

IDontWantToBeAPie · 21/01/2023 08:38

I mean the dandruff thing isn't really their fault they can't just stop producing it. The bread thing is bizarre but I've also never seen anyone wrap a banana in bread so they probably thought you were the weird one.

I work in a female dominated sector of a male dominated sector. They've learned to adapt to us pretty well. They've had to.

BabyOnBoard90 · 21/01/2023 08:32

Women only seem to take issue where they are the minority and never the majority.

Strangely they never complain about why there aren't more women working on garbage collection, or construction or general physical/ manual labour. Why don't they complain there aren't more men working in nursery or primary schools, or as nurses/midwives etc?

FlamingoOfDoom · 21/01/2023 05:04

Women almost always need to be 'likeable' to be promoted. History has proven time and again that that criterion does not apply to men.

FlamingoOfDoom · 21/01/2023 04:57

@TrishM80 I'm not exactly sure what point you're trying to make.

But I think it is pretty clear that a person with a brilliant mind, an out-of-the-ordinary professional demeanour, and no interest in pleasing and placating the people around them is far more likely to be tolerated and successful in business if they are male rather than female.

TrishM80 · 21/01/2023 03:46

Really silly thread, this. Where's the female Bill Gates, Elon Musk, Steve Jobs, Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg etc etc?! What, did they all bluff their way to success too?!

emptythelitterbox · 21/01/2023 03:15

Yep, schmoozing with the boss > skills.

These types hate WFH too where they actually have to do their own work and not get by by being visible in the office and delegating to some sap.

Aprilx · 21/01/2023 02:42

*business breakfasts

Aprilx · 21/01/2023 02:42

DanseAvecLesLoups · 20/01/2023 19:01

Which industry is this? I work in engineering, and the idea that you can bluff, bullshit and waffle your way through multimillion pound projects and still have a job at the end of it is laughable.

I agree. My background is financial services and my occupation is accountant, I am semi retired now but was reasonably senior up until a few years ago.

There is no doubt that it is harder for women to progress and there are fewer women in senior positions. But I find the OPs description a caricature of real life. My breakfast breakfasts have served a variety of healthy and less health options, speakers are prepared, nobody is covered in dandruff.

Yes men have it easier, but the idea that any and every man will succeed just by turning up is not correct.

Swipe left for the next trending thread