Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed DP hasn't proposed

207 replies

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 16:55

I feel a bit pathetic even writing this... but I can't help but be disappointed and sad.

DP and I have been together for 10 years. For the past 4 years or so I have mentioned that I would like to get married – I have also made clear that I'm not interested in a big, fancy wedding and that I'd be just as happy with civil service or us eloping somewhere just the two of us (nothing elaborate, just a holiday with a civil service somewhere). I have discussed with him that it would make me feel more secure as 'de facto' is not a thing here in the UK (I'm from Aus where couples have the same rights as a married couple after cohabitating for a certain number of years). This isn't something I've brought up constantly – maybe once or twice a year. I'm worried that if we were to have kids, or one of us were ill, or were to pass away that everything would be that much more difficult as we wouldn't be seen as being 'family'. For context, we don't have kids – we were TTC but are going through fairly significant fertility issues.

He has not been that keen whenever I have brought marriage up (his parents did not have a happy marriage, and he has had several friends divorce shortly after getting married), but last year asked if it was something I was still interested in. I said it definitely was. He asked again a few months later. Towards the end of the year, he told me about a jeweller he had seen on IG whose work he thought I would like (which is a pretty unusual thing for him to do) – the jeweller in question specialises in engagement jewellery and her work is definitely my style, and I told DP I loved it. And, I kind of felt that maybe he was about to propose... it was my birthday recently and I really thought that I might be getting a ring.. but obviously didn't. I didn't say anything, but can't help but feel disappointed.

I don't know what to do. I've told him that it's important to me. He knows why. I'm not asking for anything ridiculous. I honestly don't even care if there is a ring, I just want the security of being recognised as being each other's family. I don't want to become that girl that forces a partner to get married, but after 10 years and approaching 40 I also don't want to be in this situation. I feel a bit stupid and pathetic even writing this but I just feel like I need some advice.

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 20/01/2023 17:42

Here we go again.
So traditional but happy to live together without marriage tc.

Just ask him.
I told mine, I would quite like to be married to him, one of the few people I can tolerate well, so how about we get married. He said, "yeah ok" and there it was. Told people we are engaged, enjoyed the fawning, then started planning.

There was no forcing, no fluffy white bridezilla. Just an adult conversation people who regularly enjoy each others genitals and share living quarters, should be able to have.

Frankly, I always think that women doing all that mental gymnastics about why it should be the guy to propose are 1- martyring themselves, 2-scared he will say no and it will fully uncover different life paths each wants to take.

Just do it. Don't bee miserable wet blanket. Do it for yourself and your future happiness.

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:41

@Tandora Thanks – I think you've put it really well. At some point soon I do need to decide where my red lines are because the past 10 years have gone so quickly, and I'm sure the next 10 will too and (as another poster said) I need to work out what I want from the future. And, if we don't get married / civil partnership then we definitely need to work out the legal stuff / rights as that is what the important part of all this is to me.

OP posts:
MyrtleTheTurtleQueen · 20/01/2023 17:40

well regardless of whether it's big or small – it's not something I want nor is it something I've ever been interested in. In all my posts, I've expressed that my reasons for wanting to be married / in a legal partnership are for the rights that we would automatically have if I were in my home country (in which case I wouldn't be wanting to have this conversation at all). So please don't assume to tell me that I'm 'downplaying' what I want. If anything, I resent being put into a situation where I have to have some kind of legal partnership for my 10-year-long relationship to be recognised if one of us were to get ill or pass away etc

If there was no marriage/civil partnership how would society differentiate between a 10 week relationship and a 10 year one?

It's your dp that's put you in this situation. There's a very easy solution to the legal status question but your dp doesn't want to do it for some reason so before you have the conversation i think you'll need to make a list of pros and cons of whether you want to stay in your relationship if he's honest enough to say he doesn't want to get married. It's not like he's not had long enough to think about it.

Colderthanever · 20/01/2023 17:38

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:30

@Tandora I tend to agree - we just need to have a conversation. I guess the reason I'm putting that off is that I haven't quite worked out what it means if he says he's just not interested in a legal partnership... I don't know if that's a deal breaker for me on a 10-year relationship. Which I guess I need to give some serious thought to and then have that conversation...

Op. He knows you want to get married, he’s fully aware of this, it is not something he is unsure or confused about. He is not forgetting or uncertain. He knows, he is choosing not to ask or marry you . It’s a conscious decision he is making. As is your refusal to deal with it.

you’re scared to hear it. Because when he makes it clear the you will be crushed and kmow if you stay with him you will never marry. He isn’t spelling it out, as he knows you will be crushed and as long as you keep your mouth shut. Why should he do the decent thing and tell you straight,

it’s been a decade. He knows. There will be no marriage

Bellalalala · 20/01/2023 17:37

I voted yabu, because it’s really obvious he doesn’t want to get married. You know he doesn’t but you keep visiting the discussion, in the hope he changes his mind.

Or gives in. If he did propose now, I bet it would be a long, long engagement. And you would still be sat thinking ‘he didn’t ask me because he wanted to. He asked me because he felt he should’ and you won’t be happy.

NibbledSwitch · 20/01/2023 17:36

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/01/2023 17:22

@Untitledsquatboulder

Yes and it’s always these “very traditional” men who are happy having children out of wedlock and then not providing them or their mothers with the legal protection they need.

Funny old world.

This
Please think very carefully about having kids with this man.

Better to find someone who wants the same things as you.

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:36

@Colderthanever well regardless of whether it's big or small – it's not something I want nor is it something I've ever been interested in. In all my posts, I've expressed that my reasons for wanting to be married / in a legal partnership are for the rights that we would automatically have if I were in my home country (in which case I wouldn't be wanting to have this conversation at all). So please don't assume to tell me that I'm 'downplaying' what I want. If anything, I resent being put into a situation where I have to have some kind of legal partnership for my 10-year-long relationship to be recognised if one of us were to get ill or pass away etc.

I obviously do need to have a proper conversation with my partner, but first need to work out what my expectations are around that conversation and what it means if it isn't something he wants.

OP posts:
MeridianB · 20/01/2023 17:36

Untitledsquatboulder · 20/01/2023 17:17

It's OK to want to be married.
It's OK for marriage to be very important to you.
It's OK for it to be a dealbreaker.
It's OK for you to sit him down and spell this out. No more hinting and coy little remarks. Forget the last 10 years, what do you want from the next 10?

Great post.

And of course marriage brings some legal protection and rights. If you decide to stay with him but not marry, it's really worth addressing these.

Tandora · 20/01/2023 17:35

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:25

@Tandora Sorry - re-reading that part is a bit cringe and I didn't mean it to come across as offensive. It was a bad way of expressing that we know more than one couple where one partner was very keen on marriage and the other wanted to wait but felt pressured into it, and they have ended in divorce – and I don't want to enter into a marriage / civil partnership because my partner feels forced or pressured into it. But likewise I don't want to just hang around waiting for something that is important to me.. so the only place that leaves us is for me to initiate an actual conversation and talk about it like the grown ups that we (apparently) are 😬I just am not sure how to approach that conversation if it ends up with him saying it's definitely not something he wants – I know it's important to me, but am I prepared to walk away from a ten year relationship??

❤️ that’s all understandable. I don’t think you need to decide right now what your red lines are. Maybe just start with that really honest chat. No demands, no judgement, just this is what I really want, the status quo is starting to make me feel unhappy. How are you feeling / where are you with this? Etc. then hear what he says and take it from there..

MeridianB · 20/01/2023 17:34

Ihatethenewlook · 20/01/2023 16:59

The simple answer is that he clearly doesn’t want to get married. Otherwise you’d be married. He knows you’re waiting for a proposal, but he hasn’t done it. If you don’t want to be the sort of person to force his hand, you’ll just have to decide if being with him is worth not being married.

Sorry OP, I agree with this. We talk a lot on MN about people 'showing you who they are'. Your DP has shown you he doesn't want to get married. You need to decide if that's a dealbreaker for you.

Invisiblewoman23 · 20/01/2023 17:32

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/01/2023 17:22

@Untitledsquatboulder

Yes and it’s always these “very traditional” men who are happy having children out of wedlock and then not providing them or their mothers with the legal protection they need.

Funny old world.

Yes it is very strange the traditions they cherry pick. Probably expect the child to have their name too without giving the mother said surname also. Tradition. A funny old thing.

dontleaveitthere · 20/01/2023 17:30

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:25

@Tandora Sorry - re-reading that part is a bit cringe and I didn't mean it to come across as offensive. It was a bad way of expressing that we know more than one couple where one partner was very keen on marriage and the other wanted to wait but felt pressured into it, and they have ended in divorce – and I don't want to enter into a marriage / civil partnership because my partner feels forced or pressured into it. But likewise I don't want to just hang around waiting for something that is important to me.. so the only place that leaves us is for me to initiate an actual conversation and talk about it like the grown ups that we (apparently) are 😬I just am not sure how to approach that conversation if it ends up with him saying it's definitely not something he wants – I know it's important to me, but am I prepared to walk away from a ten year relationship??

Jesus wept. You're an adult right?

If you can't have a conversation about marriage then maybe you shouldn't be doing it

The question isn't whether you want to throw away ten years. The question is whether marriage is more important to you than this relationship.

I would also take into account that he has known for YEARS how important this is to you. And it doesn't seem to bother him.

Bread crumbing you with jewellers you might like. Yeah. That's unbelievably cruel

But I see you've 'liked' the one comment from a poster saying she waited for her traditional partner to propose. So hey knock yourself out.

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:30

@Tandora I tend to agree - we just need to have a conversation. I guess the reason I'm putting that off is that I haven't quite worked out what it means if he says he's just not interested in a legal partnership... I don't know if that's a deal breaker for me on a 10-year relationship. Which I guess I need to give some serious thought to and then have that conversation...

OP posts:
TellMeTheTruthTheWholeTruth · 20/01/2023 17:29

Hold out until Valentines Day.

If he hasn't proposed by then you need to ask him or make other plans about your future!

MyrtleTheTurtleQueen · 20/01/2023 17:29

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/01/2023 17:19

@MickeyMouseShithouse

I too was beat down by thou wise independent women-MN’s who we’re baffled by my lack of proposal to him. So I asked if (after he’d already eventually asked me) what he would have thought if I’d proposed to him and he said he would say no and wouldn’t have liked it, because if we were going to get married he would want to be the one to ask.

Congratulations for waiting it out and not expressing your needs. And well done for landing a caveman. Have a medal.

Some of us just don’t want to be married to someone who doesn’t think women have a right to any agency in a life-changing decision. Shoot us.

Yes, quite.

If your dp was that traditional, he would have proposed ages ago. It's not traditional to cohabit for 10 years before marriage. A few decades ago you'd have been married within a couple of years.

Colderthanever · 20/01/2023 17:28

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:26

@Colderthanever haha actually a big wedding event with friends sounds absolutely awful to me, so I'm not downplaying anything! My ideal 'wedding' would be eloping and having a civil partnership somewhere on holiday with just the two of us!

I didn’t say big, I said joyous.

I think you’re not asking him and having the conversation as you are scared he will say no. That’s also why you’re trying to make it as easy as possible for him. Give him less reason to say no

but when he says no you need to deal with it. All hope is lost. So you don’t ask. And keep hoping.

crochetmonkey74 · 20/01/2023 17:28

Theeyeballsinthesky · 20/01/2023 17:11

Gently OP If he knows exactly how you feel & he hasn’t proposed or discussed marriage with you like a grownup then it’s obvious he doesn’t want to marry you

question is whether that’s a deal breaker for you

This OP
I wasted 7 years like this exactly. You have already asked him really. And he has ignored you for years. You have to get out

Reindear · 20/01/2023 17:28

I would give it til after Valentine’s Day incase he’s going for a corny valentines proposal. If still nothing then you need to say you want to get married and it is really important to you - can we set a date please. If not then maybe you shouldn’t be together?

Yayyayitsaholiholiday · 20/01/2023 17:27

I told my BF (at the time) I wouldn’t move in without a ring on my finger and a wedding date in the diary.
He got me a ring within a fortnight and we were married just over 2 years later (covid got in the way a bit).

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:26

@Colderthanever haha actually a big wedding event with friends sounds absolutely awful to me, so I'm not downplaying anything! My ideal 'wedding' would be eloping and having a civil partnership somewhere on holiday with just the two of us!

OP posts:
Colderthanever · 20/01/2023 17:26

I too was beat down by thou wise independent women-MN’s who we’re baffled by my lack of proposal to him. So I asked if (after he’d already eventually asked me) what he would have thought if I’d proposed to him and he said he would say no and wouldn’t have liked it, because if we were going to get married he would want to be the one to ask

its just so depressing reading these stories.

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 17:25

@Tandora Sorry - re-reading that part is a bit cringe and I didn't mean it to come across as offensive. It was a bad way of expressing that we know more than one couple where one partner was very keen on marriage and the other wanted to wait but felt pressured into it, and they have ended in divorce – and I don't want to enter into a marriage / civil partnership because my partner feels forced or pressured into it. But likewise I don't want to just hang around waiting for something that is important to me.. so the only place that leaves us is for me to initiate an actual conversation and talk about it like the grown ups that we (apparently) are 😬I just am not sure how to approach that conversation if it ends up with him saying it's definitely not something he wants – I know it's important to me, but am I prepared to walk away from a ten year relationship??

OP posts:
Colderthanever · 20/01/2023 17:24

I feel so sad when I read these downgrading of expectations, an almost desperate attempt to make it palatable to the man, I don’t want a ring, a small civil ceremony. Anything. Just marry me.instead of being honest and saying I’d love a joyous event with my friends and family, a beautiful ring. So the choice Is make it as small as possible to hope to get it over the line.

he doesn’t want to marry you. If you can’t have an honest conversation with him and you need to downgrade it so far it’s Just signing a piece of paper in the hope he will agree, then it’s not a good relationship. Neither of you are being honest with the other.

mrsbyers · 20/01/2023 17:22

I asked my husband , I was 40 and didn’t want another living together relationship - I even put a modest engagement ring on my credit card which he paid off and we married 5 months later

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/01/2023 17:22

@Untitledsquatboulder

Yes and it’s always these “very traditional” men who are happy having children out of wedlock and then not providing them or their mothers with the legal protection they need.

Funny old world.