Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed DP hasn't proposed

207 replies

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 16:55

I feel a bit pathetic even writing this... but I can't help but be disappointed and sad.

DP and I have been together for 10 years. For the past 4 years or so I have mentioned that I would like to get married – I have also made clear that I'm not interested in a big, fancy wedding and that I'd be just as happy with civil service or us eloping somewhere just the two of us (nothing elaborate, just a holiday with a civil service somewhere). I have discussed with him that it would make me feel more secure as 'de facto' is not a thing here in the UK (I'm from Aus where couples have the same rights as a married couple after cohabitating for a certain number of years). This isn't something I've brought up constantly – maybe once or twice a year. I'm worried that if we were to have kids, or one of us were ill, or were to pass away that everything would be that much more difficult as we wouldn't be seen as being 'family'. For context, we don't have kids – we were TTC but are going through fairly significant fertility issues.

He has not been that keen whenever I have brought marriage up (his parents did not have a happy marriage, and he has had several friends divorce shortly after getting married), but last year asked if it was something I was still interested in. I said it definitely was. He asked again a few months later. Towards the end of the year, he told me about a jeweller he had seen on IG whose work he thought I would like (which is a pretty unusual thing for him to do) – the jeweller in question specialises in engagement jewellery and her work is definitely my style, and I told DP I loved it. And, I kind of felt that maybe he was about to propose... it was my birthday recently and I really thought that I might be getting a ring.. but obviously didn't. I didn't say anything, but can't help but feel disappointed.

I don't know what to do. I've told him that it's important to me. He knows why. I'm not asking for anything ridiculous. I honestly don't even care if there is a ring, I just want the security of being recognised as being each other's family. I don't want to become that girl that forces a partner to get married, but after 10 years and approaching 40 I also don't want to be in this situation. I feel a bit stupid and pathetic even writing this but I just feel like I need some advice.

OP posts:
Nosleepforthismum · 20/01/2023 20:54

I understand OP. I was with a man for 11 years, we spoke about marriage and kids “someday” and I was exactly the same. I didn’t want the big wedding or any kind of fuss, but it was important to me to have the legal protection that comes with marriage, to have a family name that we all share etc. Looking back, I can’t believe I wasn’t more assertive and I let the relationship drag on for such a long time without actually pinning him down and demanding a proper answer. Obviously it all came out in a big argument and he didn’t want to marry me or commit to me in that way. Happy to have kids with me but didn’t want to be “tied down” by marriage. Prick.

Needless to say the relationship ended pretty quickly after that and I met my now DH six months later and married him three years after that with a gorgeous DS and another on the way. Don’t fall for the sunk cost fallacy of staying with this man because you’ve invested so much time in him. Focus on what you actually want and if marriage is important to you, you must be prepared to walk away.

WineDup · 20/01/2023 20:38

NovaNomen · 20/01/2023 20:06

To those suggesting that there is, there is NO different system today in Scotland. Marriage or civil partnership are the only legally recognised arrangements. Years ago, there was something else, but the people to which that still applies are vanishingly scarce. Don't kid yourselves, or be kidded.

To anyone talking about next of kin, this is not a legally-recognised relationship.
(Nor is common-law husband or wife.) Various hospitals - out of kindness to people in tragic circumstances - will be flexible as to visiting etc but marriage or civil partnership are the only legally-binding categories.

www.howellslegal.co.uk/news/post/Next-of-Kin-What-are-my-Rights

I'd also give your DP an ultimatutm -
marriage or civil partnership in 6 months, or look elsewhere. Why does he get to make all the decisions for your JOINT future? Why are you - why is anyone - 'waiting for him to propose'?

I’ll take advice from my actual lawyer rather than you, thanks. I mentioned that it MAY be different in Scotland as I am not aware of the rules in England. Your own link states that next of kin can be anyone so I’m not sure you are proving what you think you are, lol.

crochetmonkey74 · 20/01/2023 20:28

This has turned into a debate about marriage but having been there, its really not. He doesn't want to marry you. You have to tackle it

Penguinsista · 20/01/2023 20:12

If you see yourself as wanting to be married at some time in the future tell him this. Say you want to be married within 6 months and if he doesn't see his future as being married to you then end the relationship and start again. Don't go along with not being married if it's what you want in life.

NovaNomen · 20/01/2023 20:06

To those suggesting that there is, there is NO different system today in Scotland. Marriage or civil partnership are the only legally recognised arrangements. Years ago, there was something else, but the people to which that still applies are vanishingly scarce. Don't kid yourselves, or be kidded.

To anyone talking about next of kin, this is not a legally-recognised relationship.
(Nor is common-law husband or wife.) Various hospitals - out of kindness to people in tragic circumstances - will be flexible as to visiting etc but marriage or civil partnership are the only legally-binding categories.

www.howellslegal.co.uk/news/post/Next-of-Kin-What-are-my-Rights

I'd also give your DP an ultimatutm -
marriage or civil partnership in 6 months, or look elsewhere. Why does he get to make all the decisions for your JOINT future? Why are you - why is anyone - 'waiting for him to propose'?

sunseaandme · 20/01/2023 20:00

Do you think he's perhaps waiting to propose at a time you wouldn't expect?

BloodAndFire · 20/01/2023 19:52

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:49

A good example is my mum. Dad left and she found a new guy. It's been 8 years and they've never married and have no intention because they don't want to share finances. Same love, just no financial complications.

But OP does want to share finances. She wants to have children with him (and would be very unwise to do that without getting married). Your mum is presumably on a second (or more) significant relationship, with adult children. Totally different situation

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:49

Patanat · 20/01/2023 19:40

I guess what I’m saying is that if I were in a long term relationship that I was fully committed to and I knew marriage was very important to the other half of that relationship, I’m finding it hard to imagine why I would be so averse to it. It is, as you say, a piece of paper. So why not sign that piece of paper if it means so much to a partner you’re committed to?

As I say, I can’t think of a reason other than a lack of commitment. Emotionally, a lack of wanting to get into the legal obligations or both.

But even if there is some meaningful reason that he is strongly averse to marriage while being solidly in a relationship with the op, this bloke should be honest and say it. He’s toying cruelly with her feelings, hopes and confidence. That’s enough in itself to say this situation needs to be resolved one way or another.

A good example is my mum. Dad left and she found a new guy. It's been 8 years and they've never married and have no intention because they don't want to share finances. Same love, just no financial complications.

Patanat · 20/01/2023 19:40

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:24

OK, so tell me a good reason for marriage.
Because SHE wants it isn't exactly a one either.

She wants it so he should bend, is just as good an argument as he doesn't want it so why is she pushing.

The relationship has lasted this long without a bit of paper.

I guess what I’m saying is that if I were in a long term relationship that I was fully committed to and I knew marriage was very important to the other half of that relationship, I’m finding it hard to imagine why I would be so averse to it. It is, as you say, a piece of paper. So why not sign that piece of paper if it means so much to a partner you’re committed to?

As I say, I can’t think of a reason other than a lack of commitment. Emotionally, a lack of wanting to get into the legal obligations or both.

But even if there is some meaningful reason that he is strongly averse to marriage while being solidly in a relationship with the op, this bloke should be honest and say it. He’s toying cruelly with her feelings, hopes and confidence. That’s enough in itself to say this situation needs to be resolved one way or another.

Pyewhacket · 20/01/2023 19:40

IMO, marriage is one of those things, like having children, where you have to be 100% certain you are doing the right thing and it's what you want too because you can't get married just to please somebody else. Also, marriage puts any assets you have at risk. If those are significant assets then you'd be insane to entertain it.

BloodAndFire · 20/01/2023 19:38

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:36

Big woop. That's hardly an incentive. It's still his choice and he has just as much right to a no as she does to a yes. If he doesn't fancy tax perks, still his choice. Doesn't mean he loves her any less, and to throw away a 10 year relationship over day and a signature is silly.

You asked:

so tell me a good reason for marriage.

I sent you a link to an entire web page of excellent reasons.

That's hardly an incentive

I mean, OK. Saving hundreds of thousands of pounds and having legal protection would be an incentive for many people, but sure, you do you.

It's still his choice and he has just as much right to a no as she does to a yes

Who said anything otherwise?

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:36

Big woop. That's hardly an incentive. It's still his choice and he has just as much right to a no as she does to a yes. If he doesn't fancy tax perks, still his choice. Doesn't mean he loves her any less, and to throw away a 10 year relationship over day and a signature is silly.

DietCock · 20/01/2023 19:32

Btw, I have a long-term partner now, and nfw would I marry him. What's mine is my children's in law, and nobody else's.

BloodAndFire · 20/01/2023 19:32

DietCock · 20/01/2023 19:31

@ConfusedFlamingo All I can say is that I married the great love of my life and had children with him. We are now divorced, and marrying him was the best move I ever made. I would have been fucked under UK law if we had not been married, and so would our children. Stop thinking about proposals, rings, who's doing the proposing etc. Marriage is a legal contract. My ex husband and I got married with two witnesses from the register office. The whole thing was over in 15 mins. It was purely a legal transaction. That's all it needs to be.

100% this.

See it for what it is and make an intelligent, informed, adult decision on that basis.

All this shit about rings and dresses etc. is meaningless nonsense.

Eatentoomanyroses · 20/01/2023 19:31

I’d just say that you’d like to be married and if that’s not something he wants you don’t want to continue. Then act on it. Move out or he moves out.

DietCock · 20/01/2023 19:31

@ConfusedFlamingo All I can say is that I married the great love of my life and had children with him. We are now divorced, and marrying him was the best move I ever made. I would have been fucked under UK law if we had not been married, and so would our children. Stop thinking about proposals, rings, who's doing the proposing etc. Marriage is a legal contract. My ex husband and I got married with two witnesses from the register office. The whole thing was over in 15 mins. It was purely a legal transaction. That's all it needs to be.

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/01/2023 19:29

@C1N1C

The relationship has lasted this long without a bit of paper.

It has lasted because the DP gets to have his cake and eat it and the OP hasn’t rocked the boat. Not because it’s some great romance.

Grimly sticking something out which doesn’t deliver what you want isn’t what I would want.

MissyB1 · 20/01/2023 19:29

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:24

OK, so tell me a good reason for marriage.
Because SHE wants it isn't exactly a one either.

She wants it so he should bend, is just as good an argument as he doesn't want it so why is she pushing.

The relationship has lasted this long without a bit of paper.

He doesn’t have to “bend to her will” at all, don’t be ridiculous! He’s absolutely free to tell the truth and say “I don’t want to marry you”. Then she will know exactly where she stands and can make a choice.

Twattergy · 20/01/2023 19:27

Say that you are confused by your past conversations about marriage. That you'd assumed it would happen by now. Say that you want to be married (not engaged) during 2023 because it is important to you. See what he says.

BloodAndFire · 20/01/2023 19:25

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:24

OK, so tell me a good reason for marriage.
Because SHE wants it isn't exactly a one either.

She wants it so he should bend, is just as good an argument as he doesn't want it so why is she pushing.

The relationship has lasted this long without a bit of paper.

www.unbiased.co.uk/discover/personal-finance/family/getting-married#:~:text=One%20advantage%20is%20that%20spouses,of%20you%20were%20to%20die.

Lizziet64 · 20/01/2023 19:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

honestlove · 20/01/2023 19:24

Your thought that you don't want to be "that girl that forces their partner to get married" is the main problem from what I can see

With that mindset no doubt he isn't proposing you cause he can subconsciously sense your fear.

Have the mindset that it's well within your rights to hope and expect and ask for marriage.

Nothing about being "that girl" I am sure this is some crazy idea propagated no doubt by ill intentioned men themselves

C1N1C · 20/01/2023 19:24

Patanat · 20/01/2023 18:37

Whether or not it’s necessary for everyone, the op clearly wants to get married and her partner knows it. This isn’t a situation where both are indifferent to the idea. I’d find it very hurtful to know that my partner was withholding marriage in the full knowledge I wanted it and without good reason. And what could a good reason be? ‘Not fancying it’ doesn’t really cut it when you know your partner is keen (and you’re sending out mixed messages about your intentions). I can’t actually imagine any that doesn’t boil down to simply not wanting to be with that person enough or not wanting to share what you have with them.

OK, so tell me a good reason for marriage.
Because SHE wants it isn't exactly a one either.

She wants it so he should bend, is just as good an argument as he doesn't want it so why is she pushing.

The relationship has lasted this long without a bit of paper.

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/01/2023 19:20

ConfusedFlamingo · 20/01/2023 18:48

@BloodAndFire I was always of the opinion that if a couple is living together for a substantial period of time then they deserve those rights automatically... so I do tend to agree with the concept of de facto (although thinking about it now, two years does seem to be quite a short period of time.. I've had a few terrible 2-year relationships in my 20s! I would probably say 5+ years).

I really don't agree with this.

Marriage should be a choice. At heart it's a financial contract which protects the interests of the financially weaker spouse and obviously is a really good idea if you want to take time off to raise children or your ability to work is going to be limited for some other reasons. It has lots of other ancillary benefits to do with things like inheritance and tax. But fundamentally its an insurance policy and has to be entered into willingly rather than by default.

It works really well for some people but is disastrous for others.

Marriage for me would be a nightmare: I'm in a stable and happy relationship with someone and we will probably cohabit at some point but hell would freeze over before I would marry him. I would hate for him to end up owning half of all my assets (and a lot of my daughter's inheritance) simply by virtue of the fact that he's shared my bed for several years.

It's a seductive idea that women who have been economically inactive but in a relationship should be entitled to that but the law would have to be applied equally and that would mean a lot of able-bodied men who don't have childcare responsibilities being able to take half of their partner's assets in a split by virtue of the fact that they've cohabited. It would basically be a cocklodger's charter.

Butchyrestingface · 20/01/2023 19:20

You seem very passive, OP.

Rather than do what most posters have suggested and propose yourself, you're sitting round wasting the best years of your life on a bloke who doesn't appear to want to get married.

And you're not prepared to find out for certain by proposing YOURSELF, because your boyfriend is "traditional" and IF he wanted to get married, he would want to do the proposing himself.

So what? IF I had big ears and a trunk, I'd be Dumbo. It's not gonna happen so no point me planning for a career in the circus.

Propose to him or leave. Or sit around wasting more years on a guy who doesn't want to get married. And even if he DID propose, you'd still have to get him to the altar. Which could take another 20 years of stalling.