Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People should stop blaming young people for not knowing stuff they've not been taught

93 replies

Echobelly · 20/01/2023 16:48

I see quite a lot of social media posts and articles about 'Generation Z don't know how to do X' or 'Gen Z don't know how to behave in an office' or (and this has been going of for years) 'Young people starting their careers lack job skills'

A recent one has been complaining they basically don't know how to use a desktop or computer filing system because they all use phones/apps. Well that's hardly their fault workplaces are still using the stuff most people have grown up with, and that those people have then assumed everyone will know how to use it automatically. Just because 'the kids' are social media savvy doesn't actually mean they're automatically 'tech savvy'.

And with the rules of workplace and flexibility changing, again it's not suprising if some young people misjudge what's OK. I think workplaces may need to spell it out a bit more what might need to be cleared with a manager and what's OK to make a call on. Those of us who've been in the office for decades (sorry, can only talk about office-based work from my own experience) know how to make that call, but someone who's not worked before might not realise. Especially if coming out of uni where, let's face it, some people play fast and loose with their attendence at things, especially now when lots of stuff is available on a recording.

Like we knew how to do everything when started our careers, or it's school/higher ed's task to teach kids how to be 'Marketing executives' or 'Junior content managers' - no employers, that's your job! I do think people are unfair on young people like this.

OP posts:
JustWantedACat · 20/01/2023 20:45

Sometimeswinning · 20/01/2023 20:37

Maybe other generations just weren't as easily upset or offended? Honestly though, work ethic is probably what we learn from our parents. My children will learn from me.

You could turn that around into - maybe other generations put up with too much shit/abuse/harassment (women)/ casual "funny" comments that were sexist/racist/homophobic? All things this generation are less likely to accept as "the norm" like previous but are no doubt accused if being "upset or offended" because they "can't take a joke."

Sometimeswinning · 20/01/2023 20:37

Maybe other generations just weren't as easily upset or offended? Honestly though, work ethic is probably what we learn from our parents. My children will learn from me.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/01/2023 20:36

lieselotte · 20/01/2023 20:06

What do you suggest though, when the retirement age keeps rising? People need to eat.

For them not to coast. Do some work.

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/01/2023 20:32

People have always said these things. It isn’t new.

PeekAtYou · 20/01/2023 20:30

Anybody with half a brain will realise that Gen Z will inevitably not be as good on phones as older people as many use text 99% of the time. That's a shit tonne less practice than us older people.

I know that there's voice notes and video messages but gen z will have used texts much more.

PeekAtYou · 20/01/2023 20:27

It might be because my kids went to comps but the only 16+ teens that I know without a part-time job either go to their other parent every other weekend or have a heavy sport training schedule.

If you go to the supermarkets, shops or restaurants round here you regularly see 16-18 year olds working as did my kids.

I think that older generations always bitch about the younger ones. In time, Gen Z will bitch about Gen Alpha

DerangedViper · 20/01/2023 20:23

Do you really think it was any different a generation ago?

Really?

Or that it's somehow impossible to get stuck in and take charge of your own learning?

JustWantedACat · 20/01/2023 20:17

lieselotte · 20/01/2023 20:06

What do you suggest though, when the retirement age keeps rising? People need to eat.

I suggest they need to step up. They're often in senior positions being paid well, so they need to be doing the job they are being paid (well) to do. Or organisations just need to make it more difficult to retain in these positions if your job performance isn't cutting it. Yes, they may have been there 20 years, but if business is suffering and/or not moving forwards like they need to because Sally and John are coasting until they retire then something needs to change.

JarByTheDoor · 20/01/2023 20:17

I've noticed with my own kids that in an era where people don't have a landline (or use it much if they do), they didn't really know how to politely talk on the phone, like if they were younger and rang a friend's parents, they'd just say 'Hi, is X there?' and not say hello to the parent and ask how they are (obviously, we discussed that when I realised) or they'd answer a phone and say 'I'll just go to Mum' or whatever. When I was much younger than them, I was answering the phone saying 'Hello [phone number] and taking messages. But they haven't had that experience.

Confused But that's pretty normal phone behaviour isn't it? I'm in my late thirties and if I rang a friend as a teenager, or they rang for me, standard intro was "Hi, is so-and-so there?" (sometimes with "It's Sarah/Laura/Emma" added). And if someone calls for DP or me at home now and the other one answers, they usually say "Oh hi, is [whoever] there?" (unless it's close family where there's a relationship with each of us). If one if DP's friends that I don't know that well, whose main relationship is with him and not with me, called to speak to him but went into a whole conversation with me about how I was doing, I'd think that was a bit unusual, or at the very least I'd think it was completely normal if they just said "Hi, is Mark there? It's Tom". And if someone called and it was clearly something I wasn't equipped to deal with, I wouldn't sit there taking a message if I could tell the caller "I'll just go and get [the person they need]". I'd also think it was a bit unusual to hear someone rattle off their phone number on answering the phone, and would be thinking of Victor Meldrew the whole rest of the conversation Grin

JustWantedACat · 20/01/2023 20:09

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/01/2023 19:55

In the organisation I work for, the worst employees are the ones who are quite literally coasting until retirement

They block internal promotion too. If there is no possible way for someone younger on a lower rung to move up, what can they learn? What progression can they see? None. So they either coats themselves or leave and take their valuable (alternative) skills elsewhere.

Absolutely. My line manager (who is in her 50s and became the manager of the team 2 years ago) hired myself (under 40) and another colleague who is 26 onto her team last year which is something unheard of before as the old manager wouldn't entertain any "youngsters" because she didn't think they had enough experience or knowledge. Our "new" team has made a profit for the first time ever and smashing it!
Promoting younger internal staff can be so good for business and really drive things forward. Gone are the days of "you need 20 years experience." A lot of younger workers in their 20s and 30s learn quick, have skills you don't realise until they are given the opportunity and also have the drive for positive change. I'd never overlook a younger employee just because "they're only 26" or whatever!

JustWantedACat · 20/01/2023 20:09

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/01/2023 19:55

In the organisation I work for, the worst employees are the ones who are quite literally coasting until retirement

They block internal promotion too. If there is no possible way for someone younger on a lower rung to move up, what can they learn? What progression can they see? None. So they either coats themselves or leave and take their valuable (alternative) skills elsewhere.

Absolutely. My line manager (who is in her 50s and became the manager of the team 2 years ago) hired myself (under 40) and another colleague who is 26 onto her team last year which is something unheard of before as the old manager wouldn't entertain any "youngsters" because she didn't think they had enough experience or knowledge. Our "new" team has made a profit for the first time ever and smashing it!
Promoting younger internal staff can be so good for business and really drive things forward. Gone are the days of "you need 20 years experience." A lot of younger workers in their 20s and 30s learn quick, have skills you don't realise until they are given the opportunity and also have the drive for positive change. I'd never overlook a younger employee just because "they're only 26" or whatever!

lieselotte · 20/01/2023 20:06

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/01/2023 19:55

In the organisation I work for, the worst employees are the ones who are quite literally coasting until retirement

They block internal promotion too. If there is no possible way for someone younger on a lower rung to move up, what can they learn? What progression can they see? None. So they either coats themselves or leave and take their valuable (alternative) skills elsewhere.

What do you suggest though, when the retirement age keeps rising? People need to eat.

lieselotte · 20/01/2023 20:05

I think there's a reluctance to ask questions now. I don't know if it's a generational thing, or a "I just can't be bothered thing". People just won't do their jobs properly and if they don't know the answer they don't go to a manager and ask. It's infuriating if you are a customer.

On the other hand, managers who say "work it out for yourself" are not helping, and it's not efficient. If you know the answer to something, just tell your colleague, it's much more efficient.

I also agree that employers who allow people to make mistakes and learn from them instead of sacking them, will do better overall, but that's not an age thing.

What I will say is that the younger staff at my employer are really good. I would never have got a job in my field now. They are ridiculously talented.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/01/2023 19:57

JenniferBooth · 20/01/2023 19:27

Seems ok to blame some of the older generation for not being au fait with the tech they didnt grow up with and wernt taught.

But it's OK for the older generation to judge youngsters of their use of the new technology that exists?

I'm not Gen Z or Gen X, no skin in this game, but it's not on to brand all early 20s as Love Island watching instagrammers who wouldn't know what a penguin was or a top loading spin tub.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/01/2023 19:55

In the organisation I work for, the worst employees are the ones who are quite literally coasting until retirement

They block internal promotion too. If there is no possible way for someone younger on a lower rung to move up, what can they learn? What progression can they see? None. So they either coats themselves or leave and take their valuable (alternative) skills elsewhere.

JustWantedACat · 20/01/2023 19:50

In the organisation I work for, the worst employees are the ones who are quite literally coasting until retirement. They are usually in senior positions but just aren't interested in taking on/implementing/enforcing changes vital for the organisation to keep up with rivals and move things forward, mainly because they've lost all drive. They roll their eyes almost at new legislation/new policies, which aren't unnecessary "bollocky" ones but ones which enable things to move on with the times because they "did things just fine before". These changes include things like keeping up with technology and its changes and implementing the changes needed to fulfil the commitment to reduce waste and environmental impact. They just aren't interested (in the organisation i work for) so give me the youngsters any day.

JenniferBooth · 20/01/2023 19:27

Seems ok to blame some of the older generation for not being au fait with the tech they didnt grow up with and wernt taught.

Dolares · 20/01/2023 19:11

We've been trying to recruit at work recently (retail) and we've had a lot of applicants that have no previous work experience due to their age (16-18), which is fair enough, but their application forms are awful.

Also, not answering their phone when we call to arrange an interview and then sending a text message to the store's landline number in reply to a voicemail. Its just a really basic level of communication that people should just know.

Mehmeh22 · 20/01/2023 19:11

StrawberryAnnie · 20/01/2023 17:18

How do you suggest people ( young or not) in new roles know what to LEARN without being given advice/feedback?

Using initiative is important, but guidance from others has always been needed.

Can you be 100% percent sure that your senior colleagues would have described your 16 year old self as perfect?

It’s quite likely they were understanding of your inexperience, and allowed you to develop your skills and confidence without berating you.

They can LEARN the same way I LEARN, which is saying 'I don't know that. Let's find out'. I'm still learning now, in my 40s.

I deal with quite a lot of young people and I agree with PP who said school need to spoon feed their kids....not the school's fault really. Many parents leave the schools to parent their kids when infact it takes a village.

Young people brought up since smart phones don't develop general knowledge because they can find the answer at the click of a button. In the past you had to search, discuss etc which helps to develop your memory.

I'm not saying all young people are like this, but there is a definite shift in taking responsibility and that affects a lot.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 20/01/2023 18:47

It's a big issue I see with graduates and so on. Expecting to be spoon fed knowledge and capability.

This is a good example actually. I remember people moaning about this when I was a teenager - 25 years ago. I hear my colleagues (my age) moaning about it in the next generation too.

It's a bit like my yr13 class going on about how small and rude the year 7s are (eg "I'd never have barged past a sixth former when I was in year 7"). When they were in year 7 the sixth formers of that time moaned about them in exactly the same way.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 20/01/2023 18:42

Older people have always moaned about the younger generation being a bit rubbish. 'Twas always thus and always thus will be.

I think it's because as you get older you tend to have a rose tinted view of your own abilities in youth, and it's so easy to forget the little hints and tips your older colleagues gave you.

KILM · 20/01/2023 18:42

Agree that people lack confidence to ask for help/seek out the answers themselves but this goes across all ages. I'm much more likely to hear 'I was never taught that at school' and then continued resistance to learning from anyone 50+ I'm my job when it comes to anything technical, despite the fact they've had much longer to learn...

Bamboozle123 · 20/01/2023 18:36

YABU for thinking everyone has to be "taught" rather than that they need to identify what they need to learn and seek the answers.

It's a big issue I see with graduates and so on. Expecting to be spoon fed knowledge and capability.

Echobelly · 20/01/2023 18:33

@JustWantedACat - yes, confidence is always an issue. Many young people, whenever they were born, will have been shy of asking for help in the workplace as they not have the self assurance to know asking doesn't make them look bad. A culture that takes a 'there are no dumb questions' attitude will get much more out of ones that moan that young people coming in don't have the exact skills they want fully developed.

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 20/01/2023 18:08

I agree with some of this but I have to say that there is a very clear difference in our workplace between those born before 90 and those after. In fact I’d go as far as saying those born after 1995-2000.
Constantly late with an excuse
Always on their phones
A lot of sickness.
We may just be unlucky but the older staff are very different.