Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think strikes won’t achieve anything in the UK

111 replies

Sunshineseabeach · 20/01/2023 14:07

What are people opinions; In my opinion education and health will eventually become private and the gap between rich and poor will become bigger

OP posts:
renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:19

@noblegiraffe I think you're conflating issues.

Of course everyone benefits from good teachers & nurses I agree with you on that point.

However there is an issue because of the current economic climate; high costs, high tax, low wages & poor services that people who have opportunities will look elsewhere. Some of those will be public sector employees. I have teacher friends in NZ & Dubai & I know through family lots of doctors are going elsewhere

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 15:19

renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:15

But imo one thing Blair did right was not target ‘the rich’. If Starmer makes a huge deal out of taxing the rich and people leave then it won’t be great. That tax burden gets passed down.

What's the "rich", you can't target the true rich as they are already global.

It's also stupid that workers can paid a low wage & then tax is used to subsidise that pay & housing costs.

you can't target the true rich as they are already global.

Yes you’ve got it

That’s the funding Labour is relying on to fix the issue

Which is I agree laughable as other countries are more than happy to welcome them.

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 21/01/2023 15:18

The whole country needs to drag these corrupt politicians out like we did when Thatcher was in power. Hit the Tories where it hurts, beyond contempt for the electorate, corrupt to the core,mass walkout, bring the UK to a standstill.

renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:15

But imo one thing Blair did right was not target ‘the rich’. If Starmer makes a huge deal out of taxing the rich and people leave then it won’t be great. That tax burden gets passed down.

What's the "rich", you can't target the true rich as they are already global.

It's also stupid that workers can paid a low wage & then tax is used to subsidise that pay & housing costs.

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 15:12

Some people don’t seem very alert to the need for teachers and nurses.

It’s also astonishing, this open admission that rich people will be off, leaving the country at the first sign of getting a bonus that is less than ^double their annual salary* because obviously they don’t give a shit about the country, only themselves and their money, but public sector workers should be expected to suck up endless pay cuts because it ‘might drive up inflation’ if we actually paid them not a ridiculous wage, like the ones who might leave the country are on, but a reasonable one.

Rich people don’t care about either the country, or it’s people, but ordinary workers are expected to self-sacrifice over and over and over again for the greater good.

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 21/01/2023 15:10

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 20/01/2023 14:59

Withdrawing labour (striking) is the only real way people have of making their displeasure heard. The only
other solution is mass resignation. Anything else is not hurting employers profits and shareholders dividends. Those to things being affected makes the employers listen to workers demands.

This. I'm not sure what anti-strike people think workers should do instead?

I'm not sure these strikes will do much so we need more strikes, like a general strike. Make an impact.

There is so much wealth in this country, it's just concentrated in the hands of the few who own everything. These owners couldn't generate profits without workers, yet they pretend that giving someone a job is some kind of act of charity. It's not. Workers get the raw end of the deal in the first place and still the bosses want more.

Coldblackcat · 21/01/2023 15:02

@roarfeckingroarr why should they need sympathy to receive better and fair pay? They are workers trying to earn a decent wage not a charity asking for donations.

As a side note I'm a lower paid NHS emploee and I receive UC as a top up, costing the government more then it might to pay a higher wage. I won't be the only person needing to claim. either.

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 15:01

People are blind to needing higher earners paying tax burden.

Blair knew it unfortunately Starmer isn’t as good at taking everyone with him.

Public sector needs to be funded somehow. Labour can do well when it doesn’t try to demonise higher tax payers for votes.

Middle earners pay lower taxes here comparatively. If it gets passed down it won’t be nicer for those people - even if people leaving makes them feel good temporarily.

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 14:55

If the U.K. does lose many higher tax payers when Labour get in I agree it’s going to be tough as tax burden gets bigger for lower earners.

We’re losing teachers and nurses in droves but this is never considered a problem for the lower earners who can’t buy their way out of state education or the NHS.

It’s only when it’s affecting rich people, do rich people pay any attention to this argument.

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 14:54

renonovice · 21/01/2023 14:48

If the U.K. does lose many higher tax payers when Labour get in I agree it’s going to be tough as tax burden gets bigger for lower earners.

If depends on the policies though. DH is a higher rate tax payer but we have a home & dc are in school. Higher taxes aren't necessarily a problem if the burden is equal & services for all are good.

Is he a Labour voter? He may not mind.

But imo one thing Blair did right was not target ‘the rich’. If Starmer makes a huge deal out of taxing the rich and people leave then it won’t be great. That tax burden gets passed down.

renonovice · 21/01/2023 14:48

If the U.K. does lose many higher tax payers when Labour get in I agree it’s going to be tough as tax burden gets bigger for lower earners.

If depends on the policies though. DH is a higher rate tax payer but we have a home & dc are in school. Higher taxes aren't necessarily a problem if the burden is equal & services for all are good.

Ariautec · 21/01/2023 14:17

Sunshineseabeach · 21/01/2023 13:42

Just found out my daughter school have planned 4 days of strikes/loss in education between now and March on the other hand they have sent us 3 letters because we took her out of school for 3 days for a very important family event overseas and keep treating us with a penalty if her attendance fall below 95%.

You are comparing the incomparable. Strike action has government policy to follow. Children attendance at school has government policy to follow.

Unions/DfE/education HR set/agree policy for strike action, in accordance with government policy. Schools have to follow it.

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1128077/Handling_strike_action_in_schools.pdf

The government (DfE) sets guidance for attendance. Schools have to follow it.
www.gov.uk/government/publications/working-together-to-improve-school-attendance

Two sets of guidance, achieving two separate things. Can't compare them.

Rowthe · 21/01/2023 14:11

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 13:55

What’s the demographic like?

Here we have more receiving benefits than paying taxes there’s no wonder we’re feeling the strain.

For my dc I’m happy with London as one option but they know the expense already. They love it as a city but I could see the oldest taking what he wants to do o/s as it seems a degree with good options.

If my kids stay here.

Despite working hard, and getting a professional job as a teacher/ in the NHS.

I will worry how they will pay their bills, will they be able to find an affordable place to live? How will their kids get healthcare or dental care? And what the education system will be like for their kids.

People who are professionals shouldn't have to worry about basics like this. It should be a given if you work full time you shouldn't need benefits/ tax credits or the food bank to feed yourself or your family.

Something has gone completely wrong if NHS workers/ paramedics/ teachers/ postal workers etc feel they need to strike.

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 14:10

Strikes and threatened strikes have been working all over the UK. It depends on whether the employer is reasonable or not.

When your pay is decided by this corrupt, shitty, self-pocket-lining government it seems far less likely to achieve much.

To think strikes won’t achieve anything in the UK
To think strikes won’t achieve anything in the UK
To think strikes won’t achieve anything in the UK
MissyB1 · 21/01/2023 14:09

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 21/01/2023 14:02

Frankly, the public deserve to suffer. The majority have stood quietly at the sides while the tories asset stripped the country, bled public money into private pockets, and decimated public services.

The fact that so many of the public continue to support the government, or at the very least refuse to support the strikers, means they should reap the consequences of their actions i.e., the breakdown of services.

It's just a shame those of us who do support this part of the proletariat have to suffer too because the bourgeoisie and a section of self-loathing workers can't stomach the thought of someone bettering themselves or getting something they've not got.

Very true!

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 21/01/2023 14:02

roarfeckingroarr · 20/01/2023 14:39

They won't achieve anything.

They're also making the public suffer as a result of a dispute between government and employees. Eventually sympathy will run dry.

Frankly, the public deserve to suffer. The majority have stood quietly at the sides while the tories asset stripped the country, bled public money into private pockets, and decimated public services.

The fact that so many of the public continue to support the government, or at the very least refuse to support the strikers, means they should reap the consequences of their actions i.e., the breakdown of services.

It's just a shame those of us who do support this part of the proletariat have to suffer too because the bourgeoisie and a section of self-loathing workers can't stomach the thought of someone bettering themselves or getting something they've not got.

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 13:58

Sunshineseabeach · 21/01/2023 13:54

It is sad but I agree; the UK is going downhill. The UK reminds me now of the country I come from when I was growing up; eventually education, health, postal services became private. They are still a few state schools but for the very poor and education isn’t great so no chances for those kids to get ahead in life. There is a massive gap between poor and rich 😢

If the U.K. does lose many higher tax payers when Labour get in I agree it’s going to be tough as tax burden gets bigger for lower earners.

We could go but I still love London so will try to stay

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 13:55

Rowthe · 21/01/2023 13:49

In this country despite working your arse off and finally getting a professional job there still isnt even a guarantee of basic healthcare or dental care unless you arrange it privately.

My nieces and nephews in Sweden will not have to worry about their education- it is all paid for by the government.

They will not have to worry about getting sick, there is good healthcare.

They wont have to worry about funding private education for their kids.

They will never have to worry about paying their rent as long as they are in a job. Housing is good quality and affordable.

And you dont have to be in the top 10% of earners to be in this position.

What’s the demographic like?

Here we have more receiving benefits than paying taxes there’s no wonder we’re feeling the strain.

For my dc I’m happy with London as one option but they know the expense already. They love it as a city but I could see the oldest taking what he wants to do o/s as it seems a degree with good options.

Sunshineseabeach · 21/01/2023 13:54

Rowthe · 21/01/2023 13:43

YANBU.

I'm making sure my kids will have skills in demand worldwide.

I doubt their future is here in this country.

It is sad but I agree; the UK is going downhill. The UK reminds me now of the country I come from when I was growing up; eventually education, health, postal services became private. They are still a few state schools but for the very poor and education isn’t great so no chances for those kids to get ahead in life. There is a massive gap between poor and rich 😢

OP posts:
renonovice · 21/01/2023 13:52

I'm making sure my kids will have skills in demand worldwide.

I doubt their future is here in this country.

Doing the same here, I think it's their best option.

ProseccoOnIce · 21/01/2023 13:52

I think some strikes may have an impact & more public sympathy eg NHS.

But others such as Royal Mail & rail workers - will have less - since covid, fewer of us use rail or postal services so there is less impact & inconvenience.

Teachers - well, we had long periods of home working/schooling during covid, so again it is not having the same impact or inconvenience.

Rowthe · 21/01/2023 13:49

In this country despite working your arse off and finally getting a professional job there still isnt even a guarantee of basic healthcare or dental care unless you arrange it privately.

My nieces and nephews in Sweden will not have to worry about their education- it is all paid for by the government.

They will not have to worry about getting sick, there is good healthcare.

They wont have to worry about funding private education for their kids.

They will never have to worry about paying their rent as long as they are in a job. Housing is good quality and affordable.

And you dont have to be in the top 10% of earners to be in this position.

Rowthe · 21/01/2023 13:43

YANBU.

I'm making sure my kids will have skills in demand worldwide.

I doubt their future is here in this country.

Sunshineseabeach · 21/01/2023 13:42

Just found out my daughter school have planned 4 days of strikes/loss in education between now and March on the other hand they have sent us 3 letters because we took her out of school for 3 days for a very important family event overseas and keep treating us with a penalty if her attendance fall below 95%.

OP posts:
Sunshineseabeach · 20/01/2023 19:12

Sadly, education will become more funded by parents; this is already happening slowly where schools are asking for more voluntary contributions. State schools in wealthy areas can provide more things as parents are able to contribute more, including the pta activities

OP posts: