Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think strikes won’t achieve anything in the UK

111 replies

Sunshineseabeach · 20/01/2023 14:07

What are people opinions; In my opinion education and health will eventually become private and the gap between rich and poor will become bigger

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 22/01/2023 08:04

Labour did go out due to that winter. One difference is Thatcher won and reduced union power to help resolve the issues and the public thought tg and kept Labour out for a while.

Labour and Tories have different ties / approaches to unions so it was possible for Thatcher.

Nellodee · 22/01/2023 07:49

Strikes bring down governments. Remember how no one would vote labour, because everyone said “We can’t go back to the 70s - don’t you remember the winter of discontent?” Well, this is the year of Broken Britain, and it’s all down to the tories. We change things by voting them out and keeping them out, because this is what they do - every single time.

Fairyliz · 22/01/2023 07:47

xogossipgirlxo · 20/01/2023 14:39

I understand why people strike, but stupid and tone deaf politicians won't come up with sensible solution, I'm afraid. UK became horrible when it comes to distribution of goods. GDP is similar to Germany. Why healthcare is so crap then? Why public services are so crap? Pensions are non existent. Sick pay is non existent. Same for maternity leave. Housing is absolute crap.

Well public sector pay isn’t wonderful, but pensions, sick pay and maternity pay are certainly decent.

Sunshineseabeach · 22/01/2023 07:43

I just don’t trust this government. It is sad that they don’t care about basic rights like education and health. I do feel for people that work on those sectors. What future is there in the UK if education and health is not value snd pay fairly.

OP posts:
Catlady2021 · 21/01/2023 20:38

I’d imagine most people would morally be against banning striking? Isn’t it part of the Human rights act ?

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 20:32

It has to get through the Lords though, and because it wasn't in the manifesto and is clearly terrible legislation, they might have difficulty there.

Catlady2021 · 21/01/2023 20:28

I agree that teachers have become social workers. Sorting out things for kids because no one else is.

The Tories are pushing the anti strike law legislation through soon aren’t they? Angela Rayner was having a debate in parliament a few days ago, meanwhile Grant Shapps just sat there smirking.

The Tories have the numbers to vote it through thought.

I can’t believe they may pass this law through. And it was the Tories that said Brexit was a democracy!

What about the democratic right to strike ?

WineDup · 21/01/2023 19:08

Alwaysgiraffe · 21/01/2023 18:28

Here's the thing. Public sector jobs have had numerous pay freezes over the last 10 years, as a result people are leaving the professions in droves and there is a serious struggle to recruit replacements AND to retain those who still work there. The staff who work in these professions are expected to put up with ever deteriorating conditions as the people who are suffering most are the patients/children/general public. The only way to get a proper message across is through strikes.

The issues in the NHS were not caused by strikes - ambulances were queueing outside A&E before the strikes started, patients were waiting 10+ hours to be seen, people were dying before an ambulance was even sent to them, there were not enough beds and the corridors were full of seriously ill patients as there was nowhere else to put them.

Teachers were leaving and still are in droves - many cannot be replaced as not enough new teachers are being trained and those who are often leave after a few years. Teachers are expected to be parents, nurses, social work and still produce high quality lessons when what little time they have to plan, prepare and mark is eroded covering for missing staff.
In England this is often solved by putting unqualified teachers in front of the class - many parents have no idea that the 'teacher' their child has is actually a cover supervisor or TA. In Scotland there has to be a properly qualified teacher so classes are put together, staff lose planning time to cover and in the last few years its certainly not unheard of to have to put several classes together in the hall, or leave senior classes uncovered (16+)
Some classes might not have had a proper teacher that's not cover for months or even years. Many schools are dropping subjects at secondary since they can't recruit staff for it. And the staff are getting home at 6pm having taught all day, had no planning and prep time, meetings after school and still need to do their marking and prep for the next day.

To be a teacher (in Scotland at least) you need both a degree and a post grad and a year as a probationer (secondary school) to get paid considerably less than you would in industry, to be sworn and assaulted on an all to regular basis, to have endless reams of paperwork to complete and then still have parents bitching that they only had 10 minutes at parents night and that teachers should be responsible for teaching everything from how to tie shoe laces to how to fill in a job application form.

I can't afford to strike, but I certainly can't afford not to strike. If I was 18 again I absolutely wouldn't go down the teaching path and I love teaching. Right now, if something doesn't change I will be yet another ex-teacher within the next couple of years.

Louder for those at the back! There was also chat that they were going to be requiring masters plus postgrad to become a teacher. To attract that calibre of teachers they are gonna need to top out above the current £42k pay award.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 21/01/2023 18:36

@Overthebow if you read the small print with that deal it's terrible.

Being able to change days off at very short notice etc. They'd basically never be able to plan anything outside of work.

Alwaysgiraffe · 21/01/2023 18:28

Here's the thing. Public sector jobs have had numerous pay freezes over the last 10 years, as a result people are leaving the professions in droves and there is a serious struggle to recruit replacements AND to retain those who still work there. The staff who work in these professions are expected to put up with ever deteriorating conditions as the people who are suffering most are the patients/children/general public. The only way to get a proper message across is through strikes.

The issues in the NHS were not caused by strikes - ambulances were queueing outside A&E before the strikes started, patients were waiting 10+ hours to be seen, people were dying before an ambulance was even sent to them, there were not enough beds and the corridors were full of seriously ill patients as there was nowhere else to put them.

Teachers were leaving and still are in droves - many cannot be replaced as not enough new teachers are being trained and those who are often leave after a few years. Teachers are expected to be parents, nurses, social work and still produce high quality lessons when what little time they have to plan, prepare and mark is eroded covering for missing staff.
In England this is often solved by putting unqualified teachers in front of the class - many parents have no idea that the 'teacher' their child has is actually a cover supervisor or TA. In Scotland there has to be a properly qualified teacher so classes are put together, staff lose planning time to cover and in the last few years its certainly not unheard of to have to put several classes together in the hall, or leave senior classes uncovered (16+)
Some classes might not have had a proper teacher that's not cover for months or even years. Many schools are dropping subjects at secondary since they can't recruit staff for it. And the staff are getting home at 6pm having taught all day, had no planning and prep time, meetings after school and still need to do their marking and prep for the next day.

To be a teacher (in Scotland at least) you need both a degree and a post grad and a year as a probationer (secondary school) to get paid considerably less than you would in industry, to be sworn and assaulted on an all to regular basis, to have endless reams of paperwork to complete and then still have parents bitching that they only had 10 minutes at parents night and that teachers should be responsible for teaching everything from how to tie shoe laces to how to fill in a job application form.

I can't afford to strike, but I certainly can't afford not to strike. If I was 18 again I absolutely wouldn't go down the teaching path and I love teaching. Right now, if something doesn't change I will be yet another ex-teacher within the next couple of years.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 21/01/2023 17:08

Catlady2021 · 21/01/2023 15:53

I don’t know the answer but the Tories obviously would ban strikes if they could.

What they don’t realise is, if they in theory banned teachers striking for example, people wouldn’t go into the industry because they wouldn’t have union power.

So there would be even more of a lack of teachers and the problem would get worse.

Banning nurses and teacher’s from striking wouldn’t improve the situation. It would put people off doing the jobs altogether.

I, for one, would leave teaching if our right to strike was restricted any further. I think there are a lot of teachers for whom this strike is a last resort- if there's no response, or a negative response from the DfE I think we will see an even higher % of teachers leaving the profession in the next year or so.

And in 2024 there will be less training places for teachers.

If you have DC who won't have finished secondary school by about 2025, then you really ought to be hoping the strikes do have some positive effect. Even getting the already agreed pay rise funded would be something as it would help massively stretched school budgets and ensure all teachers actually get the pay rise!

Catlady2021 · 21/01/2023 15:53

I don’t know the answer but the Tories obviously would ban strikes if they could.

What they don’t realise is, if they in theory banned teachers striking for example, people wouldn’t go into the industry because they wouldn’t have union power.

So there would be even more of a lack of teachers and the problem would get worse.

Banning nurses and teacher’s from striking wouldn’t improve the situation. It would put people off doing the jobs altogether.

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 15:47

renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:37

@noblegiraffe well I'm certainly not making that argument & you clearly didn't read my post correctly so...

Others on this thread are certainly making that argument and my responses are mainly to them.

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 21/01/2023 15:43

Sunshineseabeach · 21/01/2023 13:42

Just found out my daughter school have planned 4 days of strikes/loss in education between now and March on the other hand they have sent us 3 letters because we took her out of school for 3 days for a very important family event overseas and keep treating us with a penalty if her attendance fall below 95%.

I hope you can see why those are two completely separate issues.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 21/01/2023 15:40

BTW in terms of affording to strike, unions do have hardship funds for those who suffer financial hardship due to the strike.

renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:39

@MarshaBradyo I'm a floating voter, most often voted lib dem but don't really like any party at the moment although won't be voting Tory.

renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:37

@noblegiraffe well I'm certainly not making that argument & you clearly didn't read my post correctly so...

containsnuts · 21/01/2023 15:33

It's the timeing. I appreciate they feel overworked and undervalued, but so do tens of millions of other workers who are struggling on even lower wages and without sick pay, holidays and pensions.

Andrelaxzzz · 21/01/2023 15:31

Winterday1991 · 20/01/2023 14:18

I don't understand how all these under paid public sector employees can afford to strike

Because their forefathers were willing to put up with the pain if short term pain to ensure that future generations benefit as they are doing now.

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 15:30

However there is an issue because of the current economic climate; high costs, high tax, low wages & poor services that people who have opportunities will look elsewhere

Yes, so the argument is made that we have to continue giving tax breaks to the rich, and insane bonuses to keep them around.

While at the same time it is being argued that teachers and nurses shouldn’t be paid more to keep them around even though they are also vital to the economy.

Why can that argument be made for the rich (pay more to keep them around) and be agreed by the government but not for the teachers and nurses whose strike action, according to this thread, will fail?

MarshaBradyo · 21/01/2023 15:29

renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:24

@MarshaBradyo but there are loads of people like me who labour could target. I wouldn't run off if I got less inheritance.

Are you generally a Labour voter anyway? You might not mind paying more inheritance but that’s not always the case.

They have stated how they intend to fund what they want to do. Which is also nuts wrt NHS

It’s frustrating as they have a fairly open remit at next election and there are better options than what they propose.

I think past failure is worrying them and they’re going for safest vote winner, but it doesn’t sound good.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 21/01/2023 15:28

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 15:26

We already got millions in extra taxes just by targeting Nadhim Zahawi.

How many others out there like him are not paying what they owe?

committees.parliament.uk/committee/127/public-accounts-committee/news/175322/hmrc-approach-to-compliance-means-public-purse-is-missing-out-on-billions-in-lost-revenue/

£42 Billion in unpaid tax, apparently.

With £42 Billion, we could sort out health and social care, we could really invest in education, we could invest in things like libraries and leisure centres and youth workers again.

I'm sick of being told there is no money.

noblegiraffe · 21/01/2023 15:26

We already got millions in extra taxes just by targeting Nadhim Zahawi.

How many others out there like him are not paying what they owe?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 21/01/2023 15:26

How do we improve the economy without investing in education? Lots and lots of teachers have left the profession over the last 5-10 years and it is getting harder and harder to recruit new teachers.

This year, the government missed its target for recruiting Biology teachers by 66%. That doesn't bode well for the future of e.g. healthcare or biosciences in the UK. They missed their target for English teachers by about 33% too- how do we compete on a global scale if school leavers don't have good communication skills.

If we don't invest in education, we will end up in a vicious cycle where things get worse and worse- at least now we are talking about this and having conversations about the situation in schools and the lack of qualified teachers etc. As a teacher, I don't feel I can just put up and shut up as education crumbles in front of me.

I worry about the kids coming into my school in Y7- what will their school look like in 5 or 7 years time?

renonovice · 21/01/2023 15:24

@MarshaBradyo but there are loads of people like me who labour could target. I wouldn't run off if I got less inheritance.