Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thinking that these baby assessment (SS) are spectacularly late.

96 replies

LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 10:41

Friend/neighbour is - as I posted months ago - pregnant (again) and due around 21/2.

This baby, as have two prior to this, most likely to be taken into "the system" - BUT, certain assessments need to be done. She is still getting legal help over the adoption of the last one, and what she "wants" (which is I think, annual photos), and now there is of course cross-over of the cases regarding these two babies (last one is now 18 months old and with adoptive parents - finally; it took a while). But she could easily give birth to this one at any moment, and to still be getting assessed, seems so late minute!

They are still saying that they will not be completed, and thus, a decision made, until mid-February. And yet they will be critical of the fact that she has not made much preparation herself.

I have obviously failed with regard to boundary setting - although some ARE respected. I simply cannot turn my back on her - and am slight pissed off at her parents (themselves adopters and foster parents) who do seem to be supportive with this, which is why a lot of it falls on me.

Does anyone else think that this should have been settled - as much as it can be long before now, It would be hard enough on someone without mental struggles (part of why, 1. theses children and taken away from her, and 2. she keeps getting pregnant....) - so being to late with these processes it almost tantamount.

Or any official perspective would be greatly welcome as well.....

OP posts:
2bazookas · 21/01/2023 16:08

Its none of your business.

If you stood back; like her parents have, she might finally
realise there's no more mileage to be squeezed from her pity-party attention seeking -b- pregnancy.

Then she might get sterilised.

Has it occurred to you that by playing the guardian angel supporter, you are in fact enabling her to carry on the feckless irresponsible lifestyle, repeatedly getting pregnant, offloading babies etc? Your sympathy and attention might be what she seeks; the reason she keeps re-enacting her own life story. Another tragic replay of SW wresting the baby from an inadequate mother's arms .

When adoption is delayed for 18 months for a baby removed at birth, it could be necessary for medical /developmental assessment of suspected damage in utero from drugs or alcohol; FASD, or the longterm effects of being born with drug dependency .

SW may be waiting to see if the new born exhibits such symptoms , before making a care plan for it.

As you say, you 've not seen the case notes and don't have all the information SW do. The delays that concern you, may be loud clues to what you're missing.

Ponoka7 · 21/01/2023 15:29

Tandora · 20/01/2023 19:22

What- for the grandparents to take their grandchild in , they would have to cut off their daughter? What kind of a choice is that- so messed up- surely there must be a better way?

It depends on the case. In some cases the parents will get a residence order and contact can happen between parent and child. The plan for contact, boundary setting etc will be set out clearly with all parties knowing what their part is and that if they are broken the child could be removed. Where a parent is a possible danger to the child, in any way, then sometimes that person has to be completely cut off. In the case of addicts they are exceptionally manipulative and it's easy to get sucked in. That Isn't in the best interests of the child. The child is now at the centre of the planning. It's no different than contact not happening with a perpetrator of DV. It took the case of Baby P for it to be realised that the plans centered on the adults and SWs tended to get caught up in their story. Sadly that seemed to be the case in the Logan Mwangi murder. The aim is to make it about the child and the need for stability and safety.

nothingcomestonothing · 21/01/2023 15:06

I suppose that you are one who suggested or supported "disentangling".... Oh, SO much easier said than done, with words on a page.

I understand that better than you think - I had a neighbour a bit like yours. She'd turn up crying saying her benefits were being stopped, while I was in the middle of cooking or bathtime for DC, and have no understanding that it wasn't a good time and I couldn't give her my attention (and the letters always said she was getting a Xmas bonus or something, she'd just panic when she saw the letterhead). Once I said I wouldn't be able to talk for a few days as we were going to Legoland - she rang me at 7am the first day. I had to cut her off, she couldn't manage a normal level of interaction and I couldn't and didn't want to offer what she wanted, though I still feel a bit guilty occasionally.

So I do get it's not easy, what I don't get is asking for help then not doing anything. If you don't change it, it won't change.

LoveMyPiano · 21/01/2023 13:58

And she named me without my knowledge or consent, only telling me after the fact.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 21/01/2023 13:57

I suppose that you are one who suggested or supported "disentangling".... Oh, SO much easier said than done, with words on a page.

If you want to discourage and disparage, feel free. I honestly am not interested.

OP posts:
nothingcomestonothing · 21/01/2023 11:20

You don't know for sure what I did and didn't do, so thank you, please keep out of it with the nastiness

Well you didn't disentangle yourself from the neighbour did you, if you've got letters from her solicitor in your hand and have been named on her paperwork? Despite pages and pages of support and helpful suggestions previously, when you said that was what you wanted. Which is your choice. It's not 'nastiness' to say that other posters might want to be aware that you are unlikely to do anything different, before they give you their time, energy or expertise.

LoveMyPiano · 21/01/2023 10:39

nothingcomestonothing · 21/01/2023 09:34

I have been looking for advice rather than criticism, but realise that is part of the whole Mumsnet experience.

You had pages and pages of advice on your previous threads, you ignore it all. Which is your choice, but I think it's fair for posters to know that, before they spend time and energy offering you help and info which you won't use.

You don't know for sure what I did and didn't do, so thank you, please keep out of it with the nastiness. Which is pointless.

(I posted last year that she was pregnant again, and literally no-one responded. Now, here I am again. Input like yours is absolutely worthless to me, and I don't need it thank you. )

OP posts:
nothingcomestonothing · 21/01/2023 09:34

I have been looking for advice rather than criticism, but realise that is part of the whole Mumsnet experience.

You had pages and pages of advice on your previous threads, you ignore it all. Which is your choice, but I think it's fair for posters to know that, before they spend time and energy offering you help and info which you won't use.

LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 23:28

AFS1 · 20/01/2023 20:26

It’s desperately and heartbreakingly sad, and your neighbour is not unusual in repeatedly getting pregnant following removal of previous children. My heart goes out to her.

That is a kind and understanding thing to say. Thank you 💕

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 23:26

nothingcomestonothing · 20/01/2023 20:45

Oh it's you again. I'd advise posters to have a look at OPs previous threads on her issues with this neighbour, before investing too much energy into this one.

It is quite OK if people want to do that; I am not ashamed of what I have tried to do (reluctantly, I must add), which has included standing as Godmother to the child who has been adopted.
Any nastiness in the other threads was aimed at me, did not come from me.

I did not want to go much beyond mentioning that this was the second time, and that I have had involvement through both. I have been looking for advice rather than criticism, but realise that is part of the whole Mumsnet experience.

I did feel for sure that someone form the other thread(s) would come along with something to say. However minor.

And look, here you are.

OP posts:
Proteinpudding · 20/01/2023 21:08

Cheesetoastiesz · 20/01/2023 21:02

Decisions are made pre birth all the time, foster to adopt placements are just that, decisions are made that a child will be removed at birth.

@Cheesetoastiesz I don't know if you misunderstood my post, but decisions - final decisions by a judge - are not made pre birth at all. Assessments may be done, plans formulated, likelihood assumed, but applications to court cannot be made until the baby is born, won't be an 'urgent' (EPO) hearing unless there is immediate danger, typical wait for an initial hearing in our area is min 3 weeks after application.
The post you quoted was before OP gave updates about the urgency of this case, but regardless a judge wouldn't make a decision pre birth. The local authority plan is just that, a plan, until agreed by the courts.

Cheesetoastiesz · 20/01/2023 21:02

Proteinpudding · 20/01/2023 11:00

What do you expect them to do - make the decision before the baby is born? Take the baby away at birth? Make the decision in week one, when mum is recovering from giving birth?

It sounds like social services are very involved with this mum, every part of that will feed into the assessment. However they would only have a plan for removal at birth if there was the likelihood of immediate danger to the newborn.

The process is horrible but I don't think you've thought through what the alternatives would be?

Decisions are made pre birth all the time, foster to adopt placements are just that, decisions are made that a child will be removed at birth.

scarletandblack13 · 20/01/2023 20:54

Care proceedings can only be issued when a baby is born. You can assess as much as you like during pregnancy but a final assessment that a baby will be permanently placed away from its birth parents will never be made until after a child is actually born. Given the vast majority of countries worldwide do not allow a child's ties with its birth parents to be legally severed via adoption, with no contact, in the way UK law does, that is a very good thing.

nothingcomestonothing · 20/01/2023 20:45

Oh it's you again. I'd advise posters to have a look at OPs previous threads on her issues with this neighbour, before investing too much energy into this one.

AFS1 · 20/01/2023 20:26

It’s desperately and heartbreakingly sad, and your neighbour is not unusual in repeatedly getting pregnant following removal of previous children. My heart goes out to her.

AFS1 · 20/01/2023 20:15

LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 19:15

@AFS1

So, very little hope of the photos?
I thought as much....
And do agree that it shouldn't happen..
But she is very persuasive, and demanding.

It may depend on what risk is or could be posed. If, for example, there has been DV and there’s a risk the perpetrator could have access to the photos it would make it easier for the child to be located. It’s why adoptive parents are advised not to put any photos on social media. There are obviously open adoptions where there is direct contact between the child and birth parents. If there isn’t, it’s very unusual for photos to be given to birth parents on a yearly basis.

Tandora · 20/01/2023 19:22

Ponoka7 · 20/01/2023 11:00

You can't do the assessments early because otherwise the judge will halt things to reassess, especially in the case of MH and/or addiction. Are you reading her files? I wouldn't judge the parents. SS/Court will want permanency plans as quick as possible, which means that the parents would have to decide to cut their daughter off and have a baby until adulthood, as you age that's hard going. She can put her lack of preparation because of the uncertainty to the court. The Judge makes the decisions, not SS.

What- for the grandparents to take their grandchild in , they would have to cut off their daughter? What kind of a choice is that- so messed up- surely there must be a better way?

Mayhemmumma · 20/01/2023 19:22

Legal proceedings can not commence prior to baby's birth. If the local authority are seeking separation they can only apply to courts once baby is born.

LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 19:15

@AFS1

So, very little hope of the photos?
I thought as much....
And do agree that it shouldn't happen..
But she is very persuasive, and demanding.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 19:13

Thank you @AFS1

Yes, the waters are clouded by her continuation of issues with last baby, and mention of her in the Solicitor's letter - but, having re-read, they mention the previous PAMS assessment as reference for their concerned re. the new circumstances.
It is a different Solicitor to last time, so she has no previous knowledge of the people, but obviously (I would hope) files and official communications.

There has been a PLO meeting, but it seems that the Local Authority are certain to apply to remove, in the same way as last time. It just, again, seemed very late to be assigning an independent Social Worker, but (obviously) what do I know....

Of course ---- when a baby is relinquished, it must be (as well as rare) more straightforward, even though my mother apparently umm-ed and ahh-ed for six weeks. But she didn't want him in the first place.

OP posts:
AFS1 · 20/01/2023 18:32

The test for removal of a baby at birth is a high one. The fact that she has recently gone through proceedings where her child was removed at birth makes it highly likely the same will happen again. If there was any chance of a M and baby placement, this would have been pushed very hard in the last proceedings by her solicitor and quite possibly by the solicitor acting for the baby. The risk she and/or her partner pose must be very great and I would imagine there’s virtually no chance of a residential placement this time round.

If this baby is not due until 21st Feb, it doesn’t surprise me that pre-birth assessments are only just taking place. The LA will not have resources to assess pregnant women until birth is imminent, and in this case they will be merely updating previous assessments which won’t take as long.

However, your friend and her baby have a right to assessment and for care proceedings to be conducted fairly. The only way things can be “done” at birth is if she relinquishes her baby. That’s exceptionally rare and highly unlikely from what I‘ve gleaned from what you’ve written about this woman.

I would also anticipate that she is unlikely to succeed in getting photos of her adopted child. I don’t know how she’s being represented in those proceedings. It is highly unusual to get legal aid for adoption applications.

LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 18:18

[Posted too soon]

And yes! @Wednesdayschildhasstubbedhertoe - if parenting capacity is the reason - which it is - then the decision could surely be reached sooner (which was my initial issue). They know who they are dealing with - and she will never change - it is mental disability rather than (as well as) illness.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 18:15

Wednesdayschildhasstubbedhertoe · 20/01/2023 18:02

Is there concern with her as much as him, or is it their relationship they are concerned about? Would she have capacity on her own if she ditched the dad? They give people enough time to make the changes, or enough rope to hand themselves with, whichever way you want to see it. But if they were hoping they would split up, because their relationship or the dad is the issue not their or her parenting capacity without that relationship or his involvement, then they give lots of opportunities to do that. A lot can change in 9 months, or even a few weeks, but if it is her parenting capacity they are concerned with then it does just seem cruel to not come to a quicker decision, yes.

She seems to think that he would actually have more chance of custody - and I highly disagree.

The present assessments are being done on the basis that they are not together anyway (although they "are".

And when I say that I am being supportive, I would not let them keep the baby with them. It would become something else they argue about, and use as a weapon.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 20/01/2023 18:12

LIZS · 20/01/2023 17:55

Is she likely to try to "replace" this baby by getting pg again quickly? Sadly the concerns must be very high to remove both children at birth.

Oh, I definitely think so.
And yes, the concerns were high.... certain things have changed this time around - but as I said to her - just thinking that "it's better because the Police have not been involved so often" is having a very low bar. There is so much more, and the environment - no matter how much support (including from me) and omissions by them can do a different kind of damage to what she sees as "actual harm".
In one sense,. the M&B unit might have been option, but would I suspect be delaying the inevitable.

Her own mother did the same, I think with 10, of which she is one, and all were taken away for foster/adoption.

OP posts:
Wednesdayschildhasstubbedhertoe · 20/01/2023 18:02

Is there concern with her as much as him, or is it their relationship they are concerned about? Would she have capacity on her own if she ditched the dad? They give people enough time to make the changes, or enough rope to hand themselves with, whichever way you want to see it. But if they were hoping they would split up, because their relationship or the dad is the issue not their or her parenting capacity without that relationship or his involvement, then they give lots of opportunities to do that. A lot can change in 9 months, or even a few weeks, but if it is her parenting capacity they are concerned with then it does just seem cruel to not come to a quicker decision, yes.