Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about a teacher

40 replies

Upsettyspaghetti · 20/01/2023 08:31

Advice please. I'm thinking of complaining about a teacher, DD 14. All fairly low level. Very disorganised, forgets to set homework and then cross when it isn't done. Also forgot to tell the class that they were having a test so they all got a lower mark than the rest of the year. Books are unmarked. My worry is that this is a subject that DD loves so don't want her to be put off but also don't want the teacher to take against her. Should I complain and if so to whom? Teacher came across as fairly arrogant and a bit defensive at parents evening. DD and class have complained to form tutor but nothing was done. This is an independent school if that's relevant. Thanks all

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lala1302 · 08/02/2023 01:25

Feedback is given in a whole host of different ways! Teachers also look at books without having to physically write something and then give whole class feedback based on common themes which pupils are finding more challenging. Pupils get verbal praise throughout the lesson and teachers can check on their individual progress via the use of mini whiteboards in lessons etc. I would rather spend my limited time allocated for each class planning a quality lesson and building specific whole class feedback in than writing "Good!" and a smiley face in 30 plus books... Just because things were done differently when you were at school does not mean it's the right way to do it and large bodies of research have since evaluated the effectiveness of book marking. It's very low value compared to other methods we use in every lesson.

SammyScrounge · 08/02/2023 01:10

Nimbostratus100 · 20/01/2023 08:52

depends - teachers can spend their time far more productively than marking books -we are stuck on it a bit in our culture, but other teacher around the world dont do it, and I have heard many teachers in other countries express incredulity that UK teachers do - thankfully, it is becoming less common now

I cannot imagine anything more soul destroying for a child than to work hard at something and not have his work checked and feedback given. How can a child be blamed for not bothering try when the teacher doesn't value his efforts?

MrsHamlet · 21/01/2023 09:48

Don't bother the head with it. They don't need to be involved in every thing. Contact the head of department. If you get no response from
them, then you can escalate it.

pleasehelpwi3 · 21/01/2023 09:45

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/01/2023 07:55

All three of my children have their books marked regularly, I'm really glad their teachers have the time and can be bothered. It seems pointless them writing anything in their books if it's not going to be looked at by anyone but themselves, and there may be errors / valuable feedback

You can bet that their teachers don’t have the time and are marking books when they should be paying attention tto their own children.

Just remember time spent marking is time not spent planning quality lessons, spending time with small groups of children who need a bit of extra help with a topic, or any other valuable activity. Most children don't spend that much time looking at feedback. It's much better for children to mark their own work at the end of the lesson, with the teacher going through the answers. That way you get instant feedback, and the teacher can pick up on any misunderstandings and correct them in the lesson. Then the teacher can review the work; it's so much more valuable than getting marked work returned a week or so later.
Teachers only have a certain amount of time that can be spent working- and that time should be used most efficiently.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/01/2023 07:55

All three of my children have their books marked regularly, I'm really glad their teachers have the time and can be bothered. It seems pointless them writing anything in their books if it's not going to be looked at by anyone but themselves, and there may be errors / valuable feedback

You can bet that their teachers don’t have the time and are marking books when they should be paying attention tto their own children.

Quinoawoman · 21/01/2023 07:48

Ginseng1 · 20/01/2023 15:38

I have never got anything complaining about teachers to be honest. my son has a shocking English teacher. He misses loads classes & just comes across as having no real interest in the subject. When I mentioned this was told no one else ever says this we don't know what you on about etc etc etc I know other parents complain too but he always given the lower streams / weaker kids so no one surprised when they don't do well. It's awful but what else can I do? I have similar with a subject my daughter does teacher was not even at the parent teacher meeting am told she has 'personal problems' misses loads of classes. Am in Ireland it's extremely frustrating because I see the difference a good teacher makes to my own kids learning.

Parents often have odd impressions of teachers that don't match up with reality. I had a parent last year ask for her child to be placed with a particular teacher this year 'because he is strict' - but he is renowned for being the least strict teacher in the school!

Just because you have a patricular impression of a teacher, or have complained, it doesn't mean that there is actually an issue or that it will be upheld.

Nimbostratus100 · 20/01/2023 22:48

Ginseng1 · 20/01/2023 15:38

I have never got anything complaining about teachers to be honest. my son has a shocking English teacher. He misses loads classes & just comes across as having no real interest in the subject. When I mentioned this was told no one else ever says this we don't know what you on about etc etc etc I know other parents complain too but he always given the lower streams / weaker kids so no one surprised when they don't do well. It's awful but what else can I do? I have similar with a subject my daughter does teacher was not even at the parent teacher meeting am told she has 'personal problems' misses loads of classes. Am in Ireland it's extremely frustrating because I see the difference a good teacher makes to my own kids learning.

its often the stronger teacher's given the lower streams

Nimbostratus100 · 20/01/2023 22:46

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 14:50

All three of my children have their books marked regularly, I'm really glad their teachers have the time and can be bothered. It seems pointless them writing anything in their books if it's not going to be looked at by anyone but themselves, and there may be errors / valuable feedback.

I'm glad none of you 'non-marking' teachers work at my childrens school.

how do you know we are not 😂

But seriously, the decision to mark or not is not made at teacher level, and really, marking books is not an effective use of teacher time, or much use to students - hence why more and more schools are cutting back on it.

YOu may want to see your children's books marked, but you are probably just conditioned to think this is what should happen, without actually understanding why, or thinking it through.

95% of the world's children dont get their books marked, and that includes many countries who achieve far higher educational standards than we do.

ANd the culture of book marking is one reason teachers from other countries are often reluctant to be recruited to work here - the UK is quite notorious for it world wide

Citylab · 20/01/2023 22:41

We had an a level teacher that was sacked half way through our a levels - never marking and losing essays, not teaching syllabus properly. I'm glad someone realised or I probably would have failed!

pleasehelpwi3 · 20/01/2023 22:08

Quinoawoman · 20/01/2023 15:11

I would say that the most important attributes of a teacher are:
High levels of empathy
Excellent relationships with the children
High expectations of conduct and achievement
Excellent subject knowledge
Ability to inspire a love of learning
Excellent understanding of pedagogy
Excellent understang of how to support pupils with SEN

My child's teacher has all of that, and I think if you look at the Teacher Standards you will see this reflected in them. So no, she is so much more than 'well meaning' and is absolutely suited to teaching.

If you expect teachers to be super human, I'm afraid you'll be continuously disappointed.

I'm disorganised. My desk is a mess. I get homework muddled up.

I often get stopped in the street years after teaching children by them/their parents/even other family members and told that:
I inspired them to become a /study at university/learn more about_ due to my inspirational lesson/teaching etc
I made them feel ok about wanting to change gender/come out/feel less anxious about _
I was that teacher who understood them/was kind/made them enjoy school.
Year _ was the best year at school, and they still remember it many years later.

I would love to better organised, I really would. It would make my life a lot easier. But I'd take being motivational and inspiring over organised any day.

As for the original post, don't go straight to the Head. Other posters have given good advice about phrasing the complaint as a concern, going to the HoD etc. The points about marking are spot on, all the research backs this up. That said, I would be mortified if I hadn't looked at a child's book all year by late January!

neverbeenskiing · 20/01/2023 16:07

PaddyDingDong · 20/01/2023 12:44

Of course they do. Definitely complain but I'd go straight to the head.

Why? The Head's PA will just pass this straight to the HOD to deal with it.

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 16:05

@Soontobe60

I didn't say I thought it was a great teaching method, where did I say that please? Please do quote me when you find it.

It's the forgetting something you should be doing, then doing it later than you should... just comes across as sloppy and not very professional.

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 16:03

@vintagechristmas

Well it's still done at my child's school, and my other child who attends a different school.

If that's outdated I don't really care.

vintagechristmas · 20/01/2023 16:01

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 14:50

All three of my children have their books marked regularly, I'm really glad their teachers have the time and can be bothered. It seems pointless them writing anything in their books if it's not going to be looked at by anyone but themselves, and there may be errors / valuable feedback.

I'm glad none of you 'non-marking' teachers work at my childrens school.

Me too. I'm hugely glad I don't work at your child's school. Marking is hugely outdated and ineffective in most cases.

No marking doesn't equal no feedback.

Ginseng1 · 20/01/2023 15:38

I have never got anything complaining about teachers to be honest. my son has a shocking English teacher. He misses loads classes & just comes across as having no real interest in the subject. When I mentioned this was told no one else ever says this we don't know what you on about etc etc etc I know other parents complain too but he always given the lower streams / weaker kids so no one surprised when they don't do well. It's awful but what else can I do? I have similar with a subject my daughter does teacher was not even at the parent teacher meeting am told she has 'personal problems' misses loads of classes. Am in Ireland it's extremely frustrating because I see the difference a good teacher makes to my own kids learning.

Soontobe60 · 20/01/2023 15:35

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 14:54

@Quinoawoman

Interesting that you refer to it as parents 'nit picking', implying that it's not something worthy of raising.

Consistently forgetting to set homework?? That's pretty poor, I would be requesting a meeting and he certainly wouldn't get a chance to be arrogant with me.

Homework is not the great teaching method you think it is. Most of the time it’s pointless.

Soontobe60 · 20/01/2023 15:33

Sarahcoggles · 20/01/2023 08:47

Are you kidding? Are you saying OP should pay £10k per year and not expect her child's work to be looked at?!!

Work that a student has done needs to be assessed. That assessment can be carried out in a number of ways. Feedback can vary. A teacher taking a set of books home to mark and providing written feedback that most students don’t even bother to read, let alone act on, is the least effective way of providing constructive feedback.
So no, books really don’t need to be marked.
I think the advantage to a student being in a private school is the much smaller class sizes. This means that teachers can give verbal feedback and support to all students as they need it - at the point of learning. This is nigh on impossible where classes are 30 or more.

Oblomov22 · 20/01/2023 15:30

So, email HoD and see what they say.

Quinoawoman · 20/01/2023 15:28

@Princesspollyyy and as if to prove a point, DD's just come out of school with a little present from the teacher for Chinese New Year - every child in the class got one, paid for and organised by the teacher, but my DD is a coeliac so she has a separate 'safe' chocolate bar just for her. She said 'Mrs X is the best teacher in the world.' 😭😭😭

Quinoawoman · 20/01/2023 15:11

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 14:52

See I don't think that's good enough. I would say organisational skills are a vital part of being a teacher. Also, how can you expect your pupils to be organised if you aren't? Surely you need to be a good role model and set an example?

Sounds like they mean well but they would probably be more suited to something else.

I would say that the most important attributes of a teacher are:
High levels of empathy
Excellent relationships with the children
High expectations of conduct and achievement
Excellent subject knowledge
Ability to inspire a love of learning
Excellent understanding of pedagogy
Excellent understang of how to support pupils with SEN

My child's teacher has all of that, and I think if you look at the Teacher Standards you will see this reflected in them. So no, she is so much more than 'well meaning' and is absolutely suited to teaching.

If you expect teachers to be super human, I'm afraid you'll be continuously disappointed.

PhillySub · 20/01/2023 15:07

Don't complain, ask for somebody to explain why things are not happening the way that you would understand them to.

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 14:54

@Quinoawoman

Interesting that you refer to it as parents 'nit picking', implying that it's not something worthy of raising.

Consistently forgetting to set homework?? That's pretty poor, I would be requesting a meeting and he certainly wouldn't get a chance to be arrogant with me.

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 14:52

Quinoawoman · 20/01/2023 14:42

Makes me sad when people get cross with teachers for having normal human traits like being disorganised or forgetful. I work with a fantastic teacher who cares deeply about the children and works very hard for them but who also has various special needs and struggles to stay on top of the organisational side of things. She is currently teaching my daughter and I couldn't be happier, despite the fact that homework is sometimes uploaded a day or two late.

I can see how getting cross with the kids when they haven't completed the homework would be a problem though. Maybe the defensiveness is because this teacher knows they don't do a great job with being organised despite their best efforts and is sick of parents nit picking?

See I don't think that's good enough. I would say organisational skills are a vital part of being a teacher. Also, how can you expect your pupils to be organised if you aren't? Surely you need to be a good role model and set an example?

Sounds like they mean well but they would probably be more suited to something else.

Princesspollyyy · 20/01/2023 14:50

All three of my children have their books marked regularly, I'm really glad their teachers have the time and can be bothered. It seems pointless them writing anything in their books if it's not going to be looked at by anyone but themselves, and there may be errors / valuable feedback.

I'm glad none of you 'non-marking' teachers work at my childrens school.

Lividity · 20/01/2023 14:45

Exercise book marking (rather than focused marking of assessments) is very outdated. A huge waste of time for limited gain, and from an era when teachers didn’t have the pressures on them that they do now.

Yes, my books were marked in the 80s and 90s. No, my teachers didn’t have the demands on their time or the better research knowledge we have now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread