Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wrong dog

68 replies

Fasthorses23 · 19/01/2023 23:37

I know, he's not a 'wrong dog' in fact he's an absolutely lovely wee boy but he's the wrong dog for his owners. He's a border collie and he's 2 , going on 3 so was bought in lockdown as a pup when said owners were at home all day. They live in a 2 bed semi with a small garden and are now back working full time. They probably want the majority of the dogs care to fall to me now. He's a lovely natured boy but has a lot of issues. He's very nervous, scared of loud noises, has IBS? So limited diet, no recall on walks, pulls when walking on the lead. At my home he pees in the bathrooms so we have to be vigilant about closing doors. He humps cushions and he's absolutely petrified of my grandchild who's 4 so cowers away in a corner ( I'm always in and out looking after and reassuring him) I absolutely 100% know that this is not the dogs fault but everyone keeps saying they shouldn't have bought a dog in lockdown blah blah. He's here now though so what should I do?

OP posts:
dontgobaconmyheart · 20/01/2023 02:26

There isn't any reason that two adults who are capable of working full time can't understand the needs of a dog, or what you're saying to them. They clearly just aren't overly interested because they don't want to spend any time or expense on it and at the moment they've got it set up so they can take advantage of you and let it all fall to you and have no interest in switching that around or taking responsibility.

I'd not treat a parent (or a dog!) like this and I don't think most people would expect someone else to look after the dog they chose to get on a full time workweek basis, whilst not actively looking after it anyway.

Poor dog sounds lovely and is the one that's going to suffer here, and is, but it's owners are letting it down regardless of whether they are your relatives and that's hard to swallow.

They need to at the very least find a dog trainer to start asap in their own time to work on these issues, and a dog walker to provide decent structured walks to appropriately meet the needs of the breed and socialise it. I don't think it's unreasonable to ask them to do this (or indeed ask them to pay a dog sitter a few days a week) and if they say no or don't want to I would tell them I just can't look after it if they won't. It's their responsibility for goodness sake.

HolyZarquonsSingingSeals · 20/01/2023 02:23

You don't have to have this dog in your home. And if I were you, I wouldn't.

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 02:18

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 02:10

Mediumred · 20/01/2023 01:30

Oof! This sounds really hard, poor you and poor dog but I agree your GC is your no 1 responsibility while you have him with you.

I have a nervy lockdown border collie (only just turned two) and she doesn’t like little children. I think I made a mistake in many ways as she is hard work but I love her. I would never leave her alone with little children but she is fully house trained, walks well on a lead and has decent recall after lots of training (novice dog owner). Am also working through the KC obedience levels, she is on fluoxetine and we are looking into agility.

I think if your son won’t give this dog up and you are willing to look into some ideas then what I have found most helpful is

  • classes, it’s not just pups, there are a lot of older and rescue dogs learning and reinforcing their training

  • one to one training sessions to work on specific issues like recall or lead walking

  • tricks - collies are very clever and like to learn new stuff, some helpful books etc

  • toys, my girl loves tuggy toys and outside loves a ball, we can’t let her have one in the house as she is obsessed! Ball outside can help with recall.

  • medication like fluoxetine (you need the vet for this I think) can reduce anxiety. There are over the counter meds too like adaptil but it sounds like this boy is quite nervy and might need vet meds.

good luck, this shouldn’t be your problem but it sounds like it has become it!!! Xx

Thank you for for your post I've just found it in amongst all the crap about border collies and it's really cheered me up. I'm not giving up on him

OP posts:
HandsOffMyCarrierBags · 20/01/2023 02:08

If you’ve got the dog regularly you can probably teach it recall and not pulling. You can also provide lots of puzzles/toys for enrichment and long walks. If the grandchild can give treats that might enable positive association.

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

oakleaffy · 20/01/2023 01:53

FurAndFeathers · 20/01/2023 01:42

@Fasthorses23 please tell them not to neuter him without a behavioural assessment.

removing his testosterone will reduce his confidence and increase his anxiety - it will likely make his destructive, fearful or aggressive behaviours worse or start to emerge.

they must see an ASAB approved behaviourist or they are likely to ruin this dog’s life

Agree 100%.
Castration can make anxiety and fear become much worse.

Poor dog.

He needs re~homing via a BC breed rescue ASAP.

Ponderingwindow · 20/01/2023 01:52

Why? Why is the dog at your house in the first place? This thread makes no sense.

oakleaffy · 20/01/2023 01:49

shimmerbubbles · 20/01/2023 00:44

This is a people problem, not a dog problem.

There's two options:

  1. They sort their shit out and provide a proper home for their dog and train him
  2. They rehome the dog

This dog is definitely not safe around your grandchild, perhaps ever. You simply must put your grandchild first, which means you can no longer care for their dog - and it is not your responsibility to do so.

A very sad situation.

I'm appalled.
How can people be so utterly DENSE and do no research.

A Border Collie is absolutely the worst dog to have as a ''Pet'' if one isn't into training and doing lots of work to keep the Collie happy and active.

Someone I know of bought a BC in lockdown , and the poor dog suffers.

We advised her a BC was absolutely the wrong type of dog, pleaded with her not to get the puppy, but she wouldn't be deterred.

Deeply selfish and the dog suffers.

BC's are hair trigger reactive, this one @Fasthorses23 sounds extremely fearful, and you owe it to that poor dog to re~home to a reputable rescue, but it sounds like the crucial early socialisation was never done {Afraid of everything} and not even house trained?
Jeez.

It's so utterly depressing that people buy and ruin dogs by not socialising them.
The Greeder should never have sold such a dog to an irresponsible home like this.

Poor dog.

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:48

Ponderingwindow · 20/01/2023 01:47

this Is ridiculously simple. Just tell them the dog is no longer allowed at your house.

im guessing the parents of the young child are in no rush to host the untrained dog or to visit the errant dog owners with their child so that will keep the child and the dog separated. It will also keep the dog from damaging your home and from becoming your responsibility in any way. Let them solve their own problem.

Well you'de be wrong then

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 20/01/2023 01:47

this Is ridiculously simple. Just tell them the dog is no longer allowed at your house.

im guessing the parents of the young child are in no rush to host the untrained dog or to visit the errant dog owners with their child so that will keep the child and the dog separated. It will also keep the dog from damaging your home and from becoming your responsibility in any way. Let them solve their own problem.

FurAndFeathers · 20/01/2023 01:42

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:13

I have. Today I told them that his digestive problems and the fact that he's ripping their clothes to bits is probably down to him being bored. To be honest they don't get it. He's getting neutered in a few weeks. I fear that might make him worse

@Fasthorses23 please tell them not to neuter him without a behavioural assessment.

removing his testosterone will reduce his confidence and increase his anxiety - it will likely make his destructive, fearful or aggressive behaviours worse or start to emerge.

they must see an ASAB approved behaviourist or they are likely to ruin this dog’s life

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:42

Mediumred · 20/01/2023 01:30

Oof! This sounds really hard, poor you and poor dog but I agree your GC is your no 1 responsibility while you have him with you.

I have a nervy lockdown border collie (only just turned two) and she doesn’t like little children. I think I made a mistake in many ways as she is hard work but I love her. I would never leave her alone with little children but she is fully house trained, walks well on a lead and has decent recall after lots of training (novice dog owner). Am also working through the KC obedience levels, she is on fluoxetine and we are looking into agility.

I think if your son won’t give this dog up and you are willing to look into some ideas then what I have found most helpful is

  • classes, it’s not just pups, there are a lot of older and rescue dogs learning and reinforcing their training

  • one to one training sessions to work on specific issues like recall or lead walking

  • tricks - collies are very clever and like to learn new stuff, some helpful books etc

  • toys, my girl loves tuggy toys and outside loves a ball, we can’t let her have one in the house as she is obsessed! Ball outside can help with recall.

  • medication like fluoxetine (you need the vet for this I think) can reduce anxiety. There are over the counter meds too like adaptil but it sounds like this boy is quite nervy and might need vet meds.

good luck, this shouldn’t be your problem but it sounds like it has become it!!! Xx

Thank you. I'm so thankful for your support. Xx

OP posts:
FurAndFeathers · 20/01/2023 01:40

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:13

I have. Today I told them that his digestive problems and the fact that he's ripping their clothes to bits is probably down to him being bored. To be honest they don't get it. He's getting neutered in a few weeks. I fear that might make him worse

@Fasthorses23
please tell them do NOT have an anxious male dog neutered without a professional behavioural assessment first!

removing his testosterone will almost certainly worsen his anxiety which is likely to lead to an increase in destructive and aggressive behaviours
they really need an ASAB accredited behaviourist to assess him

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:36

NumberTheory · 20/01/2023 01:01

Your DS won’t take any suggestions from you so you’re basically asking what you can do to make the dog happy while he’s in your care?

If so:
Stop having your grandson round when you have dog. If the dog’s terrified of him then you’re making the poor dog miserable.

Get a trainer and start training him. Give him lots of affection and plenty of exercise. Try and have him as much as possible, eventually your DS may let you keep him.

If your son won’t do it and won’t get the dog rehomed and you want the dog to be happy, you have to do what your son ought to.

My grandchild comes first

OP posts:
Mediumred · 20/01/2023 01:30

Oof! This sounds really hard, poor you and poor dog but I agree your GC is your no 1 responsibility while you have him with you.

I have a nervy lockdown border collie (only just turned two) and she doesn’t like little children. I think I made a mistake in many ways as she is hard work but I love her. I would never leave her alone with little children but she is fully house trained, walks well on a lead and has decent recall after lots of training (novice dog owner). Am also working through the KC obedience levels, she is on fluoxetine and we are looking into agility.

I think if your son won’t give this dog up and you are willing to look into some ideas then what I have found most helpful is

  • classes, it’s not just pups, there are a lot of older and rescue dogs learning and reinforcing their training

  • one to one training sessions to work on specific issues like recall or lead walking

  • tricks - collies are very clever and like to learn new stuff, some helpful books etc

  • toys, my girl loves tuggy toys and outside loves a ball, we can’t let her have one in the house as she is obsessed! Ball outside can help with recall.

  • medication like fluoxetine (you need the vet for this I think) can reduce anxiety. There are over the counter meds too like adaptil but it sounds like this boy is quite nervy and might need vet meds.

good luck, this shouldn’t be your problem but it sounds like it has become it!!! Xx

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:20

Fleabigg · 20/01/2023 00:44

As a minimum keep this dog well away from your grandchild, it shouldn’t even be put in a position where it can be “terrified” by a 4 year old. I wouldn’t even have them in the same room. The way your OP reads about you always popping in to reassure the dog sounds like you’ve left them in a room together but I really hope that’s not the case and I’m misreading it.

No I never ever leave them together. The pup has his own safe spaces in our house and the grandchild is never allowed in unless I'm there

OP posts:
Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:14

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 20/01/2023 01:02

The poor dog. They HAVE to put its welfare first. Their set up is totally unsuitable. They cannot both work full time away from home with a young Border Collie. I'm afraid I would absolutely have to have it out with them as they clearly don't understand that the dog is truly suffering here.

What should I do then?

OP posts:
Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 01:13

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 20/01/2023 01:02

The poor dog. They HAVE to put its welfare first. Their set up is totally unsuitable. They cannot both work full time away from home with a young Border Collie. I'm afraid I would absolutely have to have it out with them as they clearly don't understand that the dog is truly suffering here.

I have. Today I told them that his digestive problems and the fact that he's ripping their clothes to bits is probably down to him being bored. To be honest they don't get it. He's getting neutered in a few weeks. I fear that might make him worse

OP posts:
halfsiesonapotnoodle · 20/01/2023 01:02

The poor dog. They HAVE to put its welfare first. Their set up is totally unsuitable. They cannot both work full time away from home with a young Border Collie. I'm afraid I would absolutely have to have it out with them as they clearly don't understand that the dog is truly suffering here.

NumberTheory · 20/01/2023 01:01

Your DS won’t take any suggestions from you so you’re basically asking what you can do to make the dog happy while he’s in your care?

If so:
Stop having your grandson round when you have dog. If the dog’s terrified of him then you’re making the poor dog miserable.

Get a trainer and start training him. Give him lots of affection and plenty of exercise. Try and have him as much as possible, eventually your DS may let you keep him.

If your son won’t do it and won’t get the dog rehomed and you want the dog to be happy, you have to do what your son ought to.

Triflenot · 20/01/2023 00:57

Sorry you are in this situation OP, it sounds very difficult.
I would tell your son the facts as you have laid them out here, and ask him to find a solution.
Hopefully he will come to the decision to rehome the dog, but I wouldn’t leap to suggest it yourself, as then it may be blamed on you.

KettrickenSmiled · 20/01/2023 00:51

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 00:20

Sorry just to clarify. My son and his wife bought the pup. They don't have any kids. Thanks for all your replies

So ... your grandchild is from another of your children?
And when you are expected to dogsit, you sometimes have that grandchild at the same time?

You are going to have to refuse to do this in future. You CANNOT risk this, with a nervous, reactive, poorly trained & under-worked dog.

Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 00:50

Fleabigg · 20/01/2023 00:44

As a minimum keep this dog well away from your grandchild, it shouldn’t even be put in a position where it can be “terrified” by a 4 year old. I wouldn’t even have them in the same room. The way your OP reads about you always popping in to reassure the dog sounds like you’ve left them in a room together but I really hope that’s not the case and I’m misreading it.

I never leave them together. The dog is a nervous wreck around my gc so he always has a safe quiet space alone but he's not my dog and I don't know what to do

OP posts:
Fasthorses23 · 20/01/2023 00:45

Thank you so much FUR and FEATHERS

OP posts: