Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Maintenance Issue

143 replies

Throwaway0912 · 19/01/2023 23:16

Name change as don't want this linked back or picked up by The Sun.

Looking for some outside perspective on this as I think we've got overly emotional.

Background info
DH has a child (11) from a previous short, casual relationship. Child maintenance by private arrangement since birth, currently £500pcm and has been for 2-3 years now. He uses the calculator as a guideline and rounds up to an easy number.

Child's mum got in touch and said she's struggling and needs CMS increased to £700.

The issue is, in the last couple of years, we've had children and DH has dropped hours to reduce our childcare bill. He was the higher earner initially, but I then overtook him and his job is more flexible so it made sense for our circumstances. The CMS was never reduced, wasn't really considered because we work from one pot, it's a non-negotiable outgoing, it was just left as it was. However, based on his current situation, when he checked the calculator said he should be paying around £330.

He got back to child's mum and said he can't increase to £700, he'd need to stay at £500 and then reassess in September when our childcare reduces. All hell has broken loose.

He's now saying screw it, go through CMS and pay the £330.

Child's mum is saying it needs to be £700 or she's "taking it further".

I'm just lost on what to do. I know it's not my issue to sort but he's my family and we're a team, I'm also a mother and don't like to think of another mother struggling. AIBU for wanting to push for it to remain at £500? Or should I step back and leave him to his knee jerk reaction of the CMS route? Is there a middle ground we've not considered?

OP posts:
rwalker · 20/01/2023 07:11

RedHelenB · 20/01/2023 07:06

Why should she come back crawling? Has the father crawled to her given that she is doing most towards bringing up THEIR child.

The obvious thing is just to say, look when financially things improve I'll look to increase it. There should be no element of " punishment" in it.

Going round throwing threats about then finding out your child will loose out because of her threats
then yes you would have to crawl back so her child doesn’t loose out

tbh isn’t the first thing you’d check how much you’d be entitled to before kicking off

rwalker · 20/01/2023 07:07

leave her to it the only person who’s going to loose out is the child if she carries on
doubt any parent would do this
once she’s exhausted her threats she’ll probably be more reasonable to deal with

RedHelenB · 20/01/2023 07:06

climbthathill129 · 20/01/2023 01:58

Everyone seems to be missing the point here.

She can't kick off because he won't increase it further than he should be paying and it's great that he has always paid more than he needs to.

If she keeps being a cow about it, then yes go directly through the csa and it will be reduced right down to the £330.
Serves her right for being a cow and making demands of your DH.

You can then make a decision if you keep paying the £500 when she comes crawling back and realises she has made a mistake.

Why should she come back crawling? Has the father crawled to her given that she is doing most towards bringing up THEIR child.

The obvious thing is just to say, look when financially things improve I'll look to increase it. There should be no element of " punishment" in it.

RedHelenB · 20/01/2023 06:52

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/01/2023 23:20

I'd encourage him to leave it at £500.

I can see why it would annoy him, but CMS is the basic so paying a little more when you can afford it is the decent thing.

No point spiting his child just to get back at the mother.

This. Why is he punishing his first born over this, he doesn't sound very nice.

Hesma · 20/01/2023 06:31

I get her point, I’m struggling with how to have a similar conversation with my ex but I think expecting a 40% increase is a lot and she needs to be realistic. Let her go down the CMS route, her choice. As for “Sure, it would be lovely to have an extra £170 right now but not by removing it from a child” believe me, she doesn’t give a shit about your kids… not her problem and she won’t be thinking about it like that.

Username6194 · 20/01/2023 06:23

Changechangechanging · 20/01/2023 00:10

So he reduces his hours to suit his new family circumstances and now intends to reduce his maintenance because he can get away with that by his ex going through the CMS? Is that right?

He's a petty little man if so, isn't he? Don't make excuses for him. This is how he will treat you and your children should you split.

That's not at all what OP has said!

Lialou · 20/01/2023 05:54

You're coming across really well OP. There's just some cranks on here who like to pick people apart no matter what. £500 sounds like the best option.

SpacersChoice · 20/01/2023 02:25

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 01:28

@SpacersChoice

It in absolutely no way excludes the child, it excludes the ex.

How does it exclude the ex? She’s an ex so she is already excluded. Stating the relationship was short and casual is designed to make the child seem less than.

climbthathill129 · 20/01/2023 02:00

Changechangechanging · 20/01/2023 00:10

So he reduces his hours to suit his new family circumstances and now intends to reduce his maintenance because he can get away with that by his ex going through the CMS? Is that right?

He's a petty little man if so, isn't he? Don't make excuses for him. This is how he will treat you and your children should you split.

Have you even read the post ?! 😳

climbthathill129 · 20/01/2023 01:58

Everyone seems to be missing the point here.

She can't kick off because he won't increase it further than he should be paying and it's great that he has always paid more than he needs to.

If she keeps being a cow about it, then yes go directly through the csa and it will be reduced right down to the £330.
Serves her right for being a cow and making demands of your DH.

You can then make a decision if you keep paying the £500 when she comes crawling back and realises she has made a mistake.

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 01:28

@SpacersChoice

It in absolutely no way excludes the child, it excludes the ex.

MissTrip82 · 20/01/2023 00:38

Chantelle302412 · 19/01/2023 23:43

Bloody hell she’s lucky to be getting 500 as it is I get £160 a month. I’d let her shoot herself in the foot and come running back. Everyone’s struggling and he has other children and family to think of.

It’s not ‘lucky’ for a child’s parent to do slightly more than the absolute bare legal minimum.

I’d encourage him to keep it as is. In the child’s interests.

Throwaway0912 · 20/01/2023 00:19

Changechangechanging · 20/01/2023 00:10

So he reduces his hours to suit his new family circumstances and now intends to reduce his maintenance because he can get away with that by his ex going through the CMS? Is that right?

He's a petty little man if so, isn't he? Don't make excuses for him. This is how he will treat you and your children should you split.

It is ridiculously petty, I agree. And why I'm here, looking for some rational input.

He never has paid the minimum, but he has been lax the past couple of years in keeping on top of increases, so in that respect she was perfectly right to ask for a review.

I don't think he'll go down the CMS route, I honestly think he's just had an irrational reaction to what's happened between them. I hope so anyway, he's never behaved like a dick where children are concerned before so I wouldn't like to think he's capable of it for exactly the reasons you describe.

OP posts:
Yousee · 20/01/2023 00:18

Changechangechanging · 20/01/2023 00:10

So he reduces his hours to suit his new family circumstances and now intends to reduce his maintenance because he can get away with that by his ex going through the CMS? Is that right?

He's a petty little man if so, isn't he? Don't make excuses for him. This is how he will treat you and your children should you split.

You've got everything back to front I'm afraid.

He reduced his hours to suit his new family circumstances, kept maintaince to ex at the previously agreed higher level, fully intended to continue with that as they have arranged their household finances with the £500 ringfenced, got a demand for more money from the ex, told her "not right now, possibly later in the year when circumstances change", were met with a load of abuse, got fed up and decided to go down the official route to arrange payments which would result in a loss of £170pcm to the ex.

I agree that reducing the payments out of anger would be petty.
However I'd be tempted to let her get on with it, see it through, then just return to the £500 amount once she's seen the difference between what she gets and what the law says she's entitled to.

charabang · 20/01/2023 00:12

I think you've come across as very well balanced and reasonable. The Ex probably isn't aware of how much she stands to lose going via CMS. It's tough times for a lot of people so putting her in the picture with an update on your finances should help her understand what is or isn't unreasonable to expect by way of an increase.

Changechangechanging · 20/01/2023 00:10

So he reduces his hours to suit his new family circumstances and now intends to reduce his maintenance because he can get away with that by his ex going through the CMS? Is that right?

He's a petty little man if so, isn't he? Don't make excuses for him. This is how he will treat you and your children should you split.

Throwaway0912 · 20/01/2023 00:03

Will try to answer what I can.

Contact wise, yes, there is now consistent contact after a rocky start. Has been for a long time now.

I'm not sure she was aware his hours were reduced, their contact is minimal. He didn't reduce his child maintenance so I don't suppose she would have noticed. We don't live close enough to do school runs so contact is weekends (3 in 4) and school holidays.

With regards to extras, there's obviously birthdays and Christmas - sometimes they do their own or they half depending on what DC wants. Big things like school trips, uniform, one off big expenses, is usually at least half.

Some things I hadn't thought about here like offering to cover additional childcare, thank you. We do buy clothes and pick up things along with ours if we see something, or replace if something looks like it's getting small, but also something to make a conscious effort over so good suggestion also.

I know we're all struggling and it's not a race to the bottom. We're going to have a proper look at outgoings and see if it can be increased any before September.

I'm aware I've not come across well but I do appreciate all of the comments and viewpoints, it's helped see things more calmly.

OP posts:
Deathbyfluffy · 20/01/2023 00:02

Tell her you’ll need to stick at £500, and if she pushes it further make it clear you agree to abide by any CMS award.

I think she’ll regret that rather quickly!

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 19/01/2023 23:59

Rtmhwales · 19/01/2023 23:43

I don't feel the OP meant it to disregard the first child.

To me it felt more she was pointing out DH and his ex were never married so the ex wasn't used to a certain standard of living her ex provided and that it set the history of how long he's been paying £500 for, consistently despite income fluctuations.

It makes no difference if it was a one night stand or long term relationship, end result was a child.

SpacersChoice · 19/01/2023 23:56

Chantelle302412 · 19/01/2023 23:43

Bloody hell she’s lucky to be getting 500 as it is I get £160 a month. I’d let her shoot herself in the foot and come running back. Everyone’s struggling and he has other children and family to think of.

I get £0, it’s not a race to the bottom. Tell your ex to get a better job.

BelleMarionette · 19/01/2023 23:55

You sound perfectly reasonable.

How often does he have his child for overnights? Could this perhaps increase if the mother is struggling so much?

caringcarer · 19/01/2023 23:53

£500 per month pays for the child's food, clothing and contributes to the gas and electricity. Sounds like ex partner is just struggling at the moment. Has your DH told her he is working less hours as doing childcare for his other children. Maybe she does not know this. He should tell her he is playing £500 but only has to pay £330. If she wants to go to CMS she will find out for herself. If he does not have formal access he should secure it.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 19/01/2023 23:50

Chantelle302412 · 19/01/2023 23:43

Bloody hell she’s lucky to be getting 500 as it is I get £160 a month. I’d let her shoot herself in the foot and come running back. Everyone’s struggling and he has other children and family to think of.

Bloody hell. You're lucky to be getting £160 as it is I get sweet fuck all.

Ffs. I hate this attitude. She's not 'lucky'. Her ex is clearly a decent guy who (presumably) earns more than yours or mine.

Ponderingwindow · 19/01/2023 23:48

I would encourage him to keep up the current payment. Cms is the absolute minimum and he voluntarily reduced his income. Could he really sleep at night taking money from his child?

the truth is that costs are going up. He probably should be looking for ways to increase his financial support. It’s not a legal obligation, it’s a moral one. If he can’t afford the increase she has requested, then she has to accept that, but he could still be looking for other ways to help. Perhaps he could cover more childcare or more school runs since he is on reduced hours? Maybe he could be using some of his extra time to shop sales for cheaper clothing, not just for the clothing he buys for the child for your house, but he could offer to do some of the mother’s shopping if she gives him a specific list and a budget.

Overandunderit · 19/01/2023 23:48

You're not going to get a fair ride OP.

Ive no idea what "taking it further" could even mean given he's paying more than minimum.

Did your DH explain to your his ex about the change of hours before it happened? It could seem like an excuse now if he didn't