Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Maintenance Issue

143 replies

Throwaway0912 · 19/01/2023 23:16

Name change as don't want this linked back or picked up by The Sun.

Looking for some outside perspective on this as I think we've got overly emotional.

Background info
DH has a child (11) from a previous short, casual relationship. Child maintenance by private arrangement since birth, currently £500pcm and has been for 2-3 years now. He uses the calculator as a guideline and rounds up to an easy number.

Child's mum got in touch and said she's struggling and needs CMS increased to £700.

The issue is, in the last couple of years, we've had children and DH has dropped hours to reduce our childcare bill. He was the higher earner initially, but I then overtook him and his job is more flexible so it made sense for our circumstances. The CMS was never reduced, wasn't really considered because we work from one pot, it's a non-negotiable outgoing, it was just left as it was. However, based on his current situation, when he checked the calculator said he should be paying around £330.

He got back to child's mum and said he can't increase to £700, he'd need to stay at £500 and then reassess in September when our childcare reduces. All hell has broken loose.

He's now saying screw it, go through CMS and pay the £330.

Child's mum is saying it needs to be £700 or she's "taking it further".

I'm just lost on what to do. I know it's not my issue to sort but he's my family and we're a team, I'm also a mother and don't like to think of another mother struggling. AIBU for wanting to push for it to remain at £500? Or should I step back and leave him to his knee jerk reaction of the CMS route? Is there a middle ground we've not considered?

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/01/2023 10:53

Sounds like ex partner is just struggling at the moment.

Does she think she's the only one, though? Does she never see the news?

As for “Sure, it would be lovely to have an extra £170 right now but not by removing it from a child” believe me, she doesn’t give a shit about your kids… not her problem and she won’t be thinking about it like that.

Did I misunderstand that? I read it as OP saying that, yes, they could well use the extra money, if the child's mum wanted to shoot herself in the foot by insisting on the amount that the CMS ruled, but was acknowledging that it would be very unfair on the child to lose that money; not that the £170 would/should be taken from OP and DH's child.

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 10:39

@Sleepless1096

Unortunately that’s just the reality of being a separated family, you can’t expect the financial support you once would have had as a couple. If the father was rich then I can see an argument for it but you can’t just demand more money and expect to get it because you are a mother and then have a tantrum when you do not get it.

There are many things that would benefit my children that I am unable to afford. There is not an unlimited pool of money for most people, sometimes a mum has to step up and maximise her own earnings even if she’d rather spend time with her children, single or not.

euff · 20/01/2023 10:15

I don't think you come across badly at all. You've come on here to get feedback and instead of pointing things out that some may see and be aware of that others don't in a constructive way people have to jump down your throat. They don't come across well op.

You guys know what you can afford if you can't afford to increase don't. Just keep stating the same calmly. She may be panicked about the col increases and not having an increase in years will make her feel that one is due but that doesn't mean you have the means. Don't make counter threats. Don't respond to threats to 'take it further' unless it affects seeing his DC. If she allows him to have a rational conversation then he can tell her that if your situation improves then of course you would look at it again?

Sleepless1096 · 20/01/2023 09:53

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 09:04

@Tandora

£700 isn’t really for the child though is it? It’s to make the mums life easier so she doesn’t have to either get a better paying job or work more and contribute an equal amount.

You would have to argue that this child costs £1400 a month bar the 4 days they are with father , so £1400 for 24 days?!

This child already has a father who doesn't live with her or spend that much time with her. Surely it's directly for her benefit if her mother can afford to work less, is less stressed and can spend more time with her, as otherwise she has very minimal quality parental input compared to the dad's other children.

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 09:50

@Colderthanever

Youd side eye your husband for not allowing somebody to demand a substantial chunk of your family pot that impacts your other children?

£500 is a lot of money when you are a separated couple.

Sleepless1096 · 20/01/2023 09:50

Ideally, he'd make a similar level of contribution (financial and otherwise) to all of his children.

His financial contribution to your joint children has reduced, but he has increased his parenting contribution and spends additional time with them, which they benefit from in terms of their relationship with their father. This also provides you as the higher earner with more flexibility to do your job, and so has an indirect financial benefit for your children.

His reduction in hours has no similar parenting benefit or indirect financial benefit for his other child. So if he chooses to reduce his payment to £330, based on lifestyle choices he and you have made for the benefit of your family, he's directly disadvantaging his other child - she receives the same amount of time (which is quite a small amount of time anyway) but much less money. So that does seem a bit of shit thing for a parent to do.... in making career or other decisions, they should take the welfare of all their children into account, not just the children they live with at the moment.

Colderthanever · 20/01/2023 09:24

Sounds to me like he thinks the moneys for her he’s not making the direct correlation that it’s for his child. I’d be side eyeing him over this and it would give me pause for thought.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/01/2023 09:11

For clarity - I don’t mean the Op

Flamingogirl08 · 20/01/2023 09:10

You're being reasonable OP just some people on here who have obviously been treated poorly by their children's father and are protecting on to you

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/01/2023 09:07

Some people have incredibly low standards for men.

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 09:04

@Tandora

£700 isn’t really for the child though is it? It’s to make the mums life easier so she doesn’t have to either get a better paying job or work more and contribute an equal amount.

You would have to argue that this child costs £1400 a month bar the 4 days they are with father , so £1400 for 24 days?!

OneForTheRoadThen · 20/01/2023 09:01

WigglyGlowWorm · 20/01/2023 08:11

At the end of the day, if DH and the ex were still together, he would only have his money to contribute to the household. Has his money suddenly gone up by £200…no. So where does she expect this money to come from, that’s right…you. We get this from the ex all the time.

In fact, DH and the ex had a private arrangement for years. The ex was absolutely convinced that DH was screwing her over and insisted on a CMS case, even though DH said he was paying more. Oh how we laughed when the CMS calculated he needed to pay £65pcm LESS than he had been.

Spoiler, he carried on paying the same amount as he’s not petty but it did kinda serve her right, especially when we got the panicked text messages.

If her DH and his ex were living together then he'd be contributing more than £500 a month so this argument doesn't really make sense.

And if your husbands ex was sending panicked emails about £65 a month then it sounds like she's struggling. It's really unkind for the pair of you to laugh about it.

LemonTT · 20/01/2023 08:57

Both the mother and your husband escalated. Whilst his reaction was in response to her aggression it was aggressive too. They both threatened each other.

The right response would have just to restate his offer. Without all the justification and background which just create potential points of grievance for her to focus on.

There is nothing you can do about her anger. If she is struggling financially it comes from stress. A bit like your husbands response.

Speak to him and ask what he really wants to do for his child. Get him to move away from responding to the mother’s behaviour. Hopefully it will be to continue to pay £500. Then go back to the mother and remove the CMS threat and offer £500. Keep offering it. Don’t explain why just offer it as it is.

Hopefully she when she finds out it is more than she is entitled to she will climb down her ladder.

when the tension is gone your husband might want to speak to the child or mother about the current situation. The hardship might be very serious and it might put his child’s welfare at risk. Beyond the situation you are in.

LikeTearsInRain · 20/01/2023 08:48

Does the mother work? is she still single?

Many mothers get by with their own income (or not if they don’t work) and whatever benefits they may or may not be entitled to. £500 is a lot of additional money and as OP stated has always been rounded up above the CMS calculation. £6k a year would pay for all the additional utilities, food, school uniform, personal clothes and birthday/Christmas presents for the child and leave some aside for any wraparound childcare and hobbies.

Times are hard for everyone and she is demanding more simply because she can, even though she knows cost of living will have also affected her child’s father and presumably is aware he now has more children. Seems like she is hoping it is the path of least resistance to improve her financial situation.

Threats to take it further clearly imply refusing contact and similar. Completely unreasonable.

I would keep offering the same with the explanation that it is more than CMS calculator and what can be afforded in the current situation. Offer to increase nights with the child if that will help with her costs, if it works for your family. If she does go to CMS it may humble her and she’ll accept the situation. If contact becomes an issue and it goes to court, she won’t win and she will have inflicted a whole bunch of unnecessary drama and stress on her child.

Throwncrumbs · 20/01/2023 08:48

Chantelle302412 · 20/01/2023 08:37

@SpacersChoice hey there is a reason I get £40 a week and mostly that is because he has 3 other children so he pays £560 out a month to all 3 mothers. We are also still in a relationship but living apart mostly when we are all under one roof he pays for most of it as it’s his place we live in so it is pretty shallow of me to say what I did but I’d love to be getting £500 or a bit more than £160 cause it would help more as he earns £££ a week and I struggle. But then I do take note of the ones like you that don’t get nothing and realise how hard it must be for you on your own

3 kids by 3 mothers …red flags everywhere!

PizzaPastaWine · 20/01/2023 08:45

I'd keep it as it is. If she wants to take it further I guess that's the CMS and if so pay that amount.

Let's not forget there are other DC here. They have financial requirements too - the SC does not trump any other child and visa versa.

And of course the DM is just as entitled to reduce/increase her hours as your DH has done. She has a responsibility in this too.

Throwncrumbs · 20/01/2023 08:42

Does the mum work, if not she needs to get a job!

Tandora · 20/01/2023 08:38

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 08:36

@SpacersChoice

I don’t agree, I think it is to give context that the bond between ex’s is not so great that you would be disadvantaging yourself for their benefit.

I would be far less likely to put myself out for somebody I have known for a little while over somebody I have know for a lot longer and have a deeper bond with.

Presumably the child is loved by their father as child is his, so really can’t see how pointing out it was a short relationship excludes the child.

Errrr because the money is for CHILD support. It’s for his child.

Tandora · 20/01/2023 08:37

Ponderingwindow · 19/01/2023 23:48

I would encourage him to keep up the current payment. Cms is the absolute minimum and he voluntarily reduced his income. Could he really sleep at night taking money from his child?

the truth is that costs are going up. He probably should be looking for ways to increase his financial support. It’s not a legal obligation, it’s a moral one. If he can’t afford the increase she has requested, then she has to accept that, but he could still be looking for other ways to help. Perhaps he could cover more childcare or more school runs since he is on reduced hours? Maybe he could be using some of his extra time to shop sales for cheaper clothing, not just for the clothing he buys for the child for your house, but he could offer to do some of the mother’s shopping if she gives him a specific list and a budget.

This.

Chantelle302412 · 20/01/2023 08:37

@SpacersChoice hey there is a reason I get £40 a week and mostly that is because he has 3 other children so he pays £560 out a month to all 3 mothers. We are also still in a relationship but living apart mostly when we are all under one roof he pays for most of it as it’s his place we live in so it is pretty shallow of me to say what I did but I’d love to be getting £500 or a bit more than £160 cause it would help more as he earns £££ a week and I struggle. But then I do take note of the ones like you that don’t get nothing and realise how hard it must be for you on your own

Mumuser124 · 20/01/2023 08:36

@SpacersChoice

I don’t agree, I think it is to give context that the bond between ex’s is not so great that you would be disadvantaging yourself for their benefit.

I would be far less likely to put myself out for somebody I have known for a little while over somebody I have know for a lot longer and have a deeper bond with.

Presumably the child is loved by their father as child is his, so really can’t see how pointing out it was a short relationship excludes the child.

WigglyGlowWorm · 20/01/2023 08:11

At the end of the day, if DH and the ex were still together, he would only have his money to contribute to the household. Has his money suddenly gone up by £200…no. So where does she expect this money to come from, that’s right…you. We get this from the ex all the time.

In fact, DH and the ex had a private arrangement for years. The ex was absolutely convinced that DH was screwing her over and insisted on a CMS case, even though DH said he was paying more. Oh how we laughed when the CMS calculated he needed to pay £65pcm LESS than he had been.

Spoiler, he carried on paying the same amount as he’s not petty but it did kinda serve her right, especially when we got the panicked text messages.

kittensinthekitchen · 20/01/2023 08:03

(For disclosure, my ex pays £35pw, and has done for over a decade for our two teenagers, so £150 a month-ish - for both, not each)

I think you sound very reasonable. I understand his snap reaction to the hassle from her, by suggesting he go along with reducing the maintenance in line with CMS calculations, but agree that if the £500 figure is still manageable, it would be best to continue paying that.

Has he been honest with his ex regarding his income at the moment? I bet she imagines his income is much higher, she won't have picked a figure out of nowhere, especially when it seems things areHasreasonWonkabhad le between you all.

You've

is won

Had some great suggestions of other ways you could contribute in the meantime.

Good luck, I hope it works out peacefully for you all.

(Formatting
Wonky because eMN can't get their shit together)

Theunamedcat · 20/01/2023 07:35

SpacersChoice · 19/01/2023 23:56

I get £0, it’s not a race to the bottom. Tell your ex to get a better job.

Or tell him to get "a" job my ex was told to pay 180 he countered that offer by paying zero 🤔 his girlfriend helps him buy paying for his new xbox his new car just until his inheritance comes in obviously she doesn't realise its never going to go back in her pockets

And yes she thinks we had a short casual relationship too we were actually married she also thinks both the kids were my idea they actually were not plus the marriage was his idea im not bothered its AMAZING how people twist things

Changechangechanging · 20/01/2023 07:27

Serves her right for being a cow and making demands of your DH

It's the child that matters here. Attempts at punishing the ex are also going to impact on the child.

isn’t the first thing you’d check how much you’d be entitled to before kicking off

How would she check? They live a distance a part. Ex will have little sense of lifestyle. He's hardly going to be providing his wage slip each month. The way to check is by contacting the CMS, surely?

That's not at all what OP has said!

OP agreed with me.