Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To object to having to call a man accused of rape 'she' in a criminal court trial?

378 replies

Appalonia · 19/01/2023 22:50

Firstly, the definition of rape is penetration by a penis without consent. Only men have a penis. This case makes a mockery of the law and the criminal justice process and is a gross victimisation of this victim?
www.clydebankpost.co.uk/news/23259685.clydebank-court-hears-woman-raped-clydebank-home/?ref=twtrec

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/01/2023 04:38

WallaceinAnderland · 19/01/2023 23:12

You are sworn in and have to tell the truth but them you are forced to lie. Ridiculous isn't it.

That's exactly it. I couldn't sit up there and lie, I'd rather be fined. And I'd make a point of saying why I was calling him he if I was asked.
It makes a mockery of the legal system and of the women who have been raped. How anyone could defend the victim having to call her male rapist she, is beyond me, but I'm sure there will be someone.

StarsSand · 20/01/2023 04:12

@Appalonia

Sorry but you're misrepresenting this. Here are the reasons she didn't get compensation:

'However, Judge Grant refused to grant Ms Maclachlan any compensation, saying: "Compensation would not be appropriate, particularly due to the unhelpful way in which the victim was present [at the protest] and the way she was filming.
"She was asked at different stages not to film but continued to do so.
"Another factor I have to take in to account is the Twitter post that has been submitted that was posted after the case had been brought to the attention of the police and there were criminal proceedings pending.
"It was foolish of her to post that tweet in the way that she did.
"It was notable that when I asked Ms Maclachlan to refer to Ms Wolf as 'she', she did so with bad grace - having asked her to do so she continued to refer to Ms Wolf as 'he' and 'him'".

So basically her antagonistic behaviour lead the to escalation of the incident to begin with. She filmed without permission, after being told repeatedly to stop. She deliberated undermined the legal proceedings by publishing about them online- jeopardising the defendants legal right to a fair trial and then in a court room she ignored the direction of a judge.

This isnt simply a matter of her being ineligible for compensation because she wouldn't use pronouns. That wouldn't be legally possible.

MarieKlepto · 20/01/2023 02:34

Madness. Unnecessary madness. I live in Scotland. It's losing the plot. As a light aside, in big chunks of Scotland, whatever class you are (if this is in any way relevant to anyone), we don't use he/she pronouns, our speech pattern is they/them. E.g. "Dave said he was in Glasgow on Tuesday"; "Well why did they say to me they were in Stirling?" or "My neighbour asked me if I could pick up her daughter after school on Tuesday and I had to say to them that I had an appointment". For non-Scottish people or the grammar particular, I realise this sounds like nails down a blackboard . . .

DulcetTones · 20/01/2023 01:47

I understand the "playing them at their own game" aspect of pointing out that Adam committed this crime before transitioning, so therefore we can refer to him as "he/him". But what about the times when a man commits violent crimes after he's transitioned? He'll still be a man, regardless of what he likes to believe.

It's so infuriating and almost incomprehensible that people and legal systems are catering to the bizarre fetishes and mental illnesses of the few and expecting the rest of us to lie to perpetuate the sick fantasy that it's possible to magically change your DNA. When will this slide into insanity stop?!

Appalonia · 20/01/2023 01:41

This account in the Evening Standard, although not entirely accurate, makes it clear about the situation re criminal injuries compensation and pronouns. Tara Wolf is 6 ft 4 and now a kick boxer in Thailand, btw.in a
www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/transgender-activist-tara-wolf-fined-ps150-for-assaulting-exclusionary-radical-feminist-in-hyde-park-a3813856.html

OP posts:
Appalonia · 20/01/2023 01:35

StarsSand · 20/01/2023 01:29

Source for this?

using pronouns isn't a criteria for receiving this compensation. It's not relevant legally in the decision making process.

This can't be accurate.

To be eligible for criminal injuries compensation you have to comply with the legal process. The magistrate reprimanded her for not used the ' correct ' pronouns during the trial. I assure you this is completely accurate, no matter how far fetched it sounds.

OP posts:
Octopusmittens · 20/01/2023 01:33

Yazo · 19/01/2023 23:05

Someone is a rapist and you object to their choice of pronoun?!

I kind of think there is a stronger objection here!

You are spectacularly missing the point.

StarsSand · 20/01/2023 01:29

Appalonia · 19/01/2023 23:36

There was a case a few years ago where a woman was assaulted by a 6 foot 4 trans identified man. She refused to use she pronouns in court and consequently was denied criminal injuries compensation. If you were a rape victim in a case like this and refused to comply with this, you would be losing approx £11k in compensation...

Source for this?

using pronouns isn't a criteria for receiving this compensation. It's not relevant legally in the decision making process.

This can't be accurate.

CharlotteRose90 · 20/01/2023 01:27

I’m sorry what. Who gives a toss what the rapist is pretending to be now, at the time of the attack he was a male and should be trialled and treated like one. I certainly wouldn’t be calling him she in a court as he most definitely isn’t and will never be one.

DdraigGoch · 20/01/2023 01:24

Yazo · 19/01/2023 23:05

Someone is a rapist and you object to their choice of pronoun?!

I kind of think there is a stronger objection here!

A victim being forced to refer to her attacker in court as "she" is a pretty big thing when trying to give evidence.

Sparklybanana · 20/01/2023 01:07

In this case, when the crime occurred, the man that did it was Adam. It doesn't matter if they are a she now - at the time "isla didn't do it" but Adam did. If Adam did it, then Adam should be sent to a male prison as it'd not be right to send isla to prison as she didn't even exist then.
I'm talking semantics of course - it's a fucking stupid world we live in right now.

smileladiesplease · 20/01/2023 01:02

Abhorrent disgusting wrong

PoIIyPandemonium · 20/01/2023 00:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2023 00:38

ErrolTheDragon · 20/01/2023 00:25

You expect a rape victim to be "careful" about pronouns when giving evidence, having sworn to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?Hmm

From the OP’s post wording it sounded like she was objecting as a journalist or court worker so I assumed she was coming at it from an impersonal but morally frustrated place. Yes I think it’s horrible to penalise a victim for misgendering, particularly as they were living as a man when the victim would have know them and the offence occurred anyway.

Nanny0gg · 20/01/2023 00:32

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2023 00:18

Surely you just use they and them.. instead of 'and then what did she do' its 'and then what did they do'... no need to specify gender at all if you're careful,

It's pretty important to specify sex in a rape trial

Nanny0gg · 20/01/2023 00:31

Yazo · 19/01/2023 23:05

Someone is a rapist and you object to their choice of pronoun?!

I kind of think there is a stronger objection here!

If you accept that women can rape (they can't) it skews the stats on rapists. Also means if convicted, he will be put in a women's prison. We don't want that, do we?

ErrolTheDragon · 20/01/2023 00:29

Poonicorn · 20/01/2023 00:02

As a Christian I would not be able to swear on the Bible and then tell a lie. I would have to clarify with the court that they are compelling me to lie in contravention of my faith.

As an atheist, I would similarly not be able to lie after making the affirmation 'I ... do solemnly, sincerely and truly declare and affirm the evidence I shall give shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

sst1234 · 20/01/2023 00:27

If you tolerate this, then your children will be next.

By the way, next time a group of rabid progressives tells you to follow the science on anything, just remember, they make up their own science to suit their agenda.

ErrolTheDragon · 20/01/2023 00:25

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2023 00:18

Surely you just use they and them.. instead of 'and then what did she do' its 'and then what did they do'... no need to specify gender at all if you're careful,

You expect a rape victim to be "careful" about pronouns when giving evidence, having sworn to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?Hmm

sst1234 · 20/01/2023 00:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rainbowbaby13 · 20/01/2023 00:20

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2023 00:18

Surely you just use they and them.. instead of 'and then what did she do' its 'and then what did they do'... no need to specify gender at all if you're careful,

Yes you're right we wouldn't want to upset a rapist

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2023 00:18

Surely you just use they and them.. instead of 'and then what did she do' its 'and then what did they do'... no need to specify gender at all if you're careful,

FOJN · 20/01/2023 00:11

Yazo · 19/01/2023 23:05

Someone is a rapist and you object to their choice of pronoun?!

I kind of think there is a stronger objection here!

Gosh you're right, someone's feelings might get hurt, who cares about traumatised women.

WOMEN DO NOT HAVE PENISES

IcakethereforeIam · 20/01/2023 00:08

As this is in Scotland, there is a chance that this person, if jailed, will be sent to a women's prison. If not now then later in the sentence. This person could insist on being searched by female officers, no matter how they feel about it. I'm being careful about the pronouns I use for this person because MN (although thank you for letting us have these thread) can be a bit twitchy about misgendering.

There is a Government petition currently collecting signatures to try to strengthen the Equality Act to keep men out of women's prison, hospital wards, domestic violence shelters, etc. If you haven't already, please follow the link below to sign it and share it if you can

www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668426-petition-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?page=33&reply=122785416

LulooLemon · 20/01/2023 00:07

You are absolutely right OP