Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To object to having to call a man accused of rape 'she' in a criminal court trial?

378 replies

Appalonia · 19/01/2023 22:50

Firstly, the definition of rape is penetration by a penis without consent. Only men have a penis. This case makes a mockery of the law and the criminal justice process and is a gross victimisation of this victim?
www.clydebankpost.co.uk/news/23259685.clydebank-court-hears-woman-raped-clydebank-home/?ref=twtrec

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
HufflepuffRavenclaw · 20/01/2023 08:39

If "Ms Bryson" is convicted of rape, this person will be sent to a woman's prison because in Scotland, a woman is anyone who says they are a woman. Little details like being a convicted rapist and a danger to women, and having a penis are irrelevant.

And people wonder why there has been such a stooshie about the gender reform bill which makes this sort of nonsense all the easier.

Personally, I would not lose any sleep over misgendering or dead naming a person accused of such violence.

IcakethereforeIam · 20/01/2023 08:37

Re. pp, please sign and share the petition linked to below

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4722618-petition-to-update-the-equality-act-thread-2

LadyHarmby · 20/01/2023 08:29

While I agree with the sentiment here, we all need to stop referring to this person as a ‘rapist’ because there has not yet been a conviction. The trial is ongoing.

IcakethereforeIam · 20/01/2023 08:26

I read on another thread, and I hope the poster was mistaken, that once a rapist utters the magic words the prison service treats them as a woman. This includes risk assessments and offender treatment pathways, designed to cut reoffending, which aren't as effective on tw because they are men.

A chief of police stated that tw officers can carry out intimate searches of women. I expect this also applied to prison officers who are trans. Women prisoners who object to tw or, God forbid, misgender them can be punished. It can even affect their chances of parole.

There was recently a tw, jailed for paedophilia, who was put in a women's jail that has a mother and baby unit. He didn't even have a GRC. I believe he was eventually moved to a men's prison after he struck up a relationship with a woman who was described as young and extremely vulnerable.

Please sign and share the petition linked upthread.

MiaMoor · 20/01/2023 08:23

Or they are, not if!

MiaMoor · 20/01/2023 08:22

WalkthisWayUK · 20/01/2023 08:14

@MiaMoor wow that’s pretty shocking. Have any media outlets picked this up?

I’m not sure. If it is, not widely.
A few years ago a feminist group did a FOI request and uncovered this, it was not believed so a media outlet (maybe the telegraph? Not sure!) checked again and found the figures were worse.

It absolutely should be written about. There is so much evidence to prove that teens should not be transitioning, that women should retain single sex spaces, that much of gender ideology is quietly dismantling safeguards for women and children, but those in positions of authority are totally captured and will not listen to it. If they are part of a bigger agenda.

Calmdown14 · 20/01/2023 08:22

This scenario was raised as one of the amendments put forward to the Gender Reform Bill in Scotland and they voted against it.
Against it! Measures to try and stop exactly this scenario as they now only need to live in their chosen gender for 12 weeks, there are no criteria as to what this means and no medical or professional advice is required.

But this is progressive?!

And I am even more staggered to see this www.rapecrisisscotland.org.uk/news/news/a-statement-from-scottish-civil-society-organisations-on-the-uk-governments-intervention-o/

But then again, rape crisis see no issue with a biological man at the helm of one of its services

WalkthisWayUK · 20/01/2023 08:14

@MiaMoor wow that’s pretty shocking. Have any media outlets picked this up?

WalkthisWayUK · 20/01/2023 08:13

It is also very disturbing that it forces the victim to deny the reality of it, if he was actually a woman he could not have physically raped her. And if she was not actually a woman she could not have been raped. The whole trial is because of this biological reality.

MiaMoor · 20/01/2023 08:08

“i wonder how many rapists actually identify as women now”

Cross dressing is the biggest paraphilia, which often comes hand in hand with sex offences (a female ex prison officer wrote about this, but her article was banned from several platforms).

The recent census has confirmed that, going by prison data, TW are far more likely to be incarcerated for sex crimes than other men. See photo attached.

There is absolutely no evidence to back up TW being as safe as women to be around.

To object to having to call a man accused of rape 'she' in a criminal court trial?
IneedanewTV · 20/01/2023 08:06

Eventually 50% of rapes will be committed by women and 50% by men. How do you suppose that will affect funding and resources? Suddenly there will be no need to worry about women’s safely on the streets as less males are raping. It’s just bloody common sense otherwise statistics and focus and funding will be screwed.

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/01/2023 08:04

Yanbu

I think i walked find this worse tbh. I'm fortunate enough to not have been a victim of rape and all my dubious situations which I won't go into where it would now be considered assault but at the time I didnt know it was so I wasn't affected by it as much as I should be at the time, well I guess I was kinda used to men taking my body in ways I didnt always like . But I'm not sure id cope with anyone trying to take my mind, my thoughts and feelings and what I see with my own eyes from me.

This must be worse for the victims? I mean rapists are gonna rape. U dont expect anything else from.rapists.

But these guys, arent they meant to be the good guys? The ones there to help you. To get you some.kind.of justice ? The ones that should know better? I think I'd find it worse.

BromCavMum · 20/01/2023 08:03

YANBU

Swimswam · 20/01/2023 07:57

What also struck me is that the defendant says he is going to have surgery to remove his penis. But hasn’t actually had it yet. This could just be a tactic to get him either aquitted because how could a man who wants his penis removed be a rapist or also add to a claim to be sent to a woman’s prison if he is found guilty. Either way women lose.

MiaMoor · 20/01/2023 07:52

YANBU at all.
There have been cases of paedophiles being referred to as she as well, one fairly local to me - there was a big FB fight over pronouns for a convicted paedophile - the pronoun people completely ignoring the fact that this man had raped a child and focusing entirely on misgendering, and a pile on from TRAs following the calls of transphobia. Pretty sure it peaked an awful lot of people round here.

Catonlapfireon · 20/01/2023 07:49

i wonder how many rapists actually identify as women now.
It seems the script now, rape, court case and somewhere in the middle identify as women. It’s almost like…. Well I’ve not gotten away with it, may as well identify as a woman then I can rape some more when I get to a women’s prison.
I feel heartfelt sympathy for the victim here, ha I g to go through the trauma of a trail, and have everyone call her rapist a she, when it was a very male act of rape.

C8H10N4O2 · 20/01/2023 07:49

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2023 00:38

From the OP’s post wording it sounded like she was objecting as a journalist or court worker so I assumed she was coming at it from an impersonal but morally frustrated place. Yes I think it’s horrible to penalise a victim for misgendering, particularly as they were living as a man when the victim would have know them and the offence occurred anyway.

Nice attempt at backpedaling but the OP makes no such point.

Only men have penises, only men can penetrate without consent using a penis. Nobody should be prioritising the man's feelings in such a situation, especially considering men exploit the court system to intimidate the victims.

These are men, exploiting trans identities to attack women, just as they would exploit any opportunity against women.

ChaToilLeam · 20/01/2023 07:45

This pronoun nonsense is ridiculous and needs to stop. It’s just being used as another stick to beat vulnerable and traumatised women with.

You bet that rapist is getting a little frisson every time he is referred to as she. Turning the courtroom into his wank bank. 😡

hattie43 · 20/01/2023 07:43

Yazo · 19/01/2023 23:05

Someone is a rapist and you object to their choice of pronoun?!

I kind of think there is a stronger objection here!

Wow you're a piece of work aren't you . That's your only concern in this , jeez

unclebuck · 20/01/2023 07:41

This is interesting. I was banned from contacting the BBC for pointing this out.

I described it as state sponsored gas lighting of rape victims for them to describe Karen White as a woman and use she pronouns when the rape victim may be listening to the show. They were furious. I wonder if they'd do the same now?

ExiledElsie · 20/01/2023 07:38

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2023 00:18

Surely you just use they and them.. instead of 'and then what did she do' its 'and then what did they do'... no need to specify gender at all if you're careful,

Fuck me. You would do mental gymnastics in court to avoid telling the truth with clarity.

ExiledElsie · 20/01/2023 07:32

TangledWebOfDeception · 19/01/2023 23:15

I long ago decided that this is one hill I would definitely die on. I absolutely will not be compelled to outright lie to spare the feelings of a rapist/sexual criminal. I’d rather be jailed.

Absolutely agree. I couldn't lie, especially in court, if the person I was talking about was a man I would describe them as such.

To put women under pressure to do so in a rape trial is grotesque.

WalkthisWayUK · 20/01/2023 04:57

Is it just me, but I think that there is something quite sinister and disturbing about a man, who has used his male penis to rape a woman, something only a man could do, then demanding he is a woman?

Rape is about power isn’t it, power to inflict harm in this case with an exclusively male power? And yet now he wants to present as a she, the victim’s sex and covet this as his own. It’s almost like it’s a continuation of the power play in court, with the courts and victim compelled to affirm this power.

Doesn’t it make you feel a bit like the Silence of the Lambs?

Surfsenior · 20/01/2023 04:56

I would stoically refer to “The defendant sitting over there who has spent their whole life as a man with a penis and is now identified as a woman” and avoid using any pronoun at all.

If the NHS didn’t have to pay for it, chopping off his penis seems like a good plan to me.

StarsSand · 20/01/2023 04:49

@Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious

she wasn't fined. She wasn't raped.

This page is just creating boogeymen scenarios now.