Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disturbed by what I heard

114 replies

Mtngfres · 19/01/2023 22:43

Seeing the post about not wanting to share life stories at work has reminded me of a group training exercise I did just a few weeks ago that involved sharing and being vulnerable.

Everyone felt comfortable and shared some difficult things about their childhood. Mine were fairly tame compared to others - parents divorcing, low self esteem, bit of depression etc.

It turned out that nearly half the room had been victims of some pretty terrible abuse. Details were revealed that I won't go into but I've been left feeling quite disturbed by what I heard. One story in particular was so horrific and everyone cried, including the very unemotional men.

I see rationale for being open in these settings and admire this person for their bravery at speaking about it but a few weeks later I feel so disturbed by what I heard and part of me wishes I'd not heard it. It's not that I see them differently or don't feel sympathy for their ordeal but I just didn't expect that level of revelation in a training setting and its floored me.

They also shook and cried a lot when they told it and so it's clearly still very very raw and difficult for them.

Maybe IBU for feeling like this - I just felt unprepared to hear those things and I guess horrified that it happened to so many in the room. The world can be such a terrible place.

OP posts:
ChaToilLeam · 20/01/2023 07:04

Saz12 · 19/01/2023 23:55

Sounds wildly inappropriate- an employer deliberately deciding to get employees to tell personal trauma on the off chance it’ll make them more money.

Id either decline or just lie if it were me - make something up that is just about enough. My personal life is fuck all to do with my employer, and my childhood or family life even less so.

This really hits the nail on the head. And it is so, so wrong. Asking people to expose their trauma just so shareholders or business owners can make as few more quid, that’s what it boils down to really.

On this and the other thread, very few seem to have found this kind of exercise personally beneficial. It’s intrusive and should not be done. My mental health is non-negotiable.

LakeWindermere · 20/01/2023 07:03

Also, it means that because people remember this stuff because then it defines those people as the victims of that trauma for the rest of their time there. "Do you know Sue, from accounts? You know, the one that had that still birth."

And what about the fact that it lays people open to bullying.

Fuck me. It beggars belief in its scope for damage.

ShandaLear · 20/01/2023 07:01

This must have been pretty terrible for your whole team, and I’d hope this wasn’t some gimmicky ‘trust’ exercise that then left the victims and those who listened with nowhere to go and no follow up support. Sharing information like that in anything other than a therapeutic setting, or amongst close family or friends, is entirety inappropriate, unnecessary, and unethical, and I think you do need to inform HR. Has your team discussed it post event?

pilates · 20/01/2023 06:59

Sounds inappropriate. Not sure what your workplace were trying to achieve by doing that.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 20/01/2023 06:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It is about her and has every right to protect her mental health.
She sat through it with no warning or prep. Very unprofessional of the company.
There's a reason people train to be therapists. Not everyone is equipped for hearing about traumatic experiences especially when they feel helpless.

LakeWindermere · 20/01/2023 06:58

Jeez this practice sounds highly unethical and I would very strongly question the motives behind any management team that felt that it would be beneficial. The fact that some people here who have experienced it feel that there is an ulterior motive to sort the wheat from the chaff is shocking and manipulative in the extreme. I am very private at work and this would make me deeply un comfortable. It is up to us as individuals how and when - and even if - we share our vulnerabilities, and that is an important part of peoples' coping mechanisms after trauma. I would either refuse to share or make something up. And then I would complain.

Fairyliz · 20/01/2023 06:57

So basically they are trying to make you bond over bad experiences so they can make more money?
This is absolutely disgusting can’t believe it’s allowed.

Tripofalifetime343 · 20/01/2023 06:53

boxingdayisbest · 19/01/2023 23:37

I also went to what sounds a very similar few days long course.

It was horrific.

I'm still angry if I think about it now.

People were forced (it was almost brain washing) into sharing stories that made them vulnerable and emotional with other people from the same company that they didn't know well (multiple large departments had people attending). It was almost a form of brainwashing as they built it up slowly and cleverly (slyly) to the point where if you didn't share an emotional story you were a failure.

I am so shocked by this! It sounds highly manipulative not to mention unethical.

What are the management of these companies thinking? People who have no experience or knowledge of mh and abuse have no business initiating these sorts of discussions. At best it is naieve and at worst it is hugely cynical.

HaveYouSeenNancy · 20/01/2023 06:52

I would absolutely hate that. I never share anything other than cake, work info and jokes with my colleagues.

How are you supposed to handle it? With your sister or friend you know what they want from you - a hug/drink/ring someone etc. You can't possibly know what a vulnerable colleague would want because it's a forced intimacy.

FangsForTheMemory · 20/01/2023 06:46

BeachesDiary · 19/01/2023 22:56

I don't believe everything I hear. There's currency in victimhood. People are full of bullshit, people lie and people make stuff up. I wouldn't give it too. Much thought.

You seem nice.

SpaceMonitor · 20/01/2023 06:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Don’t be ridiculous. No one should be forced to listen to traumatic and potentially driggering experiences. The OP isn’t a trained professional. Also, no one in a workplace setting should be coerced into sharing such intimate experiences. I wonder how many of those who shared really regret it now.

Where do you work OP? I can’t begin to imagine this kind of thing happening in my office. It seems so wildly inappropriate.

PAFMO · 20/01/2023 06:18

Though I'd say the fact that everyone felt comfortable opening up, (as per your OP) yet you are still traumatized might say more about whether the job (again, if such training is relevant) is for you or not.

PAFMO · 20/01/2023 06:16

If it's a relevant work situation, then this kind of training has gone on since time immemorial and surely you expected it? As your work field is so unique you can't say what it is, we have no way of knowing.
If it was for a job in which vulnerable people/abuse/legality etc aren't everyday situations then clearly there was no need.
But while we don't know if you work in Tesco or in a top grade psychiatric unit/prison, who knows?

donttalkaboutbookclub · 20/01/2023 06:10

Your workplace sounds terrible doing this in the name of training. I would be furious about this - they have no right to out people in this situation. I can look back at 'training' exercises I've been at in the past and some have been inappropriate (massaging your colleagues) and unpleasant (first aid training where the trainer was delighted to share very unpleasant details with us from when he was a paramedic) but sharing trauma in such an unprotected way is unethical and potentially very damaging to everyone. I can't see any way this can be justified.

Mtngfres · 20/01/2023 04:38

Thanks for all the comments. Can't reveal details about line of work but it's not psychology or a setting where people may be better equipped to hear and deal with certain things.

I see the comment that I'm making it all about me - i know my reaction isnt important in grand scheme of things but I'm not ashamed to admit I found it very hard to hear and don't feel well equipped to hear about other people's abuse, not because I have no empathy or don't care but because I have a lot of empathy and it's really hit me. I couldn't stop crying when I heard and then when it was my turn to speak almost felt bad for sharing fairly run of the mill problems that seem so insignificant next to real trauma

OP posts:
iyzzz · 20/01/2023 00:08

Yes, I've noticed this trend too and not sure how I feel about it. I've been on a work course recently where some of the prompts resulted in people being very open and vulnerable about their personal lives, and raised some difficult issues. I mainly appreciated it. It was good to have a development course that recognised everyone has different goals and encouraged people to be open about how their career is part of the overall picture, rather than a blind focus on how to progress up the career ladder.

However, I'm a fairly heart on my sleeve person and I recognised that some of my colleagues who prefer to keep a very professional 'work self' probably weren't enjoying the environment. I also wasn't subjected to any conversation that I found uncomfortable - your example sounds very difficult.

I think you could feed back to the moderator/organiser that this type of session isn't welcomed by everyone and actually they need to exercise more control over the group and this type of potentially triggering discussion. I also think people need to feel empowered to share nothing and it to be recognised that that is equally ok!

GossipIsMarmite · 20/01/2023 00:06

I’ve been shocked reading threads about things like this happening in a work setting. Surely it must be against human rights to force people to reveal such personal things. All of the plasters being ripped off and trauma being exposed. And some people must feel differently about their colleagues after hearing certain things.
we live in an over-sharing world, it feels like the world is going crazy. I don’t understand what peoples personal lives have to do with their jobs.

PureBlackVoid · 19/01/2023 23:58

I don’t understand why this is being pushed in the name of training or inclusivity. I genuinely don’t see one benefit of forcing personal trauma to become public knowledge amongst colleagues.

Saz12 · 19/01/2023 23:55

Sounds wildly inappropriate- an employer deliberately deciding to get employees to tell personal trauma on the off chance it’ll make them more money.

Id either decline or just lie if it were me - make something up that is just about enough. My personal life is fuck all to do with my employer, and my childhood or family life even less so.

Spongeboob · 19/01/2023 23:55

If it's affected you this much you need to report it to HR.
But also, how awful for you Hmm

Littlemoon31 · 19/01/2023 23:52

"You don't see them differently."

This is why I would never tell anyone what happened to me because of people like you.

Honestly.

Backofthenet20 · 19/01/2023 23:41

My old boss had a lunch meeting called “pause and be inspired”. Some of the things people shared were personal, quiet traumatic and just too much. I declined to be the “sharer”. Even attending and listening to everyone’s stories was traumatic

boxingdayisbest · 19/01/2023 23:37

I also went to what sounds a very similar few days long course.

It was horrific.

I'm still angry if I think about it now.

People were forced (it was almost brain washing) into sharing stories that made them vulnerable and emotional with other people from the same company that they didn't know well (multiple large departments had people attending). It was almost a form of brainwashing as they built it up slowly and cleverly (slyly) to the point where if you didn't share an emotional story you were a failure.

MamaidhMathMath · 19/01/2023 23:36

We had a similar training exercise many years and I still get cross thinking about it. There was no easing into it, the trainer just went straight from team bonding ideas into asking each of us to share a traumatic experience. I had recently lost a grandparent and was still grieving, but one woman had just returned to work after a stillbirth. Utterly, utterly inappropriate and insensitive, and someone must have complained as we never used that trainer again

SpinningOutWaitinForYa · 19/01/2023 23:36

As a victim myself, it's hard not to give you a bitter response, but instead I will try to understand...
Like others, I'm not sure if it's an appropriate exercise or not, mainly because what people choose to share can't be predicted and if someone goes down deep it then tends to have a domino effect and you can get multiple traumatic stories... or silence. If the company wanted to do this again they could perhaps give some guidance that certain topics may be triggering for others to hear. Though it may then defeat the object of being vulnerable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread