Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disturbed by what I heard

114 replies

Mtngfres · 19/01/2023 22:43

Seeing the post about not wanting to share life stories at work has reminded me of a group training exercise I did just a few weeks ago that involved sharing and being vulnerable.

Everyone felt comfortable and shared some difficult things about their childhood. Mine were fairly tame compared to others - parents divorcing, low self esteem, bit of depression etc.

It turned out that nearly half the room had been victims of some pretty terrible abuse. Details were revealed that I won't go into but I've been left feeling quite disturbed by what I heard. One story in particular was so horrific and everyone cried, including the very unemotional men.

I see rationale for being open in these settings and admire this person for their bravery at speaking about it but a few weeks later I feel so disturbed by what I heard and part of me wishes I'd not heard it. It's not that I see them differently or don't feel sympathy for their ordeal but I just didn't expect that level of revelation in a training setting and its floored me.

They also shook and cried a lot when they told it and so it's clearly still very very raw and difficult for them.

Maybe IBU for feeling like this - I just felt unprepared to hear those things and I guess horrified that it happened to so many in the room. The world can be such a terrible place.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BornBlonde · 20/01/2023 22:24

That sounds triggering and entirely inappropriate based on the course content.

I definitely think you should go to HR (despite them having people present) and raise concerns

SilverGlitterBaubles · 20/01/2023 17:14

I would be asking what the aim and expected outcome of this interpersonal skills this training was to be exactly? How was the sharing of personal traumatic experiences with colleagues in the workplace likely to help you in your current job role? Was due diligence done on the organisation brought in to run this workshop?

Waterfallgirl · 20/01/2023 16:44

Just read your update.

I am sorry they had go through that but I’d still complain - go above them to their line manager.

i think I’d also be looking into the background of the training company and their credentials around this . Dealing with trauma is a complex area and needs professional support.
Please can I ask what support (after this training ) anyone is offered? I would be really worried that someone having to ( or being encouraged to) disclose the level of trauma you described may well be tipped into further crisis.

Mtngfres · 20/01/2023 16:05

dumbstruckdumptruck · 20/01/2023 13:37

OP, can you say a bit more about what actually happened to make everyone feel they had to share such personal stories?

I hear that you were on a training and someone shared something super-personal, and then lots of other people did, but I've missed the part where the training specifically prompted anyone to do that.

So it was interpersonal skills training and were all in service business (law/ insurance).

The trainer himself shared first and spoke about a family stillbirth so that set the tone. Then one by one we went round and revealed 'what made us who we are today' which included the abuse stories, family suicide, mental health issues etc.

For those saying report to HR - one of the stories was shared by main HR person. I'd essentially be telling them their story made me uncomfortable after they had courage to share. I don't feel like I can do that

OP posts:
dumbstruckdumptruck · 20/01/2023 13:37

OP, can you say a bit more about what actually happened to make everyone feel they had to share such personal stories?

I hear that you were on a training and someone shared something super-personal, and then lots of other people did, but I've missed the part where the training specifically prompted anyone to do that.

LemonGelato · 20/01/2023 11:28

Please formally complain OP. Put it in writing as you have in your post. I speak as someone who works in HR that this sort of course is completely inappropriate in the workplace. Awful both for those feeling manipulated or coerced into sharing, and those having to hear it.

It's probably some trendy new fad that training people pick up on as a great new way to justify their existence. I would strongly oppose something like this in my organisation, if it was ever suggested. I am not a 'sharer' and have some difficult things in my past that I've not even told close friends less alone some random person from Accounts.

A formal complaint will bring home to those organising and approving this sort of 'training' that it does have consequences, and you may then help others then not have to go through the same thing.

BellePeppa · 20/01/2023 11:07

4longweeks · 20/01/2023 08:03

I have just done a day's training on trauma with an external trainer. The trainer stressed that no one should share anything if they weren't comfortable. He warned beforehand what each section would be about. Throughout the day he checked if anyone needed some time out.

I would say that this training has possible re traumatised some people, totally unethical. OP I would be complaining to HR but have you also got access to an employment assistance programme where you can speak to someone?

And surely the others should have the choice to be the audience for the sharing. It should definitely be a two way street.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/01/2023 10:35

Is all this ‘sharing’ a newish fashionable import from across the pond?

Makes me think of the often dreaded rustic ‘team bonding’ exercises from some time back, where staff had to make rafts out of dead sheep and catch hedgehogs to cook for dinner.
OK, I exaggerate, but not far off. Dh was once sent on one - he actually didn’t mind it but for ‘bonding’ purposes he thought it a complete waste of the company’s money. It was a trendy exercise then, though - not to mention a nice little earner for the businesses that ran them.

PugInTheHouse · 20/01/2023 10:32

You are completely fine to be feeling this way, it's not making it about you at all, it was totally inappropriate and I imagine I would feel similar in the same situation. My husband has had an extremely traumatic past and I struggle to hear about it, I am not trained to deal with it and its a big thing to have on your shoulders and not be able to help the person at all.

MN can be awful at being nasty to posters in similar situations to yours, of course you are posting about your feelings and how it affects you, that's the point of posting, to get advice and help for you. You can't help the other person but you have been upset by something and are entitled to feel that way.

Nocutenamesleft · 20/01/2023 10:25

Mtngfres · 19/01/2023 22:43

Seeing the post about not wanting to share life stories at work has reminded me of a group training exercise I did just a few weeks ago that involved sharing and being vulnerable.

Everyone felt comfortable and shared some difficult things about their childhood. Mine were fairly tame compared to others - parents divorcing, low self esteem, bit of depression etc.

It turned out that nearly half the room had been victims of some pretty terrible abuse. Details were revealed that I won't go into but I've been left feeling quite disturbed by what I heard. One story in particular was so horrific and everyone cried, including the very unemotional men.

I see rationale for being open in these settings and admire this person for their bravery at speaking about it but a few weeks later I feel so disturbed by what I heard and part of me wishes I'd not heard it. It's not that I see them differently or don't feel sympathy for their ordeal but I just didn't expect that level of revelation in a training setting and its floored me.

They also shook and cried a lot when they told it and so it's clearly still very very raw and difficult for them.

Maybe IBU for feeling like this - I just felt unprepared to hear those things and I guess horrified that it happened to so many in the room. The world can be such a terrible place.

I helped a friend once who was a severe alcoholic. She asked me to take her to go see her sister. Which I did. She then said would I be sit with her. Which I did

she then told a story to her sister which obviously I heard that terrified me to my very soul. I didn’t sleep for days and I could t believe what she’d gone through. Even 3 years later I suffer severe nightmares from it but all I think is

i didn’t go through it……….fuck me

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/01/2023 10:22

determinedtomakethiswork · 19/01/2023 22:49

And it's not always safe for people to let go of their feelings and reveal private information to colleagues and then just be sent home to deal with the aftermath. That really isn't good.

This - the revelation itself may or may not have been appropriate - forgive me if I missed anything, but it depends on your job/ training/circumstances etc - but for someone to open themselves like this to a room full of people (something the may later regret) and not to receive trained support afterwards - and for as long as they needed it - is very troubling.

Pyewhacket · 20/01/2023 10:01

Dotcheck · 19/01/2023 22:47

There is no rationale for a workplace creating a situation where people feel pressured to share overly personal information. Totally inappropriate.

I agree. I have always kept work and my personal life totally separate.

Genevieva · 20/01/2023 09:55

@2023bebetter I completely agree. Most adults are not mature enough to cope with even a small amount of sharing. They gossip. It changes how they perceive that person. This can harm the career prospects of the sharer. It is totally inappropriate to ever put someone in a position like this. We don't live in a commune with our work colleagues. The idea that we should feel obliged to share information with them that we don't even share with all our friends is preposterous.

ClockingTime · 20/01/2023 09:49

Rubbish. I smell BS.

katepilar · 20/01/2023 09:43

In group therapy people only share their stuff if and when they are ready and with help of a trained proffessional. People in group therapy are not allowed to form relationships outside of the group.
The whole thing as you describe it is disguasting and highly unproffesional and harmful. Completelly wrong on so many levels.

Rafferty10 · 20/01/2023 09:38

Just WHY would a work setting (excluding a counselling /coaching/ psychotherapy business) benefit from this??

I simply think it is a fad and a dangerous one. I would flat out refuse to participate and refuse to sit and listen to others being manipulated to reveal traumatic things that could be used to embarrass, manipulate or bully them with by others.

Bestcatmum · 20/01/2023 09:38

Ive been invited to "share" like this before and I've refused to even go. I've cited mental health problems. These people are not trained to deal with trauma, work is not the place to deal with trauma. People with mental health problems or past trauma should never have to go to these sessions, I don't want anyone at work to hear the abuse I went through as a child. Its none of their damned business.
I would sue if they made me go and they know it so I haven't been invited again.

maranella · 20/01/2023 09:36

I think that's completely inappropriate for a work event. I would be making a formal complaint to HR, if it were me. Not only is that person's trauma no one at work's business, but putting vulnerable people in the position where they feel pushed to share traumatic experiences with a roomful of their colleagues, who they have to face at work every day afterwards, is abusive IMO. The rest of you in the room were also abused by having to sit there and here something terrible that (at least you OP) did not want to hear. Please complain.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 20/01/2023 09:33

BobDear · 20/01/2023 09:29

This is bullshit. You need to make a complaint.

Someone has given this the green light with no real thought or understanding for the harm they are doing. Amateur, woke and dangerous bollocks . Not fair on anyone and not remotely necessary for an office work environment.

Absolutely this!

tinatea · 20/01/2023 09:30

Maybe they couldn't hold it in whatever they were dealing with. Compassion goes a long way here. It may not have been appropriate to share at that event but I'm sure whatever the experience was caused a lot of trauma and all rationale goes out of the window.

BobDear · 20/01/2023 09:29

This is bullshit. You need to make a complaint.

Someone has given this the green light with no real thought or understanding for the harm they are doing. Amateur, woke and dangerous bollocks . Not fair on anyone and not remotely necessary for an office work environment.

katepilar · 20/01/2023 09:25

OP, your childhood trauma is just as valid as anyone elses. There isnt bigger and smaller trauma. Trauma isnt the thing that happened but your internal reaction to it. Please try not to feel bad about the reaction you had to this event as it has been really badly handled. They really should provide counselling for working through your emotional response. It may be more efficient if you seek help independently though.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 20/01/2023 09:20

BeachesDiary · 19/01/2023 22:56

I don't believe everything I hear. There's currency in victimhood. People are full of bullshit, people lie and people make stuff up. I wouldn't give it too. Much thought.

You sound nice.

Lily246 · 20/01/2023 09:18

i feel dreadfully sorry for your colleague & I think that the workplace activity was very likely to be inappropriate (unless, perhaps, you work in some sort of mental health setting, and even then, I’m not sure it’s acceptable).

I have had some training regarding acute/crisis mental health, including past abuse, & worked as a phone volunteer. I also have a traumatic personal history that I won’t go into here.

One of the things that victims of abuse, neglect or other horrific experiences often find difficult, whether they were ongoing or one-off events, is to know how to share, and who to share with. Some dive in and tell everyone everything, and they are, unfortunately, often seen as attention-seekers, but they are just trying to make sense of what happened, and perhaps repeat it until it feels and sounds normal. Maybe they are tying to ensure that people understand how common trauma is, or perhaps they didn’t feel listened to, supported, or believed by the people who matter most, and so they keep seeking to be heard.

Others say nothing at all to anyone.

Given this, your workplace should have put much more thought into how they delivered the session, if at all: what were they hoping or expecting people to share? How did they plan to set parameters to ensure everyone understood what was suitable material for sharing? What change did they hope for by holding the session? Was the format of the session likely to make this change?

RecoIIectionsMayVary · 20/01/2023 09:15

Are you able to share the training provider? I would be very interested to look into their qualifications.