Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to take DDs secret second phone away?

114 replies

PineappleRightsideup · 19/01/2023 19:03

Name changed so as to try not to give DD something else to complain about 😁

Would really appreciate any advice. DD is 14, since she turned 12 she's been difficult, argumentative and generally unpleasant. Despite this I have tried to stay positive and set firm rules. One non negotiable rule is that they have family link on their phones and phones (and other screens) are handed in at bedtime and not kept in rooms over night.

DD have been trying to avoid this rule for ages, she pretends to be asleep or hides her phone and says she can't find it etc. Last night she hadn't handed in so I went to get it and found she has another phone. I asked her about it today and apparently she bought it because she doesn't think she should have to had her phone in at nights as none of her friends do. She also thinks she should be able to have whatever apps she wants and have no restrictions because she's 14.

I could go on with everything DD currently dislikes but basically it's everything except her three friends. She's not well behaved at school either unfortunately and is currently refusing to do PE or wear shoes and doesn't care if she gets detentions.

Oh so not to drip feed, I feel I have to be a little bit careful as I'm worried she will move in with her biological father otherwise. He was extremely abusive to me but she has never seen that side of him and I have never wanted to tell her as they have a good relationship.

I feel a bit stuck at the moment.

Anyway part of me is hoping IABU and I should give the new phone back as it would be easier, but I don't think I am...

OP posts:
Lialou · 19/01/2023 21:12

Onnabugeisha · 19/01/2023 21:09

You do not respect her privacy.
You use family link to filter her search results, to track her location, to track all her internet activity, to disable when she can and cannot use apps.
Shes not allowed a means to communicate with friends in the evenings, because she has to hand her phone in ‘at bedtime’.
You obviously go through her phone.

That is disrespect. She is 14…when exactly are you going to teach her online safety versus keeping her wrapped in cotton wool? When exactly is she going to learn how to self-regulate phone use if you’re keeping her phone off her past bedtime every night—-when she’s 18? At what age do you think she has any right to privacy?

I agree with most of this. I do agree with the odd checking of the phones considering they are still children and could be hiding something serious like bullying or being exploited in some way. But I agree with the rest.

Onnabugeisha · 19/01/2023 21:09

You do not respect her privacy.
You use family link to filter her search results, to track her location, to track all her internet activity, to disable when she can and cannot use apps.
Shes not allowed a means to communicate with friends in the evenings, because she has to hand her phone in ‘at bedtime’.
You obviously go through her phone.

That is disrespect. She is 14…when exactly are you going to teach her online safety versus keeping her wrapped in cotton wool? When exactly is she going to learn how to self-regulate phone use if you’re keeping her phone off her past bedtime every night—-when she’s 18? At what age do you think she has any right to privacy?

PineappleRightsideup · 19/01/2023 21:05

Thanks everyone for all your replies, have read them all and will definitely taken everything on board. I had dd unlock the phone on front of me and we went through it together and I explained why I was concerned. There was nothing on there I wouldn't have approved except TikTok and the dubious fan fic. Also it doesn't have a sim which was a bit of a relief.

I think Saturdaynoon is correct and she has just got it so she cam have an unmonitored phone. She basically doesn't feel she should have to follow rules, including the schools and thinks we're all unreasonable. She then did say she'd just leave and I did snap and say well you can't go to your dad's because he does drugs and I'll call the police. Not my finest moment but she said she wouldn't want to live there anyway so that was something.

I can't tell her about the abuse. He is an incredibly charming and manipulative person and he absolutely would do everything he could to ensure she never spoke to me again if I did. I left when she was three months old when he beat me because he didn't like the sound of her drinking milk. I then refused to allow overnights til she could speak. She sees him sporadically now but when she does she's very much spoilt by him and her step mum and has no rules there.

I think that's answered all the questions, oh re her whereabouts, she's not secretive but is out a lot. Her friends all seem to be home bodies though so she just seems to sit round theirs.

OP posts:
PineappleRightsideup · 19/01/2023 20:54

Onnabugeisha · 19/01/2023 20:44

Yep. All my DCs’ friends had secret phones and SM accounts because their parents had no respect for their privacy and had them wrapped in cotton wool.

This is very common, and her attitude of disrespect is only mirroring what you show her.

Genuinely interested in knowing how I'm showing her disrespect. Really not wanting a drama, just curious, I feel like I saw yes to everything unless there's a good reason to say no.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 19/01/2023 20:44

Saturdaynoon · 19/01/2023 20:16

The reality is that, if a teenager feels that their phones are too closely monitored, they simply buy a second phone. DS told me that years ago.

Not saying don't monitor, but it is the easiest thing in the world for them to get around, so I think parents are fighting a losing battle with this one.

Yep. All my DCs’ friends had secret phones and SM accounts because their parents had no respect for their privacy and had them wrapped in cotton wool.

This is very common, and her attitude of disrespect is only mirroring what you show her.

AdamRyan · 19/01/2023 20:28

Saturdaynoon · 19/01/2023 20:16

The reality is that, if a teenager feels that their phones are too closely monitored, they simply buy a second phone. DS told me that years ago.

Not saying don't monitor, but it is the easiest thing in the world for them to get around, so I think parents are fighting a losing battle with this one.

Exactly
Much more likely than county lines

Zola1 · 19/01/2023 20:25

I'd want some more details about rhe second phone...if she bought it, who from, how much for, why didn't they need it? If online can you see the ad, if off a friend would their mum confirm it? Etc

Zola1 · 19/01/2023 20:24

Hedjwitch · 19/01/2023 20:19

What are county lines?

Criminal exploitation? When children znd vulnerable people are trafficked for the purposes of supplying drugs 'across county lines', although criminal exploitation and trafficking also happens in Borough too with the victim moving, minding or supplying drugs in their local area.

Hedjwitch · 19/01/2023 20:19

What are county lines?

Swannning · 19/01/2023 20:18

Check in with the school to see if there is any change in behaviour there. As others have said, a second phone is a big red flag for CSE / grooming etc.

Has her friendship group changed? Does she have unexplained money? Is she secretive about her whereabouts?

Saturdaynoon · 19/01/2023 20:16

The reality is that, if a teenager feels that their phones are too closely monitored, they simply buy a second phone. DS told me that years ago.

Not saying don't monitor, but it is the easiest thing in the world for them to get around, so I think parents are fighting a losing battle with this one.

GirloutofAfrica · 19/01/2023 20:15

Bigweekend · 19/01/2023 19:19

2nd phone coupled with a change in behaviour can be a warning sign of county lines or CSE.

How did she pay for the phone? Does she have other unexplained valuables or cash?

This. Be vigilant.

OhmygodDont · 19/01/2023 20:15

This is bigger issues than the phone ultimately. Also don’t throw it away. You didn’t pay for it but it or the registered owner of it. That would be theft she may be a child but that’s her personal possession that she has hopefully purchased not stolen. Confiscation is fine but binning or destroying not.

She needs to speak to someone so I would involve the school also don’t feather coat issues with dad be suitably honest.

Honestly as well during school holidays I’m not fussed what time my teen leaves his pit it’s his holiday from school his break. Unless we have plans to get up and be somewhere for if he wanted to lounge in bed watching YouTube that’s on him.

Hesma · 19/01/2023 20:14

I don’t want to panic you but a second phone is a major safeguarding red flag we get told about in school. Can be a sign of grooming or county lines. Please seek advice from school on this

LolaSmiles · 19/01/2023 20:12

2nd phone coupled with a change in behaviour can be a warning sign of county lines or CSE.

That would be my concern as well.

She needs to hear the truth about her dad in an age appropriate way, and OP might need to reach out to the school safeguarding lead about the second phone or to see what support there might be locally for children who are potentially at risk of county lines/cse.

user143677433 · 19/01/2023 20:09

It's keeping firm boundaries that gives her stability and a feeling of safety. Often kids will (subconsciously) push boundaries just for the reassurance of knowing they will be enforced. Stick to your guns.

AdamRyan · 19/01/2023 20:08

It's a "trap phone" she will be using it on WiFi to get round your bedtime and family link restrictions.

When I caught my DS doing this I bought a router where you could see what devices were connected and block ones you didn't know. And also you could set up blacklists of websites and "allowed" times. He hated it but it stopped the trap phone nonsense

www.tp-link.com/uk/support/faq/1531/

JanglyBeads · 19/01/2023 20:01

Are school not helpful? Do they know her background?

watchfulwishes · 19/01/2023 19:53

You need to tell her the truth about her dad, to some extent - I get you don't want to give all the details but you do have to be honest with kids.

You can confiscate both her phones. You have to parent her - you can't not parent her in case she goes to her dad's.

chocolateisavegetable · 19/01/2023 19:48

It might be worth talking to the school and see if they can give you some advice and support

Mariposista · 19/01/2023 19:37

Gosh no, you stick to your guns mum. Little madam needs to grow up and learn who is boss, and have a little respect for authority.

twohomesneeded · 19/01/2023 19:35

When friends have told me about their children behaving this way, the background is one of trauma. Is DD getting any support to talk through why she is choosing to act this way?

Teens being on mobiles til late and staying in bed til 2pm can still be with normal parameters but the lying, stealing, mood swings and deception over a 2nd mobile is a massive concern. Are you able to explain to her that your actions are because you are worried for her? That good parents don't let their teens do whatever they want when they want? She may feel at 14 she's in control (or wants control) but sadly some people the world will exploit her just because of her age.

JanglyBeads · 19/01/2023 19:30

Sorry just re read the OP and see you haven't told her anything. Read the Lundy book it talks about how to navigate this difficult path.

Is the contact court ordered?

JanglyBeads · 19/01/2023 19:27

How much contact does she have with dad? How old was she when you split and what has she witnessed directly (not that any of that was your fault of course)?

Read "When Dad Hurts Mom" by Lundy Bancroft.

Try Therapeutic Parenting.

LIZS · 19/01/2023 19:27

Who took the phone contract out for her ?