Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you've ever removed your child from nursery in favour of a childminder and your reasons?

35 replies

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 13:31

Currently thinking about doing this for my son who just isn't settling very well. He's upset every morning going to nursery, apparently angry whilst there and is refusing to nap. He used to love it but I think due to ever changing 'key workers' he's just feeling more and more unsettled and overwhelmed and I think he'd benefit from a smaller group / one caregiver instead of several.

Any positive stories? What have you found the benefits of a childminder over nursery?

OP posts:
Cyclingforcake · 19/01/2023 13:53

Yes I did reject one that had 3 big dogs. Current CM has a menagerie of small animals which they all adore.

Stonebridge · 19/01/2023 13:51

Yes, we did. My little guy started creche at about 13 months but by 15 months still hadn't settled. Wouldn't eat or drink or nap while there, crying a lot at drop off, and the staff were very inflexible and not willing to work with us to solve the problems, wouldn't allow us to provide food from home for him (may have been COVID rules, can't remember) but also wouldn't look into adapting his meals to things he would eat (he has sensory food issues). And their attitude was we can't hold him and comfort him all day because there are so many other children too. So I think he was left to cry for long stretches.
Moved to childminder and within a week he was running in by himself, no tears and hasn't looked back. He's now 3. She let us stay with him for short periods over the first week to settle him and then leave so he could see we trusted her. And she let him nap in the buggy as he wouldn't nap in the cot. We could then also provide food from home so he has always eaten for her. Just overall much more able and willing to adapt to his needs.
We originally went with a creche as we thought of the tighter health and safety regulations but his mental health was not considered by creche.
Child minder isn't as up to speed with health and safety though but overall we are so happy with her. Issues have been putting child in car seat with coat on and letting child sleep in car once home in warm weather. But no issues with changing what she was doing once we raised the concerns to her.
Hope that helps.

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 13:51

Thank you, it's great to hear the positive stories! I'm going to have a look around tonight.

A few I've looked at briefly the last few days seem to have dogs, which is just immediately putting me off those (I have a dog myself so nothing against them!) But I just don't think I'd be comfortable if they did. Anyone else have a no dog rule?

OP posts:
SilverHydrangea · 19/01/2023 13:48

Yes for a child who just did not settle at nursery. Move to childminder was so positive - lots more focussed attention in a lovely family environment & excellent communication. Did need to plan round childminders holidays but plenty of notice given and grandparents stepped in. Moved to school nursery for 12 months before starting full time education and this worked well too.

Cyclingforcake · 19/01/2023 13:43

Oh and the ill thing - most CMs don’t get paid when they’re ill so they mainly plough on through. And they’re often better at taking the slightly under the weather but not truly sick child than a nursery would. Ours has shut once (for Covid) in 3 years.

Cyclingforcake · 19/01/2023 13:41

Yes. I did. Lots of reasons but none of them because I was unhappy with the nursery.

DD was at the same nursery as DS but when he started school he went to the childminder for wrap around and I wanted them to go together. DD was in both settings as childminder didn’t have availability initially and then finally switched over completely at the start of lockdown as I needed bulletproof childcare during the early stages of the pandemic.

Best decision I ever made - she thrived in the smaller setting, loved the family environment and liked the challenge of being one of the ‘older’ ones last year. Her best friends are still the ones from the childminder even though they’re all in different years. And our childminder has become more like an extra grandparent than a key worker at a nursery could ever be - the consistency of the care has just worked for all of us.

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 13:39

Amuseaboosh · 19/01/2023 13:35

Aren't your reasons for removing him enough?

What do the nursery say?

Definitely try a CM. He'll get more one to one and be able to build a relationship with 1 person.

Yes, I'm just interested in discussing it with people who've already done it.

OP posts:
Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 13:38

Thanks. Have you found it difficult with things like potential time off when they are ill/on holiday?

OP posts:
OhBitchPeas · 19/01/2023 13:36

Yes I did.
best thing I ever did and my second and third child went straight to CM.

Nursery was rubbish, mainly 18 years olds, DS was overlooked, the closeness and attachment wasn't there like it is with a childminder.

Im not a fan of nurseries.

Amuseaboosh · 19/01/2023 13:35

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 13:31

Currently thinking about doing this for my son who just isn't settling very well. He's upset every morning going to nursery, apparently angry whilst there and is refusing to nap. He used to love it but I think due to ever changing 'key workers' he's just feeling more and more unsettled and overwhelmed and I think he'd benefit from a smaller group / one caregiver instead of several.

Any positive stories? What have you found the benefits of a childminder over nursery?

Aren't your reasons for removing him enough?

What do the nursery say?

Definitely try a CM. He'll get more one to one and be able to build a relationship with 1 person.