Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you've ever removed your child from nursery in favour of a childminder and your reasons?

35 replies

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 13:31

Currently thinking about doing this for my son who just isn't settling very well. He's upset every morning going to nursery, apparently angry whilst there and is refusing to nap. He used to love it but I think due to ever changing 'key workers' he's just feeling more and more unsettled and overwhelmed and I think he'd benefit from a smaller group / one caregiver instead of several.

Any positive stories? What have you found the benefits of a childminder over nursery?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
justgotosleepffs · 19/01/2023 21:28

I used a CM for my DCs many years ago. Advantages are:

  1. Home-like environment. DCs can have peace and quiet when they want, and get away from it all if they need to.
  2. I always felt young children need a close bond with a primary adult figure rather than lots of different adults.
  3. Flexibility, e.g to do a different day next week, paid half price retainer in school holidays
  4. Normal life experiences of birthday parties, toddler groups, etc.
  5. Illness, CM much more flexible about minor illnesses, temperatures. No silly 48 hours after vomiting when we all know they just went on the trampoline too soon after eating 3 slices of cake.
  6. If DCs were ever teary at drop-off, CM would then send me a photo of them playing happily but the time i arrived st work, such a nice touch so i didn't worry all day.
OCDmama · 19/01/2023 20:57

Have a simply wonderful childminder. DD will be hopefully going to a school nursery once she turns three and I'll be very sad she'll leave the CM, but have already asked CM to look after our son (due Feb) after mat leave.

Our CM is Ofsted inspected, provides a beautiful home from home setting and doesn't cancel. She's had to take a week off for surgery and appointments but gives loads of notice. She is term time only so we know when holidays are.

I'll also say - DD really benefits from CM's own children and the other kids she looks after. And she doesn't get sick nearly as much as friends kids in nurseries.

lovepigeon · 19/01/2023 16:49

I used childminders for both of mine from age 1 to 2.5, then mixed part time pre nursery from 2.5 gradually increasing till just nursery from 3ish. I did have a wobble with my eldest a few months after going back to school because all my colleagues and other working mums I knew favoured nursery so I had a few sessions at different local highly regarded nurseries. Those convinced me that whilst nursery was brilliant for the slightly older children (say 2.5 or 3 and older) it felt very stressful for the under 2s.

I used a different childminder for each child due to moving areas and both were brilliant. My children settled quickly and did lovely outings and activities with the childminder. I preferred the more relaxed homely environment whilst they were younger then switching to nursery later when they were ready.

nokidshere · 19/01/2023 16:20

Often childminders cancel sessions (sometimes last minute) due to illness, holidays etc and then you're left with no childcare, whereas with a nursery you generally know when they'll be shut in advance. There's also no guarantee a childminder will be able to put your child down for a nap either. If I were you I'd just switch nurseries.

On the other hand most childminders I know only shut if it's absolutely unavoidable, are available to have your child if they are 'under the weather' and always book holidays in conjunction with parents or a long way in advance.

I've been childminding for over 20yrs and have never had an instance where I have been unable to put a child down for a nap. On the contrary, I can get children to nap even when the parent has told me 'they never sleep in the day'.

jellybe · 19/01/2023 16:11

I did for very similar reasons to your post. Best thing I did for DS and my peace of mind whilst at work.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/01/2023 16:09

I did with DD4. I had used the same nursery for my elder three children. However, a new manager came in, staff retention became poor, corners started being cut and bumped heads/falling over/scrapes and bumps (which I appreciate totally are normal) became far too frequent so I moved her.

She loved the CM. She loved the smaller group and loved the mixed ages of the children - especially after collecting the "big kids" from school in the afternoon.

chocolatebuttonlover · 19/01/2023 16:05

Am considering pulling mine out of nursery at the moment, feel like since she moved from baby room the quality of care is way lower and I don't feel that she's looked after as well.

Kindofcrunchy · 19/01/2023 15:21

OhBitchPeas · 19/01/2023 14:29

Napping in a noisy nursery is much harder!

OP I've had three different childminders (3 kids) and all three have been reliable and never had issues with putting the kids down for a nap.

My friend's 18 month goes to a childminder full time since she was 1yo. She recently stopped napping completely, even though there's only 1 or 2 other children being looked after there. I know that's only one example and probably not the norm, but you can't say it's a given that they'll sleep better at a childminder. Conversely I have a friend who has been a nursery worker for many years, the kids there all nap together well in a special quiet room for a set period. It must vary massively.

morechocolateneededtoday · 19/01/2023 14:58

Used childminder for both children until they were 3 and definitely the right choice for me. I wanted a home environment when they were younger which the childminder provided. It most closely replicated if the child were to be at home with me - the daily school run, going to shops, park and also developing bonds with older children. They developed a good attachment to her and still remember her very fondly. Our childminder was extremely reliable - only unplanned days off were the few days she was Covid positive and not legally allowed to open. She would have planned holidays and would tell us the dates a year in advance.

I felt much more confident finding a nursery for an older child - picked one based on their personality and what I wanted from it. Chosen nursery was staffed by older, more experienced staff members with a big focus on learning (through play ofc). When they started at 3 years old, they settled into nursery without looking back once - they were absolutely ready for the step.

muddlingthrou · 19/01/2023 14:46

I've literally just done this from the start of the year with my 10 mo. I liked the nursery and my DD clearly had a lot of fun there, but she just would not nap!
We gave it four months and it got worse rather than better, so we decided to move her to a childminder. Now, she sleeps for an hour in the morning and 1.5-2hr in the afternoon and is so much less overtired in the evenings. Just go with your gut.

Matleavemummy · 19/01/2023 14:44

@Gurrrrr hmmm that’s bad of your nursery - ours change once a year, like a teacher. They change rooms in the same way they change classrooms. One might argue they don’t need that when a bit younger though. You mentioned lashing out, Oddly I’ve had friends moved children from a CM to a nursery when they started showing these traits, I don’t think they tend to with more children around.
ultimately no one knows your child’s needs better than you, these forums can be tricky as you’ll get people’s experiences and views but they almost mean nothing as all children are different -
a great move for one isn’t good for another

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 14:37

Main reason for considering CM now over nursery is I'm wondering if he is now more suited to a smaller group and the potential for more focused attention with there not being as many children. And the fact there is one sole caregiver who doesn't change rather than many/changing rooms etc..

OP posts:
Matleavemummy · 19/01/2023 14:29

Hi @Gurrrrr is there a reason why you aren’t switching nurseries rather than considering switching to a childminder? You must have “preferred” the idea of a nursery over CM originally if that’s the route you went down. It’s quite difficult to get advice as parents are often firmly in one camp.

How old is your child? I am in the nursery camp but only because evidence was overwhelmingly in favour of pre-school age children being in a nursery settting rather than CM, so wanted to keep him in a nursery to save moving about. I much prefer the idea of them having several adults to interact with a day and always being around children their own age, like school, rather than lots of children with different needs. I know you didn’t ask for this but there would have been a reason why you chose nursery in the first place! They might just be unsettled there rather than needing a CM!

OhBitchPeas · 19/01/2023 14:29

Kindofcrunchy · 19/01/2023 14:15

The general consensus between friends with preschoolers is that nurseries are far more reliable. Often childminders cancel sessions (sometimes last minute) due to illness, holidays etc and then you're left with no childcare, whereas with a nursery you generally know when they'll be shut in advance. There's also no guarantee a childminder will be able to put your child down for a nap either. If I were you I'd just switch nurseries.

Napping in a noisy nursery is much harder!

OP I've had three different childminders (3 kids) and all three have been reliable and never had issues with putting the kids down for a nap.

Kindofcrunchy · 19/01/2023 14:15

The general consensus between friends with preschoolers is that nurseries are far more reliable. Often childminders cancel sessions (sometimes last minute) due to illness, holidays etc and then you're left with no childcare, whereas with a nursery you generally know when they'll be shut in advance. There's also no guarantee a childminder will be able to put your child down for a nap either. If I were you I'd just switch nurseries.

Forthelast · 19/01/2023 14:14

It was just the right time - nursery was great for the younger years for mine but they didn't have the programme that a good childminder did when they were old enough to enjoy being out and about.

DorotheaHomeAlone · 19/01/2023 14:12

DC1 went to cm but was ready for nursery by the time dc2 started so we put them both in nursery. Dc2 hated it and was miserable. Not moving him to a CM is my biggest parenting regret (although he’s fine now, no lasting harm). He never settled there really. DC3 is at CM and will be until she’s ready for preschool. I think it’s just a much better, more homely and emotionally secure environment for little ones.

Current CM has a small dog, 3 cats and a hamster. We have no concerns because we trust her judgement.

fruitpastille · 19/01/2023 14:10

My cm has a dog but it is mostly kept away from the children. I rarely see it unless I pop round out of hours. It's worth considering which school they do pick up and drop off for future wraparound care. Also ask around locally for word of mouth recommendations. My cm is well known and respected in the local community. All the teachers at school know her too!

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 14:03

Maybe I'd feel differently if I met them and they seemed perfect. For now, I'd like to avoid dogs if I can.

OP posts:
Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 14:02

I'm also wondering if a CM would be better to suited in terms of his behaviour as well. He's started lashing out and being defensive a bit like pushing other children away if they get close to him / hitting if another child tries to take a toy etc.. I know these are common behaviours but it worries me that they are being sort of heightened at nursery because there are just so many children to contend with and the staff don't have the time to effectively deal with it.

OP posts:
Whydotheyallhaverubbishwheels · 19/01/2023 14:02

No CMS round here had availability. I was very lucky to find ours, she is highly recommended. The dogs wouldn't have put me off though if there had been other choices of cm.

Gurrrrr · 19/01/2023 14:01

Whydotheyallhaverubbishwheels · 19/01/2023 14:00

Oops forgot to say the cm has 2 dogs, they're lovely and gentle and my son adores them. I'm a dog lover though so it really doesn't bother me.

They go on lots of outings with the cm. He calls her nanny 🤣 he's only been there 4 weeks. I just got a good feeling when I met her.

I absolutely love dogs too (have one ourselves who's just gorgeous and so gentle) but I don't know... It just makes me a bit uncomfortable so I think it would just be best for me to avoid those with dogs.

OP posts:
Whydotheyallhaverubbishwheels · 19/01/2023 14:00

Oops forgot to say the cm has 2 dogs, they're lovely and gentle and my son adores them. I'm a dog lover though so it really doesn't bother me.

They go on lots of outings with the cm. He calls her nanny 🤣 he's only been there 4 weeks. I just got a good feeling when I met her.

Whydotheyallhaverubbishwheels · 19/01/2023 13:57

Yep, recently change to a childminder because he broke his 2 front teeth at nursery and they didn't notice.

Stonebridge · 19/01/2023 13:55

Also to add, I love that with the childminder he gets to experience more of the community as they're out and about to the shops and the playground and school pick ups for the other kids so it's a lot more varied than a full day of creche in the one setting.