Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect my GP receptionist to not block me from seeking treatment?

186 replies

GoldenCagedBird · 19/01/2023 10:00

Been dealing with a thrombosed, prolapsed pile since Saturday. It’s my first one, never had one before nor a history of poo problems. Came on very quickly. (I have been moaning about it on another thread in chat-
sorry for the constant threads about my bumhole)

In agony. Can’t walk properly. Can’t parent properly. Can’t sit. Breastfeeding, holding my baby, pushing my pram- all hurt and put pressure on the area. The pile has just got more and more blue and angry. I constantly feel it pulsing.

Spoke to a doctor on Monday who prescribed me the prescription-only steroid cream, painkillers and other stuff to ward off any constipation. Strict instructions to call back if the pile doesn’t seem to be improving in 48 hours.

It’s been over 48 hours. The strong painkillers manage the pain, but I can still ‘feel it’ pulsing and need to stay topped up with alarms. No shrinkage, if anything it’s gotten bigger (plum sized)

I called back today and this was how the exchange went.

Me- ‘Good morning, just calling the doctor back. My name is xyz abc. Date of birth- 11th novembuary 2003. I was prescribed some steroid treatment for a severe pile and was told call back in 48 hours if it hasn’t improved’.

GPR- ‘Hello there, we are only doing acute illnesses and emergencies today so you will need to call back tomorrow. Goodby-‘

me interjecting- ‘I have a blue, pulsating pile protruding from my anus the size of a plum, I can barely walk, I’m struggling to look after my child, I’m in constant pain without the naproxen, the doctor told me to call back if the steroids prescribed hadn’t improved the situation.’

GPR deep audible sigh - ‘I’ll put you on the list for the doctor to call you. Bye.’

Is this a common exchange now? I’m in quite good health and haven’t had to call the GP in a while. My first appointment on Monday, the receptionist at least asked what was wrong and triaged me accordingly.

I completely get that gate keeping needs to be done as they are so stretched, but it just felt really mean and unhelpful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bakebeans · 20/01/2023 14:30

C8H10N4O2 · 20/01/2023 08:08

The receptionist told her "no, goodbye" and the OP had to assert herself strongly to get a reluctant appointment. This is a common experience - you have to become the "sharp elbowed" to get access to health care. Those without sharp elbows or the hours to hang around on the phone miss out on health care.

Receptionists are not qualified to triage but the problem is just as much with practices using them as cheap triage services.

I believe that on the second attempt the receptionist put her down for a call back? So that wasn't blocking her was it.
no they are not medically trained but you shouldn't be tying everyone with the same brush!

some are in fact very valuable and do pick things up. Some don't! I've had both positive and negative experience.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 20/01/2023 08:28

Forthelast · 19/01/2023 12:56

Clearly you'd be in the wrong job then.

Exactly. What an absolutely horrible thing to say, makes the point that disclosing medical details to medically unqualified people is wrong

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 20/01/2023 08:24

SultanOfSwing · 19/01/2023 12:54

The whole arrangement is a disgrace. GP receptionists are not nurses and absolutely do not have enough medical knowledge to safely triage anyone. No one should have to give a medically untrained receptionist intimate details of their symptoms. A receptionist without medical/ nursing qualifications is not in a position to decide who needs to be seen.

If the system is now phone and get triaged, then GPs need to be hiring nurses to answer the phone. (Press 1 to speak to a triage nurse or hold the line for the receptionist.)

YANBU.

Yes. Agree. Another poster on here mentioned that receptionists have trainkng in confidentiality....
thids is very, very minimsl compare to degree level and higher degree level teaching on tbe topic to doctors and nurses during their undergraduate and post graduate training. You need years of experience of seeing and caring for patients in pain , distress etc. to have a real understanding of confidentiality and the need for a relationship of trust not just data protection and GDPR stuff.
Experienced practice nurses could perhaps be on hour long triage rotas during their hours of work throughout the day... routine calls to receptionist, triage calls to practice nurse on a different number.

C8H10N4O2 · 20/01/2023 08:08

bakebeans · 19/01/2023 21:18

Not sure why you were told 48 hours as usually 3 days but you are only doing as advised. The receptionist hasn't blocked treatment though as you are down for a call. Did the Gp inform you of the next steps of no improvement after the 48 hours should you call back ie referral to colorectal team for a camera or admittance to a&e? Hopefully you will get some answers soon. I can't imagine how painful it must be especially with a baby. Take care

The receptionist told her "no, goodbye" and the OP had to assert herself strongly to get a reluctant appointment. This is a common experience - you have to become the "sharp elbowed" to get access to health care. Those without sharp elbows or the hours to hang around on the phone miss out on health care.

Receptionists are not qualified to triage but the problem is just as much with practices using them as cheap triage services.

Kiwirose · 19/01/2023 23:47

PumpkinQueen1 · 19/01/2023 20:07

I work in a GP surgery. Receptionists do not triage patients, as they are not clinically trained.

In our surgery, when a patient asks for an appointment, and there is one available, they are booked. They are asked for a brief description of the problem so it can be noted on the appointment, so the GP has some idea of what the patient is seeing them for.

If the appointments are full, which often happens by 9am due to the sheer volume of calls, the patient will be asked if it is medically urgent for today. If they say it is, the receptionist will put them on the duty Dr's list for a call. The receptionist does not triage, if the patient says it's urgent they are put on the list.

When the duty list is full, receptionists send a task to the duty dr for each patient requesting an urgent call, asking how to proceed. The GP will decide whether it is urgent and needs a call today, or whether it can wait. This is why the receptionist asks for details of the problem.

This continues until the duty dr advises reception they are unable to take any more patients that day, at which point receptionists will advise patients to call 111 or go to A&E.

Most days the duty list becomes full, usually in the afternoon. Before christmas the duty list was full by 10am on several days, due to the news coverage of strep A.

GP receptionists at my surgery are not employed to block anyone's care. The real problem is the system. We have 7 GPs, and 11,000 patients. You do the maths, it's not the receptionists fault.

I hear you pumpkin.

I can't believe the basing GP receptionists get for following the protocols the GPs devise. It must be and unbelievably stressful job.

bakebeans · 19/01/2023 21:18

Not sure why you were told 48 hours as usually 3 days but you are only doing as advised. The receptionist hasn't blocked treatment though as you are down for a call. Did the Gp inform you of the next steps of no improvement after the 48 hours should you call back ie referral to colorectal team for a camera or admittance to a&e? Hopefully you will get some answers soon. I can't imagine how painful it must be especially with a baby. Take care

dollytot · 19/01/2023 21:12

@SiennaSienna

Thanks for sharing. It's always interesting to see how other countries deal with things. Personally, having lived in Asia I loved being able to go to any pharmacy and get my medication with ease, or see a doctor whenever I wanted. I had to pay of course, but the cost was a fraction of that in the West and the care was excellent.

I foresee American style privatisation instead thanks to our Conservatives and their American healthcare lobbyists.

This - 100%.

Frenulumetta · 19/01/2023 20:50

How fucking rude she heard the word pile and thought you were being ridiculous probably rolled her eyes to her colleagues it's not a trivial matter it is bloody urgent and not normal call 111 and get their advice and ring back and demand ir is an emergency if you cannot sit walk and are in agony it needs bloody sorting properly hope it's better soon.

temporarynamehere · 19/01/2023 20:46

Maybe they shouldn't do it, but I got triaged by my GP's receptionists. I'd been told by a HCP to talk to my GP about a specific problem I'd mentioned in passing, as it needed investigating. When I rang & tried to make an appointment for a phone consultation with the GP, the receptionist told me I should go in & see their nurse who specialised in exactly this problem, & not bother with the GP. But when I saw the nurse she asked me why I was there, as she deals with the acute version of this problem, & mine was chronic. Complete waste of time, & neither of us was happy about it. So yeah, they shouldn't triage patients.

PumpkinQueen1 · 19/01/2023 20:07

I work in a GP surgery. Receptionists do not triage patients, as they are not clinically trained.

In our surgery, when a patient asks for an appointment, and there is one available, they are booked. They are asked for a brief description of the problem so it can be noted on the appointment, so the GP has some idea of what the patient is seeing them for.

If the appointments are full, which often happens by 9am due to the sheer volume of calls, the patient will be asked if it is medically urgent for today. If they say it is, the receptionist will put them on the duty Dr's list for a call. The receptionist does not triage, if the patient says it's urgent they are put on the list.

When the duty list is full, receptionists send a task to the duty dr for each patient requesting an urgent call, asking how to proceed. The GP will decide whether it is urgent and needs a call today, or whether it can wait. This is why the receptionist asks for details of the problem.

This continues until the duty dr advises reception they are unable to take any more patients that day, at which point receptionists will advise patients to call 111 or go to A&E.

Most days the duty list becomes full, usually in the afternoon. Before christmas the duty list was full by 10am on several days, due to the news coverage of strep A.

GP receptionists at my surgery are not employed to block anyone's care. The real problem is the system. We have 7 GPs, and 11,000 patients. You do the maths, it's not the receptionists fault.

Allblackeverythingalways · 19/01/2023 19:15

I had to get some incorrect information changed on my records. Contacted the gp surgery as it seemed a good starting point.

Got passed back and forth between GP, clinic and 111 many times. Clinic and 111 INSIST the GP surgery must sort it.

I ended up really pissing off the gatekeeper at the GPs because when she refused (for the third time) I said "Oh... Well I asked 111 what I should do when you inevitably fob me off again and they said speak to the practice manager so I will speak with her now please."
It was done within 24 hours.
I am VERY pushy now. I'm rarely ill. If I am I won't be dictated to by someone with zero medical training.
I really feel for people that can't advocate clearly or themselves.

babsanderson · 19/01/2023 18:54

My surgery you ring for an in the day appointment either at 8am or 2pm.

Boscoforever · 19/01/2023 18:52

GP receptionists must not, can not and should not triage patients. The GP surgeries know this. Complain in writing OP.
On another note, I had this after my first-the pain! I remember the home midwife had a look and felt so sorry for me. Anyway, GP said you need proctosedyl ointment AND the suppositories to kick it. They worked pretty quickly. Hope you get sorted.

SnowyOwl1 · 19/01/2023 18:41

fishonabicycle · 19/01/2023 16:50

Did you phone when the surgery opened, or late in the day? Obviously bookable appointments will have gone by late in the day. We get tired of the people who play the system, can't be bothered to call at 8 when the surgery opens, and then demand an appointment, always saying it's urgent. I'm not saying that is you, but there are a lot of people do this.

I love it if you have any sort of illness with sudden onset during the day after 8am you are screwed.

My son has issues with his breathing when he gets a cough, he's still not diagnosed with Asthma due to his age, he's 4. He's been to hosptal around 5 times with breathing difficulties (gasping and turning blue, not a little wheeze). He came home from school and I realised he was unwell and his inhaler was very empty, I rang the doctors at 3.30pm to say he had a cough come on and his breathing was wheezy, once he lies down to sleep he'll need his inhaler as a matter of urgency and its empty. I was told no appointments, I said I don't want one, I just want another prescription to pick an inhaler up. No. You've just changed doctors and there's no repeat prescription on the record so the doctor can't without an appointment. OK can I wait at the end of the surgery as he'll not be able to breathe later. No. OK what do you suggest? Go to A+E. He doesnt need A+E right now, are you proposing I wait until its an emergency and he can't breathe rather than trying to squeeze us in and getting an inhaler to prevent a trip to a+e. Well yes... so would you like the appointment tomorrow or shall I cancel. Well I need an appointment or we'll never be able to get an inhaler! (I'll add my husband had already rang up before me and been met with the same reply and I told him he clearly didn't explain the urgency, he said he did and they said no 🤣, he was right!)

I ended up going to my parent's house and getting a spare inhaler my dad has (same inhaler). Good job i did he did need it in the night several times. When I saw the gp the next day for the appointment I told him about my exchange with the receptionist, he was horrified and told me there's always space at the end of the day for emergencies like this. He said I want you to book another appointment for 2 weeks time and take spirometry measurements twice a day. I said well it'll be 6 weeks time when we see you as I can't book anything sooner according to your receptionist, as by magic he said "I see, ok I will book you an appointment now for 2 weeks time", and booked one for us.

Everyone is treated like a time waster at the moment. I haven't visited the doctors for myself since 2015, I only make appointments when it's something serious, I hate the attitude you are met with. I will be changing doctors, my old GPS had a wonderful online system where the doctor read your online requests, no receptionist in the way, an amazing service. I had mastitis just after giving birth 18 months ago, I messaged that I was v unwell (in bed and couldnt lift my head ill) and knew it was mastitis (3rd child), gp rang within 30min and offered an appointment that day (I didn't want it, just a prescription, first time having antibiotics as an adult ill add!). If I rang my new GPS I'd have had to beg for an appointment using their shitty telephone system and hope they felt my raging infection warranted an appointment, according to their years of intense training 🤣.

Bananallamarama · 19/01/2023 17:56

GoldenCagedBird · 19/01/2023 12:58

Im sorry you didn’t get the result you wanted!

I do think GP receptionists can be a little curt at times, but you never know who they’ve dealt with that morning. They could have had patients yelling at them, or an influx of non urgent stuff and people demanding to be seen.

Ar our GP practice EVERYTHING is phone triaged. Emergencies are same day, and routine appointments are usually 2-3 weeks away.

After the phone call, when I’ve needed to be seen, they’ve called me in the same day.

I think that’s just the post covid world we live in.

Sympathy btw - I had a thrombosed pile too, although it was grape sized. Very blue and pretty painful, although not unbearable. It did shrink back after treatment but it took a week!

PrinceYakimov · 19/01/2023 17:18

OP, you are NBU.

I am prescribed a extremely common medication, but for an off-label indication (ie for a slightly niche medical reason). Every single time I contact my surgery to renew my prescription, the reception staff triage me into the wrong prescribing route, no matter how carefully I explain.

I frequently end up having to have multiple appointments just to get a single prescription renewal because I invariably get sent to see the wrong clinician. This wastes my time and the clinician's time, and often means I end up missing doses because I can't get the right appointment before I run out.

Advicerequest · 19/01/2023 17:07

I get appointments but I have to fight and argue. I am articulate and unintimidated by doctors. This gave me the confidence to question a registrar who ignored a potentially life threatening condition.
I am aware every single time this happens that my local area is full of far less assertive privileged and fluent English speakers than myself. They haven't a hope of navigating this system.

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 19/01/2023 17:07

before the pandemic I had to make a follow-up apointment in person after seeing another medical professional. Handed over my letter to the receptionist at the GP. She glanced down, back up at me, and in the most patronising voice "um, WHY do you need this appointment?" like I'd asked her for a fucking kidney. It was an upsetting thing (not life threatening but had been something ongoing for a long time), and I couldn't help myself, I just came out with, "um, why don't you READ the letter?"

SiennaSienna · 19/01/2023 16:54

SiennaSienna · 19/01/2023 16:51

@dollytot That's a good question. It's not a perfect system over here and each province is different although healthcare is free. The conservative led provinces are unfortunately trying to run down the public system by not spending federal healthcare Dollars in order to bring in private alternatives (they are spending on unnecessary highways instead of healthcare staff but I digress) My experience (admittedly in a wealthy, middle class part of Ontario) has been fantastic - GP appointments are same day or in the same week, specialist referrals as necessary. Walk-in clinics for out of hours appointments and open access to paediatric hospitals for kids emergencies and general care. Waiting times for non-urgent care can be long however. Ideally, I'd love to see a French or German system with parallel public and private options, which would bring down general waiting times. Unfortunately, I foresee American style privatisation instead thanks to our Conservatives and their American healthcare lobbyists.

oops I meant 'waiting times for non urgent specialist care can be long'

fishonabicycle · 19/01/2023 16:51

Because so many people were doing this we have recently been told to only let people have a triaged appointment if they are really pushing for it/sounds really urgent.

SiennaSienna · 19/01/2023 16:51

@dollytot That's a good question. It's not a perfect system over here and each province is different although healthcare is free. The conservative led provinces are unfortunately trying to run down the public system by not spending federal healthcare Dollars in order to bring in private alternatives (they are spending on unnecessary highways instead of healthcare staff but I digress) My experience (admittedly in a wealthy, middle class part of Ontario) has been fantastic - GP appointments are same day or in the same week, specialist referrals as necessary. Walk-in clinics for out of hours appointments and open access to paediatric hospitals for kids emergencies and general care. Waiting times for non-urgent care can be long however. Ideally, I'd love to see a French or German system with parallel public and private options, which would bring down general waiting times. Unfortunately, I foresee American style privatisation instead thanks to our Conservatives and their American healthcare lobbyists.

fishonabicycle · 19/01/2023 16:50

Did you phone when the surgery opened, or late in the day? Obviously bookable appointments will have gone by late in the day. We get tired of the people who play the system, can't be bothered to call at 8 when the surgery opens, and then demand an appointment, always saying it's urgent. I'm not saying that is you, but there are a lot of people do this.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 19/01/2023 16:47

Kennykenkencat · 19/01/2023 16:07

Our gp’s receptionists only give out appointments if you tell them why you need to see a doctor.
Then they decide if in their non medical opinion it warrants seeing a dictor

Not that when you see the doctor you actually get anywhere to a diagnosis

I have taken to booking a 111 doctor as at least you don’t have to waste upteen appointments where nothing gets done and then you end up in A&E because all your skin is falling off your face because a doctor told you that you couldn’t possibly be allergic to hyaluronic acid.

Turns out it took my skin off during the allergy test Not that my GP surgery think you can test for allergies. My daughter wanted to book her own but was told firstly that there was no such thing and secondly after she said that I had a patch test and that was what she wanted.
Dd was told I made it up about having an allergy test and I wasn’t to be believed.
When Dd said she had seen all the stuff attached to my back they insisted it was fake and I had made the patch test up myself.

Hyaluronic acid ? As in face cream ? Why did you end up with your ‘face falling off’ when you could have done a patch test on the back of your hand ?

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 19/01/2023 16:42

Shutthefrontdoor99 · 19/01/2023 16:05

This is what I hate about doctors surgeries now. A receptionist is just that, a receptionist. I don't like having to divulge my health problems with a non health professional, who then gets to decide how important my health problem is, with their non doctorate training, and assess whether I need help or not (to be seen by a doctor or just a call or whatever).

Triage nurse is a different story. Give me one of those any day!

20th December 8am. Rang the surgery because my partner who has a vascular ulcers on his leg woke up in agony and when I checked under the dressing, the skin was angry and the wound was weeping - dressed two days earlier by district nurses who, at that point, were coming once a week and were fantastic. He has ischaemic heart disease, has lost a leg due to the same vascular problems causing the ulcer I was reporting as worse, and is diabetic which doesn’t help. She told me there were no more appointments left and that ‘if I was worried’ I should ring 111. Which I did. They were useless. After referring on to the triage nurse they decided that my partner should ring the local pharmacy who could prescribe appropriate antibiotics until I could get an appointment with my GP. Thank God I didn’t. I got him to A&E at our local hospital and they checked his records and got a vascular consultant down. He was admitted immediately and put on IV antibiotics for two days, then discharged into the care of daily district nurses to make sure the wound wasn’t showing signs of gangrene. I have absolutely no faith in GPs for a number of reasons and this experience just reinforced it.

Seeingadistance · 19/01/2023 16:38

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 19/01/2023 16:31

Why is it hell, unless they make it so ?

Since Autumn I've been getting frequent text message before 8am from my GP surgery saying that they are overwhelmed, understaffed, have very few appointments available and can only deal with emergencies.

I imagine it must be pretty hellish being a receptionist in that surgery, having to tell people that they can't get an appointment.

I've had mostly bad experiences with GP receptionists who are almost always (in my experience) dragons with little empathy or people-skills, but right now I think they are trying to do the impossible and I really feel for them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread