Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cannot forgive my daughters boyfriend

195 replies

user1474905027 · 19/01/2023 09:41

I’m being made to feel that I’m the bad person here .. My daughter was buying a property with boyfriend. She had saved and saved and had a good amount .. he apparently said he had done the same - it was an equal share both apparently looking after their own finances. At the last point a few days before exchange he revealed to her he had lost his savings for deposit to online betting/gaming. She was devastated we all were. The house and dreams of their future had gone. His lies for months and months to her and everyone around him came to light. She was angry but insisted she stays with him, loves him and wants to help him. I can’t bear the thought of her being with him now .. how can he ever be trusted.

Our relationship is fraught now. I can’t bring myself to understand her decision. She’s worth so much more. I don’t want to loose my daughter.

OP posts:
BaconChops · 20/01/2023 20:39

I’m a mum and completely understand and empathise where you’re coming from BUT after many arguments a friend gave me some good advice. It’s your job to love your daughter not to tell her who she can and cannot love. It works trust me.

5128gap · 20/01/2023 20:35

Don't be angry with her or think less of her.
She is young, and it takes many of us many years before we lose our inate trust in those we love, our capacity to forgive as a sign of our own commitment, and our faith in our own ability to 'love them better'.
All you can do is hope that this is one of the rare occasions where this is a one off (unlikely) or that your daughter will gain the awareness she needs as quickly and painlessly as possible.
I assume you've said your piece, so no point in repeating it. This is a lesson that can't be taught, only learned from experience.

Wally1983 · 20/01/2023 20:32

You can’t say anything, the only thing you can do is support her decision.
as hard as that is she needs to make the choice herself, when she’s ready/when (or if) he’s done it again.
advise (I say that as she’ll not want to hear it currently) that she keeps her finances her own and she does NOT bail him out EVER.
having supported my best friend through her ex h being a gambler I’m saying it as someone that never stepped in ever, she needed to do it for her and her kids! She’s finally free and living her best life. (He also drove wedges between her and her friends and family over the years so be aware incase it’s similar in your case…always check in even if things are difficult between you)
wishing your daughter a happy and non gambling life because it’s one I’d not wish on my worst enemy xx

mathanxiety · 20/01/2023 20:24

I think you could be blunt with your daughter.

In a way, the decision to stay with someone who is very bad for her mirrors the behaviour of an addict. She's choosing a course of action that makes no sense but must be getting something out of it if she won't walk away.

She and her BF may both need to experience the consequences of their choices. You are not obliged to pretend anything is OK here.

Fudgemonkeys · 20/01/2023 20:21

All you can do is say you'll support her, be there for her, respect her decision and let her get on with it. If you try and dictate you'll lose her. She's an adult after all. Think about how you'd feel if someone tried to tell you what to do? . I do understand how you feel. Good luck.

mathanxiety · 20/01/2023 20:17

I can understand your horror.

I'd feel exactly the same.

Your daughter needs to wake up. She's loyal to a complete loser who has totally shafted her.

Best advice I would give her is to never, ever marry him, absolutely never have a baby with him, and to always keep her finances separate. This isn't a recipe for a solid relationship, obv.

ExtraOnions · 20/01/2023 19:47

I always tend to jump into these threads. I was a compulsive gambler, for me it was online slots. It was a dark & miserable time in my life, that almost ended with me stepping in front of a train.

However, I told my husband who was very supportive. I got help from Gamcare, and registered with Gamstop. I handed my cards over to my husband, and just got a cash allowance for the first few months. We were also transparent with finances.

I had quite the debt - all personal stuff, I’d never missed a payment for household stuff. 4 years on, I’m still gamble free .. and still clearing the debt - nearly there!

Thing is, you have to want to stop .. and prepared to take the steps to remove the opportunity & means

Lovely13 · 20/01/2023 19:34

Have been there on the other side. Son got a gambling habit, including taking all his student loan to a casino! It was a bad time. Got him to gamblers anonymous. Some years later, He’s now a happy, home-owning person with a good job and lovely partner.
If he wants to change and gets proper help, it’s not the end. Be there for her. And him. People can grow and learn from idiotic mistakes. Best of luck to you all 🤞

AcrossthePond55 · 20/01/2023 19:33

Who in the hell says you have to 'forgive' him? I certainly wouldn't. But if I wanted to keep my relationship with my child, the decisions I'd have to make would be 1-whether or not I ever permitted their partner to enter my home or be in his/her presence again AND 2-whether and/or how I would discuss the matter with my child in the future.

If my child were to tell me they were staying with an addict (of any kind) I would certainly let them know off the bat where I stood and that there would be no active 'support' for them from us, but then I'd clam up. I'd also tell my child that I would be 'polite' to their partner. But in return, my child would need to understand that if they brought up their relationship I wouldn't lie about my feelings or pretend I was happy about it. As far as admitting them to my home, I'd probably do that unless the person had ever been caught stealing. Then I wouldn't allow them to cross my threshold.

Hopefully that would be enough of a 'compromise' that my child would stay in my life. If not, then I'd let them know they were always welcome back, at any time.

momtoboys · 20/01/2023 19:20

Watching our adult children make mistakes in life is so difficult. Unfortunately, this is not your decision to make. If you push it I'm afraid you WILL lose her.

CockSpadget · 20/01/2023 19:20

If they got to the point of nearing exchange, then he must have gambled it recently, as to get a mortgage approved and that far down the line, you have to prove you have the deposit. Ie, show bank statements etc. something doesn’t add up.

Brighteyedtriangle · 20/01/2023 19:07

Err try everything possible to get her away from this man. He will let her down again and again.

If his savings if he ever had any are now gone. He will start spending hers. So sad for you and her. What a peice of shit.

user1467306011 · 20/01/2023 19:02

user1498572889 · 19/01/2023 10:14

You are right OP. Once a gambler always a gambler.

Wrong! Not in every case. One of my family had a really bad gambling habit until he was found out. It took that major shock of him nearly losing his family for to stop. He hasn't gambled since.
Don't lose your daughter over your anger Op. Help and support your family. They both need you right now.

Sep200024 · 20/01/2023 18:41

If you show your animosity and dislike towards this man, then you are going to drive a wedge between yourself and your daughter (regardless of whether you are right or not).

Losing you will put your daughter even more at risk.

Who will give her the right advice to ensure that her financial assets are protected from any poor decisions made by her boyfriend?

Who will be there when one day when she realises that giving him this second chance was a mistake, and she needs support to get herself and her financial assets out of the relationship intact?

It’s not easy, but your role here is to be her mum, unconditionally. Not to judge her mistakes choices.

rangagirl · 20/01/2023 18:38

I’m sure we all completely understand your distress over the situation and your concern for your daughter. Any parent would probably feel the same things.

BUT:

You need to stay out of their relationship. It’s not your business or problem. She’s an adult, and she wants to stand by her partner and help with his problems.

I’d also like to point out that he hasn’t even really done anything to your daughter… except maybe the lying, I guess.

He wasted HIS money on gambling, not hers or yours or his workplace expense account. He hasn’t stolen from anyone or committed any crimes. That doesn’t directly affect your daughter and HER savings or reputation. She still has the option and resources to leave him later on if he doesn’t quit or whatever.

The cold, hard truth is that if you get involved and tell your daughter to dump him, you WILL be the bad guy in her eyes. That’s how it works. We have the right to make bad decisions as adults if we want to, and you don’t get a vote.

So keep your opinions about what a loser her boyfriend is to yourself, and let her know you’re there for her as she goes through this process of helping her partner break his addiction.

Mollymoostoo · 20/01/2023 18:32

user1498572889 · 19/01/2023 10:14

You are right OP. Once a gambler always a gambler.

Actually gambling is the one addiction that has a high success rate of overcoming.

Smoking is harder to stop than heroin.

yaysummerisover · 20/01/2023 18:30

It’s very difficult. The worst thing is to have done that he clearly has a problem and it would be hard to trust him again. If you moan about him it pushes them together. If it was my daughter my advice would be. Talk to him and get him to agree to transfer nearly all his wages into an account that he cannot get access to jointly. That way she can keep an eye on the spending and maybe agree to give him a small amount weekly to do with as he pleases and the rest can go towards saving and bills.

cherish123 · 20/01/2023 18:19

YADNBU
It's very risky to a buy a property with non-family.
I would not do it.

Missingpop · 20/01/2023 18:03

What a complete arsehole; she does deserve better your right; but she has to reach that conclusion on her own you can’t force it; he will fuck up again & again & she will see him for the waste of space he is eventually let’s just hope it’s sooner rather than later

1onway1under12and1over18 · 20/01/2023 17:58

Having had a relationship with a gambler I want to scream to tell / force her to leave him. But you don’t need to, she will reach that conclusion herself. It may take time but she will get there. Be there for her now and then. Be an ear for her for the times she will come to you and vent at the stupid things he’s going to do between now and when she realises supporting him won’t help him. He has to want to help himself. If you demand she leaves or cut him off you will lose her at worst, at best she will hide things from you. Tell her you love and support HER and that she can confide in you without judgement.

Alexandra1991 · 20/01/2023 17:51

I think it all depends on whether he has actively taken steps to stop gambling and get over his addiction. Ive been in a similar situation (but found out way way before exchange he had no money) I ended up buying the house in my name only, I took control of his finances whilst he went to counselling, and all is good now. I won't lie that I do have terrible financial anxiety because but he has broken the addiction.
Obviously it's your daughter's decision whether she wants to support him through it, it can be a tough road.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/01/2023 23:47

kateandme · 19/01/2023 23:32

the mental state of someone with an adiction is like any other illness.and choosing to do the behaviours is not a choice.
nor actually is choosing help. wouldnt the sufferers choose to stop if they could.would they really put themsevles through this and those they loves. addiction is a symtom of whats going on in the mind. it is complex.
and one of the hardest things is its not a simple of choose of getting well or not or seeking help to do so. becasue of the very nature of the ill health of the persons mind their minds stop them from getting help.
noone chooses addiction. noone choose this way to cope. not all can choose help and it can be becasue of far too many factors to make it so black and white a decision.adn often we dont see or know why and when someone finds themsevles able to. often though you can see it in those that are supported and find reason to change.are being helped mentally. and healing whats gone wrong.
there is far too much nuance in how people can or cant recover from these things.
ithis is what makes it so hard for all concerned becasue it isnt a choice. its not a magic pill or medication the sufferer can choose to take or not to get well. there is soo much more to it than that.

& I've said throughout the thread that addiction is complex.

Of course it makes choices limited, & much harder to take the better course of action - but it doesn't negate them entirely.
If it did - nobody could choose to get help, choose to commit time & energy to recovery, choose to stay 'recovering' for the rest of their lives.

Or are you only counting the negative choices?

kateandme · 19/01/2023 23:32

KettrickenSmiled · 19/01/2023 18:13

The tragedy is - this IS how addiction works.

It's a series of choices - initially seemingly small, inconsequential - which end up with the addicted person having little or no choice over the larger decisions, which have also consequences on their loved ones. Ultimately, it becomes the choice over whether to get help & make an attempt to overcome the addiction.

OP's b/f is likely nowhere near that stage: we can't be sure, as we're hearing his story 3rd hand, but it sounds like his splurging of the savings (if he even ever had them - more uncertainty to manage) is being presented as a one-off 'mistake'. Addiction is complex, but ultimately, he CHOSE to deceive his g/f. The fact that he had less control over that choice than a non-addicted person doesn't lessen the blow, or the consequences to OP's DD.

the mental state of someone with an adiction is like any other illness.and choosing to do the behaviours is not a choice.
nor actually is choosing help. wouldnt the sufferers choose to stop if they could.would they really put themsevles through this and those they loves. addiction is a symtom of whats going on in the mind. it is complex.
and one of the hardest things is its not a simple of choose of getting well or not or seeking help to do so. becasue of the very nature of the ill health of the persons mind their minds stop them from getting help.
noone chooses addiction. noone choose this way to cope. not all can choose help and it can be becasue of far too many factors to make it so black and white a decision.adn often we dont see or know why and when someone finds themsevles able to. often though you can see it in those that are supported and find reason to change.are being helped mentally. and healing whats gone wrong.
there is far too much nuance in how people can or cant recover from these things.
ithis is what makes it so hard for all concerned becasue it isnt a choice. its not a magic pill or medication the sufferer can choose to take or not to get well. there is soo much more to it than that.

Icecreamlover63 · 19/01/2023 22:41

My DD left her husband a year ago. It was her decision and hers alone. Try to remember that your concern isn’t the only voice she will hear. Her friends will feel the same as you. One day she will feel used and abused and it’s horrible and dark. But when she finishes with him (and she will) she will feel like a weight has been lifted. Gamblers are charmers but are also manipulating and are liars.

Our DD is a strong women but there is the odd day of tearful despair. But these are quite infrequent. I would just try to help build her self esteem and confidence. It’s obvious right now she doesn’t want to loose face so will try to defend the indefensible. Let the dust settle and I’m sure she will start to see how this really is. However it really is going to be her decision at the end of the day. All you can do is be there for her. I wish you well I really do. Use this thread as a source of strength and kindness. X

Zanatdy · 19/01/2023 20:42

You have a right to be angry but if she’s chosen to forgive him then don’t make things difficult for her as it’s the parent who ends up pushed aside if things get worse

Swipe left for the next trending thread