Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that neglecting your child to death should be murder (warning: distressing content)

130 replies

Onnabugeisha · 19/01/2023 08:14

I’ve been following the news on the horrendous murder of a vulnerable disabled girl, Kaylea Titford who died at age 16 due to the neglect of her parents.

TW Distressing Details
Kaylea was born with spina bifidia and hydrocephalus. She was a wheelchair user and had no mobility in her lower body. She was fed takeaways five nights a week until she became morbidly obese. Her parents did not ensure nutritious food or that her exercises were done. When the lockdown happened, her mum put to her bed and then left her to die. Kaylea tried to keep clean- they found milk bottles of urine around her bed and soiled puppy pads she was told to use for poo on the floor of her room. She was left unwashed, in soiled clothes & bed linen, with live maggots and flies crawling across her due to ulcerations from being obese and filthy. Six months later, she died in that bed. Only after her mum was sure she was dead did she call 999 for the paramedics who entered the nightmare of that room to the stench of urine, excrement and rotting flesh.

Her mother has plead guilty to manslaughter by gross negligence. Her father has pled not guilty and his trial is ongoing.

This was obviously a premeditated and planned campaign to slowly kill Kaylea in one of the worst and most degrading ways imaginable. I don’t understand how it cannot be murder. It seems to me it takes more evil intent and cruelty to slowly kill a child over six months than in six minutes.

Neglect has long been taken less seriously than physical or sexual abuse imho, even though it technically kills just as many children.

AIBU to think the charges should be murder, not manslaughter?

YANBU= should be murder
YABU= it’s manslaughter (accidental or unintended death)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Onnabugeisha · 05/03/2023 08:39

I posted this link on the other thread about Kaylea. I and some others have emailed the Attorney General to request that the sentences be reviewed for being unduly lenient. It is an eligible case because they list child cruelty as one of the types of cases where they review sentences. If you’d also like to request that the sentences be reviewed. Keep in mind you can get a life sentence for manslaughter and the starting point is 12yrs. So Kayleas parents having sentences so far below the starting point is a travesty imho. This was six months of not getting your disabled daughter to a toilet, not getting her in a shower, not trimming her toenails or even changing her socks so they fused to her feet and left the flesh falling off them to the bone, six months of ignoring her pleas for the necessary care and basic humanity any living being is due. Six months of blocking her window so her room was dark as a dungeon. This isn’t oh I was overwhelmed…this was half a year of keeping a child prisoner in a dark, filthy hole and the swearing, mocking and gaslighting her until, she predictably died and they knew this would be the consequence of their neglect. They should be in for much longer than 6 or 7.5 yrs which means out on licence in 4 or 5yrs.

www.gov.uk/ask-crown-court-sentence-review

OP posts:
Saschka · 05/03/2023 00:38

lljkk · 01/03/2023 22:22

the term murder should be reserve for people who committed harm knowingly. That is a different level in harm.

If you want greater penalties for people who cause harm or death thru terrible negligence that's a different thing to campaign for.

I read that KT's mum was begging some people for help. She has always accepted responsibility. It doesn't help KT's siblings or any other vulnerable person for KT's parents to be vilified on social media (like MN). Her sibling's lives were torn apart, too. There's detail here about how the family functioned, and where they started slipping thru social safety nets in 2017.

From your own link:

”Mr Titford's representative argued that the father had been let down by social services, adding that Kaylea was discharged from physiotherapy in 2017 and the following year was discharged from a dietetics service because her mother, Sarah Lloyd-Jones, did not book more appointments.”

So they were repeatedly failing to take her to hospital appointments even in 2017, long before lockdown. They were not open to services because they had refused to engage with them. This is neglect, and they cannot hide behind lockdown as an excuse - they used it as an opportunity to neglect her even more, out of sight of everyone.

(I do agree with you that manslaughter isn’t murder and the two shouldn’t be conflated, but this is not a poor struggling parent who couldn’t cope when services were cut during lockdown, it is someone neglecting their child’s medical needs over a prolonged period of many years).

Morph22010 · 04/03/2023 15:15

x2boys · 04/03/2023 14:57

Assuming she got full DLA/ PIP, they would have had carers, allowance ,enhanced due to.disability tax credits/ universal.credirs ,it's not a fortune but it's a decent amount,I have a severely disabled child so I roughly know the amounts the associated benefits equate to.

It’s a lot if you are not using the money to meet the extra costs of having a disabled child!! Extra washing, heating etc

JMSA · 04/03/2023 15:03

Dreadful. I'd bet they were never adequate parents, but pre-lockdown would have had the assistance they so heavily relied upon. Their true colours were shown when this was no longer available.

x2boys · 04/03/2023 14:57

JMSA · 04/03/2023 14:45

How did these thick-as-pigshit scumbags afford 5 takeaways a week??
What happened to that poor girl is just too awful for words.

Assuming she got full DLA/ PIP, they would have had carers, allowance ,enhanced due to.disability tax credits/ universal.credirs ,it's not a fortune but it's a decent amount,I have a severely disabled child so I roughly know the amounts the associated benefits equate to.

JMSA · 04/03/2023 14:45

How did these thick-as-pigshit scumbags afford 5 takeaways a week??
What happened to that poor girl is just too awful for words.

Soothsayer1 · 04/03/2023 13:44

user12345678213 · 04/03/2023 13:16

Lockdown is not an excuse or a mitigation, i wish the death penalty existed for cases like these.
The parents will serve no useful purpose in life once released, you cannot be rehabilitated if you do this to another human being.

I agree with you, I think the parents must be sociopathic and/ or extremely personality disordered, incapable of forming normal bonds with humans.
I agree that these people cannot be rehabilitated, and should never be trusted but at the same time I do not agree with the death penalty. I don't know what the answer is, it's a huge problem, what should we do with people who behave like this how can we stop people from becoming people behave like this ☹️

I'm not saying this to excuse them in any way but how did those parents become people who could treat someone like that?

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 13:28

lljkk · 01/03/2023 22:22

the term murder should be reserve for people who committed harm knowingly. That is a different level in harm.

If you want greater penalties for people who cause harm or death thru terrible negligence that's a different thing to campaign for.

I read that KT's mum was begging some people for help. She has always accepted responsibility. It doesn't help KT's siblings or any other vulnerable person for KT's parents to be vilified on social media (like MN). Her sibling's lives were torn apart, too. There's detail here about how the family functioned, and where they started slipping thru social safety nets in 2017.

Theres another thread on this. I thought I read she did not accept responsbility. She pleaded guilty yes but deflected blame everywhere, including on her daughter apparently.

Onnabugeisha · 04/03/2023 13:20

user12345678213 · 04/03/2023 13:16

Lockdown is not an excuse or a mitigation, i wish the death penalty existed for cases like these.
The parents will serve no useful purpose in life once released, you cannot be rehabilitated if you do this to another human being.

Absolutely. Lockdown was an opportunity for them to slowly kill their daughter by confining her to her bed in such a way she could not move, withholding essential care and responding to her begging for care to mock, swear or shout at her. No one who has read the court documents can even think that this was done “unknowingly” as an ‘ooops’. This was callous, calculated and unspeakably cruel. They even closed her blinds and curtains, Kaylea didn’t see a single ray of sunshine, or a bird fly by her window for six months as she was slowly killed in her bed.

OP posts:
user12345678213 · 04/03/2023 13:16

Lockdown is not an excuse or a mitigation, i wish the death penalty existed for cases like these.
The parents will serve no useful purpose in life once released, you cannot be rehabilitated if you do this to another human being.

Onnabugeisha · 04/03/2023 13:08

lljkk · 01/03/2023 22:22

the term murder should be reserve for people who committed harm knowingly. That is a different level in harm.

If you want greater penalties for people who cause harm or death thru terrible negligence that's a different thing to campaign for.

I read that KT's mum was begging some people for help. She has always accepted responsibility. It doesn't help KT's siblings or any other vulnerable person for KT's parents to be vilified on social media (like MN). Her sibling's lives were torn apart, too. There's detail here about how the family functioned, and where they started slipping thru social safety nets in 2017.

You read wrong. Per the court, Sarah Loyd Jones REFUSED or IGNORED all offers for help. The only person she asked for help was her husband and in her request she did not even mention that the help was for Kaylea. For all we know she couldn’t cope making dinner and thus the grand spent on takeaways.

Kaylea’s parents, especially her mum being a professional carer, knowingly neglected her to death by withholding essential care from Kaylea. Despite Kaylea begging them to do this care repeatedly, they mocked her or told her to shut up or swore at her.

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 02/03/2023 08:54

To any of us the description of how this poor girl was found is extremely disturbing but was there maybe an element of boiling frog from the family's perspective who saw it all happen very gradually? Especially if they were also vulnerable and weren't the most skilled at pushing for help. I'm not justifying what they didn't do just trying to imagine how you would even get to that point.

With budget cuts and lack of support it seems like service providers have to start from a basis that any parent is capable of meeting the needs of any child however complex. Obviously this isn't the case and there must be a lot of lower level neglect and abuse going on that doesn't get picked up at all.

flapjackfairy · 02/03/2023 07:56

@Sirzy
I completely agree. The lack.of support for families with disabled members is a disgrace . l cant see anything being done to change it sadly.

Untitledsquatboulder · 02/03/2023 07:27

There are no "lessons that can be learnt" that will stop wholly inadequate people having children then beating or neglecting them to death. If you need a service constantly on hand to ensure what happened to Kaylea doesn't happen then you shouldn't be left in charge of a goldfish let alone a vulnerable human being.

Sirzy · 02/03/2023 06:56

Nobody is saying the parents weren’t responsible for what happened or that they don’t the punishments.

but it does raise wider questions about support for disabled people and those who care for them. During lockdowns many where abandoned and since a lot of services still haven’t returned properly.

lessons have to be learnt to make sure nobody else is left to suffer in this way

flapjackfairy · 02/03/2023 06:49

but if the mother really wanted to get help.all she needed to do was call an ambulance or ring the police. They would have taken one look and removed her from their care. Yes she would've been in trouble but not as much trouble as she now has on her hands.
I think dad was a different kettle of fish and couldnt give a toss . He just wanted to pass the blame to the mother.
Even more unbelievable is the fact that the mother was a carer for others whilst she let he own child of neglect at home. The girl was screaming for help and was ignored. There are no.mitigating circumstances extreme enough to offset that.

Morph22010 · 02/03/2023 06:36

MammaYamada · 01/03/2023 20:08

There was no help or support during lockdown. Even previous sources of support such as school, clubs, respite or extended family were not available when most families needed it more than ever. Parents who previously held it together hit the wall. Even asking for help - what help? I could cry now thinking about it.

Obviously this is a horrific case, I'm not making excuses for the parents and I don't know details, but I feel the context of lockdown should not be underestimated.

I listened to the judges summing up yesterday lockdown was taken into account in the mitigating factors.

lljkk · 01/03/2023 22:22

the term murder should be reserve for people who committed harm knowingly. That is a different level in harm.

If you want greater penalties for people who cause harm or death thru terrible negligence that's a different thing to campaign for.

I read that KT's mum was begging some people for help. She has always accepted responsibility. It doesn't help KT's siblings or any other vulnerable person for KT's parents to be vilified on social media (like MN). Her sibling's lives were torn apart, too. There's detail here about how the family functioned, and where they started slipping thru social safety nets in 2017.

x2boys · 01/03/2023 22:08

MammaYamada · 01/03/2023 20:08

There was no help or support during lockdown. Even previous sources of support such as school, clubs, respite or extended family were not available when most families needed it more than ever. Parents who previously held it together hit the wall. Even asking for help - what help? I could cry now thinking about it.

Obviously this is a horrific case, I'm not making excuses for the parents and I don't know details, but I feel the context of lockdown should not be underestimated.

This annoys yes there was no support during lockdown but most parents of disabled children didn't resort to.neglecting their children to.the point of death i,m one of those parents ,this is on the.parents .

flapjackfairy · 01/03/2023 21:58

@MammaYamada
you dont have to tell me. I have 2 children with extremely complex needs and my husband and I cared for them for a year day and night with no support at all.Not one single minute off.The whole pandemic was v hard for our family and many more like us who were forced to isolate completely for the duration . We didnt do anything special just cared for our children as best we could. So I get it I really do and I still say it wasnt a long enough sentence.

MammaYamada · 01/03/2023 20:08

There was no help or support during lockdown. Even previous sources of support such as school, clubs, respite or extended family were not available when most families needed it more than ever. Parents who previously held it together hit the wall. Even asking for help - what help? I could cry now thinking about it.

Obviously this is a horrific case, I'm not making excuses for the parents and I don't know details, but I feel the context of lockdown should not be underestimated.

flapjackfairy · 01/03/2023 18:32

it's not enough !

Sporty2022 · 01/03/2023 16:52

Sentenced today.Seven years and six years.

Morph22010 · 08/02/2023 13:08

I read in another articles yesterday that the mother had told the school during a welfare call that she was struggling to take care of kaylea and manage working her own job as a carer whether thst was referred on or not it does not say. I said during a school call during pandemic we were struggling (autistic child) and it just kind of got brushed off thst the pandemic was hard for everyone. We were no where near the levels of this family and did get through ok but I can see how the mothers comments could have been brushed off in same way

x2boys · 08/02/2023 09:59

Xol · 08/02/2023 09:46

If a child with spina bifida and wheelchair dependent hadn't been referred to services, that in itself would indicate some gross negligence on someone's part, including both the health authorities and the council.

Why?
My son has severe autism and learning disabilities we currently have a socisl.worker ,because he has just been allocated over night respite ,he's been under the child disability team in the past and is waiting to be seen again for behavioural issues ,but we have gone long periods of time with no services involved ,ime,professionals don't stay involved just in case ,they are involved when there are.specific issues that need addressing and when these issues are resolved the child gets discharged from the services and only referred if needed .
assuming there had been no current concerns about her it's quite possible there were no.professional.s involved other than school.