Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fucking Council Tax Single Person Penalty

354 replies

Honper · 18/01/2023 23:41

Or: why should I pay 50% more tax than my neighbours?

Council tax is a regressive abomination anyway and ofc like everyone else I resent paying it so my useless council can spend thousands on things like Tree Stories Near You or Four Foot Long Cycle Path Initiatives while failing to patch potholes so big that geese nest in them but still. As a single person I have a very particular axe to grind wrt paying 50% more TAX than someone in a couple.

I know that single life is more expensive, economies of scale yadda yadda and I already pay out proportionally more from my wages for bills, food and so on. I get that and it's not great but it's how it is.

But why is my tax liability so much greater than that of my married neighbours? I pay 50% more tax than each of them.

Come on, that's not right is it? It's not a bill. It's a tax. Single people's tax burden should not be so much more.

Or should it? AIBU?

OP posts:
Honper · 19/01/2023 00:51

@SpaceRaiders LOL! I think I was quite polite to DixonD given the circs.

@LastOfTheChristmasWine that's double annoying! Paying more but getting less access to amenities because of an arbitrary rule.

OP posts:
ganvough · 19/01/2023 00:50

If it bothers you so much, you could get a flatmate or room mate in. It's your choice to live alone....

I too live alone, despite having a DP who also lives alone, because it suits us to stay this way until we are married. It's my choice and I don't see it as a 'single person penalty' but as the price I pay for choosing to live alone.

NewNovember · 19/01/2023 00:35

You do realise that couples where one is to disabled or unwell to work still have to pay 100% despite one income? Two people doesn't always mean more money.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 19/01/2023 00:34

DontMakeMeShushYou · 19/01/2023 00:28

On that basis, single people should have a bin a quarter of the size of a family of four. To make sure everything is fair and no-one is getting less or more than anyone else.

But 4 people won't necessarily generate 4x the amount of rubbish. They might generate more, but not 4x more.

That's why I said it's "the fairest" way, not that it's totally 100% fair. I. Don't know how it could be completely fair to everyone all the time. Which is why I'm not in charge Grin

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 19/01/2023 00:31

Agreed.

My current gripe with the council is that - purely because I drive a van - I'm only allowed to go to the tip once a month, and have to book ten days in advance.

Anyone who drives a car can get a same-day appointment and can go up to three times per day!

Allegedly this is to prevent commercial waste from being taken to the tip. In reality, I'm not a tradeswoman despite driving a van (self-employed, not building trades, not producing that sort of waste), my builder drives a normal car, and my DF has more boot space in his car than I have in my van.

If only I was wealthy enough to drive a car as well as a van...

Yet I still get charged the same amounts of council tax as my car-owning neighbours - and literally double the amount as when I lived in London (Wandsworth) for the same band of property.

Harrumph!

Starryskiesinthesky · 19/01/2023 00:31

pinkpotatoez · 19/01/2023 00:02

Never thought of it like that, that does seem wrong...

Your example is good but the OP keeps saying they pay 50% more than both parties whereas they dont really, they pay 50% more because they pay 750 compared to 500 but they only really pay 250 more than one person, and the same as the other person.

Ariela · 19/01/2023 00:30

Before kids I used to begrudge the fact that I had no children in education, worked outside of the borough that I live on the edge of (so no driving on their roads), was never at home so didn't create rubbish, so only put the bins out once every 6 weeks (tend to do every 3rd or 4th week now we are at home more)

Honper · 19/01/2023 00:29

This is not just about bloody bins 🤣

OP posts:
DontMakeMeShushYou · 19/01/2023 00:28

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 19/01/2023 00:26

Well we all get a fortnightly bin collection. If you have more rubbish than fits in the bin then you have to sort out getting it to the tip yourself. IMO that means we're getting the same.

The house on my road that most often has overflowing bins is a single occupancy so that person seems to generate more waste than anyone else. No idea how/ why.

But as I said I'm a single parent, so single adult but not single occupancy. Maybe I'd feel differently if it was just me.

On that basis, single people should have a bin a quarter of the size of a family of four. To make sure everything is fair and no-one is getting less or more than anyone else.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 19/01/2023 00:26

Chimna · 19/01/2023 00:20

As PPs have said 50% is for the property and 50% for the person. Hence receiving the 25% Single Person Discount.

Yes, this.

A halfway house between rates which were based entirely on the value of your property regardless of how many people lived there and community charge/poll tax which was based entirely on the number of people living in a property regardless of it's size/value.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 19/01/2023 00:26

GrumpyPanda · 19/01/2023 00:16

"While I get what you're saying I think it's the fairest way.
I get exactly the same council services as my neighbours who pay full council tax."

But you don't really, do you? For one thing your neighbours who live two or maybe even four to a property are certain to generate a lot more waste and in consequence are getting a lot more for their tax payments than you do. And so on and so forth..

Well we all get a fortnightly bin collection. If you have more rubbish than fits in the bin then you have to sort out getting it to the tip yourself. IMO that means we're getting the same.

The house on my road that most often has overflowing bins is a single occupancy so that person seems to generate more waste than anyone else. No idea how/ why.

But as I said I'm a single parent, so single adult but not single occupancy. Maybe I'd feel differently if it was just me.

SpaceRaiders · 19/01/2023 00:24

I love how @DixonD misses the point completely. 😂

Op i agree, it’s the one thing I begrudge paying for especially when the bin men refuse to collect rubbish from outside my house meaning I have to walk it 15 meters to the curbside.

Honper · 19/01/2023 00:22

Yes I get that. But in practice it means I have a 50% greater tax bill than each of my married neighbours.

50%!!!

OP posts:
EBearhug · 19/01/2023 00:21

I might not produce as much rubbish as the couple next door, but it still costs as much to send the dustbin lorry to collect it. My costs as a single person are less than a couple, but not as little as half.

Longleggedgiraffe · 19/01/2023 00:21

EmmaEmerald · 18/01/2023 23:43

I'd go further and say it should be paid per person

Adults will have to pay for their children.

They tried that. It was called the Poll tax. It caused an absolute riot.

Chimna · 19/01/2023 00:20

As PPs have said 50% is for the property and 50% for the person. Hence receiving the 25% Single Person Discount.

GrumpyPanda · 19/01/2023 00:16

"While I get what you're saying I think it's the fairest way.
I get exactly the same council services as my neighbours who pay full council tax."

But you don't really, do you? For one thing your neighbours who live two or maybe even four to a property are certain to generate a lot more waste and in consequence are getting a lot more for their tax payments than you do. And so on and so forth..

DontMakeMeShushYou · 19/01/2023 00:15

EmmaEmerald · 19/01/2023 00:09

Honestly, if I were a ghost I'd probably not be online.

i'm one person using local council services. It gets complicated in flats be ause we don't have one bin per flat.

Obviously four people wouldn't live in my flat, I doubt it anyway, but yes, I think a four person household should pay more (for example).

I was surprised when I found out that was a core objection to Poll Tax because what we have makes even less sense, but it does seem it was a new tax per se that was the issue?

The core objection was that it was regressive.

Honper · 19/01/2023 00:13

PureBlackVoid · 19/01/2023 00:08

But that applies to most bills, unless they depend on usage. Rent, mortgage, TV license, water if you’re on rates. They don’t get reduced because you live alone. Except maybe if you get housing benefit, I’m not sure how much difference that makes with singles vs couples.

Why would CT be any different?

Because it's not a bill. It says 'bill' on that big bloody letter you get in March but it's not a food/utility/etc bill. It's a tax demand.

If I don't pay my electric, they can put me on a payment plan, put me on a meter, cut me off if necessary, even take me to small claims, but it's just a civil matter.

But council tax is different. It's a tax. It's a statutory demand. From the state I have to pay it, one way or another. Else they will hunt me down, they will find me and they will put me in prison.

I get that I pay more for running a household as a single person. It's not nice but that's how money works.

But I shouldn't have increased tax liability.

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 19/01/2023 00:09

LordEmsworth · 18/01/2023 23:53

Maggie? Is that you, posting from beyond the grave??? Trying to get the OP to riot in favour of the poll tax?

Honestly, if I were a ghost I'd probably not be online.

i'm one person using local council services. It gets complicated in flats be ause we don't have one bin per flat.

Obviously four people wouldn't live in my flat, I doubt it anyway, but yes, I think a four person household should pay more (for example).

I was surprised when I found out that was a core objection to Poll Tax because what we have makes even less sense, but it does seem it was a new tax per se that was the issue?

Honper · 19/01/2023 00:08

DixonD · 19/01/2023 00:04

Yes but they don’t necessarily pay 50% each. I don’t pay anything towards council tax; my husband pays all bills.

How you organise your own domestic affairs is your business. Your tax liability is split between you and according to that split you have a 50% lesser tax liability than I do.

That's not right, is it?

OP posts:
PureBlackVoid · 19/01/2023 00:08

But that applies to most bills, unless they depend on usage. Rent, mortgage, TV license, water if you’re on rates. They don’t get reduced because you live alone. Except maybe if you get housing benefit, I’m not sure how much difference that makes with singles vs couples.

Why would CT be any different?

Rebel2023 · 19/01/2023 00:08

@DixonD but that's your choice and you have the option that he pays the bills
As a single person you can't just not pay it

HRTQueen · 19/01/2023 00:07

It is expensive being single

I have far more of an issue that it’s expensive being poor and so many are trapped in a cycle

DixonD · 19/01/2023 00:04

Honper · 18/01/2023 23:45

The single person discount is 25%. Therefore I am taxed 75%. Couples are taxed at 50% each. So I pay 50% more than each of them. In tax.

Yes but they don’t necessarily pay 50% each. I don’t pay anything towards council tax; my husband pays all bills.