Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fucking Council Tax Single Person Penalty

354 replies

Honper · 18/01/2023 23:41

Or: why should I pay 50% more tax than my neighbours?

Council tax is a regressive abomination anyway and ofc like everyone else I resent paying it so my useless council can spend thousands on things like Tree Stories Near You or Four Foot Long Cycle Path Initiatives while failing to patch potholes so big that geese nest in them but still. As a single person I have a very particular axe to grind wrt paying 50% more TAX than someone in a couple.

I know that single life is more expensive, economies of scale yadda yadda and I already pay out proportionally more from my wages for bills, food and so on. I get that and it's not great but it's how it is.

But why is my tax liability so much greater than that of my married neighbours? I pay 50% more tax than each of them.

Come on, that's not right is it? It's not a bill. It's a tax. Single people's tax burden should not be so much more.

Or should it? AIBU?

OP posts:
ganvough · 19/01/2023 01:50

It's not really "the same" as anything I don't think, but the closest analogy would be if single people had 30% of their wages over £12570 taken off them in tax instead of 20%. It makes about as much sense as that ie none.

Income tax = personal
Council tax = household

Personal (not equal) household

This is a very concept of taxation separating out the individual from the taxable entity- even in business where you have sole trader tax (that treats the person and business as one entity) and limited company tax (business is separate to person).

Imagine if you were a lone business person paying company tax, and there was a partnership business with two people paying the same rate of company tax. You'd be individually paying more than the other business splitting it between both. And it would have nothing to do with whether you were 'single' or in a 'couple' but how you structured your business. Same goes for how you structure your household.

That's why many single people do live with flatmates.

mildlydispeptic · 19/01/2023 01:49

* "maybe because as a weak and feeble woman you're not big and strong enough to pick up a car and twirl a spare wheel onto it with your bare hands?*" 😆

Summerfun54321 · 19/01/2023 01:48

Having lots of people living on their own in houses suitable for more than 1 person doesn't help with the national housing crisis. It's not in the government's best interests to promote single person households and the council tax system reflects that.

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:48

Yes, yes, get us all into HMOs, that's a societal goal worth pursuing.

OP posts:
AtLastShrugs · 19/01/2023 01:39

Maybe it would help you to look at it as not a disadvantage to living alone but a bonus or incentive to those willing to live with someone else (which as PP have pointed out is not just couples) - it's the housing equivalent of a carpool lane. __

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:31

PleaseCleanTheWholeToilet · 19/01/2023 01:12

But thats the same as saying they pay 50% of gas , Electric, Food Shopping, Petrol.
Literally everything
Its a very odd way of thinking about it

No it isn't. Because it's a tax.

It's not really "the same" as anything I don't think, but the closest analogy would be if single people had 30% of their wages over £12570 taken off them in tax instead of 20%. It makes about as much sense as that ie none.

OP posts:
Tinkerbyebye · 19/01/2023 01:22

Oh grow up

council tax is paid on a property, not a person. What happens is there are two parents and two adult children over 18, they only pay 25% each! You know that doesn’t happen

more people in a property means more waste to be collected, more cars using the roads helping create those lovely potholes, elderly using adult social care etc etc etc

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:21

I will no longer be responding to any posts that say "my husband pays all my council tax" or similar.

OP posts:
theblackradiator · 19/01/2023 01:18

LordEmsworth · 18/01/2023 23:53

Maggie? Is that you, posting from beyond the grave??? Trying to get the OP to riot in favour of the poll tax?

🤣🤣🤣

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:18

Tippexy · 19/01/2023 01:10

Quite scary how few people understand the maths on this thread.

Innit.

And yet we all get the demand, year after year.

OP posts:
ganvough · 19/01/2023 01:17

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:13

@mildlydispeptic maybe because as a weak and feeble woman you're not big and strong enough to pick up a car and twirl a spare wheel onto it with your bare hands?

Actually no, I know it's not that. There's something about insurance algorithms where in some circumstances having an additional names driver with years and years' worth of no claims makes it cheaper. You could have done the same with a friend, if you were so minded, even one at a different address, if you said you'd given them permission to drive you to hospital every time you had a hip replacement/etc.

But again, this is a BILL. I am talking about TAX. You and I pay 50% more tax than couples.

No, you don't pay 50% more than a couple. You pay 50% more than any TWO or more people who share a household, many of whom are NOT couples.

You also pay the exact same as people who are in couples but choose to live separately.

Council tax is households. How that household is populated is upto you.

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:16

Great. So now in addition to "take in some Jeffrey Dahmer type itinerant" I've got "tax fraud" as a possible solution. This is the thread of all the wins.

OP posts:
Jellywellyfish · 19/01/2023 01:13

You can recoup some costs - when you move in with someone, don’t tell the council for years and stay on a single person reduced rate.

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:13

@mildlydispeptic maybe because as a weak and feeble woman you're not big and strong enough to pick up a car and twirl a spare wheel onto it with your bare hands?

Actually no, I know it's not that. There's something about insurance algorithms where in some circumstances having an additional names driver with years and years' worth of no claims makes it cheaper. You could have done the same with a friend, if you were so minded, even one at a different address, if you said you'd given them permission to drive you to hospital every time you had a hip replacement/etc.

But again, this is a BILL. I am talking about TAX. You and I pay 50% more tax than couples.

OP posts:
PleaseCleanTheWholeToilet · 19/01/2023 01:12

But thats the same as saying they pay 50% of gas , Electric, Food Shopping, Petrol.
Literally everything
Its a very odd way of thinking about it

ganvough · 19/01/2023 01:11

Honper · 19/01/2023 00:59

@ganvough yeah I guess if I was a complete mentalist i could entirely overhaul my life by inviting a stranger into my home and then WIN on the tax demand. That is an entirely proportionate and sensible solution, thank you 👏

eyeroll that you think the 'single person' tax refers to relationship status rather than household occupier status. By your logic, I'm not 'single', I'm part of a couple and pay the exact same tax you do as a single person. Because we are both single occupiers.

Unless you think the council is going to start levying taxes based on your actual relationship status... What they offer is the only fair and reasonable way to levy tax. HOUSEHOLDS generate usage and waste and use council services. The logic is no one can determine whether one person in a house generates/needs 50% less waste, usage, services than 2 people in a house. So it's a standard household tax with the acceptance a single person does probably generate a bit less. Some people are in relationships, some are flatmates, some are single.

If you'd stop viewing council tax as a relationship status thing and a household thing, you'd probably be less prickly about it.

Tippexy · 19/01/2023 01:10

Quite scary how few people understand the maths on this thread.

BetaMom · 19/01/2023 01:08

Honper · 18/01/2023 23:47

Yes. Which is 50% more than each person in a couple.

So, should couples have to pay more rent for the same property than a single does?
Council tax is higher on multiple occupancy properties but gets split across more people.

It’s not just couples who get to split it - friends or housemates who share split too.

For those who want more space and the same level of service it’s normal to pay more I think.

mildlydispeptic · 19/01/2023 01:04

As a single occupant I'm not bothered by the council tax and am grateful for the 25% discount. What got right up my nose was that adding a man to my car insurance brought the premiums way down. Not quite sure why single women would get penalised on that count.

Honper · 19/01/2023 01:02

@Easternext there is no road tax. I know, mind-blowing isn't it? There's a fuel emissions tax. It doesn't pay to fix roads. Councils do that.

OP posts:
Honper · 19/01/2023 00:59

@ganvough yeah I guess if I was a complete mentalist i could entirely overhaul my life by inviting a stranger into my home and then WIN on the tax demand. That is an entirely proportionate and sensible solution, thank you 👏

OP posts:
cabbageking · 19/01/2023 00:59

My husband pays the full amount which is per household. I could suggest he pays100% and I pay 0. So he pays more than you using your reasoning. But that would be pedantic

Easternext · 19/01/2023 00:58

Council tax pays for pot holes well what Is road tax for? i don't drive why am I paying to fix roads?

Honper · 19/01/2023 00:55

@NewNovember like I said it's up to couples how they organise the split.

OP posts:
Notcontent · 19/01/2023 00:54

I agree that it’s a pretty unfair tax and can lead to some odd results. What I find weird about it is that it’s determined by reference to a property address, but pays for more than just things like rubbish collection.