Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was what he did justified?

154 replies

1999its · 18/01/2023 22:09

DP and I have been seeing each other again after 5/6 months apart and I'm really enjoying my time with him.

We had an argument today about what has previously happened between us. We almost ended because of this argument. It got heated and I got emotional and raised my voice, which I shouldn't have.

Long story short:

I got pregnant after the relationship was essentially over. We weren't officially together anymore and hadn't been for just under two weeks but were still seeing each other every day, having sex, going on dates etc.

I told him the news over the phone. Less than 24hrs after finding out he came round and told me he was abandoning and the baby if I kept it, that was it, no conversation. He didn't ask me if I was okay.

I had said I needed to find out how far along I was before I made a decision. I never said I had any intention to keep the baby.

I told him to go to hell and told him to leave, I was probably shouting. I also said I was going to call him mum, so he called her first.

His family blocked me on everything. I didn't hear anything for a month. He resurfaces and asks if I've kept it or not. Says that he does want to be involved and did all along but he wanted me to feel like I had no choice but to terminate. I told him to fuck off.

I was mentally through the floor. There was a lot of swearing and "you're a piece of shit" types texts from me.

I miscarried and then got a severe infection following. All very scary and messy. We weren't in contact at this point, I felt so alone.

His perspective:

He doesn't feel that what he did was selfish. He said he did care about me in the situation, that he loved me.

He did it because he had an inkling I'd keep the baby, he says he still thinks that was my intention. He said that he had to weigh up between doing a horrible thing or having a baby ruin our lives and our families life. He said he had to take an extreme measure.

He says that guys do this all the time and say things like "I won't have anything to do with that baby" so he's not in a minority and it's not some crazy, left field thing that he's done.

I could well be overreacting to the situation. I would like the perspective of outsiders and I'm prepared to get flamed. Should I accept his reasons and let it lie?

I have forgiven him. It's important for me in all my relationships in life to forgive and not hold onto things. But it still hurts.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ireolu · 19/01/2023 18:25

Please have a serious think about contraception ideally long acting contraception to prevent pregnancy with this person again. I unfortunately think that you will stay with him. I am happy to be wrong.

Aphrathestorm · 19/01/2023 18:13

No

That's all the answer you need to your question.

ladycarlotta · 19/01/2023 10:52

Hope you come back and read all these replies, OP. All I can do is add my voice to the choir: he not only manipulated you into doing what he wanted, he felt comfortable telling you that He sees it as a completely acceptable way to control you in your most vulnerable moments and he is frank about it. He's showing you exactly who he is.

Nothing about this is forgivable, or normal, or acceptable, or respectful. It's certainly not love.

JudgeRudy · 19/01/2023 10:09

I'm a bit confused about what you're arguing about. He abandoned you when you fell pregnant with his child. He later 'reconsidered' things and got back in touch but you had miscarried the baby. You're now dating again and discussed this. He's of the opinion that what he did wasn't so bad and is justifying his actions....is that correct?
You're dating him now. You said you've forgiven him. That's entirely up to you but I know many people would not even give him the time of day.
What's the argument about now though? Are you disagreeing what happened? Do you feel like hes 'tricked' you into forgiving him and he's not really sorry? Is he trying to justify his actions or trying to explain(badly) how he felt. Ask him how he would handle the situation now if he could go back or even if it should happen again (please say it wont).
My confusion is why you are arguing about it now after you've already agreed to get back together.

DottyLittleRainbow · 19/01/2023 09:55

I think you’ve posted about this before.

His behaviour was abusive, he was trying to coerce you into a termination and left you to deal with your miscarriage alone. It’s even worse that you’re back together even though he doesn’t accept any responsibility for his actions being wrong, huge red flag.

Dump and run. You deserve better.

inloveandmarried · 19/01/2023 09:24

Horrific.

He'd never cross my threshold ever again.

Do not have so little self esteem that you take him back. Yes, let it go if that is how you need to think but do not enter into a relationship with this person again.

He's shown his true personality. Despicable. He won't change, they don't. What he's show you are his core values.

Find a decent partner.

Patineur · 19/01/2023 09:18

ComfortablyDazed · 19/01/2023 02:22

If he didn't want a child, he should have kept his trousers on.

Sorry, but this argument is shit. We don’t say that to women facing an unwanted pregnant.

I’m not defending him (assuming he’s even real 🙄), but this argument ^^ holds no water.

No, it isn't. As a man, if you don't want a child, either you don't have sex or you use reliable contraception. What you do not do is bully the mother into an abortion.

stevalnamechanger · 19/01/2023 08:54

Sorry I'm going to be harsh here

How can you take someone back who behaved like that , you deserve better

Woman up and get rid sorry

WhenDovesFly · 19/01/2023 08:52

I haven't read every page of responses as I'm certain most, if not all, will echo what's been written on page 1.

OP, if you want to accept his apology and forgive him for the sake of your own mental health then do so, but I'm with everyone else who has said don't go back to this man. Why would you give him the chance to do this to you again?

No, his behaviour was not justified and what he did was despicable. I personally couldn't rekindle a relationship with someone who had treated me so badly. I hope you come to see that you're worth so much more than this.

Workinghardeveryday · 19/01/2023 08:46

@1999its its hard isn’t it when you still love him to get your head around this situation.

He hurt you dreadfully but for some reason you had him back. Ask yourself why? Do you think you can’t do better? Do you actually believe deep down he is sorry (probably not or you wouldn’t be posting about it). You want to move on and be happy with him yes?

Not going to happen… You will never forget what he has done. You can pretend to yourself you have, but you won’t. What he did was utterly disgusting. As they say on here, he has shown you who he is, believe him..

So if in the future you accidentally fall pregnant, then what? Ah that’s right, you already know how that will pan out.

Sorry you have been through all of this. No one should have to. Have more respect for yourself and move on. He will not bring you happiness x

Giggorata · 19/01/2023 08:33

This man is a piece of shit.
That is all.

NoMoreLifts · 19/01/2023 08:20

Everything everyone said, already, in detail.

I'm only posting cos it feels like need to hear it again.

He is a shit, he treats you like shit, and justifies it.

Life has hard bits. Don't saddle yourself with someone who has already shown you how he'll manage those (by threatening you, lying to you, using you for sex, leaving you to deal with it alone and only coming back - for sex - when the hard thing over).

He's given you the gift of prescience here - take note and act accordingly. Protect yourself.

Naunet · 19/01/2023 08:08

He’s a nasty PoS, and his family are trash. Don’t you think you deserve a man who treats you with respect and kindness?

billy1966 · 19/01/2023 08:01

He is utter and complete scum.

He has showed you that he is completely comfortable treating you so badly.

God help you that you are so confused that you think this loser is all you deserve.

Please do the www.freedomprogramme.co.uk to help you find some self esteem and respect for yourself.

You have an utterly sad wasted future ahead of you if scum like him and his family are all you think you deserve.

Dump and block.

Typo22 · 19/01/2023 07:40

He is scum. Don't waste your life with this loser.

Maggie178 · 19/01/2023 07:34

He treated you appallingly. He thinks he's not in the wrong. He'll do it again. Maybe you love you him and it's hard to let him go but for you're wellbeing and happiness you need to.

BMrs · 19/01/2023 07:04

You are not overreacting. Run for the hills!!

Marigoldandivy · 19/01/2023 07:03

You deserve better than this man.

yousmellnice · 19/01/2023 07:00

1999its · 18/01/2023 22:14

He has apologised and acknowledged it must've been hard for me.

Oh right that's ok then..

Come on. You're better than this.

yousmellnice · 19/01/2023 06:59

Why on earth have you got back with him?

Glorianna · 19/01/2023 06:56

Is this what passes for love these days? This isn’t love, OP. This man will keep hurting you.

You have been warned.

Zanatdy · 19/01/2023 06:36

I think you’re mad to go back to him

NEmama · 19/01/2023 06:35

What a catch, I mean cunt

NellietheElephantpackedhertrunks · 19/01/2023 06:33

Takenoprisoner · 18/01/2023 22:17

You're underreacting. He's an awful disgusting human being who abandoned you at your most vulnerable. I struggle to understand how you can feel anything positive towards him, let alone let him back into your life and be intimate with him.

I'm so sorry for everything you went through with him and the miscarriage. You really need counselling to work out why you've gone back to him. I couldn't bear to look at someone who left me in that state, and I think that's a healthier response. For some reason, you are not protecting yourself against this man who has caused you such anguish and pain.

100%. You had a truly horrible experience but at least he showed you his true colours (together with those of his family) so you know never to go there again.

Shoxfordian · 19/01/2023 06:16

No it wasn’t justified - why are you giving this man any of your time at all? Find some counselling, have some self respect and dump him op.