Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not discuss my life story at work?

408 replies

HangryBerd · 18/01/2023 22:01

My work is conducting training which tells us that we need to share our life stories, disclose what makes us "us", be vulnerable, share our emotions. If we don't, we are told that we're being anti-inclusion. My colleagues and manager are therefore having a go at me for being too private.

I'm finding this really upsetting as I'll chat to anyone about many things but there are aspects that are very difficult to talk about. They're nothing to do with work and quite frankly nobody else's business.

AIBU to stand my ground?

OP posts:
Whatthediddlyfeck · 19/01/2023 11:09

Are they going to have someone on standby to help you with the resulting emotions/headfuck that this creates? No, I thought not.

I’ve done a lot of “self therapy” over the last couple of years to deal with some really difficult times in my life, and part of this does involve putting a lot in “boxes. Like hell would I be unpacking these boxes so my employer can tick a few boxes of their own

TangledWebOfDeception · 19/01/2023 11:07

We should not be required to play the game at all. I simply will not facilitate this kind of intrusive, coercive practice at work. It’s complete bollocks. We don’t all need therapy and I don’t want to be parented at work.

It’s completely my choice how much or how little of myself I share with my colleagues. ‘Opening a space’ is of absolutely no value to me and I will not be made to engage with that sort of power play (because that’s what it actually is). It benefits very few people and potentially harms or at least negatively affects a lot more, in my view.

JudgeRudy · 19/01/2023 11:03

There's a middle ground and it's probably possible to 'play the game'. You don't need to be too personal or specific but maybe mention a few things to 'tick a box'....eg" I grew up with 2 working class parents in a small market town. Attended the local comprehensive which was predominantly white working class. I didn't know of anyone who was gay and although I don't consider myself racist I do not have any BAME friends and have never been inside a mosque. Ive never claimed benefits or used a foid bank but have been broke before and borrowed money to pay for essential bills. I'm sometimes nervous of offending people at work so stay out of political and social arguments."
I'm guessing that paragraph ticks a few boxes and isn't too personal.

ICouldHaveCheckedFirst · 19/01/2023 11:01

Relations were difficult between me (team lead) and a difficult staff member. My boss set himself up as a mediator (unqualified, and unsolicited!). All 3 of us (boss included) listed 3 things we liked about the other 2, and 3 things we didn't like. Staff member's dislikes about me included that I was "too private"! Well - tough. She was an over-sharer, IMO, and was no more likely to change her personality than I was, just to suit her preferences.

Hold your ground, OP.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/01/2023 10:57

Judgyjudgy · 19/01/2023 00:09

I've done this over the years with both sexes. Have you ever done anything like this? That's the point, when everyone shares something it opens up a space. Don't knock it until you try it. I've done this twice, and found it quite life changing.

And people for whom it is utterly anathema?

Or don't we matter? Must we acquiesce so you can get your jollies?

Merryhobnobs · 19/01/2023 10:57

Sounds like they want to be vultures preying on peoples trauma and gossip. I reserve the right to be polite and friendly but only share what I deem appropriate with my work colleagues. It is also very rare that experiences are a singular thing - so they are intruding into personal life of non work colleagues too.

Blueisthecolour1 · 19/01/2023 10:56

YADNBU!!! It's your right to maintain your privacy, and they can't force you to talk about your private life at all, if you don't wish to. Work is totally NOT a place to bring your private self to, in my humble opinion. I purposefully strive to maintain considerable distance between me and my personal life and work colleagues. They a) have no effing reason to know everything about me, and my history - it's got absolutely nothing to do with my performance or my ability and b) they don't care anyway.

There is also the rather horrid option of c) which is that some people use it as ammunition against you and unless these colleagues are very very good friends, I would be seriously wary of oversharing with them. Some people love the "Bring your whole self to work" ethos but in reality, no-one does this. It's human nature to protect yourself by putting up Chinese walls. And you clearly aren't comfortable with sharing your private life - who would be?

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 19/01/2023 10:54

Judgyjudgy · 19/01/2023 10:47

The difference with what I was doing was it was a facilitated session, where everyone has agreed its a safe space, and everyone is sharing. It's not just random gossip by the watercooler. Each to their own pf course. Just wanted to share a positive experience, having done it myself with a very positive outcome.

So not the same as the OP then.

And I still would not share anything personal at work about my life. Even in an alleged safe space. Curious what makes it safe? I would not believe they wouldnt gossip. If I need to talk about my terrible previous life I'd pay a professional.

Handyweatherstation · 19/01/2023 10:53

I could have fun with this by talking in depth about something that calms my mind and which I find greatly satisfying, which is field walking. That means that you choose a field you think has the possibility of yielding human-made artefacts or fossils, then you walk back and forth across it until you've examined the entire field. Every time there is heavy rain or the field is ploughed you do it again. I could expand on the optimum speed to walk and the best angle of stoop to adopt in order to avoid back ache whilst also achieving the best angle for viewing the soil, plus methods to stop my glasses falling off. I could include an aside into the quality of the soil and difficulties encountered on heavy clay and add in something about my longings for a metal detector. It would be interesting to see how long I was allowed to talk.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/01/2023 10:52

Mammajay · 18/01/2023 23:04

The only time I was asked to do that was on an introduction to counselling course. It sounds unethical for a company to ask this of their employees

Yes. And that has a lot of well known, effective paperwork around it, obvious reasons for it's being done proper debriefs built in and is done by professionals who know what it is they are digging into.

Workplace versions sound like nasty titillation and would probably fuck up quite a few people.

I can't even begin to understand the ethos behind it.

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 19/01/2023 10:48

Iateallthechips · 19/01/2023 08:05

Fucking hell. A job is just a job.

I got hauled into a managers office at a job once for not being open and engaged enough with the team.

Did I do my actual job well? Was I good with clients? Yes.

So what was the problem?

I went to work, kept my head down, did the work I was supposed to do and went home. None of the other bullshit and I would certainly not share private details of my life with other members of staff.

Lol, I got hauled in once for saying I cant wait to retire. Not even kidding. So that could be seen as oversharing. And Michelle if your reading this and recognise yourself, you were a useless and terrible boss.

Judgyjudgy · 19/01/2023 10:47

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 19/01/2023 10:24

That's naive. Any workplace will have its share of a cross section of the whole of society. It's why The Office was so popular. Everyone in it reminded us of our similar colleague. So by numbers alone, there will be a talkative one, a shy one, a narcissist, a hugely private one, a sex addict one (that might just be my workplace) a sly one, a bouncy one, a slimy one etc.

And then there's just gossip, although I do my level best to not bitch about people, i do share gossip. My entire workplace runs on gossip, it's how I find out anything before the official email announcement.

You share something private and it's no longer private, people will gossip. And they even take it home as gossip. I'm as guilty as my partner for telling each other stuff. Granted not really personal stuff yet, but still I know an ex colleague of my partner is now a convicted peadophile.

The difference with what I was doing was it was a facilitated session, where everyone has agreed its a safe space, and everyone is sharing. It's not just random gossip by the watercooler. Each to their own pf course. Just wanted to share a positive experience, having done it myself with a very positive outcome.

HectorPlasm · 19/01/2023 10:46

Fuck that - more woke bollocks designed to keep HR and diversity czars in a job

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/01/2023 10:46

Being too private?

Fuck that. Absolutely fuck that. I'd have to leave. Or start a grievance procedure.

That's horrendous.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 19/01/2023 10:41

I remember sharing something in a work situation because I was asked a direct question and so I answered it directly, even though I wasn't comfortable talking about it. . I regretted it and wished I'd had the confidence to say "Sorry. I keep that private."
You really can't trust people to not gossip about stuff and hold it against you. You are best to have a couple of stories prepared - like the spilling drinks at a party, or that time it rained all the fortnight of your holiday and how it made you feel. Get your thinking cap on!

seineingefrohrenerpimmel · 19/01/2023 10:33

I would absolutely hate this and I wouldn't be sharing no matter what they said. I'd also be keeping an eye open for another job. It's not inclusive forcing people to share things they don't want to.
Being open and giving people an opportunity to talk about issues and share them if they wish is good but it must be only if they actually want to.
I am a very private person and really can't cope when people who I don't know particularly well get really pushy about wanting to know about more private aspects of my life. I taught in a school once where staff were constantly asking very personal questions and getting pissed off when I didn't want to answer. In fact, one of them complained to the head once who sent the deputy round to give me a ticking off and for being rude by not answering questions. The person's question which I really didn't want to answer was "What was your first time like?". FFS. At that point I hadn't even had sex and wouldn't have wanted to answer the question anyway. I told the deputy what the question was and she said "Oh, she was just being friendly, trying to get you to open up".

milveycrohn · 19/01/2023 10:32

Well, you can always make up some fairly innocuous stuff to share. It doesn't have to be true, and it doesn't have to be very dramatic.

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 19/01/2023 10:24

Judgyjudgy · 19/01/2023 10:09

I really don't, but I trusted them and as far as I'm aware nothing has ever been shared elsewhere. I don't know why they would as I would equally not share information about someone else. I imagine these sessions are in the same nature as an AA meeting or similar. I find it very sad that so many people work with people who don't have the very basic level of integrity, that's very depressing. Obviously no one should be forced to share anything they're not comfortable with sharing.

That's naive. Any workplace will have its share of a cross section of the whole of society. It's why The Office was so popular. Everyone in it reminded us of our similar colleague. So by numbers alone, there will be a talkative one, a shy one, a narcissist, a hugely private one, a sex addict one (that might just be my workplace) a sly one, a bouncy one, a slimy one etc.

And then there's just gossip, although I do my level best to not bitch about people, i do share gossip. My entire workplace runs on gossip, it's how I find out anything before the official email announcement.

You share something private and it's no longer private, people will gossip. And they even take it home as gossip. I'm as guilty as my partner for telling each other stuff. Granted not really personal stuff yet, but still I know an ex colleague of my partner is now a convicted peadophile.

thenightsky · 19/01/2023 10:18

workiskillingme · 18/01/2023 22:16

I would be tempted to look squarely at my manager and say 'well one of my biggest traumas and regrets in my life was sleeping with your husband. An all round disappointment. Did he ever get those antibiotics?'

I love this!

Judgyjudgy · 19/01/2023 10:09

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 19/01/2023 09:49

You must only work with lovely people. I imagine if I was to share any part of my terrible life story that one man (the mental health colleague no less) would both share it all around my workplace and use it somehow to get me in bed with him.
I do not know how he became the MH ambassador. He is the creepiest creep ever and wants to shag all the women, young, old, elderly, he doesnt care. I mean kudos to him for being so inclusive eh.

I really don't, but I trusted them and as far as I'm aware nothing has ever been shared elsewhere. I don't know why they would as I would equally not share information about someone else. I imagine these sessions are in the same nature as an AA meeting or similar. I find it very sad that so many people work with people who don't have the very basic level of integrity, that's very depressing. Obviously no one should be forced to share anything they're not comfortable with sharing.

Scooby5kids · 19/01/2023 10:03

AaandAway · 18/01/2023 22:14

On the plus side, there's someone in nearly every office who would seize this golden opportunity to monologue solidly about themselves for the full time allotted so you might never even have to do it, once Martin from IT gets going...

There is always a Martin in every workplace 🤣

xogossipgirlxo · 19/01/2023 10:02

What a fucked up idea. I would never go for it.

Scooby5kids · 19/01/2023 09:58

Just make up some BS- how are they going to know? Don't tell them anything that was traumatic or personal

Newnamefor23 · 19/01/2023 09:56

This has just reminded me of a staff day out - a day of fun.

But a stressful day of near disaster. Nothing as mad, stressful or worrying as sharing life experiences sitting in a circle.

Just a walk up in gentle hills. No risk assessment as we weren't taking children. No need for a risk assessment as we were all adults.

What they hadn’t done was to think of the group going and their capabilities.

One colleague, who was v overweight and unfit, couldn’t get to the end of the car park and had to sit in the bus for the day. Others were having problems getting up some of the gentle hills.

This proposed day is about inclusion. Our staff bonding walk ended up an excluding event despite its over optimistic intentions. Fortunately there were no accidents - but we never went on another.

If I’d been older and wiser back then I’d have aired my worries before we went.

SillySausage81 · 19/01/2023 09:52

A friend of mine went for an interview once (also for a bog standard office job) and they asked her what was the hardest time she'd ever been through in her life (can't remember the exact wording but they made it clear they were talking about her personal life, not just professional life). She was so taken aback with the stupidity of the question that she just answered bluntly and honestly that it was the night her 15 year old daughter hanged herself. They were rendered speechless and very embarrassed... it seems they wanted openness... but only as long as you'd led a fairly blessed life. They probably hadn't even considered the potential outcome of such a question.

Absolutely horrific thing to ask people to do... some people's woes will only be as bad as having witnessed their parents rowing a few times and having an unsuitable boyfriend whilst some people will have gone through unimaginable traumas. Some people wouldn't even talk about their private life to their close friends. It's extremely short-sighted.

I think it's worth putting your foot down. As others have said, it's the opposite of "inclusive"... coercing people to reveal potentially traumatic experiences, or even just very private things, when they aren't comfortable doing so. I agree with pps who've said they probably haven't really thought it through at all. It could have serious MH ramifications for some people.

Go back to them using their own language: it's making you "unsafe", you don't give your consent, you find the pressure they are putting you under very triggering, you need to look after your mental health...

Ffs, you don't need to be able to trust Alan from Accounts with your life and your emotional wellbeing, you just need him to pay your wages on time.