Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not discuss my life story at work?

408 replies

HangryBerd · 18/01/2023 22:01

My work is conducting training which tells us that we need to share our life stories, disclose what makes us "us", be vulnerable, share our emotions. If we don't, we are told that we're being anti-inclusion. My colleagues and manager are therefore having a go at me for being too private.

I'm finding this really upsetting as I'll chat to anyone about many things but there are aspects that are very difficult to talk about. They're nothing to do with work and quite frankly nobody else's business.

AIBU to stand my ground?

OP posts:
babsanderson · 19/01/2023 13:07

If I was due to be leaving an organisation I think I would lie, but stun them into silence. For example, my parents were both highly abusive and my first memory is of attending sex parties with their friends, etc etc. If they want personal, I would give them made up personal and it would be the worse scenario they could imagine. And then finish with - thank you for creating an open and safe space where I could share that. I trust you will all continue to respect this safe space and not share my private information outside of it. I would then have to take the afternoon off for my mental health as a result of the sharing. And if anyone ever shared any of it I would sue the company, fuck em.

roarfeckingroarr · 19/01/2023 12:58

Recently I was asked to join a diversity workshop. Everyone else was a diversity specialist or a member of one of the company's people networks - so someone invested in D&I bollocks.

We were asked to share why D&I matters to us, why we are passionate etc.

I was honest - it's not an area of expertise for me but I appreciate learning more about the experiences of others.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 19/01/2023 12:57

I would not answer. No-one wants their employee's whole self at work, they want their best productive selves. If you reveal your whole self, especially in relation to things that could impact on productivity, you leave yourself massively open to real capacity, sick leave and other problems further down the line. If you mention menopause, brain fog, Long Covid, mental health problems, large life problems briefly it might be fine, but if it looks like it will translate into long-term health problems and impact sick leave or productivity, you will be vulnerable if there are capability procedures or redundancies they can use against you. I was honest about one of these and have had no end of trouble with HR since then, and I have now taken to denying all problems and presenting the best possible face to HR, otherwise, I risk performance capability proceedings, this is not in my imagination, this happened!

Do not tell the truth, your employer does not have your best interests at heart. They want some lovely tiny non-problematic problem revealed that won't impact the bottom line. I am not in the private sector by the way, but public and I thought the protections would be much better but they are not.

Phos · 19/01/2023 12:52

I refused to do this. My line manager respected my decision. It's all very well to be ABLE to bring your whole self to work if it's something you feel the great desire to do, but you cannot force others to want to do the same.

OMG12 · 19/01/2023 12:51

Tell them you’re a werewolf, you got bitten by an American tourist in the 80s your vulnerabilities include silver bullets and full moons.

if they don’t like it tell them they are not being inclusive of people who suffer from lycanthropy. Tell them you’re glad they are being so inclusive it’s such a relief and assume they will not have an issue if you take off every full moon as a reasonable adjustment to deal with your excess hair and for the safety of your colleagues.

LlynTegid · 19/01/2023 12:51

I think you could argue that it is indirect discrimination and fails any Equalities Act test.

Invoke the bullying policy or harassment one if they persist. Or even say what you think should not be disclosed, perhaps with examples that haven't happened to you.

ProfessionalWeirdo · 19/01/2023 12:47

If it were me I would refuse to participate, ask for their business case for how this supports inclusion, ask to see the risk assessment with particular focus mental health, and ask how this fits with data protection and right to privacy at work.

^^ THIS. OP, have you asked your employer WHY they think this so-called "training" is necessary? What exactly is it "training" you for?

Iateallthechips · 19/01/2023 12:46

Seriously, what are they doing to do if you just refuse?

No one can force you to do anything. They can’t sack you for refusing to speak about anything non job related.

I would argue that sharing your personal life is unprofessional.

The whole thing is nuts.

QOD · 19/01/2023 12:40

i hate this - day 1 of a course i foudn out my best friends dh had been in an ultimately fatal car accident so day 2 and 3 i was not in a place to do this and wow. The course leader was such an arse. My manager did actually deal with it and i was allowed to not participate - your work should SUPPORT you in these things. arseholes

ihavespoken · 19/01/2023 12:39

YANBU AT ALL. Like fuck would I do this

babsanderson · 19/01/2023 12:37

Twiglets1 · 19/01/2023 08:21

It's so intrusive. I'll never forget in my work as a Teaching Assistant I was playing a social skills game with a boy where you turn over cards asking personal questions (not a good idea as I found out). To encourage him to get involved I said I will go first and turned over a card asking about "something that recently upset me". My mum had just died. I just froze and sat there in silence and would you believe? This boy I was working with (very autistic, supposedly struggled to empathise) said to me quietly, " you don't have to answer".

Honestly that brought tears to my eyes. What a lovely boy.

ursuibear · 19/01/2023 12:30

"my biggest vulnerability is that I'm very introverted and private, and don't feel comfortable sharing everything about myself except with very close trusted friends."

That would be a good response @SockGoddess

ursuibear · 19/01/2023 12:28

Oh dear. Is this really a thing now?

I’d stand my ground and say I felt uncomfortable sharing. I wouldn’t make anything up, not at all. Though I love the aliens and space example given by a pp!

I could really bore with my hobbies, as another pp said! But personal, and emotional, issues are not up for discussion.

Bpdqueen · 19/01/2023 12:09

Yanbu what are they wanting people to talk about child abuse, sexual assualts, suicidal thoughts, self harm, medical history, deaths of loved ones, crimes you've committed. I don't understand this at all its called a private life for a reason

OwwwMuuuum · 19/01/2023 12:06

YANBU this is totally inappropriate.

I’d not make a fuss tho, just go in with a made-up story about someone grossly overstepping your personal boundaries!

SockGoddess · 19/01/2023 12:04

God this is awful, i'm feeling anxious just reading about it. Reason 47532 why I'm self-employed. What the hell is wrong with employers and managers who swallow all this crappy, ill-advised training? Anyone with half an ounce of sense, and anyone with ANY actual knowledge or awareness about inclusion and vulnerability, would know this is an awful idea that risks seriously upsetting and destabilising certain people. Even if you have private upsets that you don't intend to share, just hearing about someone else's could be really painful.

I hope I'm never in such a situation but if I was I'd have to say "my biggest vulnerability is that I'm very introverted and private, and don't feel comfortable sharing everything about myself except with very close trusted friends." Then look expectantly at the next person.

Twanky · 19/01/2023 12:04

WigglyGlowWorm · 19/01/2023 07:30

You could have fun with this and make it utterly ridiculous.

You- I get all my shopping in Harrods food hall and wouldn’t dream of going anywhere else

Annoying manager- But I saw you in Asda last week

You- You were clearly mistaken. I’m an identical quintuplet and it must have been one of my sisters

Annoying manager- But you said you were an only child

You could go on and on…

Or look long and hard at the manager who's implementing this nonsense and say, meanongfully, 'Surely you don't want me to talk about everything in my private life?'.

Inertia · 19/01/2023 12:03

Absolutely awful idea, they can’t possibly know the extent of the traumatic experiences people have had to deal with throughout their lives.

I would be inclined to tell them of a traumatic experience at work, where everyone was bullied into opening up about their mental health and life traumas with no consideration given to medical confidentiality, data protection, or therapeutic debriefing / counselling. As a result you avoid discussing private issues at work.

TheMagicSword · 19/01/2023 12:03

I’ve done some sessions where we were encouraged to share genuine difficulties and trauma from our lives. But those were relevant to the job (one was counselling, another was where we could expect to experience trauma in the role), everyone had joined voluntarily, and there were proper safeguards in place, including a counsellor on hand and available afterwards. Even so, hearing what some of my colleagues had been through is something that has stayed with me for many years.

This, as described, is absolutely unacceptable. No one should ever be forced (pressurised, leant on, etc) to disclose personal information which is unrelated to their job.

I’m due to return to an HR role in a particularly woke public sector organisation soon. I fear this is the kind of thing they’d think was a good idea. Some of us HR types have our heads rather more firmly screwed on! If it were me I would refuse to participate, ask for their business case for how this supports inclusion, ask to see the risk assessment with particular focus mental health, and ask how this fits with data protection and right to privacy at work (the TUC document shared earlier is good).

OneInEight · 19/01/2023 11:54

Surely it is just as discriminatory to not realise that some people are simply not comfortable talking about their personal life in public.

Apairofsparklingeyes · 19/01/2023 11:48

At a similar event in my DH’s work, the first person to who was asked to speak about himself turned to the person running the session and said ‘How much are you earning for today? I’m asking because they can afford to pay for this shit, but they haven’t given us a pay rise!’ Smile

longtompot · 19/01/2023 11:40

You need to channel your inner Chunk and tell them everything ;)

But seriously, this would be my idea of hell. I hate the "tell us something about yourself" in group intro sessions.

Terzani · 19/01/2023 11:39

@SillySausage81
A friend of mine went for an interview once (also for a bog standard office job) and they asked her what was the hardest time she'd ever been through in her life (can't remember the exact wording but they made it clear they were talking about her personal life, not just professional life). She was so taken aback with the stupidity of the question that she just answered bluntly and honestly that it was the night her 15 year old daughter hanged herself. They were rendered speechless and very embarrassed... it seems they wanted openness... but only as long as you'd led a fairly blessed life. They probably hadn't even considered the potential outcome of such a question.

Exactly! In fact this is why such stupid exercises are proposed in the first place: the organisers have themselves a fairly blessed life, so from their point of view, ”showing your vulnerabilities” is not risky at all, in fact it could be a harmless pastime.
When people like this talk about openness, sincerity, vulnerability and other terms from this jargon, they mean something different than for the majority of people. It's what they post in social media when they do paid promotion or when they try to be deep and serious. Pure storytelling, usually with a mobilising morale, or something sweet and sentimental, but nothing that could suggest MH issues or potential problems at work - IOW no real vulnerabilities at all.
”When I was a little girl, my mother used to collect dry leaves in the autumn - now as an adult sometimes I feel like crying when I see a fallen leaf” or ”When I was a little boy, we couldn't eat meat as many times as I wanted, because my family wasn't wealthy - now as an adult I know better and don't eat meat at all” etc.

CloudPop · 19/01/2023 11:24

CallTheMobWife · 18/01/2023 22:05

Tell them they aren't being inclusive of all the people who have no desire to share their secrets to co-workers, and in fact they are being highly intrusive and discriminatory.
I'd also say that any further "having a go" about it will result in a formal complaint of harrassment and/or bullying.

What new twattery is this?

This

NotTerfNorCis · 19/01/2023 11:12

That sounds like a cult! Of course they can't force you to talk about personal things.