Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not discuss my life story at work?

408 replies

HangryBerd · 18/01/2023 22:01

My work is conducting training which tells us that we need to share our life stories, disclose what makes us "us", be vulnerable, share our emotions. If we don't, we are told that we're being anti-inclusion. My colleagues and manager are therefore having a go at me for being too private.

I'm finding this really upsetting as I'll chat to anyone about many things but there are aspects that are very difficult to talk about. They're nothing to do with work and quite frankly nobody else's business.

AIBU to stand my ground?

OP posts:
Chasedbythechaser · 19/01/2023 19:27

I grew up with 5 sisters and one day, I said to one of them, you’re not my muvver and she replied oh yes I am

🤣🤣🤣

DiWoo · 19/01/2023 19:22

Chasedbythechaser · 18/01/2023 22:21

What role do you have OP? I remember doing a counselling course many years ago and we have to do something like this. I understood why as it was about getting to know ourselves first.

If it is a team building exercise in an unrelated field, I'd be inclined to make something up tbh. Think of a character in a book or tv series and be her if that makes sense (obviously not a complicated inter-related Eastenders character :))

I grew up with 5 sisters and one day, I said to one of them, you’re not my muvver and she replied oh yes I am

LakieLady · 19/01/2023 18:43

This kind of training is designed for extroverts who have had an easy life

Designed by them, too, I reckon.

LakieLady · 19/01/2023 18:23

Judgyjudgy · 19/01/2023 00:01

Tbh, I've been on leadership courses and they can be amazing if you do jump right in and have some vulnerability. I assume everyone else will be doing the same and it's a trusted space

Oh well, that's fine then.

Perhaps you could suggest where I should start? CSA by a family member and subsequently others? The DV perpetrated by my first serious boyfriend? My history of depression and self-harm? Self-medicating with alcohol and drugs? Sexual harrassment in 2 different workplaces? Emotional and financial abuse by my XH? The trauma when the partner who finally enabled me to feel safe, happy and loved for my "whole self" died suddenly, far too young?

I have enough fucking vulnerability, thanks, I don't need to inflict any more on myself. And I have (unsurprisingly) trust issues, so for me the only "trusted" spaces are those I share with my counsellor and a handful of close and emotionally literate friends.

Fuck that for a game of soldiers. I'd rather pull my own teeth out with pliers.

ManchesterGirl2 · 19/01/2023 18:11

And in babsanderson's example there was a clear learning aim, even for the minor sharing. What the hell are the learning aims for this course?

ManchesterGirl2 · 19/01/2023 18:10

babsanderson · 19/01/2023 14:22

I have only once been asked to share things. It was on a course about working with children and we had to share a time when an adult upset us (it was to talk about power relationships) and the trainer made a very big deal that we should not share things that were very upsetting but more minor everyday things. One person actually said they could only think of major things and nothing minor and the trainer said that's fine lets move to the next person.

I think people who suggest in work exercises like the OP is being asked to take part in are either pretty young with an easy life so far, or have led a very charmed life and think that is the norm.

I am older and many people I know have had major difficulties at some point in their lives and it is rarely apparent. Women in happy marriages who tell you they were in a very abusive relationship with an ex. Woman whose sister was murdered. Woman whose dad was an alcoholic and regularly beat her mother. This stuff is not unusual. And there is a reason most people do not know this kind of stuff about work colleagues.

This is how it should be done.

Even in therapy, good counselors won't push you to share until you're ready.

LakieLady · 19/01/2023 17:33

RaininSummer · 18/01/2023 22:08

That sound awful and ill thought out. Apart from privacy, it could open cans of worms everywhere and be quite upsetting for some people.

I agree. Imagine having been a victim of violence or abuse and being told to telll everyone your history?

That could be really damaging, not to mention potentially triggering for your audience.

What utter bollocks this idea is. I'd refuse.

2bazookas · 19/01/2023 16:47

It's a trick question. They don't care about a lifestory. What they want to know is, who has the balls to keep a cool head under pressure, resist negative influence, assert their own integrity.

"As a child I shared a bed and bathtime with my brothers and dog, we all ate out of the same bowl. Back then I had no privacy or autonomy at all, but now I do. My first ambition was to own my own spoon by the time I left school. Then I got a first class fork and knife at Oxford. My hobbies are chasing rabbits and catching balls."

thenightsky · 19/01/2023 15:20

That's the point, when everyone shares something it opens up a space

I don't understand what 'opens up a space' means.

drspouse · 19/01/2023 14:34

LightSpeeds · 18/01/2023 23:14

Listening to other people's issues can be upsetting and triggering, and it could also open the door to bullying and discrimination (as someone has already pointed out).

And why would you want someone you don't know or don't like to know about your most personal business?

This sounds unethical.

Yes, I'm wondering whether they have counsellors on hand for those whose childhood abuse is brought up by another colleague's description.
Not to mention, of course, the colleague who would use DARVO to tell everyone how his ex-wife forced him to hit her and then had the temerity to call the police, or to share their fetishes.

babsanderson · 19/01/2023 14:22

I have only once been asked to share things. It was on a course about working with children and we had to share a time when an adult upset us (it was to talk about power relationships) and the trainer made a very big deal that we should not share things that were very upsetting but more minor everyday things. One person actually said they could only think of major things and nothing minor and the trainer said that's fine lets move to the next person.

I think people who suggest in work exercises like the OP is being asked to take part in are either pretty young with an easy life so far, or have led a very charmed life and think that is the norm.

I am older and many people I know have had major difficulties at some point in their lives and it is rarely apparent. Women in happy marriages who tell you they were in a very abusive relationship with an ex. Woman whose sister was murdered. Woman whose dad was an alcoholic and regularly beat her mother. This stuff is not unusual. And there is a reason most people do not know this kind of stuff about work colleagues.

WisherWood · 19/01/2023 13:55

Judgyjudgy · 19/01/2023 00:09

I've done this over the years with both sexes. Have you ever done anything like this? That's the point, when everyone shares something it opens up a space. Don't knock it until you try it. I've done this twice, and found it quite life changing.

Yes, I've had group therapy, run by NHS staff trained in psychotherapy. At one session, a young woman talked about how she'd been absent from the group the previous week because she'd been having her third abortion. She talked about how difficult this was for her but that it wasn't the right time in her life to be pregnant. Unbeknownst to her, the week that she was away, another woman on the group had spoken about her recent miscarriage and how she thought her fertility issues might bring about the end of her marriage. She was sitting in the room whilst this other woman was talking about abortion. The rest of us sat there knowing what she was going through, listening to this. Somehow, I don't think Barry from HR, with his 2:2 in media studies and three years HR experience is going to be qualified or able to deal with the fallout from that one.

And group therapy feels like a safe space because you know people have been referred there. So you know that whatever they've got going on is similar to you, in some way. And you know you can walk out of the room and not see them again. You don't really want to be bumping into Brenda from accounts after you've just confessed that you don't really care if your dad lives or dies because he is, in all honesty, quite the arsehole. This is a shit idea for all concerned.

billy1966 · 19/01/2023 13:40

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 19/01/2023 13:32

I find the idea of people with the power of hire and fire, who could potentially be in charge of issuing redundancies forcing employees to confess "serious mental health conditions and our relationship histories." utterly intrusive and troubling.

I'd want to know a hell of a lot more about the purpose, the qualifications of the person conducting this research/training or whatever it was and what they were going to do with this information and I'd probably contact a union.

PPs are right when they ask if your employer has thought about the issue of having plans to deal with stirring up trauma with this exercise.
On a training course years ago, over a dozen of us had to stand in a circle and talk about the last time we were really sad and how we overcame it. It was very "self Confessing" style. I'd had a recent bereavement but couldn't/didn't want to mention it and asked to be excused. They kept pressing so I left the room. I probably should have made up some story but I couldn't think straight as I was just getting through it day by day at the time. Why should you be forced share personal vulnerabilities with colleagues? Trusted friends yes, but in the workplace? Surely you should have a right privacy? It sounds like poking a hornets nest.

For someone unwell this sort of intrusive pressure could trigger them.

I find it chilling.

On whose orders and with what qualifications are they doing this.

I think a call to ACAS is warranted.

To be forced, coerced, into spilling your guts in front of people you may not know nor like, could well trigger someone very seriously.

I think someone ringing out sick with stress because of this could have the basis of a case for constructive dismissal.

Hard to believe no one has challenged this.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 19/01/2023 13:40

I find the idea of people with the power of hire and fire, who could potentially be in charge of issuing redundancies forcing employees to confess "serious mental health conditions and our relationship histories." utterly intrusive and troubling

In exjob I had managers I didn't trust as far as I could see them. No way I would hand them vulnerabilities they could exploit, personally or professionally (learned that one the hard way).

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 19/01/2023 13:32

I find the idea of people with the power of hire and fire, who could potentially be in charge of issuing redundancies forcing employees to confess "serious mental health conditions and our relationship histories." utterly intrusive and troubling.

I'd want to know a hell of a lot more about the purpose, the qualifications of the person conducting this research/training or whatever it was and what they were going to do with this information and I'd probably contact a union.

PPs are right when they ask if your employer has thought about the issue of having plans to deal with stirring up trauma with this exercise.
On a training course years ago, over a dozen of us had to stand in a circle and talk about the last time we were really sad and how we overcame it. It was very "self Confessing" style. I'd had a recent bereavement but couldn't/didn't want to mention it and asked to be excused. They kept pressing so I left the room. I probably should have made up some story but I couldn't think straight as I was just getting through it day by day at the time. Why should you be forced share personal vulnerabilities with colleagues? Trusted friends yes, but in the workplace? Surely you should have a right privacy? It sounds like poking a hornets nest.

ShamedBySiri · 19/01/2023 13:29

@SillySausage81

In the past I had a job working in insurance doing medical interviews for life/income protection. There are A LOT of questions to go through - about 60. Some interviews can be very time consuming so it's great when you get someone answering No to all the questions. One person was answering No all along - no heart problems, no blood pressure problems etc and I was picking up speed whizzing through the list until I got to "have you had time off work for stress/depression ?" and he replied "I had a year off after my family were killed in a car crash" - wife and children. That rendered me speechless and took the wind out of my sails.
You just don't know what is going on in people's lives and it's really not appropriate for employers to expose people to these sorts of scenarios.

Also agree with everything @Terzani said.

SockGoddess · 19/01/2023 13:27

The thing is though most people have endured awful things past or present, even people with fairly humdrum lives. A massive proportion of women have been sexually assaulted and many raped, or abused as a child, and so have some men. Most people will have suffered bereavements, some incredibly traumatic. People have, or have had, awful health issues, injuries, phobias and painful addictions. As a PP said, it's a private life for a reason - most of us have things we don't want everyone to know or that it would simply be very upsetting to have to recount.

That's why this kind of thing makes me so cross - ANYONE could tell them it's a really bad idea. I just do not get who laps up this stuff and thinks ooh yes great idea! - and why?

mewkins · 19/01/2023 13:26

AaandAway · 18/01/2023 22:14

On the plus side, there's someone in nearly every office who would seize this golden opportunity to monologue solidly about themselves for the full time allotted so you might never even have to do it, once Martin from IT gets going...

If they insisted I would monologue for 10 mins on something niche until their eyes all glazed over. That will teach them!!!

Bestcatmum · 19/01/2023 13:16

I like cats....is all they get from me.

Edam1 · 19/01/2023 13:15

Blimey! Not only is this appalling, surely it is discriminatory? People with poor mental health or who have suffered tragedies are being put under pressure that others are not. It singles out ill and disabled people and you could make a case for sex and race discrimination too

CruCru · 19/01/2023 13:11

I wonder whether whoever has come up with this is very young (and has had a fairly easy life). Do they really want to hear about past relationships, gynaecological issues, family problems? Most people are quite dull (including me) - listening to a bunch of colleagues over share is going to be tedious at best and horrific at worst.

I don’t much like the suggestion that you make something up. Apart from anything else, it puts pressure on others to perform.

The grown up thing would be to say that you are uncomfortable certain things and that you really value your privacy. You were tempted to make something up but think it’s probably better to be honest.

babsanderson · 19/01/2023 13:10

My work think I am a very private person and boring. I am not. I am just not stupid enough to share private struggles at work.

tigger1001 · 19/01/2023 13:08

ProfessionalWeirdo · 19/01/2023 12:47

If it were me I would refuse to participate, ask for their business case for how this supports inclusion, ask to see the risk assessment with particular focus mental health, and ask how this fits with data protection and right to privacy at work.

^^ THIS. OP, have you asked your employer WHY they think this so-called "training" is necessary? What exactly is it "training" you for?

Absolutely all of this.

That's my idea of hell. I am a private person and don't discuss anything personal with random colleagues.

Bestcatmum · 19/01/2023 13:08

Bollocks. I let them think I'm just a boring middle aged woman, they have absolutely NO idea what an outrageous life I've led. They will never find out either.
Naturally because I'm 60 that's exactly what they do think the ageist bastards. If only they knew.😂