Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For me to be a SAHM my DH would have to earn.....

515 replies

CPHB2021 · 18/01/2023 17:32

Following on from a thread of 'if you knew all would be ok, I would...' and a resounding about said 'leave work and be a SAHP' I would absolutely LOVE to do this and by scraping the barrel, we probably could but we'd have little to no disposable income. I would only leave if I was able to still take my children to do things, meet friends for coffee etc. Go abroad once a year still. Have some money in savings. I often wonder HOW some of the mums at school don't work, we are technically 'above average' income which seem LUDICROUS given that we use almost all of it, every month! We live in the SE and I think our outgoings must be quite high! How much would one person have to earn for you to leave work?

OP posts:
whizzielizzie · 19/01/2023 22:13

Not at all. Of course parents who use child care raise their children. My point was really that we didn’t work out how much we needed to live on but rather how we wanted to live. (What roles we would both fill)
We made the choice (for our family)that I would stay home.

VioletaDelValle · 19/01/2023 21:59

whizzielizzie · 19/01/2023 21:49

When we decided (before we had children) that I would stay home with our children it was not ever about the money. It was about who we wanted to raise our children - and we both agreed it would be me. My husband worked very hard so that would be possible and was very financially savvy (he was a money mover and saver). By the time our children were both at school we were able to continue on the same route where I was always available for whatever they needed. Throughout my husband’s working life as our sole provider he worked hard and climbed the promotion ladder. We have been able to do all we wanted to do together and with our children. It was definitely a lifestyle choice rather than a financial one.

Do parents who use childcare not raise their own children?

Are working dad's not raising their children?

Bizarre comment....

Dacadactyl · 19/01/2023 21:56

Blueeyedgirl21 · 19/01/2023 21:55

This thread reminds me of my brother and SIL who on a joint income of about £160,000 in the north, claimed that they were once too skint to contribute £40 to an anniversary gift for our parents🤣

No offence cos i know its your brother, but OMG what a pair of tightarses!

I'm mortified for them

Blueeyedgirl21 · 19/01/2023 21:55

This thread reminds me of my brother and SIL who on a joint income of about £160,000 in the north, claimed that they were once too skint to contribute £40 to an anniversary gift for our parents🤣

Blueeyedgirl21 · 19/01/2023 21:52

@whizzielizzie your post seems to imply that if your kids access childcare you’re somehow not raising them? Confused. What is school then?!

Blueeyedgirl21 · 19/01/2023 21:51

We could probs manage with DP earning about £45k as we have a very small mortgage and only one child and would obviously have no childcare costs but I’d probably give my car up so have no car some days when DP had to go into the office and there would be no holidays maybe just camping. to be honest it wouldn’t be the worst but I want to progress in my career as I worked hard for my quals

whizzielizzie · 19/01/2023 21:49

When we decided (before we had children) that I would stay home with our children it was not ever about the money. It was about who we wanted to raise our children - and we both agreed it would be me. My husband worked very hard so that would be possible and was very financially savvy (he was a money mover and saver). By the time our children were both at school we were able to continue on the same route where I was always available for whatever they needed. Throughout my husband’s working life as our sole provider he worked hard and climbed the promotion ladder. We have been able to do all we wanted to do together and with our children. It was definitely a lifestyle choice rather than a financial one.

TwoMagnificentLabradors · 19/01/2023 21:35

@mollynolly

TwoMagnificentLabradors · 19/01/2023 21:34

Nah, I’m the most appalling shirker much of the time, but I’ve been fortunate in finding the right profession and partner. I can think of very many other people who deserve a wife, mother or professional trophy ahead of me.

kc431 · 19/01/2023 21:19

Yes - I’m a bit 🤔 whenever people claim that their husband could not have got anywhere in his career without a SAHwife doing all the housework. TBH it sounds like something people say to make themselves feel better/justify themselves. My parents both worked full-time and both managed to do very well in their careers. I’m sure men are capable of hiring a nanny or cleaner!

VioletaDelValle · 19/01/2023 21:03

I think @4thonthe4th is spot on with the fact that it's ONLY women talk about jobs like somewhere to intereract with others, it's interesting etc. No man I know says he chooses to work to meet other people of feel fulfilled.

Does anyone ever actually ask men why they choose to work though?
Nobody has ever asked my DH his motivations for choosing to work now that he has a family.

I've been asked multiple times!

AbcXyz123456 · 19/01/2023 21:01

@mollynolly why the unnecessary message? @TwoMagnificentLabradors was just sharing her experience and thoughts on the thread. A lot of people have questioned (often in a judgemental way) why someone would not want to be a SAHM even if their financial situation allowed it.

boodlesandpoodles · 19/01/2023 20:48

I earn £120k husband £80k he’d need to be on £250k+ to keep the children in their schools. but I would never not work. I love my job, I took 3years out with my 3rd child and it was a big nope for me being at home, I found I looked at the clock all the time!

mollynolly · 19/01/2023 20:46

TwoMagnificentLabradors · 19/01/2023 19:47

DH could not earn enough money for me to give up my career and become a SAHM. I absolutely love my job, and no amount of voluntary work, homemaking or relaxation could make up for the professional fulfilment I’ve enjoyed.

DH is a partner in a magic circle law firm, so is extremely well paid. And guess what? He managed to get there all by his little self without a SAH wife behind the scenes taking care of every last detail of the domestic arrangements. Because contrary to some narratives, successful men can multi-task, care for children and still step up professionally. And now he’s supporting and speaking up for the next generation in his firm who are doing the same. We’ve worked as a team and supported each other in our careers. He really has gone above and beyond to support me, even though my earnings are much less than his. It has been tough at times, and really hectic, and yes, we’ve had loads of paid help. But we enjoy a fantastic work-life balance, a very comfortable financial situation, a happy, equal marriage and we have both enjoyed having a chance to parent our lovely children. I’m so glad I didn’t jump career ship when DH got 500k, 750k or whatever,

What do you want, a trophy?

TwoMagnificentLabradors · 19/01/2023 19:47

DH could not earn enough money for me to give up my career and become a SAHM. I absolutely love my job, and no amount of voluntary work, homemaking or relaxation could make up for the professional fulfilment I’ve enjoyed.

DH is a partner in a magic circle law firm, so is extremely well paid. And guess what? He managed to get there all by his little self without a SAH wife behind the scenes taking care of every last detail of the domestic arrangements. Because contrary to some narratives, successful men can multi-task, care for children and still step up professionally. And now he’s supporting and speaking up for the next generation in his firm who are doing the same. We’ve worked as a team and supported each other in our careers. He really has gone above and beyond to support me, even though my earnings are much less than his. It has been tough at times, and really hectic, and yes, we’ve had loads of paid help. But we enjoy a fantastic work-life balance, a very comfortable financial situation, a happy, equal marriage and we have both enjoyed having a chance to parent our lovely children. I’m so glad I didn’t jump career ship when DH got 500k, 750k or whatever,

CalpolDependant · 19/01/2023 19:42

This thread is really interesting. Thanks to OP!

I would put my figure ludicrously high. Higher than we need to live on. So high that money would need to lose all meaning for me. 😂

I feel odd when I’m not earning and working outside the home. It’s just something hard wired into me. I have no judgement for women that are SAHPs. In a way, I envy them but also I know it’s not for me.

celticprincess · 19/01/2023 19:41

See, I’m a single parent so can’t be a stay at home mum. However I do only earn £14.5-15k with additional top up from CWTC. We manage. One of my children also gets DalA which also enhances my tax credit for her. We don’t have holidays though. They do activities but DLA money pays for one child’s a a grand parent pays for the other child to do one activity. We don’t get free school meals so one takes packed lunch 3 days and gets 2 school dinners and the DLA allows that child to have school meals 4 times a week with a packed lunch one day. We don’t have spare cash. I don’t save really. I put away £25 each month onto each of the kids savings accounts that I then withdraw when they need shoes/uniform etc. I also have wrap around to pay for one child. The other is too old for wrap around. Luckily only 2 days a week though as that’s all I work. It’s not worth me working 3-4 days as I’d only lose the TCs and gain stress of work and the cost of travel and wrap around and kids wouldn’t get to their activities. I could work 5 days and be better off but totally knackered.

LongStoryShorty · 19/01/2023 19:41

My husband earns 165k and I was a SAHM for years. Now I’m back to work and I’m enjoying the extra money as we can go away more easily and save more money. We have 2 little ones.

AmberMcAmber · 19/01/2023 19:30

Legrandetraitor · 18/01/2023 17:44

It’s possible to sign a post nup etc to ensure this doesn’t happen.

I’m a SAHM and DH earns 500k. Salary requirement depends on whether you do private/state school and holidays etc. those are the large ticket items that move the goalpost IMO.

I’d like to have your DH job lol or my DH could have a go! Currently we both work our arses off for £35k each

threatmatrix · 19/01/2023 19:20

Your doing amazing especially as all the nurses earning that are using food banks. If they are to be believed. Is their anything you can claim ?

Islandgirl68 · 19/01/2023 19:07

I was a SAHP and money was tight, but we still did things in school holidays, just find free and cheap. I think there will be a lot of non working parents at the school gate where money is tight. The catch 22, childcare too expensive, one salary not quite enough. Just have to look at outgoings and see where you can be more frugal. Kids now teenagers and glad I did, it jusrlt seems to have passed so quickly. Or get a wee weekend job or a couple evening a week. Sell outgrown toys etc on ebay and supplement your income that way. Good luck.

mandlerparr · 19/01/2023 18:53

Not every family chooses to have a SAHP because they are rolling in money. We literally had more disposable income after I quit working and stayed home. It saved us so much money. Of course, we have special circumstances with one of our children that makes our childcare expenses way higher than others.
So, for some families it costs them more money to have both parents working. For others, it doesn't.

SleepingStandingUp · 19/01/2023 18:50

ProseccoOnSafari · 19/01/2023 18:24

THIS is the only comment needed on this thread!

Why? Because we all have to agree with you and us stupid little SAHMs are too thick for a valid opinion of our own?

Happysinglemum72 · 19/01/2023 18:50

From experience I would say to any new mum not to be a SAHM. I did, I loved every minute of it. Went back to work when youngest went to school … just 15 hours… was earning no where near what I was before children… marriage broke down… Gone from being very well off to only just making ends meet. Ex works the system so pays no maintenance but holidays 3/4 times a year. Obviously upped my hours but still earning less than I was 15 years ago. No pension to speak of either…. Totally fucked! But happy

GarlandsinGreece · 19/01/2023 18:31

ProseccoOnSafari · 19/01/2023 18:24

THIS is the only comment needed on this thread!

On the flip side, I have several divorced friends. Maybe it’s because the laws are wildly different in our US state, but each receives generous child support payments, alimony, equal share of property, and two women—because the marriages were so long—are entitled to a chunk of private pension payouts.