Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For me to be a SAHM my DH would have to earn.....

515 replies

CPHB2021 · 18/01/2023 17:32

Following on from a thread of 'if you knew all would be ok, I would...' and a resounding about said 'leave work and be a SAHP' I would absolutely LOVE to do this and by scraping the barrel, we probably could but we'd have little to no disposable income. I would only leave if I was able to still take my children to do things, meet friends for coffee etc. Go abroad once a year still. Have some money in savings. I often wonder HOW some of the mums at school don't work, we are technically 'above average' income which seem LUDICROUS given that we use almost all of it, every month! We live in the SE and I think our outgoings must be quite high! How much would one person have to earn for you to leave work?

OP posts:
VioletaDelValle · 20/01/2023 12:15

I still don't understand what is sad about being lucky enough to have a job that contributes positively to your quality of life? Why is it sad to have a job that provides social interaction and that builds your self esteem?

toffeecocomars · 20/01/2023 12:02

Wow, Mumsnet, I never thought there would be so much bitterness and negativity over being a SAHP. I am a SAHM and enjoy it as much as I can, I love being with my young children although at times can be difficult, there's no doubting that. For us, childcare for 3 under 3 wasn't feasible.

4thonthe4th · 20/01/2023 11:55

Flipthefrugal · 20/01/2023 09:17

Do you think your DH is sad then?
Thought not, just women who make a different decision to you.
Nothing on this earth would make meconsider being a SAHM, I had time at home with my DC when little,as had 3 ML close together and really enjoyed it but I also love my job, enjoy the challenges and helping people- Midwife.
Oh and I get paid to do it !Grin

Theres nothing sad about it at all.
Have a think why you need to call other women sad.

I think you need to re-read what I said. I didn’t call women said; what a bizarre misinterpretation. I said it’s sad when women say things like they work for the socialisation and for their self esteem.
No, my husband isn’t sad because he doesn’t need a job to have self esteem. Nor does he need it to have a social life.
Women who make a different decision to me aren’t sad either. As I said; read my post properly, I didn’t actually call anybody sad. I said I think it is sad (a feeling, not a person) that people need a job to have self esteem and a social life.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/01/2023 11:13

JessTD · 20/01/2023 07:15

I’ve just gone back to work full time (DD2 is 11 months, DD1 is 3) because we cannot afford to live on one income (combined household is about £100k) with a large mortgage and double nursery. We struggle. I think the salaries mentioned here are completely made up. I work in the city for an investment bank and even there it’s not common for £200k plus from one earner. Crazy.

Missing the point but why would you live in one salary with a mortgage and double childcare? Surely the reason lots of people don't work is because they can't afford the double childcare on two salaries?
Anyway, you don't need to justify returning to work, I don't mean it like that but confused if you didn't want to go back

SleepingStandingUp · 20/01/2023 11:09

chopc · 20/01/2023 09:37

What is the female version of a cockloger? That's what you essentially want to be

I don't understand women who don't have careers so that it is worthwhile absorbing the costs of childcare for a while.

Tiny kids don't care who is at home with them as long as they are looked after

As they get older there is value in being able to work around when they are at school so you can facilitate extracurricular activities and help with homework . If you focused on your career up to this time maybe you will have the flexibility to do this as you may have advanced in your career

But mostly - the SAHM stint enables you to not work . If you have a healthy child , bring a SAHM is not hard. Try working and doing all the jobs at home - that's hard

Oh and please don't cry when your spouse leaves you and you are a SAHP and have made yourself vulnerable

Well aren't you a treat 😂

Your kids do care a whether you're around or not. It's OK that sometimes you can't be, that days at nursery are long. We do what we have to do but if a 1 yo could make a choice, they'd choose a parent.

Being a cocklodger doesn't involve looking after preschool kids full time, and keeping the house clean, doing the cooking etc. It might not be hard, but you don't understand what a cocklodger is if you think they're all running the house and looking after the kids.

Finally your lack of empathy for others suggests someone who's quite bitter, possibly angry, lonely etc. I hope you manage to find a happiness that isn't predicated on viewing other people are inferior to you.

xogossipgirlxo · 20/01/2023 10:09

Everydayitsgettingcloser · 19/01/2023 17:04

Our household income isn't as high as 300-500k but I suspect it boils down to: nice house in nice area (for a 4 bed in a nice area of London, could easily be 5k a month on mortgage alone), private school fees (30k a year per child), holidays, extras like cleaner/nanny/babysitter/gardener.

Yes, you're probably right. It's just when you don't have this sort of money, you really don't know what you could spend them on. Once you have them, you know I guess, because you're used to seeing certain amounts in your bank account and they don't shock you like they would shock me😅

Suprima · 20/01/2023 10:06

chopc · 20/01/2023 09:37

What is the female version of a cockloger? That's what you essentially want to be

I don't understand women who don't have careers so that it is worthwhile absorbing the costs of childcare for a while.

Tiny kids don't care who is at home with them as long as they are looked after

As they get older there is value in being able to work around when they are at school so you can facilitate extracurricular activities and help with homework . If you focused on your career up to this time maybe you will have the flexibility to do this as you may have advanced in your career

But mostly - the SAHM stint enables you to not work . If you have a healthy child , bring a SAHM is not hard. Try working and doing all the jobs at home - that's hard

Oh and please don't cry when your spouse leaves you and you are a SAHP and have made yourself vulnerable

wouldn’t like to live in your head, sounds like a pretty fucking horrible place

unfortunately a lot of the vitriol I have received as someone who wants to SAH with my children when they are small tends to be nastiness along this vein

it’s like they want my husband to treat me like a slave and leave me, they are trying to will it into action.

funny thing is- I have a great marriage, no money worries, a fabulous education and solid vocation that I can walk back into any time I want, a husband that values unpaid labour and pulls
his weight and more, plenty of time for study and hobbies. complete financial oversight- we’re a team. oh, and i can do all of the trite ‘lady of leisure’ stuff that I want

i absolutely wouldn’t want to be a SAHM if certain conditions weren’t met, and I understand if you are unmarried or in a career that demands contemporary knowledge - it certainly isn’t advisable.

but for us who have legal protection, agency, enduring careers….you’ve gotta wonder why they are so mad 😂😂😂

Ihatepcos · 20/01/2023 09:39

Tiny kids don't care who is at home with them as long as they are looked after

What a dreadful thing to say.

chopc · 20/01/2023 09:37

What is the female version of a cockloger? That's what you essentially want to be

I don't understand women who don't have careers so that it is worthwhile absorbing the costs of childcare for a while.

Tiny kids don't care who is at home with them as long as they are looked after

As they get older there is value in being able to work around when they are at school so you can facilitate extracurricular activities and help with homework . If you focused on your career up to this time maybe you will have the flexibility to do this as you may have advanced in your career

But mostly - the SAHM stint enables you to not work . If you have a healthy child , bring a SAHM is not hard. Try working and doing all the jobs at home - that's hard

Oh and please don't cry when your spouse leaves you and you are a SAHP and have made yourself vulnerable

FortSalem86 · 20/01/2023 09:36

Ihatepcos · 20/01/2023 08:58

Is that supposed to be offensive? Yes I am unemployed, by choice.
I don't know what he earns because I don't ask him, if I did he would tell me.
No I don't, I don't need a pension.
So many people on here are just ignorant about other ways of life, it's shocking.

Why don't you need a pension?

Flipthefrugal · 20/01/2023 09:26

girlswillbegirls · 19/01/2023 18:22

I think @4thonthe4th is spot on with the fact that it's ONLY women talk about jobs like somewhere to intereract with others, it's interesting etc. No man I know says he chooses to work to meet other people of feel fulfilled.
The main thing for working is independence. Women don't seem to value financial independence and that's the sad reality. When SAHMs say it's "our" money etc. they deny life changes in 0.5 seconds. It happens to many women around them but the choose to ignore that.

The fact that the question of the OP is how much money your husband needs to make for you to give up all your independence says it all.

Probably because women are constantly asked to justify their choices in a way men aren't.

LongStoryShorty · 20/01/2023 09:18

i was a SAHM and have now gone back to work, we were used to living on DH salary and that means that now saving my salary is much easier.

A lot of people are very negative about stopping work for a few years and they say it will be difficult to go back to work. I think there’s always possibilities to return to work, although of course in certain careers it’s harder. My friend is a doctor and spends all her income in childcare, she had a few years off and says she’s had to accept a job with a very small salary so it fits with being able to pick children up etc.

i’d say there’s the benefit that no matter what DH earns, you get used to living/ adjust your finances to that salary so that then if you go back it’s just bonus money which then makes a difference as it’s not money your counting on to pay the essential bills. Whatever people earn, they find a way to live up to their means (as someone stated earlier, bigger house, private school, personal trainer…)

Flipthefrugal · 20/01/2023 09:17

4thonthe4th · 19/01/2023 07:31

I always find it really sad that many woman say things like this; social aspect, being busy and having a life outside the home.

It must be a very empty life when you can’t imagine anything to do, have nobody to see or nothing to make you happy without a job.

Do you think your DH is sad then?
Thought not, just women who make a different decision to you.
Nothing on this earth would make meconsider being a SAHM, I had time at home with my DC when little,as had 3 ML close together and really enjoyed it but I also love my job, enjoy the challenges and helping people- Midwife.
Oh and I get paid to do it !Grin

Theres nothing sad about it at all.
Have a think why you need to call other women sad.

Oneortwo2022 · 20/01/2023 09:04

It wouldn’t be so much our income but what assets we had that would dictate whether I would contemplate giving up work.
I love having a mix of work and family life, but I only do three days per week so maybe that helps? I don’t have an impressive career. I’m just a nurse but there are lots of opportunities and I can work pretty much anywhere in my country. I think unless we accumulated assets I would be nervous about spending too much time out of work because I would lose my registration and my earning potential would significantly decrease. I love my OH but I also know things don’t always go to plan and it feels good knowing I have the ability to rely on myself.

Ihatepcos · 20/01/2023 08:58

SpaceMonitor · 19/01/2023 13:21

Exactly this. You’re unemployed.

Also, why don’t you know what your husband earns? That’s odd.

Do you have your own income and do you pay into your own pension? If not, you are in an incredibly precarious position.

Is that supposed to be offensive? Yes I am unemployed, by choice.
I don't know what he earns because I don't ask him, if I did he would tell me.
No I don't, I don't need a pension.
So many people on here are just ignorant about other ways of life, it's shocking.

Ihatepcos · 20/01/2023 08:55

BunchHarman · 19/01/2023 13:43

If it’s the poster I think, who frequently tries to boast talks about being a wife who doesn’t work, she knits and reads and sees friends and things. I think there might be some ADHD or something. It’s all a bit trad-wife sounding I think, including the weird kink.

If you’re not that poster, apologies.

I don't knit and I don't read.
Yes I am a traditional wife because that's my culture. I cook and clean and when I have children I will raise them. My culture isn't a link and that's just offensive to be honest.

UnicorseTime · 20/01/2023 08:03

Dreams of 100k income isn't going to happen!

UnicorseTime · 20/01/2023 08:03

And yet so many on lower jncomes can't afford to continue to work and pay childcare...

To be able to afford to carry on working is a gift in itself.

JessTD · 20/01/2023 07:15

I’ve just gone back to work full time (DD2 is 11 months, DD1 is 3) because we cannot afford to live on one income (combined household is about £100k) with a large mortgage and double nursery. We struggle. I think the salaries mentioned here are completely made up. I work in the city for an investment bank and even there it’s not common for £200k plus from one earner. Crazy.

Honeybee8409 · 20/01/2023 00:33

The only topic that loves to be discussed in a million different ways in this forum.

Stewball01 · 20/01/2023 00:02

I'd have gone mad being a SAHM. I worked, not happily, there's no pleasing me 🙄. I've 2 adult kids, middle age, DS will be 52 on the 28th. I can't believe it. I remember the day he was born. Any case we never earned a lot. Just enough to cover every thing. Then I got divorced and money went through my fingers like water. I ended up with a massive overdraft of roughly £15,000 and had to take loans to cover it. Luckily I worked for a bank so loans were low rates. When I was 58 I was asked by the bank if I'd like to stop work with 300% compensation. Oh yes. I also got dole money as it was as if I'd been fired. I was lectured by my ex and my DS about my spending and my cleaning woman helped curb me. I've no overdraft and don't know what I would do if I had one.
DS would have to come to my aid. He would too. DD wouldn't be able to help financially but I'd get her support. I'm now 78. Not in particularly good health but I'm okay 🙂.

FunctionalSkills · 19/01/2023 22:52

@jackstini Gosh I live in the south and could manage on 150k very easily. Its more than 4 x what we do live on 🤣.

I dont know all my friends ds exact salaries but as a group of teachers, OTs, nurses, police, and mostly p/t working muns.... I very much doubt any of us have that as their household income!

Mumsnet is a whole other world. I should know that by now!

DaveGrohlsMrs · 19/01/2023 22:46

I was a stay at home mum for nearly eight years. Mainly because if I had continued to work, the cost of childcare would have taken all my salary so we wouldn’t have been any better off. Our lifestyle didn’t actually change that much tbh. My husband earns a decent wage, not huge though. But we are in Scotland and have a relatively small mortgage on our 4 bedroom house.

RachelBlue · 19/01/2023 22:25

I'm just about to become a SAHP, due to multiple reasons, but mostly chronic illness making me an unreliable employee, and having two amazing children, who I very sadly don't have the energy for. My husband earns around £30k, and we could get by quite easily on just his wage, but we live in the north west and our mortgage is only around £300 pm. We do get a small amount of Universal Credit. Currently, my PT earnings are not much more than the cost of nursery for my youngest.

We definitely have room to cut back if required.

I had an extended break from work previously, due to ill health, and my husband was in a lower-paid role, but we only had one child then. We got by quite well.

I do hope that I will be able to return to employment one day, but after a lot of soul searching, I do feel this is best for us in our current situation.

jackstini · 19/01/2023 22:16

I earn over £150k to enable my dh to be a SAHD and us to keep lifestyle of a few holidays and meals out

Honestly don't know how most people manage with only one earning

Bloody good job we live in the midlands and not south!