Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For me to be a SAHM my DH would have to earn.....

515 replies

CPHB2021 · 18/01/2023 17:32

Following on from a thread of 'if you knew all would be ok, I would...' and a resounding about said 'leave work and be a SAHP' I would absolutely LOVE to do this and by scraping the barrel, we probably could but we'd have little to no disposable income. I would only leave if I was able to still take my children to do things, meet friends for coffee etc. Go abroad once a year still. Have some money in savings. I often wonder HOW some of the mums at school don't work, we are technically 'above average' income which seem LUDICROUS given that we use almost all of it, every month! We live in the SE and I think our outgoings must be quite high! How much would one person have to earn for you to leave work?

OP posts:
VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 09:44

but would your husband be ok with no holidays and no treats? So he’s just working and no nice things from it? I wouldn’t like that

Excellent point.

This really emphasises the point that it needs to be a joint decision with everyone fully on board.

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/01/2023 09:06

Legrandetraitor · 21/01/2023 05:34

Actually your post has made me think. I love being a SAHM and my mother was a SAHM even though after my parents divorced she struggled financially. Tbh there are many personal sacrifices I would be willing to make to stay a SAHM so I could make do with a lot less than we currently have. I would be fine with no holidays and no shopping/a smaller house etc.

@Legrandetraitor

but would your husband be ok with no holidays and no treats? So he’s just working and no nice things from it? I wouldn’t like that

Legrandetraitor · 21/01/2023 05:34

2023bebetter · 20/01/2023 20:14

@CPHB2021

I don't really understand what you mean? I was a sahm and we didn't go abroad for several Years because we were hit by the financial crisis and people loosing jobs everywhere.
We lived accordingly eg no hairdressers, nail's, holdidays abroad.
I used to be really into beautiful clothes and my hair when younger but I didn't care anymore when I had DD.
I went to toddler groups and uses Tesco point's for days out ( we went to so many amazing places through Tesco )

One car... chairty shops.

I work now and DH earns far more! About 20 grand more! We go abroad, not long haul but the DC are now old enough to know they go abroad,they also see mummy working, occasionally I go to a hairdresser? I buy clothes but not like in my youth.

I feel we have the normal stuff, we definitely struggled when I was a sahm but it went by in a flash and I didn't care about holdidays or hair when we had the sheer joy ( and hard times) with really small DC.

Actually your post has made me think. I love being a SAHM and my mother was a SAHM even though after my parents divorced she struggled financially. Tbh there are many personal sacrifices I would be willing to make to stay a SAHM so I could make do with a lot less than we currently have. I would be fine with no holidays and no shopping/a smaller house etc.

2023bebetter · 20/01/2023 20:21

I must say I didn't worry about loosing my husband at that time at all.

I was in a stable relationship,yes unfortunately many women have DC with the wrong man in awful circumstances but some of us don't.

It went by in a flash and it was worth it.
I can work till the day I am unfit too ...what's a few year's out?

I appreciate the caveat for really worried women but I also don't like the sheer panicking and worrying people over a few years out.

People deal with huge life changes far greater than 4 year's not paying into a pension!

2023bebetter · 20/01/2023 20:14

@CPHB2021

I don't really understand what you mean? I was a sahm and we didn't go abroad for several Years because we were hit by the financial crisis and people loosing jobs everywhere.
We lived accordingly eg no hairdressers, nail's, holdidays abroad.
I used to be really into beautiful clothes and my hair when younger but I didn't care anymore when I had DD.
I went to toddler groups and uses Tesco point's for days out ( we went to so many amazing places through Tesco )

One car... chairty shops.

I work now and DH earns far more! About 20 grand more! We go abroad, not long haul but the DC are now old enough to know they go abroad,they also see mummy working, occasionally I go to a hairdresser? I buy clothes but not like in my youth.

I feel we have the normal stuff, we definitely struggled when I was a sahm but it went by in a flash and I didn't care about holdidays or hair when we had the sheer joy ( and hard times) with really small DC.

Dacadactyl · 20/01/2023 20:04

mandlerparr · 20/01/2023 18:59

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Things that don't and do apply to working mothers. They are not all single. They don't neglect their kids. They are not all liberal or progressive. They are not all rich, they are not all poor. They don't all have lazy partners. They don't all have equally sharing in the load partners. They don't all choose to work as many hours as they currently do. They do worry about saving and what will happen if they lose their partner unless they are already single. And they still worry if the partner is still involved. They should make plans for a loss of partner if they have one. Not all working moms choose to be working moms.
Things that don't and do apply to SAHM. They are not all rich living off of somebody. They are not all conservatives. They don't all spend every waking moment with their kids. They aren't all making zero money (I actually put these with working mothers, but a lot don't, so here we are). They aren't all poor living off charity. They are not all sucking the life from their partners who are working. They do worry about saving and what will happen if they lose their partner unless they are already single. And they still worry if the partner is still involved. They should make plans for a loss of partner if they have one. Not all SAHM want to be SAHM.
Most mothers will go through periods where they are working, staying at home, a combo of both, working from home, possibly a single mother, possibly with a partner that contributes but is not around a lot because of work. Or with a partner who contributes money but doesn't contribute much of anything else.
No matter what type of mother you are, you should have savings and retirement separate from your partner. You should have life insurance. Yes, even if you are a SAHM. None should have to put up with abuse and bull from their partner.

This is the best post on the whole thread.

SecondhandTable · 20/01/2023 20:03

I could have been a SAHM now because my earnings are basically the same as the childcare costs for our two kids. DH earns £40k. We live a fairly frugal lifestyle but it wouldn't be much worse if I quit work given there wouldn't be much of a financial drop.

I didn't want to be though and was also concerned about my security for the future if I gave up work for a few years, about how difficult it might be to get back in, given I don't have a proper career. We've made the decision instead that DH is going to go down to 4 days imminently so we can bring down our childcare costs but also so he can spend more time with them, which he's wanted to do ever since we had our first really, but we couldn't before for various reasons.

girlswillbegirls · 20/01/2023 19:57

SleepingStandingUp · 20/01/2023 19:29

Why is always women taking in account their net salary to decide to ditchcarrereer, instead of thinking childcare is being paid by both partners (and not by her salary)?

Because society still thinks childcare is women's work.

Actually I think people just take it too literally.

If I earn 12k and DH 24K and childcare is 13k then it's a statement of face that the childcare is higher than my wage. As the lower paid person it makes sense I'd be giving up my job, so it's my salary that counts.

Regardless of how it's paid, our household income is now 23k after childcare. Maybe we keep our own finances and I pay £6.5k or shared and we spend £13k, the point is out overall family income is 23k, 1k less than if I didn't work

@SleepingStandingUp Thanks for your comment.
Following the same example, if you think you are using 6.5k and your DH 6.5K on childcare, you are still earning 5.5k. As a family unit you are less well off 1K, but the main thing is to know its temporary and its an investment in the future. You are keeping your skills and learn new ones even in a low paid role, and also have an updated CV. In a very few years you won't be earning 12K, you will be promoted and perhaps will be doubling that amount easily. If you ditch a job all those years at home will make you start from scratch and compete again with many recent graduates for an entry level jobs.
After a few years you won't have to pay for childcare as your child will be at school. As a family you will be better off and you are finantially safer for whatever happens in the meantime.

Recommended read: Lean In, from Sheryl Sandberg

GarlandsinGreece · 20/01/2023 19:48

mollynolly · 20/01/2023 17:05

Sometimes life wangs something unexpected at you and you can't work anymore. In our case it was a DC with multiple disabilities. DH's job is much more lucrative than my old job. Should I have clung on, somehow, to working in education? No. It would never have worked.

Amen. I fought the good fight for many years with part-time work. And then chronic illness came along, then Lyme, then Covid complications. I’m much more stable than I was, but 9-5 is completely out of the question. I do still sometimes freelance, but would rather focus my energy on my children and family, and doing whatever I can to keep my health stable. Fortunately, DH earns way into seven figures, so we are more than okay with this arrangement.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/01/2023 19:29

Why is always women taking in account their net salary to decide to ditchcarrereer, instead of thinking childcare is being paid by both partners (and not by her salary)?

Because society still thinks childcare is women's work.

Actually I think people just take it too literally.

If I earn 12k and DH 24K and childcare is 13k then it's a statement of face that the childcare is higher than my wage. As the lower paid person it makes sense I'd be giving up my job, so it's my salary that counts.

Regardless of how it's paid, our household income is now 23k after childcare. Maybe we keep our own finances and I pay £6.5k or shared and we spend £13k, the point is out overall family income is 23k, 1k less than if I didn't work

SpaceMonitor · 20/01/2023 19:26

Ihatepcos · 20/01/2023 08:58

Is that supposed to be offensive? Yes I am unemployed, by choice.
I don't know what he earns because I don't ask him, if I did he would tell me.
No I don't, I don't need a pension.
So many people on here are just ignorant about other ways of life, it's shocking.

Not ignorant, just realistic.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/01/2023 19:24

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/01/2023 17:30

Those that were stay at home mums who didn’t work out of the house and that meant having to cut back on all luxuries etc…

hats off to you!

But how did you get by?!

I would be proper miserable if I couldn’t treat myself to nice holidays, nice make up, clothes and meals out. I mean this stuff makes life nice!

And no, being there for my kids 24:7 wouldn’t compensate for that lack.

how did you manage?

I would be proper miserable if I couldn’t treat myself to nice holidays, nice make up, clothes and meals out. I mean this stuff makes life nice! because people have different interests? I don't wear make up. Never have. Having thousands in the bank wouldn't change that. And I can look suitable and presentable for a job without make up, I worked before kids. I like nice clothes but my style is long dresses and jeans over labels and fancy frocks. I have zero ability to appreciate what makes a dress worth 5k unless it's literally covered in gold and diamonds!! Can't fly in holiday as DS isn't medically able to and I have like -10 desire to drive hours across the continent with three kids, thanks. You might rather sell your kids than holiday in Wales on the beach and the pier but it works for us
We do still have money for stuff we like, but it's not the stuff on your list so presumably doesn't count as worthy of your perfect life.

mandlerparr · 20/01/2023 18:59

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Things that don't and do apply to working mothers. They are not all single. They don't neglect their kids. They are not all liberal or progressive. They are not all rich, they are not all poor. They don't all have lazy partners. They don't all have equally sharing in the load partners. They don't all choose to work as many hours as they currently do. They do worry about saving and what will happen if they lose their partner unless they are already single. And they still worry if the partner is still involved. They should make plans for a loss of partner if they have one. Not all working moms choose to be working moms.
Things that don't and do apply to SAHM. They are not all rich living off of somebody. They are not all conservatives. They don't all spend every waking moment with their kids. They aren't all making zero money (I actually put these with working mothers, but a lot don't, so here we are). They aren't all poor living off charity. They are not all sucking the life from their partners who are working. They do worry about saving and what will happen if they lose their partner unless they are already single. And they still worry if the partner is still involved. They should make plans for a loss of partner if they have one. Not all SAHM want to be SAHM.
Most mothers will go through periods where they are working, staying at home, a combo of both, working from home, possibly a single mother, possibly with a partner that contributes but is not around a lot because of work. Or with a partner who contributes money but doesn't contribute much of anything else.
No matter what type of mother you are, you should have savings and retirement separate from your partner. You should have life insurance. Yes, even if you are a SAHM. None should have to put up with abuse and bull from their partner.

Dacadactyl · 20/01/2023 18:18

@LuckySantangelo35 yes that is true.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/01/2023 18:15

Dacadactyl · 20/01/2023 18:05

@LuckySantangelo35 in any other situation I'm fairly confident she wouldn't have e.g. if we'd been married and "sorted" beforehand. But she did it because she knew we had nothing and obviously she was a good bit younger then cos DD is now 16.

@Dacadactyl

that’s great!
@
I think there would be lots who would be unwilling or unable to provide such a high level of childcare e.g because they had to go to work themselves

Dacadactyl · 20/01/2023 18:05

@LuckySantangelo35 in any other situation I'm fairly confident she wouldn't have e.g. if we'd been married and "sorted" beforehand. But she did it because she knew we had nothing and obviously she was a good bit younger then cos DD is now 16.

Everydayitsgettingcloser · 20/01/2023 18:04

I'm not fussed about luxuries - I don't work for that reason. I really really enjoy my one day off with the kids and I enjoy the weekends too but when I look after the kids for long stretches - e.g. I did 3 weeks over the summer holidays - they drive me mad. I hate it! It's exhausting and boring at the same time. I feel like my kids are happier with a mix of being with us (my DH also works four days) and childcare too

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/01/2023 18:03

UnicorseTime · 20/01/2023 18:01

I truly preferred being home when my kids get in from school/being around in the preschool years to nice makeup/clothes/stuff. It really isn't as important to me!

If we had more income I'm still more likely to spend it on kids/family activities than "stuff" for me. Those kind of "treats" aren't what does it for me!

I have a low paying part time job but it makes a huge difference in people's lives. That kind of thing does it for me. Of course more money would be great though!

@UnicorseTime

of course! Some people aren’t bothered about that kind of thing! But some of us are. Everyone should be able to spend some of their money on them self whether it’s makeup or diamond painting or boxing that they’re into!

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/01/2023 18:01

Dacadactyl · 20/01/2023 17:37

@LuckySantangelo35 I was 21 when I had my first child straight out of uni so I had a job for first 15 months of her life to earn some money (cos we had nothing to our names). My mum looked after her til we raised a house deposit and then I gave up work for ages afterwards.

I never had a "standard of living" to maintain etc and when we got a mortgage when DD was 3, it was based only on one salary and then i was focused on overpaying it so we could move. Everything else paled into insignificance because I knew I wasn't where I'd wanted to be financially when I had her.

So make up, holidays etc were the sacrifice. But I just had a deep feeling that i didnt want anyone else but me to look after her. Same thing with our 2nd child. I didn't think anyone else would do it like I would.

@Dacadactyl

thanks for replying to my post! 😊

you were super lucky your mum looked after your daughter all that time (lots of mums wouldn’t)

UnicorseTime · 20/01/2023 18:01

I truly preferred being home when my kids get in from school/being around in the preschool years to nice makeup/clothes/stuff. It really isn't as important to me!

If we had more income I'm still more likely to spend it on kids/family activities than "stuff" for me. Those kind of "treats" aren't what does it for me!

I have a low paying part time job but it makes a huge difference in people's lives. That kind of thing does it for me. Of course more money would be great though!

Dacadactyl · 20/01/2023 17:37

@LuckySantangelo35 I was 21 when I had my first child straight out of uni so I had a job for first 15 months of her life to earn some money (cos we had nothing to our names). My mum looked after her til we raised a house deposit and then I gave up work for ages afterwards.

I never had a "standard of living" to maintain etc and when we got a mortgage when DD was 3, it was based only on one salary and then i was focused on overpaying it so we could move. Everything else paled into insignificance because I knew I wasn't where I'd wanted to be financially when I had her.

So make up, holidays etc were the sacrifice. But I just had a deep feeling that i didnt want anyone else but me to look after her. Same thing with our 2nd child. I didn't think anyone else would do it like I would.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/01/2023 17:30

Those that were stay at home mums who didn’t work out of the house and that meant having to cut back on all luxuries etc…

hats off to you!

But how did you get by?!

I would be proper miserable if I couldn’t treat myself to nice holidays, nice make up, clothes and meals out. I mean this stuff makes life nice!

And no, being there for my kids 24:7 wouldn’t compensate for that lack.

how did you manage?

chopc · 20/01/2023 17:26

@xogossipgirlxo I am sorry the truth hurt you so much.
I don't hate anyone who chose to live life a different way but just pointing out it is not for the sole benefit of the kids as so many claim

Maybe you are right about the sole earners - I don't know many but the ones I do know think of their wife as "the little woman" whether they express it in those terms or not.

But hey happy to agree to disagree . Unless I have hit a nerve I don't see any other reason for such inflammatory responses 🤔

mollynolly · 20/01/2023 17:05

Sometimes life wangs something unexpected at you and you can't work anymore. In our case it was a DC with multiple disabilities. DH's job is much more lucrative than my old job. Should I have clung on, somehow, to working in education? No. It would never have worked.

redskydelight · 20/01/2023 16:47

Let's imagine a secondary school teacher giving this career advice.." Look if you are a male, look for a line of work where you will be able to support yourself, a family and perhaps a lifestyle; but if you are female, either don't bother to have a third level education and rather look for someone to support you or try to look for a job for enjoyment, to meet people but don't worry about how much it pays". Would anyone bring their kids to that school?

An awful lot of people (including women) agree with that advise. A quick perusal of MN reveals many women who want to be SAHMs and are frustrated that their DP/DH's salary does not allow it.

Of course girls are more likely to find a rich husband at university, so it probably is worth bothering with higher education.