Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For me to be a SAHM my DH would have to earn.....

515 replies

CPHB2021 · 18/01/2023 17:32

Following on from a thread of 'if you knew all would be ok, I would...' and a resounding about said 'leave work and be a SAHP' I would absolutely LOVE to do this and by scraping the barrel, we probably could but we'd have little to no disposable income. I would only leave if I was able to still take my children to do things, meet friends for coffee etc. Go abroad once a year still. Have some money in savings. I often wonder HOW some of the mums at school don't work, we are technically 'above average' income which seem LUDICROUS given that we use almost all of it, every month! We live in the SE and I think our outgoings must be quite high! How much would one person have to earn for you to leave work?

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 18:36

@Flipthefrugal fair enough. I suppose it's a question of what you consider to be a child suffering.

I personally feel like a young child suffers without his/her parents for a long period of time. My husband felt the same. Not everyone does and for some women they feel they are able to be better parents because they're not doing the parenting 24/7 (my sister for one).

To each his own and all that.

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 18:28

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 18:14

Calm down? I'm perfectly calm, but thanks for worrying though.

My point was that wehad to scrimp, not go away and had no disposable income or treats for my SAH years. But we were prioritising overpaying the mortgage and kids savings because at 21 and 23 as 1st time parents, we weren't in the financial situation we wanted to be in.

You aren't who I'm referring to then so no need for caps and exclamation marks.

If you had enough money to overpay the mortgage and save then you had disposable income.
I'm talking about women who won't WOH even though their children will suffer.
It's selfish.

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 18:14

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 18:05

Nope
I was referring to those who say that they prefer to scrimp , not go away.
Calm down and stop making assumptions.

Calm down? I'm perfectly calm, but thanks for worrying though.

My point was that wehad to scrimp, not go away and had no disposable income or treats for my SAH years. But we were prioritising overpaying the mortgage and kids savings because at 21 and 23 as 1st time parents, we weren't in the financial situation we wanted to be in.

Xenia · 21/01/2023 18:12

I earned 10x my children's father and would not as a matter of principle ever have given up work actually.

Everydayitsgettingcloser · 21/01/2023 18:10

Crumpledstilstkin · 21/01/2023 18:03

I think the sweet spot is probably both getting to a good wage before kids then cutting back to 3 days each. Kids still get a day in childcare to socialise, home load is spread, and you're minimising earning in the higher tax brackets so on the same household income you see more of it. Plus obviously both get time with kids whilst having something else too.

We both do four days and that works well for us - I think only one day in childcare would have made it hard for them to settle and make friends. Three days in childcare has been a nice balance.

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 18:05

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 17:45

@Flipthefrugal you're assuming those who stayed at home can't provide nice things for their kids EVER! My kids have a savings account each which will have nigh on 20k in them by time they're 18 (DD is 16 so not far off now)

I'm PT now too and I'm 37. My kids will be grown by time I'm 44 so will be able to put money aside for retirement as mortgage womt be far off being paid then either.

And how is not going away etc selfish is your husband would prefer you to SAH with rhenkids and you're fully on board with it.

Nope
I was referring to those who say that they prefer to scrimp , not go away.
Calm down and stop making assumptions.

Crumpledstilstkin · 21/01/2023 18:03

I think the sweet spot is probably both getting to a good wage before kids then cutting back to 3 days each. Kids still get a day in childcare to socialise, home load is spread, and you're minimising earning in the higher tax brackets so on the same household income you see more of it. Plus obviously both get time with kids whilst having something else too.

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 17:47

If your husband would prefer you to SAH with the kids

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 17:45

@Flipthefrugal you're assuming those who stayed at home can't provide nice things for their kids EVER! My kids have a savings account each which will have nigh on 20k in them by time they're 18 (DD is 16 so not far off now)

I'm PT now too and I'm 37. My kids will be grown by time I'm 44 so will be able to put money aside for retirement as mortgage womt be far off being paid then either.

And how is not going away etc selfish is your husband would prefer you to SAH with rhenkids and you're fully on board with it.

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 17:37

VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 11:16

Both me and Dh are family oriented..... we also happen to work full time! You can be both.

Precisely.
The elephant in the room is that all these " family oriented " men are so happy to have their wives SAH while they skip off to work.
I'm the other end of parenting and so happy I carried on in my career.
I do appreciate we had more flexibility than most(midwife/IT) that enabled us to share CC, school runs etc
I've just taken my pension at 55 and so am working PT now.
I'm surrounded by women who are very bitter they gave up work and have been shafted pension wise.
They are either divorced or watching their DHs retire at 60 while they plod on until 67 .
Bitter doesn't really cut it.
The question of treats is subjective but I do sometimes think all the never going away, no nice stuff/ cheap food is really selfish.
I come from a culture where great pride is taken in being able to give opportunities to DC such as travel, nice home, good food is the norm.
Not to mention the freedom financial stability brings.

Mushroo · 21/01/2023 16:35

@LookyEre we live in the north west and along the lines of:

Take home £6k (car is paid for via salary sacrifice so comes out before we see the money).
Mortgage: £2k (4 bed semi, about 1500sq feet, small garden).
Bills: £500
Childcare: £1200 (1 child
holidays: £500
day to day spending (including all food, days out, clothes, hairdressers, petrol): £1k
savings: £500 (long term for uni fees etc, emergencies)
misc: £300 (boiler fund, Xmas fund, birthdays, house stuff)

We don’t struggle but we’re not jetting off
on 5 star long haul holidays and eating at Michelin star restaurants every week.

We could move to cheaper area, but frankly, given we have a gross income of £140k, I wouldn’t want to! It’s housing that’s the killer!

To be a SAHM parent I’d need to have no housing costs I think rather than have a particular income.

LookyEre · 21/01/2023 11:47

It obviously depends on your lifestyle but surprised by those who say they couldn't be comfortable on any less than £100k+ 😳 I guess if you live somewhere extremely expensive like London.

I'm very part time at the moment so not quite SAHM but only work 2 days a week. It works out I earn about £16k on those hours. My husband earns about £48k.

We aren't wealthy by any stretch but we are fine, don't have to panic about bills etc. No we couldn't go out tomorrow and buy a sports car or take 5 holidays a year but we both have our own cars, own our house, take a one or two holidays a year, have the money for treats etc.. I'd be laughing if we had an income of over £120k like some insist they need on here!

Reinbek · 21/01/2023 11:34

@UnicorseTime you were just asked a direct question about something you posted, no need to feel you have to defend anything.

VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 11:29

Anyway I've enough of being on the defensive.

This is clearly inflecting how you are interpreting particular comments.

If you're happy with your way of life you've no need to be defensive. People are just having a debate and discussing what works for them.

Hobbitfeet32 · 21/01/2023 11:25

All I asked @UnicorseTime is whether you would consider a working mum family oriented?

VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 11:24

I was just countering the poster who said it was unfair for a working man not to have All The Things.
That's a very unfair interpretation of that comment.

My understanding of that comment was that it was in reference to someone saying they were happy not having treats or any luxuries. The poster just asked if her husband was happy working full time but living with no treats..... it's a fair question.

UnicorseTime · 21/01/2023 11:23

It feels like the only "correct" answer on these threads is to have 2 parents working full time. And criticisms are thrown at those who have chosen differently "is your husband happy with less treats" from further up the thread."

Any explanation or attempt to explain why we made the choice we have gets shot down for not being The One True Way.

Our reasoning was a focus on family over things. So our kids have been picked up by one of us, one of us was home during preschool years and were around in the holidays. That made sense for us. I imagine the equation could be loaded differently if people are in high paying jobs with lots of flexitime and paid help. But realistically most full-time jobs here would mean before and afterschool club for small kids. Very few do that full time in my area.

Anyway I've enough of being on the defensive. Why do people bother asking why people make these choices if they don't want to hear the answer?!

UnicorseTime · 21/01/2023 11:18

In our case for both of us the choice was between tiny house/old car/a holiday abroad being only every few years (some of the things people above are saying it's not fair for men to live without!) and one of us home or both working and more of the "nice things" people talk about.

We dont have "all the things" but we valued more family time over the things. Other people quite clearly make a different choice and "can't live with under 100k" or whatever high numbers the beginning of this thread came up with. And that is fine. I was just countering the poster who said it was unfair for a working man not to have All The Things.

Some people need both people to work - many couples can't afford for both people to work to put some perspective on it. These threads are skewed by high earners.

VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 11:16

Both me and Dh are family oriented..... we also happen to work full time! You can be both.

kc431 · 21/01/2023 11:16

He’s family oriented but chooses to work full time himself, and is happy for you to do all the family raising? So what you really mean is “traditional”.

Hobbitfeet32 · 21/01/2023 11:12

@UnicorseTime interesting that you describe your (presumably working) husband as family oriented. Would you describe a working mum in the same way? My husband and I both work? I consider us both to be family oriented as providing for the family is extremely important. They need food, warmth, a roof over their head, clothing etc. So we both contribute to this vital task.

VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 11:08

If both parties are happy with a simple, frugal life then that great.

We don't work for fancy cars, designer clothes or the latest gadgets. I'm not bothered about any of that.

Our dual income allows us to have a house in our specific preferred area, it means we can afford for DS to engage in his chosen hobbies without worrying about the cost and it allows us to travel (uk and abroad ) which is really important to us. It means we will be able to support DS through university if he chooses to go and with a house deposit.

Not everyone is working for fancy cars and fancy clothes!!

UnicorseTime · 21/01/2023 10:38

My husband would have supported me if I had chosen to work but his mum had stayed home when small and now mine are older and I'm working part time he does often chip in that we did the right thing for the kids being home. He's very family orientated and loves the way we've set up our family and is really greatful for the unpaid work I've done raising the kids at home. Not every man values all the extras over having someone at home with the kids.

I think if we're not too careful we devalue the choice some parents make to have one at home. And it ends up devalued ike most unpaid caring roles- I'm not sure that's a good move either. Women can end up with the worst of both worlds

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/01/2023 10:24

Decafflatteplease · 21/01/2023 10:20

I've been a SAHM for over a decade. Luckily we like a fairly simple, frugal life. We've only ever based our lifestyle on one salary eg mortgage.

One car owner outright,.not fussed about the latest cars on finance etc. In the early days DH got the bus to work before we had a car.

We've never been abroad, holidays are visiting family around the UK.

DC are happy with simple days out eg nature reserve, swimming, walks, national trust.

We aren't into the latest gadgets eg phones just keep it simple.

All clothes bought Preloved, and we have some clothes swaps going with friends.

So yeah a simple life but we are happy!

@Decafflatteplease

which is great!

some people wouldn’t like that way of life. I would struggle especially with the not going abroad bit.

it’s like a previous poster said, if both parties in the relationship are happy and on board that’s the key thing!

Decafflatteplease · 21/01/2023 10:20

SleepingStandingUp · 20/01/2023 19:24

I would be proper miserable if I couldn’t treat myself to nice holidays, nice make up, clothes and meals out. I mean this stuff makes life nice! because people have different interests? I don't wear make up. Never have. Having thousands in the bank wouldn't change that. And I can look suitable and presentable for a job without make up, I worked before kids. I like nice clothes but my style is long dresses and jeans over labels and fancy frocks. I have zero ability to appreciate what makes a dress worth 5k unless it's literally covered in gold and diamonds!! Can't fly in holiday as DS isn't medically able to and I have like -10 desire to drive hours across the continent with three kids, thanks. You might rather sell your kids than holiday in Wales on the beach and the pier but it works for us
We do still have money for stuff we like, but it's not the stuff on your list so presumably doesn't count as worthy of your perfect life.

I've been a SAHM for over a decade. Luckily we like a fairly simple, frugal life. We've only ever based our lifestyle on one salary eg mortgage.

One car owner outright,.not fussed about the latest cars on finance etc. In the early days DH got the bus to work before we had a car.

We've never been abroad, holidays are visiting family around the UK.

DC are happy with simple days out eg nature reserve, swimming, walks, national trust.

We aren't into the latest gadgets eg phones just keep it simple.

All clothes bought Preloved, and we have some clothes swaps going with friends.

So yeah a simple life but we are happy!

Swipe left for the next trending thread