Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For me to be a SAHM my DH would have to earn.....

515 replies

CPHB2021 · 18/01/2023 17:32

Following on from a thread of 'if you knew all would be ok, I would...' and a resounding about said 'leave work and be a SAHP' I would absolutely LOVE to do this and by scraping the barrel, we probably could but we'd have little to no disposable income. I would only leave if I was able to still take my children to do things, meet friends for coffee etc. Go abroad once a year still. Have some money in savings. I often wonder HOW some of the mums at school don't work, we are technically 'above average' income which seem LUDICROUS given that we use almost all of it, every month! We live in the SE and I think our outgoings must be quite high! How much would one person have to earn for you to leave work?

OP posts:
Flipthefrugal · 22/01/2023 09:51

@SleepingStandingUp
The thread title is how much would your DH have to earn for you to be a SAHM.
Having no choice due to multiples or a disabled child ?
I agree that's not a choice.

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 22/01/2023 09:31

Dunno. We could already manage on one salary but we like a nice life and we like to save for a nice retirement.

bagelbagelbagel · 22/01/2023 09:27

Yup, @SleepingStandingUp, I hear ya. Similar situation here. Life turns out very differently if you have a disabled child. Suddenly your world includes multiple clinics, therapists, assessments. You know exactly what the following acronyms stand for: DLA, PIP, CA, LA, EHCP, SALT among many others. Somebody has to be home all day. Somebody has to do the night wakes.

Impossible to know how it will affect you until you actually live it. Some people on this thread live in blissful ignorance. Slightly jealous of that but I won't hold it against them. That was me too, ten years ago. I was on target for promotion. Earning more than DH. Had a list of all the local childcare providers.

While I was on mat leave DH had a very sudden upswing in his earning potential, easy in the creative industry if your name suddenly becomes known by a lot of people. I was burnt out after 9 long months of HG followed by year of parenting a child who clearly had multiple conditions but none with a name yet. Those nurseries I'd carefully researched wouldn't take him. He clearly wasn't able to be away from me anyway, being very bonded to me and reliant on me to meet his needs.

Who stays home? Me. I wanted to. It was the right decision and still is.

My life had a clear trajectory but then it went way off course. That's ok. I'm happy, and much more empathetic.

Xenia · 22/01/2023 08:48

There is quite a problem for the UK at present in too many people working part time including over 50s since the pandemic where we are much worse than EU states are. If the state really wanted more in work of course it could provide free childcare from 1 month old babies but instead it gives just about nothing to mothers who want to preserve a career so they haev to do what we did in the 1980s when my husband and I in the first years each paid 50% of our net salaries for full time childcare the cheapest of which was a full time daily nanny for a baby, toddler and at fiest 3 year old then 4 year old (she was 4 shortly after baby no. 3 arrived). That was then and is today cheaper than 3 full time 8 - 6pm nursery places. It is even worse today costing about £60k to pay a daily nanny in London about £36k because the state forces you to pay the employee pension both employer and employee contributions £8k a year and also as in my day you also have employer, employee NI and tax for the childcare coming out of your own income taxed already. So that is about £30k for each person in the couple. If you look at a good London day nursery for a baby that is about £22k so if you have two babies (we had twins later too) or a baby and toddler that is not much change from £40k (£20k each).

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2023 08:16

Lcb123 · 21/01/2023 23:49

There’s no amount DH could earn for me to consider being SAHM. I need to keep my career, earnings and pension going as you never know what will happen. Can’t comprehend being fully financially dependent on someone else

Well yes, but you never knows what will happen is in the same category. Disabled children, Twins making childcare undo able for a few years, health changes etc. Posters might see me as a workshy loser who's sponging off my DH and setting my kids a poro example, I see I did what I had to do when my baby came our critically ill and wouldn't quit his hospital adduction.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2023 08:13

VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 23:56

The reality is tho, two people working part time with kids in jobs that are "good for the world" are unlikely to be able to afford much without relying on benefits. The good jobs rarely pay decently down the bottom

Not all 'good for the world jobs' pay low wages.

No, but a good majority of them in the early years do. I'm assuming settling down and having babies late 20s / early 30s which is still quite early in a career to both be able to earn say circa 60k pa and be able to do that job part time.
It's the availability of well paid, part time, worthy jobs within the first decade of a career I was questioning.
. And lots of voluntary sector / nursing / caring jobs are not well paid, esp if you're part time

Flipthefrugal · 22/01/2023 07:55

Sorry that was in reply to @Lcb123

Flipthefrugal · 22/01/2023 07:54

I think that's the crux of it for me, I've always WOH , earned my own money and so have all the women in our family.
Our children have been raised by both of us and I view the type of man who wants a SAHW in a poor light I'm afraid.

VioletaDelValle · 21/01/2023 23:56

The reality is tho, two people working part time with kids in jobs that are "good for the world" are unlikely to be able to afford much without relying on benefits. The good jobs rarely pay decently down the bottom

Not all 'good for the world jobs' pay low wages.

Lcb123 · 21/01/2023 23:49

There’s no amount DH could earn for me to consider being SAHM. I need to keep my career, earnings and pension going as you never know what will happen. Can’t comprehend being fully financially dependent on someone else

kc431 · 21/01/2023 23:47

SleepingStandingUp · 21/01/2023 20:12

The reality is tho, two people working part time with kids in jobs that are "good for the world" are unlikely to be able to afford much without relying on benefits. The good jobs rarely pay decently down the bottom

I dunno, mine and DH’s jobs are good for the world I think (private sector but providing a benefit to the world) and we earn 90k between us. We’re still quite young so this will go up. Not all “good” jobs are nursing/teaching/police/care work.

kc431 · 21/01/2023 23:45

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:04

@Flipthefrugal Well he didnt tell me this at the time but I've just asked him and he said "I'd have happily stayed at home with them".

But i would find it very difficult to support a man financially unless he became ill or was made redundant. It would've been a non-starter. It is just not for me and in my mind, it's a man's job to provide for his family. Not a popular opinion, but it is mine.

Jesus christ, I feel like I’ve stepped into a timewarp to the 50s. Everyone’s entitled to their opinions but I find this really sad to read in this day and age, that by virtue of being born with a dick it’s now your job to “provide” 🤦‍♀️

SleepingStandingUp · 21/01/2023 20:12

Thespiantree · 21/01/2023 19:18

I tell my son's that it's nice to aim to work part time in something that does good for the world and society, while leaving time to spend with loved ones and as much time as possible looking after their children as they grow up too fast.
I'd expect any decent school to suggest the same (though I doubt they give directives, really).

The reality is tho, two people working part time with kids in jobs that are "good for the world" are unlikely to be able to afford much without relying on benefits. The good jobs rarely pay decently down the bottom

PousseyNotMoira · 21/01/2023 19:51

DH earns £110K a year and I earn just over £70K. So, I suppose technically either of us could give up work. We quite like our careers, though. And I suppose we’d have to cut back on our outgoings, which I suspect we’d be shit at.

I’m currently pregnant and the plan is to both go down to four days when the baby turns up. We’ll see how we go!

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:19

@Flipthefrugal no worries, like i say we wont all agree on all things. Hope you have a good evening.

Thespiantree · 21/01/2023 19:18

girlswillbegirls · 20/01/2023 13:37

English is not my first language but I totally get what @4thonthe4th is saying.

My own opinion is that it really baffles me that no men is ever asked if he enjoys his job, if he has good social interaction in the office etc, it's universally accepted men go to work to earn money, full stop.
I am constantly asked this question and it really annoys me. Last time I was asked this by my MIL and SIL I said "I primarily work to be financially independent. I have friends and a social life outside work".
My MIL is an advocate for SAHMs even though her own personal experience as a SAHM was really tragic. I don't get it.

Let's imagine a secondary school teacher giving this career advice.." Look if you are a male, look for a line of work where you will be able to support yourself, a family and perhaps a lifestyle; but if you are female, either don't bother to have a third level education and rather look for someone to support you or try to look for a job for enjoyment, to meet people but don't worry about how much it pays". Would anyone bring their kids to that school?

I tell my son's that it's nice to aim to work part time in something that does good for the world and society, while leaving time to spend with loved ones and as much time as possible looking after their children as they grow up too fast.
I'd expect any decent school to suggest the same (though I doubt they give directives, really).

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 19:15

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:12

@Thespiantree yes he would, but I thought that was my job when the kids were small. I wanted the kids to be out and about and I knew he wouldn't have done the day to day routine how I would.

@Flipthefrugal well we are all different arent we and we wont all agree.

We are all different but that type of ghastly expectation of a man is direct from the 1950s.
I do admire your honesty but WTAF that's really shocked me.

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:12

@Thespiantree yes he would, but I thought that was my job when the kids were small. I wanted the kids to be out and about and I knew he wouldn't have done the day to day routine how I would.

@Flipthefrugal well we are all different arent we and we wont all agree.

Thespiantree · 21/01/2023 19:07

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:04

@Flipthefrugal Well he didnt tell me this at the time but I've just asked him and he said "I'd have happily stayed at home with them".

But i would find it very difficult to support a man financially unless he became ill or was made redundant. It would've been a non-starter. It is just not for me and in my mind, it's a man's job to provide for his family. Not a popular opinion, but it is mine.

Presumably he'd be supporting you by looking after the home and children, though.

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 19:06

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:04

@Flipthefrugal Well he didnt tell me this at the time but I've just asked him and he said "I'd have happily stayed at home with them".

But i would find it very difficult to support a man financially unless he became ill or was made redundant. It would've been a non-starter. It is just not for me and in my mind, it's a man's job to provide for his family. Not a popular opinion, but it is mine.

Crikey!
Poor man, I find that absolutely shocking and what a shame for your DC.
Toxic masculinity indeed.

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:04

@Flipthefrugal Well he didnt tell me this at the time but I've just asked him and he said "I'd have happily stayed at home with them".

But i would find it very difficult to support a man financially unless he became ill or was made redundant. It would've been a non-starter. It is just not for me and in my mind, it's a man's job to provide for his family. Not a popular opinion, but it is mine.

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 18:55

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 18:48

@Flipthefrugal for me, I didn't want my husband to do the childcare. He is a different character to me (quieter, less outgoing) and he would've stayed at home doing lots of baking, reading and playing with them. I wanted them out at playgroups, swimming, rhyme times at the library etc. I wouldn't have been happy with them SAH and not socialising as much.

I think it depends on the kind of man you're married to really.

I also think in our specific case, both our mums had stayed at home forever after they had kids. We were both happy in our childhoods, so I suppose you look to recreate that set up, but perhaps unconsciously. I don't necessarily think that's a bad thing, but again, it depends on who you're married to.

Did what he wanted ever come into it?

My DH is quiet man and I personally think DC benefit hugely from daily FT hands on care by both parents.
Sounds like your DC would have had a lovely balance if both had SAH/ WOH.

Hobbitfeet32 · 21/01/2023 18:53

Working does not mean spending long periods of time without your child.
Providing for your child = part of parenting

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 18:48

@Flipthefrugal for me, I didn't want my husband to do the childcare. He is a different character to me (quieter, less outgoing) and he would've stayed at home doing lots of baking, reading and playing with them. I wanted them out at playgroups, swimming, rhyme times at the library etc. I wouldn't have been happy with them SAH and not socialising as much.

I think it depends on the kind of man you're married to really.

I also think in our specific case, both our mums had stayed at home forever after they had kids. We were both happy in our childhoods, so I suppose you look to recreate that set up, but perhaps unconsciously. I don't necessarily think that's a bad thing, but again, it depends on who you're married to.

Flipthefrugal · 21/01/2023 18:41

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 18:36

@Flipthefrugal fair enough. I suppose it's a question of what you consider to be a child suffering.

I personally feel like a young child suffers without his/her parents for a long period of time. My husband felt the same. Not everyone does and for some women they feel they are able to be better parents because they're not doing the parenting 24/7 (my sister for one).

To each his own and all that.

personally feel like a young child suffers without his/her parents for a long period of time.
I think it depends on the age/ demeanour of the child but have no skin in this game as my DC were never in CC or away from us as pre schoolers.

Again why aren't men parenting equally?
Why aren't the ones who want a SAHP doing their share?
Mine did .