Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For me to be a SAHM my DH would have to earn.....

515 replies

CPHB2021 · 18/01/2023 17:32

Following on from a thread of 'if you knew all would be ok, I would...' and a resounding about said 'leave work and be a SAHP' I would absolutely LOVE to do this and by scraping the barrel, we probably could but we'd have little to no disposable income. I would only leave if I was able to still take my children to do things, meet friends for coffee etc. Go abroad once a year still. Have some money in savings. I often wonder HOW some of the mums at school don't work, we are technically 'above average' income which seem LUDICROUS given that we use almost all of it, every month! We live in the SE and I think our outgoings must be quite high! How much would one person have to earn for you to leave work?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
amybobs · 17/04/2023 12:24

We live in the North West, 3 teenage kids, big mortgage. DH earn 50k +commission (15k) I earn around 17k part time and we still struggle. If he earnt 100k I could probably not work but I wouldnt I would go mad. If my kids were younger then I would have definitely considered it

girlswillbegirls · 15/03/2023 10:20

@MooseBreath fair enough. I do feel for you. In my home country in the south of Europe childcare was for many decades heavily subsidised until last year that became free- only condition is to be working both parents or being a single parent. Women certainly have it much much easier.
It's really a no brainer this is so necessary for our society. And specially for women. Women are nearly always the ones ending up taking the risk.
It very unfair you had to make that choice. I didn't have any help from any of our families. I had to stop driving my car and going on holidays. But we did have some room for budgeting and afford not ditching my job, so I did feel annoyed with myself ( not your case at all). It would have made my life easier in the next few years competing with young twenty somethings graduates.
But it is actually possible to go back to where you were, and I am sure you will. Keep your skills through volunteering, anything relevant you can link yo your CV. I wish you all the best.

ArseMenagerie · 15/03/2023 08:59

Yeah, I don’t regret the SAHM years but I’m very happy to be working now they are older. It’s weird now as we don’t need the money but it’s for me.

loopyloutoo · 15/03/2023 08:57

I would always want to work, despite what my husband earns!
For my sanity, independence and for the situations you don't plan for "never rely on a man"

ArseMenagerie · 15/03/2023 08:57

I was a SAHM when DH earned 50k. He now earns much more that and we are comfortable but it was only when he started earning over 70k that a single income household became enjoyable rather than a worry.
However, that’s the payoff. We didn’t have holidays and we didn’t have treats but it was still better for the family for me to be at home because of my job and the cost of childcare. Hopefully things have changed with today’s budget as I wanted to work.
Be careful: my DH seemed to lean into the stay at home dynamic and did feck all around the house. Negotiate the domestic before you quit work is my strong advice.

MooseBreath · 15/03/2023 08:50

@girlswillbegirls In a cost of living crisis, it's not that it looks like we can't afford it right now, it's that we can't afford it right now.

It's not a problem that can be solved with a bit of budgeting. We are budgeting. We rent, so we can't remortgage. We don't have family nearby, so we can't have family help with childcare. We can't relocate for cheaper housing because DH's well-paid industry is here. He has only been out of University and earning for 4 years, so his salary will increase.
I cook everything from scratch and batch cook. All of our children's clothes are second-hand. Our heating is set at 16⁰C and can't go lower because we have an infant. We don't smoke and have given up alcohol (except one bottle of wine per month). No gym membership, no extracurriculars, time with friends is a night in playing board games. We have nothing left over at the end of the month.

I may not be able to predict the future, but I know that in the present, we cannot afford for me to work.

girlswillbegirls · 14/03/2023 23:43

@MooseBreath I can understand where you come from because I made that mistake too. And stayed at home for a few years and was difficult to return to the same industry (and to my shock horror had to go back to an entry level position).
It took me many years to go back to where I was. And it was then when I suddenly understood that taking the hit when babies are small is the best policy for women.

Other friends with very stable marriages at the time, weren't so lucky. One is divorced but still living in the same house with her ex-husband bc she couldn't return to work. Another putting up with a partner (high earner) who happens to be an alcoholic. Another has a husband with a MH issue.
And we all did it for the exact same reason as you said, "I cannot afford it"

It might look as you cannot afford it right now. But it's your pension, your career, a foot in the workplace. It's security. We cannot predict the future.

MooseBreath · 14/03/2023 22:03

girlswillbegirls · 14/03/2023 19:54

Why is always women the ones who "pay" for childcare and not half of it.
Why is always men's earning potential higher?

It's so simple. Because they don't stop working. Because they don't consider themselves as "paying" for childcare. They get experience, seniority, they get promoted, they earn more then.

This should be taught at schools. Women should stay in their jobs, as it is always a step up. And childcare is paid by two people (unless single parents)

When having the mother working a lower paid job means the family is worse off financially, it doesn't matter "who" pays childcare. We cannot afford to take the hit of me working. It is a family budget, not two individuals.

girlswillbegirls · 14/03/2023 19:54

Why is always women the ones who "pay" for childcare and not half of it.
Why is always men's earning potential higher?

It's so simple. Because they don't stop working. Because they don't consider themselves as "paying" for childcare. They get experience, seniority, they get promoted, they earn more then.

This should be taught at schools. Women should stay in their jobs, as it is always a step up. And childcare is paid by two people (unless single parents)

MooseBreath · 13/03/2023 21:43

AbcXyz123456 · 13/03/2023 20:29

@MooseBreath you should be eligible for this if neither of you earn more than £100k:

www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare

Nope. I am an immigrant (have been here nearly 8 years) and have no access to public funds. This means we cannot have tax-free childcare.

AbcXyz123456 · 13/03/2023 20:29

@MooseBreath you should be eligible for this if neither of you earn more than £100k:

www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare

stayathomer · 13/03/2023 12:29

Or you were ‘paying money’ for your husband to work, surely?
it doesn’t really matter- I was earning a lot less than him and it just happened that our childcare came out the day after I got paid so we both just saw it that way- my wage paid for childcare and I was paying 200 euro on top of that for petrol a month

Trespassing · 12/03/2023 21:47

stayathomer · 12/03/2023 14:28

All the stuff you listed went out the window when I became a sahm. Everything. I always laugh at people saying they’d love to be able to afford it but we were paying money for me to work and had no option. You’ll find it’s the family with two earners that are better off

Or you were ‘paying money’ for your husband to work, surely?

stayathomer · 12/03/2023 14:28

All the stuff you listed went out the window when I became a sahm. Everything. I always laugh at people saying they’d love to be able to afford it but we were paying money for me to work and had no option. You’ll find it’s the family with two earners that are better off

MooseBreath · 12/03/2023 14:28

DH makes just over 60k, which means we aren't eligible for any help with nursery fees or child benefit. He is also paying back his student loan on top of all other taxes.

We've worked out that if I went back to work, I would need to earn nearly 30k for our family to have more money than we are currently bringing in (nursery for 2 children without subsidies would be about 2k per month). I am a SAHM because I have to be. DH's earning potential is way bigger than mine.

Zone2NorthLondon · 12/03/2023 14:25

The cut your own hair,no holidays and eat lentils crew, will say one need very little and what price on being a SAHP?
However it is more nuanced and The op question is very open ended & subjective
Essentually it’s about what lifestyle and outgoings does one have and want to maintain without disruption or decrease

Zone2NorthLondon · 12/03/2023 14:21

BlueBellIris · 18/01/2023 17:40

I would never be financially reliant on a DH. I’ve seen too many cases in divorce/illness where women are left in dire straits because they have no income of their own.

Wholeheartedly agree, and I have seen the same. It’s too risky

RedWelliesAreBest · 23/01/2023 18:40

When our children were small, I earned about 20% of the gross family income and we were both permanently frazzled. We dreamed of being me being able to be a SAHM. I was in a job I didn't particularly enjoy and working a lot of weekends too. I was part time but felt like I spent my life running from work to school or vice versa and on my two weekdays off, I crammed in all the housework and jobs and tried to keep up with a voluntary role and some studying I had taken up to try to retrain / keep my skills up to date.

About 5 years ago, with children in year 5 and 6, I got a full time but fairly time flexible job doubling my salary and I felt like I could see the light at the end of the tunnel with the rushing around.

Now, I am earning 3 times my original salary and DH who works from home 75% of the time, has also almost trebled his salary. The children are more self sufficient and we are able to buy convenience much more (cleaner, gardener, have delivered shopping not Aldi, run a (small) second car) and much to my surprise, given that we could easily afford it now, I have no desire to be a SAHM.

I love having an interesting job, earning reasonably well has removed financial pressure from DH and made us more secure as a family and he has taken over lots of the mental load as he is home more. Maybe things would be different if neither of us could work from home (I am home 2-3 days a week most weeks) but now I'd rather work and earn money to pay someone else to clean / decorate etc.

Thesenderofthiscard · 23/01/2023 09:39

DW earns enough for me to be a SAHM and we'd be very comfortable, but it's never occurred to me. I can't imagine being financially dependent on someone unless it was an emergency. I have financial freedom, a decent pension, and long -term, what if something happened that meant she no longer worked, or earned that much?

Islandgirl68 · 23/01/2023 09:35

My experience with getting back to work, was not a issue. I was a SHAM for12 years, did some temping for a few years then went full time a few years ago in my fifties. I know other mums that got back into work no problem, and mum's who worked part time got back up the career ladder again into quite high powered job. If you were a good worker before children you will be a good worker after children. I don't know where the time has gone. It flies by so quickly and don't regret it one bit.

girlswillbegirls · 22/01/2023 21:56

@SleepingStandingUp I wouldn't think any of those things about SAHMs, I actually stopped working for 4 years when my DC were babies.
I had my 3 babies in 4 years. The decision was based on what it's mentioned here by many posters, it was going to be very expensive the childcare costs, and I told myself it was more important to be there for them etc.
As I said in previous posts it was a shortsighted decision. It was really hard to go back to work and to my shock I had to start all over again in a very junior position with recent graduates. Getting paid very little. I am very lucky I was able to get my career om track and earn good money these days but I had to work really hard to get to this point.
I have friends who also stopped working more or less at the same time and and they couldn't return as were seing as too old. And some friends had to stay in shit marriages.

I am personally not into clothes, fancy cars or 5 start hotels but I feel very fortunate to be able to fund my kids with some (expensive) sports they practice and give them opportunities. We have also private health insurance and are able to pay our mortgage quicker. If I am with my husband is because marriage is good. If it wasn't, I wouldn't have to stay, as I am able to support my children and pay the bills by myself. That makes me feel secure.
There are many reasons to keep working both parents. If any of us is ill and needs quiting, it will be a good thing to have our mortgage paid.

Flipthefrugal · 22/01/2023 17:51

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2023 17:23

I know @girlswillbegirls and @Flipthefrugal but my point was just people talk in such absolutes, as if they can control life. "ooh I'd NEVER do that, I have RESPECT for myself and I'd never DEMEAN myself like THAT!". Not sure what thread but someone basically compared SAHMs to cocklodgers, sitting at home spending all a man's money etc.

No-one has said that on this thread though.
It's not helpful to just keep slinging mud at people who so far are having a respectful conversation.
The question was how much and the answer is allowed to be there is no amount.

I've acknowledged that it's different if your life takes an unexpected turn .

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2023 17:23

I know @girlswillbegirls and @Flipthefrugal but my point was just people talk in such absolutes, as if they can control life. "ooh I'd NEVER do that, I have RESPECT for myself and I'd never DEMEAN myself like THAT!". Not sure what thread but someone basically compared SAHMs to cocklodgers, sitting at home spending all a man's money etc.

girlswillbegirls · 22/01/2023 17:16

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2023 08:16

Well yes, but you never knows what will happen is in the same category. Disabled children, Twins making childcare undo able for a few years, health changes etc. Posters might see me as a workshy loser who's sponging off my DH and setting my kids a poro example, I see I did what I had to do when my baby came our critically ill and wouldn't quit his hospital adduction.

@SleepingStandingUp I don't think anyone could argue that in the event of having an ill child/ with disabilities etc the most logical thing to do is for one of the parents to look after him/her full time and give up a job. Very sorry to hear that's your case, fair play to you and all the parents in your position.

I do think the question of the OP is more about what X amount of money earned by your spouse would make worth for a woman to give up a job. To me, it will never make sense to give up a job for whatever amount of money as there is no need to become dependent. But it is a different story if having a child with the needs you are talking about. All the best to you all, fair play.🌹

CurzonAvenue · 22/01/2023 10:14

Dacadactyl · 21/01/2023 19:04

@Flipthefrugal Well he didnt tell me this at the time but I've just asked him and he said "I'd have happily stayed at home with them".

But i would find it very difficult to support a man financially unless he became ill or was made redundant. It would've been a non-starter. It is just not for me and in my mind, it's a man's job to provide for his family. Not a popular opinion, but it is mine.

Wow, WTAF? Poor man! 😱