Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people need to stop over sharing SO MUCH on social media

83 replies

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 10:26

People share wayyyy too much online. Particularly about their kids.

I was just sat having a scroll of Facebook and came across a post this lady made, photos of her daughter (5 or 6 years old) led in a hospital bed. Then there were selfies of herself in the post, with a filter and pouting whilst the daughter is in the background super unwell!!

I went onto her profile and had a nosey and every little bit of information was on there! Which hospital, which ward, what was wrong, etc etc.

Then I realised after having a nosey on other peoples profiles etc, so many parents do it!! And it makes me sad 😩

Albums titled with the child's full name, date of birth, then photos of their children in their school uniform showing the logo and everything.
Then they post exactly where they are and when, whenever they go the gym, supermarket, work, etc, they check in, and tell everybody exactly what they're doing.

And the worst part is half of the stuff on their Facebook is set to 'public' - and then they have tiktok, Instagram, all set to public too.

All I can think is how unsafe this could potentially be for children?
Absolutely anybody could go onto their profiles, find out all the information they need on the children, what school they go to in which town, etc, they can easily get photos of the kids too - know everything about the children's parent's, where the parents are on what days of the week, etc etc.

It just makes me feel uneasy and a bit p*ssed off on behalf of their kids too.

I barely ever post anything on Facebook, all of my social media profiles are set to private anyway, but still, people didn't know I was pregnant until they saw me in person with a massive bump/pushing a pram 🙈 but I feel as though some people take it way too far.

I'd of cringed so much and would have felt so pissed off, if now, as an adult, my mum was on Facebook with photos of me in a hospital bed suffering with sepsis whilst she posed next to me, or if she was sharing memories on Facebook of photos of me sat in the bath, etc, for the whole world to see 🤦‍♀️

Is it just me?? Am I the weird one for being super conscious of what I post online?
I just feel like there's a limit. I understand people sharing their good news, or sharing the odd photos of their children/loved ones, but I just can't understand the need to overshare so much. It's quite sad really

OP posts:
JamSandle · 18/01/2023 11:42

I agree but I think social media sometimes replaces the village we have lost. People want to show their children, share their experiences and possibly want some validating for parenting in a world where it can feel like a vacuum.

WigglyGlowWorm · 18/01/2023 11:39

I know what you mean OP. Also, the ones on TikTok where it’s (normally) a girl saying into the camera ‘OMG, I’ve literally never told anyone this before. I can’t believe I’m about to tell you this guys, it’s the most embarrassing this ever’. You look and she’s got 3 million followers and 250k likes. Well, don’t tell us if it’s that embarrassing 🙈

oakleaffy · 18/01/2023 11:38

QueefQueen80s · 18/01/2023 11:37

I've even seen photos of people at funerals next to coffins and posing selfies at wakes.

That's grotesque.

QueefQueen80s · 18/01/2023 11:37

I've even seen photos of people at funerals next to coffins and posing selfies at wakes.

oakleaffy · 18/01/2023 11:37

DaSilvaP · 18/01/2023 10:46

True:

If you're not paying to use it, you are the product

It's even worse.

Not only you are sold to any advertiser willing to pay, but you make yourself an unwitting guinea pig in experiments in psychological manipulation. If you wander what I'm on about just do a search on "facebook psychological experiments"

Not to forgot how facebook was used for vote manipulation in the Brexit saga.

Absolutely true.
Facebook is awful.
The manipulation around Brexit was dire.

Tons of photos of Migrants hanging off a ship , saying that voting out would reclaim ''Our Borders'', and the ship shown was nothing to do with the English Channel.

Plus the pathetic posts that show a child or puppy with ''I bet I won't get even one ''Like''..
Plus the untrue stories put out as ''Truth''.

Farcebook and Twitter are the pits.

porpy · 18/01/2023 11:36

I had to leave some of those big groups though (the lockdown family one etc) so many attention-seeking posts clearly made for as many likes as possible. Constant stuff like ‘aww my six-year-old son randomly baked all these cakes and took them to the old people home!’ accompanied with a zillion photos. 😂

porpy · 18/01/2023 11:34

adulthumanfemalemum · 18/01/2023 11:19

I don't know who you're looking at but I find the opposite that most of my friends don't post anything, especially not pictures of their kids . It makes me sad because I have friends all over the country and world and would love to see what they're up to and how their kids are growing up. I post pictures of my kids (not in the bath!) And don't stress about their uniform etc. Anyone walking down the street can see what school they go to. I'm not sure what advantage a random person on Facebook would have from knowing. Also I am only Facebook friends with people I actually know. I don't understand why you would have "friends" you don't actually know. I certainly don't understand anyone who makes personal posts public.

Yep that’s why I post the odd update/photo with the privacy filters on, I have close family dotted about who we don’t see as much as we’d like to so just an easy way to see photos and updates

Abitofalark · 18/01/2023 11:27

Perhaps the worst thing is the using the illness and death of a child as a suitable subject for sustained public sharing in the media - I remember a particular case of that that went on and on and on, to the point where I found it distasteful and it began to seem exploitative.

I mentioned media rather than just social media because these days things often find their way from social media into newspapers and broadcasting.

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 11:27

RitaBonita · 18/01/2023 11:23

I agree, although I’ve not been on it for years now for that very reason. Some people just like to spread their business around, their kids are the same as it’s the only thing they’ve ever known. But it does come in useful sometimes. When I wanted to send my Onco a personalized card I was able to find out all sorts of things after 10 mins on FB & Twitter. Bloody brilliant card it was!

Oooh for me, it's useful to find out birthdays! (Or to find out if I've forgotten them 🤣)

OP posts:
yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 11:26

SafeMove · 18/01/2023 11:20

I have come off FB because the lack of dignity people afford their DC and their dying/dead relatives. Looking at photos of terminally ill people's hands being gripped by the Facebooker, the 'Fly high' balloon releases and pictures of graves was just too much.

There was a very high profile murder in our town and the families public FB posts were astounding to me - sharing very grim details about both the victim and perpetrator. It made me really uncomfortable to be party to that window into grief and trauma. Who is this for? Maybe it is a part of grief and shock I don't understand but I felt wrong for accessing it.

It's just purely shocking how some people have no boundaries at all. Some of the stuff I've seen people share has been horrific!

Then there's also the ones that share every itty bitty little detail of their love life, which can be amusing especially when they start to publicly argue haha, but some people just fully step over a line!

OP posts:
RitaBonita · 18/01/2023 11:23

I agree, although I’ve not been on it for years now for that very reason. Some people just like to spread their business around, their kids are the same as it’s the only thing they’ve ever known. But it does come in useful sometimes. When I wanted to send my Onco a personalized card I was able to find out all sorts of things after 10 mins on FB & Twitter. Bloody brilliant card it was!

dottypotter · 18/01/2023 11:22

Sleepwalkingintothewall · 18/01/2023 11:19

For me it's not what they share, it's their assumption that anyone else cares.

Ha Ha good one. Most of it is repetitive rubbish and dull.
Oh look here I am having a coffee while I'm out. So.

SafeMove · 18/01/2023 11:20

I have come off FB because the lack of dignity people afford their DC and their dying/dead relatives. Looking at photos of terminally ill people's hands being gripped by the Facebooker, the 'Fly high' balloon releases and pictures of graves was just too much.

There was a very high profile murder in our town and the families public FB posts were astounding to me - sharing very grim details about both the victim and perpetrator. It made me really uncomfortable to be party to that window into grief and trauma. Who is this for? Maybe it is a part of grief and shock I don't understand but I felt wrong for accessing it.

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 11:19

Twiggywinkle13 · 18/01/2023 11:17

Do I want my parents to now go through 32 years of pics and upload every memory we have to Facebook? No I don’t. Which is why I won’t do it to my child either! DH and I have agreed to share the odd thing but probably not DC’s face (due in April). So we will be very selective too.

I do have social media but I’m very private, for example I don’t know that you could even tell I was married from mine, I think DH features once on my instagram!

Although I also understand not everyone is like that and that’s their choice too, I just don’t really understand documenting everything about your children from the first scan picture to present!

You sound very similar to me!!

I bumped into one of my friends a while back and she asked me what's happened between me and my partner ... so I said nothing?? Why?👀 and she said "you don't post him on your story or anything and it doesn't have you as in a relationship, so I thought you had left him"

He's very much the same as me too though, barely ever posts! He uses YouTube mainly and sends me funny videos on his break at work and that's the peak of our social media relationship (and I love that)

OP posts:
Sleepwalkingintothewall · 18/01/2023 11:19

For me it's not what they share, it's their assumption that anyone else cares.

adulthumanfemalemum · 18/01/2023 11:19

I don't know who you're looking at but I find the opposite that most of my friends don't post anything, especially not pictures of their kids . It makes me sad because I have friends all over the country and world and would love to see what they're up to and how their kids are growing up. I post pictures of my kids (not in the bath!) And don't stress about their uniform etc. Anyone walking down the street can see what school they go to. I'm not sure what advantage a random person on Facebook would have from knowing. Also I am only Facebook friends with people I actually know. I don't understand why you would have "friends" you don't actually know. I certainly don't understand anyone who makes personal posts public.

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 11:17

MyPurpleHeart · 18/01/2023 11:12

I removed someone recently because she had shared a post showing photos of paramedics in her house treating her 2 year old who was struggling to breathe

I just thought there is nothing about that post or the parent posting it that I agree with so ill go quietly!

No way that's sad 😓 I've been unfriending alot over the last couple of weeks x

OP posts:
Twiggywinkle13 · 18/01/2023 11:17

Do I want my parents to now go through 32 years of pics and upload every memory we have to Facebook? No I don’t. Which is why I won’t do it to my child either! DH and I have agreed to share the odd thing but probably not DC’s face (due in April). So we will be very selective too.

I do have social media but I’m very private, for example I don’t know that you could even tell I was married from mine, I think DH features once on my instagram!

Although I also understand not everyone is like that and that’s their choice too, I just don’t really understand documenting everything about your children from the first scan picture to present!

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 11:16

porpy · 18/01/2023 11:14

I still use FB and post the odd photos of my kids/what we’ve been up to. But I have privacy filters so only family and close friends can see (so people who my kids physically know and are part of their lives) so they don’t have randoms from my work etc seeing what they’re up to! I also always check with my DC if they’re okay with me loading the photo on.

Definitely agree the younger generations don’t use Facebook that much. My grandparents post the most day-to-day stuff and photos more than anyone else!

But I still see a lot of people on public instagrams and TikTok accounts showing a lot of their kids lives. I do wonder how we’ll look back on this sort of stuff once that generation of babies/kids have grown into adults themselves.

You just reminded me, I have an older family member (she's in her 70s I think!) and she gets Facebook and Google search mixed up sometimes, and will post statuses of things she wants to Google 🤣

OP posts:
SlashBeef · 18/01/2023 11:14

Fb now just seems to be ads or oversharing about kids. It's totally useless as social media at this point.

DismantledKing · 18/01/2023 11:14

You see it on here too. So many threads from Mumsnet end up in the tabloids, yet people continue to post so much identifiable information.

porpy · 18/01/2023 11:14

I still use FB and post the odd photos of my kids/what we’ve been up to. But I have privacy filters so only family and close friends can see (so people who my kids physically know and are part of their lives) so they don’t have randoms from my work etc seeing what they’re up to! I also always check with my DC if they’re okay with me loading the photo on.

Definitely agree the younger generations don’t use Facebook that much. My grandparents post the most day-to-day stuff and photos more than anyone else!

But I still see a lot of people on public instagrams and TikTok accounts showing a lot of their kids lives. I do wonder how we’ll look back on this sort of stuff once that generation of babies/kids have grown into adults themselves.

123woop · 18/01/2023 11:12

It's really, really odd. It must happen at least once or twice a month that I open Facebook to find that her 8 year old son has once again 'hilariously' done a poop in a plant pot, or her 5 year old daughter has smeared poop all over the toilet as a prank.
Don't get me wrong, as a mum of three I am very used to toilet humour, but it's just bizarre. Also, other mums at the school gate comment to each other about it in obviously concerned tones, and we all said that wouldn't invite her kids round to our houses incase they did one of these hilarious 'pranks'!!

MyPurpleHeart · 18/01/2023 11:12

I removed someone recently because she had shared a post showing photos of paramedics in her house treating her 2 year old who was struggling to breathe

I just thought there is nothing about that post or the parent posting it that I agree with so ill go quietly!

dovelove · 18/01/2023 11:12

Our dd was in hospital for a small operation recently. We witnessed the family in the bed opposite posing their child to take pics for I'm presuming social Media. Taking selfies with them while they were still coming round from their anesthetic. "Hold you hand on your belly so we can see your drip" then once again taking pics.

Turned our stomachs

Swipe left for the next trending thread