Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childcare- i need perspective

238 replies

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 08:47

When i was pregnant my parents promised childcare help one day a week. When i was young my grandparents looked after me 5 days a week so obviously much less in comparison and i was grateful for the one day a week and sorted nursery accordingly on other days.

My parents caught a flu over Christmas/NY so I've managed to arrange a short notice nursery slot on their day so i had childcare cover. Very stressful!

They are due to come tomorrow and my dad has now said if he catches another bug/flu/sickness like the last one they refuse to come for the rest of the winter. He also said he's mad at me for booking a summer holiday as they are there to save us money on childcare so it seems unfair that the money is instead being used to pay for a holiday.

I don't know if I'm in the wrong here or what to think. I didn't realise i wasn't allowed to live while they helped with childcare.

Please give me some perspective. I can see both sides but i'm already on tenderhooks with the nursery sending my baby home due to bugs and having to juggle work between my husband and me and now this!!

OP posts:
Sugargliderwombat · 18/01/2023 10:55

Sounds like your mum wants to do it and your dad doesn't. What does your mum say about it all?

Sotellmethisandnomore · 18/01/2023 10:49

No debt, only mortgage and lots of savings in the bank! We don't live beyond our means and are frugal in our every day lives, we just like to splash out on a holiday (up until October last year we stayed in the UK due to covid- mostly camping or cheap Airbnb)

You can well afford the extra day in nursery so pay it. That solves all problems and you are beholden to nobody. End of.

PeekAtYou · 18/01/2023 10:49

I would end the childcare arrangement immediately. Help should not come with strings attached.

I gave adult children and can't imagine thinking like your dad. I'd rather you were spending your money on fun (holiday) than childcare.

FunnyWorldWeLiveIn · 18/01/2023 10:47

Getting sick kinda after but that doesn't help you
But
Dictating your life and holidays no f way.

Teatime55 · 18/01/2023 10:45

I have a neighbour who was really pushed into looking after her grandchildren. Her son said she ‘owed her’ because her mother had looked after him full time.
She did it, but you could see she really struggled. She wasn’t prepared for what looking after a small child was like. She was initially excited but you could tell she didn’t enjoy it.

TheOrigRights · 18/01/2023 10:43

He also said he's mad at me for booking a summer holiday as they are there to save us money on childcare so it seems unfair that the money is instead being used to pay for a holiday.

Sod that. What an ugly point of view.
I would do everything I could to arrange my life so that I did not need to be reliant on someone who wanted to care for their grandchild under these conditions.

EL8888 · 18/01/2023 10:36

Eastereggsboxedupready · 18/01/2023 08:50

Your option is be beholding to them or use nursery.....
End of thread...

This basically. They sound controlling and annoying. Your finances sound in great shape and they need to keep their noses out. What’s wrong with going on holiday if you can afford it?! I would love to know by the way how you plan to stop children getting ill?!

Sillyheadoooooo · 18/01/2023 10:35

I’m a childminder and see it not working out with grandparents as childcarers all the time. The thing is it really takes commitment from grandparents to make it work and more often than not, when it comes to it they don’t want to give up every Tuesday or similar. Most families seem to have a better relationship if childcare is ad hoc - in my experience!

if you’re happy with the nursery just get her in there full time. Can always meet up at the weekend and will keep resentment out of your relationship.

Iamtheonwandlonely · 18/01/2023 10:31

Put your child in nursery and the GP can have the DC one of the days you're at home.
That way if they bail,it won't matter.

littlelid · 18/01/2023 10:31

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 09:03

Literally not my choice. Work wouldn't let me have Monday or Friday off.

Yeah mines the same. It sucks.

Anyway, as PP said I would make clear to your dad that wires have been crossed and you were under the impression they wanted to look after DC to spend time with them rather than to save you money and that you can put them into nursery if that's what they would prefer

HiddenGiraffes · 18/01/2023 10:28

They clearly resent it and think they have the right to dictate your life choices because of it. If you can afford it just put her in nursery that day. This arrangement doesn't seem to be making anyone happy.

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 10:27

it is possible your parents offered under a sense of duty and in the mistaken belief that you were really short of cash. In that respect they're not wrong to not want to come (if they were reluctant but had that sense of duty) if you can easily afford it.

Your DF isn't entitled to tell you how to spend your money though.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/01/2023 10:26

I think they're being really unfair. 'If we catch another bug then that's it for the winter'. How are you supposed to cope with work when there is the threat of childcare being removed at any given moment?

Secondly unless you specifically asked for help with childcare once a week to save money, then (assuming they offered) it's none of their bloody business how you spend your money.

I'd put your child in nursery 3 days and maybe use your parents for ad hoc childcare.

Also remember that (assuming your childs dad is still around) your child has two parents, it sounds like you're sorting illness / childcare etc on your own

billy1966 · 18/01/2023 10:24

JusteanBiscuits · 18/01/2023 10:10

Just a devils advocate kind of thing.

My nephew and his wife are struggling, so their grandmother (my Mum) offered to pay one days childcare a week (instead of looking after the child as she is too old and unable to do it herself, and felt guilty about this) to help them out. Nephew & wife have booked a week in the sun over Easter for them and the toddler and their school age child. My Mum is understandably pissed off. She's not wealthy, but has a little set aside from downsizing, and thought she was helping them out to be able to break even each month.

It depends if they offered to help to spend time with their grandchild, or offered to help out to make working affordable for you.

THAT is vastly different and your mother needs to say she is no longer in a position to supplement their income.

She's not helping out people whom are struggling, she is giving them a stipend every month.

She can say she can no longer afford it.

THAT would annoy most people.

billy1966 · 18/01/2023 10:20

OP,

Save yourself a LOT of grief.

You have a controlling parent and your father is a PITA.

Pay for nursery and tell your father to mind his own business.

There is a type of parent that offers help and then doesn't actually want to do it, lets their children down, causes stress etc., thinks that their help means they "own" you and they can now pass remarks.

My gentle pal had this donkeys years ago, her MIL pushed to mind her child one day a week and then made a remark about how she spent their money, to her mother,......... that SHE was "funding" their lifestyle.
She said it infront of my mothers friend who was in company.
Her mother was furious at the rudeness.

A couple of other remarks and she had had enough and was done.

As dropping her daughter 20 minutes away and collecting was a PITA and it was HER not her husband who was doing it all, she told HIM that he could now do the drops to his mother or up the nursery days.

He tried to guilt her a bit on how good it was for their daughter but she stood strong, HE could do it for that ONE day...
....
Of course he wasn't prepared to be put out🙄for what HE'D earlier thought was such a good idea.
She was very annoyed with him and his mother and the scales dropped from her eyes a lot.
She toughened up a lot after it, and not a moment too soon.

OP, send your child for the extra days and don't be beholden to your parents.

It's really not worth it if it comes with digs and strings..

TolkiensFallow · 18/01/2023 10:15

for reliability I’d go down the paid childcare route. it will resolve bad feeling too.

this happens a lot where grandparents want to spend time with their grandchildren but then are a bit begrudging about how the saved money is spent.

if you pay nursery to do the routine childcare - then you might find more babysitting is more forthcoming if you need something

JusteanBiscuits · 18/01/2023 10:10

Just a devils advocate kind of thing.

My nephew and his wife are struggling, so their grandmother (my Mum) offered to pay one days childcare a week (instead of looking after the child as she is too old and unable to do it herself, and felt guilty about this) to help them out. Nephew & wife have booked a week in the sun over Easter for them and the toddler and their school age child. My Mum is understandably pissed off. She's not wealthy, but has a little set aside from downsizing, and thought she was helping them out to be able to break even each month.

It depends if they offered to help to spend time with their grandchild, or offered to help out to make working affordable for you.

SecretVictoria · 18/01/2023 10:05

Did you ask them to do it and say it would save you money? Apologies if I missed it.

Something a bit similar happened to me. A friend and I were going to flat share, but he told me he couldn’t afford his half of the deposit. I could afford my half but not all of it. My mum paid it in the end, on the understanding that when we left it was returned to her.

The first week we were in the flat, he went and bought himself an iMac. I left after 2 years and he was staying. He asked if the deposit would “just roll over with him”, until I reminded him that it was mine and my mums money 🙄.

Glittertwins · 18/01/2023 10:03

We went down the extortionate route of paid for childcare. MIL offered (we didn't want) various numbers of days which then reduced more and more over time so we went for 100% nursery. It just wasn't worth the hassle

Coffeeandchocs · 18/01/2023 10:03

The thing is, grandparents (on the whole) love their grandchildren and enjoy time with them. The downside to providing childcare so the parent can go to work is that it is a big commitment. They can’t plan holidays unless it’s a time you’re also on holiday. If they’re poorly they let you down. A toddler is hard work for a younger adult, once you’re getting to retirement age, running around after a little one is tiring!

Your parents should have gone about this in a better way. But maybe they’re just realising what they have actually committed to and now don’t feel they can do it.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 18/01/2023 10:02

And agree, I don’t think they really know what they are signing up for when they offer

DrMarciaFieldstone · 18/01/2023 10:01

I used family at first - they offered (begged!) and we paid, but it was too hard. Also what happens when they want to have a break etc?

Nursery is so much easier and less stressful, even with the additional cost

notnowmonster · 18/01/2023 09:57

Book your child into nursery - it sounds like you can't rely on your parents - certainly not your father anyway. I'd be very annoyed - as nurseries often don't have availability for extra days at short notice .
My family helped with my daughter when she was at nursery - set days/times. They did it because they wanted to spend time with her as well as to save me money - the result is she is still very close to them now and wants to spend time with them - your dad is missing out

jessycake · 18/01/2023 09:57

What does your mum say ? I wonder if having the flu , the doom and gloom news and hands off health care have shaken him a bit .

CavalierApproach · 18/01/2023 09:54

Calphurnia88 · 18/01/2023 08:59

This is why I have gone down the paid childcare route when I return to work.

When DS was younger, MIL (very kindly) offered to provide childcare to help us save money. We said thank you but when we we explained that, in practical terms, this means commiting to provide childcare on the same day each week over a long period, we could see the cogs whirring and knew immediately that this wasn't going to work.

I think sometimes grandparents offer this with the best intentions, but don't realise what their signing up for.

We did the same for exactly the same reason. It was hard, childcare costs a bomb and we never take holidays ever (not that I begrudge those who do! Just saying, it’s not like we could “easily” afford ft childcare, it was a sacrifice) — however I just knew that there would probably be upsetting conflict over reliability and our expectations of consistency if we used PIL for childcare, which they did initially want us to do.