Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childcare- i need perspective

238 replies

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 08:47

When i was pregnant my parents promised childcare help one day a week. When i was young my grandparents looked after me 5 days a week so obviously much less in comparison and i was grateful for the one day a week and sorted nursery accordingly on other days.

My parents caught a flu over Christmas/NY so I've managed to arrange a short notice nursery slot on their day so i had childcare cover. Very stressful!

They are due to come tomorrow and my dad has now said if he catches another bug/flu/sickness like the last one they refuse to come for the rest of the winter. He also said he's mad at me for booking a summer holiday as they are there to save us money on childcare so it seems unfair that the money is instead being used to pay for a holiday.

I don't know if I'm in the wrong here or what to think. I didn't realise i wasn't allowed to live while they helped with childcare.

Please give me some perspective. I can see both sides but i'm already on tenderhooks with the nursery sending my baby home due to bugs and having to juggle work between my husband and me and now this!!

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 18/01/2023 13:25

I definitely think they feel that doing childcare gives them some sort of right over your finances. And they don't actually want to help with childcare. I think that's a bit shitty, after they benefited from help in their time and they offered, but it is what it is, and you'd be better booking an extra nursery day.

mewkins · 18/01/2023 13:23

It can work out (it did with my parents looking after both of mine) but both really enjoyed doing it (they offered, I didn't ask). There were only a few times when I took annual leave to cover illness.

However, your dad doesn't really want to do it and he also has no right to tell you not to take a holiday!!! I would find a nursery/childminder.

Doone21 · 18/01/2023 13:21

Don't underestimate how bad flu makes you feel long term, maybe they're just starting to feel unappreciated and tire. Let them off the hook gently and book proper childcare.

OhMonDieux · 18/01/2023 13:19

My brother still lives at home and she does everything for him, she has to plan an evening meal, makes sure his washing is done and lunch is made etc the night before so it's more work for her. Additionally my dad picks him up from the train station every evening so coordinating that is another thing

Unless your brother has special needs of some kind this is outrageous.

65+ mum doing it all for her son.

zmq3Zm96uijcs2c · 18/01/2023 13:18

I think people who let you down and judge your choices don’t get to monopolise the precious day off you have with your child as a standing arrangement. If they want entertaining, go to the cinema!

Knittedfairies · 18/01/2023 13:17

Book that extra day OP, otherwise every time you splash out on anything -jam instead of dripping for your bread - it may be held over you.

OhMonDieux · 18/01/2023 13:17

How old are you parents @NatMoz You say they are both on state pensions so that means over 65, but their son lives at home still and they are in full-on parenting mode for him! (all his meals and collecting him from the station.)

I think your dad is right to say that if they catch flu again this winter they can't be childminders. That is reasonable.

I don't think he's right to say you can't have a holiday from any money 'saved' by using them as a day of free childcare.

Surely he knew that anyway? That you aren't hard up ?

Have you told him this?

And, if you arne't hard up why use them anyway?

Woodhouse23 · 18/01/2023 13:10

zmq3Zm96uijcs2c · 18/01/2023 13:04

What a shame this won’t work for you. They get to control their time, so you get to control yours. Be busy, a lot.

You think she should prevent her child from developing a relationship with his/her grandparents because the grandparents don't want to commit to regular frequent childcare?

Wow.

Lifeisapeach · 18/01/2023 13:06

There’s definitely a bitterness there ! I would pay for the extra day and remove your reliance on them.

astronewt · 18/01/2023 13:05

I picked up this phrase years ago on Captain Awkward, and it's been proved true over and over again on here when it comes to childcare:

Sometimes the cheapest way to pay is with money.

Professional childcare costs, but the terms of the contract and the relationship are clear, and it's reliable. Family childcare may save cash, but it often exacts a higher toll in terms of unreliability, resentment, and bonus judgement.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 18/01/2023 13:05

We had offers from both sets of grandparents, in order to save us money on nursery. We considered it, but ultimately decided that the consistency of nursery on set days through the week and that was it was the better option. Its better for DC and for us. Everyone knows where they are and the grandparents still get time with them but it's purely pleasure for everyone.

zmq3Zm96uijcs2c · 18/01/2023 13:04

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 08:57

Yes but also that they didn't mind because they got to spend time with their granddaughter. My dad did say that he could just come on my non working day and see her then instead

What a shame this won’t work for you. They get to control their time, so you get to control yours. Be busy, a lot.

Flossflower · 18/01/2023 12:58

I am a grandmother. We look after 2 sets of grandkids once a weeks. For both of my children the other grandparents also do one day a week. I love seeing my grandchildren, but as they also go to nursery/school they pick up loads of bugs. My husband and I seem to pick up these bugs! As the grandchildren are getting older they are building up some immunity and the bugs are getting less often . This has not stopped us wanting to look after our grandkids. I think your parents are being unreasonable not to expect you to have nice holidays. Our children have great holidays and we are very pleased for them. Don’t most parents wants their kids to be as happy as possible? My mother always put conditions on any help. She very occasionally baby sat for us and we would have to take her out the next day. I was determined not to be like my mother.
If you can afford it I wouldn’t put up with any blackmail and put your child in full time. This is a short period in your life and your child will grow out of having so many bugs.

Izitbedtimeyet · 18/01/2023 12:54

YANBU. If they've offered childcare that's up to them. I can see where they are coming from on the illnesses but surely they are aware kids get colds.....a lot!

They have no say in what you do with your money.

I used to get family help with childcare and still do in holidays. My family help so I'm spending all my money on childcare and can still afford things like holidays and days out.

I would look to pay extra childcare here and not use them to save the hassle.

Ponderingwindow · 18/01/2023 12:53

It is more of a commitment than your parents realized. It doesn’t matter that they are doing less than a previous generation. The current arrangement doesn’t work for them.

put your child in nursery and tell your parents it would be much more helpful to have them be people you can call in a childcare emergency. That doesn’t mean they must always be on standby, just that they can be your first choice backup.

MotherOfHouseplants · 18/01/2023 12:48

It sounds like they offered and you accepted in good faith all round but it clearly isn't working. Perhaps they underestimated the energy they'd need, perhaps they resent the limitations on their time, perhaps they are anxious about becoming unwell (this winter has been one of the worst I can remember for the prevalence and severity of bugs).

You need to end the arrangement now and put your child into paid daycare before it does irreparable damage to your relationship with your parents.

Leopardpj · 18/01/2023 12:45

I feel for you OP, this sort of thing is why I gave up on regular grandparental day care. I was very grateful but it became a strain on the relationship which wasn't worth it. Personally I'd rather pay for childcare and be able to choose what suits me rather than have it complicate personal relationships or be relying on what someone else feels they can manage! It's not worth the stress of worrying whether it's reliable or have it affecting your relationship with your parents/ in laws in my view. My children still have lovely relationship with all their grandparents and they still babysit sometimes, but their regular childcare is something we now keep separate.

Ilikemeat2023 · 18/01/2023 12:45

I don’t blame him. My kids don’t see their grandparents when they are sick. I don’t want to make my mum and dad ill. I think you should put her in nursery for the extra day

HelenHywater · 18/01/2023 12:44

It's not your business how much money your parents have or how they choose to spend it. It's irrelevant to their decision (which they're perfectly permitted to make) that they don't want to risk illness when caring for your child. It's irrelevant what their arrangements were when you were a child.

It's also not their responsibility to do your childcare or your entitlement to it (and nor is it their entitlement to question how you spend your money). So although it might be frustrating that they've seemingly gone back on a commitment, it's irrelevant whether you think they're justified.

You just need to take them out of the childcare equation and make your own arrangements I'm afraid.

May09Bump · 18/01/2023 12:41

You have a get out too - say you agree and don't want them getting sick all the time (as your Dad mentioned) and put her into nursery.

I wouldn't share any finance decisions with them as being too judgemental. Holidays you can't really hide - but I wouldn't discuss any finances to do with that either.

They can see LO at weekend or weekday if your available.

Xmasbaby11 · 18/01/2023 12:39

sounds like it will be simpler to stick to paid childcare. As pp have pointed out, it may 'only' be 1 day a week but when that's every week, it is a big commitment, and illnesses to do longer to get over at that age. It would be better if they were clear about their terms or if they want to stop the childcare - but as it is, they don't sound reliable so best to stick to nursery for now.

ProserpinaProserpina · 18/01/2023 12:28

We are gradually phasing out grandparent childcare. They used to have DC1 three days per week. When I went back from maternity leave after DC2 it went down to both on one day. DC1 (likely autistic) couldn’t cope with their lack of structure so he goes to nursery and they have DC2 one day per week. Once DC1 goes to school, we’ll knock it on the head entirely. Being beholden to them is a pain in the arse, and they always huff and puff like we’ve massively inconvenienced them (despite offering to do it). Plus they seem to pick up the kids various viruses constantly. I’d rather we all just visited on weekends and no one felt obliged. If you can avoid it I probably would tbh.

Fundays12 · 18/01/2023 12:25

OP this is why I use nurseries, child minders and eventually changed my hours so DH was home the hours I worked. In my experience childcare from family often comes with family either believing they now have a say in your finances, life or relationships or alternatively trying to take a lot of control over the child long term (worst cases I gave seen involve parents being undermined or vital information withheld). I have seen it and been through it with dc1. If you can afford to pay childcare go for it. It will only get worse not better so set your boundaries now.

Bestcatmum · 18/01/2023 12:25

And to add to that when I was small I was farmed out to relatives every single school holiday so they could go away for a break!!!

4thonthe4th · 18/01/2023 12:24

If you’ve only ever had cheap holidays and they’re helping with childcare, they probably assume you’re struggling and they’re helping you out.
I would do the extra day in nursery.