Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childcare- i need perspective

238 replies

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 08:47

When i was pregnant my parents promised childcare help one day a week. When i was young my grandparents looked after me 5 days a week so obviously much less in comparison and i was grateful for the one day a week and sorted nursery accordingly on other days.

My parents caught a flu over Christmas/NY so I've managed to arrange a short notice nursery slot on their day so i had childcare cover. Very stressful!

They are due to come tomorrow and my dad has now said if he catches another bug/flu/sickness like the last one they refuse to come for the rest of the winter. He also said he's mad at me for booking a summer holiday as they are there to save us money on childcare so it seems unfair that the money is instead being used to pay for a holiday.

I don't know if I'm in the wrong here or what to think. I didn't realise i wasn't allowed to live while they helped with childcare.

Please give me some perspective. I can see both sides but i'm already on tenderhooks with the nursery sending my baby home due to bugs and having to juggle work between my husband and me and now this!!

OP posts:
EmmaDilemma5 · 18/01/2023 16:06

bellswithwhistles · 18/01/2023 14:37

20 and 30 somethings these days fully expected their parents to do unpaid childcare. Baffles me. Your parents are generally still working or near retirement (or retired). Trust me when you get to 50 the last thing you want is to have that commitment tying you down. I would never dream of asking my parents to have my kids to save on childcare costs. They've done their parenting. It's your turn now.

Grandchildren should be enjoyed for sure. But looking after children full time is no picnic.

Sort out paid childcare. Let your parents be grandparents. Sounds like they wish they could take/pay for a holiday but instead they've being used as free childcare? (maybe that was what the dig was about?)

I think you missed the part about them accepting help from their parents 5 days per week. It's not a generational thing at all. Loads of older people had help with their kids from family members. If anything, for working parents, that was MORE common than using paid for childcare.

Tricolette · 18/01/2023 16:06

And as regards the holiday my own dc would absolutely tell me to mind my own business if I commented on their spending.

Tricolette · 18/01/2023 16:05

Well it’s obvious who the golden child is.
I would tell them you need a firm commitment because childcare needs to be definite.
And if they don’t do the childcare then absolutely make them fit visits around your own life.

EmmaDilemma5 · 18/01/2023 16:00

Your parents sound bitter and extremely tight.

My parents have my child 2 days a week to save us money. We do still eat, go out for days out and the odd holiday god forbid! Them helping us out ENABLES our children to have little luxuries. They should want that!

With your parents attitude, I'd stop the childcare, they'll clearly use it as a tool for judgement. But no way would they be coming over on my day off. They either want to help and contribute like good parents do (when they can), and as theirs did, or they don't, and they can see your child when it suits you.

I would probably explain to him that you're grateful for their offer but you weren't aware it came with caveats about how you choose to treat your children. So if they don't want you going on holiday or having any luxuries, then perhaps it's best you up the days at nursery. It's not ideal but you think it will be better for the relationship all round. Then I'd probably pretend I didn't know they had help, so say something like "I realise you didn't get much help from your parents so I've never expected it". Perhaps it'll make him realise how hypocritical he's being.

MrsCarson · 18/01/2023 15:59

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 08:57

Yes but also that they didn't mind because they got to spend time with their granddaughter. My dad did say that he could just come on my non working day and see her then instead

I'd put her in nursery full time and let him visit when it suits you, not every time you're off work, you have your own things to do and do things with your own child Take back control here.

PollyAmour · 18/01/2023 15:50

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 15:18

He has his own house, mortgage free and is rented off but it is cheaper to live rent free at my parents than pay electric/broadband etc. Also it's easier as my mum cooks/cleans for him and my dad picks him up from the station/sorts out his car MOT etc. Why give that up?

Yes he is 30.

Extra planning is required to make sure he's fed etc for my mum on the childcare day which i get.

That's all kinds of crazy. How has he managed to own a home, mortgage free, at the age of 30? Why on earth does he opt into the role of manchild, still living with mummy, when it's not necessary?

With regard to the childcare issue, cancel your parents role in this with immediate effect. They are doing it begrudgingly so tell them their services are no longer required. Organise paid for childcare and be beholden to no-one.

Stunningscreamer · 18/01/2023 15:50

Flurffyy · 18/01/2023 14:28

They are probably finding it harder and more tiring than they expected and are finding excuses to get out of it.

Well it would be much easier to be honest about it. They don't seem to find it more tiring running round after golden boy son.

billy1966 · 18/01/2023 15:42

They have clearly changed their minds and can't be arsed to follow through.

Sort yourself out and learn from this.

I think it is perfectly reasonable not towant to do childcare at all, but to insist upon it and then change your mind and drop someone in it, is not fair and people cannot expect there not to be upset when that happens.

Calphurnia88 · 18/01/2023 15:41

Coffeeandchocs · 18/01/2023 15:01

I’ve already posted but I think grandparents are more reluctant to help out with childcare these days, and rightly so in my opinion.

Retirement is much later in life now, there’s less time to spend pottering around after your working life is finished. Of course, grandchildren bring joy and fun but it’s less so when you’re obligated. It takes away any opportunity for spontaneity, never being able to just go off camping because the weather is nice or book a holiday when you fancy it, as you always have to take into consideration you look after the GC on Tuesdays.

There’s also the element, I think, that we expect a lot of grandparents but also don’t care for them in the same way that happened generations ago. They might make sacrifices to help you go back to work, but when they become elderly and infirm, would you be in a position to drop to part time work and help care for them for a couple days a week? If the answer to that is no, and for many it would be reasonable to say no, then you can’t expect childcare from them, in my opinion.

Retirement is much later in life now, there’s less time to spend pottering around after your working life is finished. Of course, grandchildren bring joy and fun but it’s less so when you’re obligated. It takes away any opportunity for spontaneity, never being able to just go off camping because the weather is nice or book a holiday when you fancy it, as you always have to take into consideration you look after the GC on Tuesdays.

I agree with your point (this is why 8 wouldn't use family as an alternative to paid childcare) but unless the grandparents were mislead somehow then surely they knew the deal when they offered to provide childcare as an alternative to nursery? If they were reluctant then they should have said before OP confirmed non-nursery days.

PearTreePie · 18/01/2023 15:40

It’s massively unreasonable for them to comment on how you spend money.

It doesn’t sound like your dad likes the current arrangement.

In your shoes, I’d increase the nursery days and tell your parents that nursery have asked for a minimum commitment of x days from a certain age.

Also, I’d make it clear that them socialising with your DD isn’t going to take priority over other plans you might have on your days off. The benefit of them doing childcare is that they get regular 1:1 time with her. They don’t get to automatically crash your time with her.

billy1966 · 18/01/2023 15:36

TheCraicDealer · 18/01/2023 14:16

I'm going to show this thread to my DH. He thinks my parents are dead stingy because they won't cover a day or two a week- literally every one of our friends has parents that provide childcare. However, DM is still working 4 days a week, and there's no way I'd be asking my DDad to look after DD on his own, it wouldn't be much fun for either of them.

DDad was always very firm and said that he and DM weren't going to provide childcare during the week; even when we were teenagers he used to comment on the next door neighbours who had four kids, who all produced multiple grandchildren that they provided care for every day. It didn't look like much of a retirement tbh. So when DSis and I started our families we both knew that when it came to weekdays we'd be on our own.

They did however also say that they would look after the kids on an ad hoc basis to allow us to go on nights out, short trips, etc. and they have completely stuck to their word. I know if I was in a real bind I could call my DDad and he'd be up to my house as soon as he could to help out. DM also recognises when I need a break and will call to tell me to drop DD off with them for the afternoon, or ask if we'd like her to stay over on a Saturday night. TLDR: full time nursery costs us a fortune but I wouldn't have it any other way.

Your husband sounds like a CF and you should be telling him off about speaking about your parents like that.

They do not owe him childcare.

That they help you out on an ad hoc basis and would do so happily in an emergency means you are already very lucky IMO.

Kerri44 · 18/01/2023 15:35

I don't get parents who do this! I'd pay for nursery if you can.

I'm so lucky, my mum had my 5yr old 2 days a week and will be having my 9mth old the same.....to help us financially so we can go on holiday n do things but also because she treasures that time!

GloomyDarkness · 18/01/2023 15:23

It doesn't sound like a healthy dynamic with your Dad comments and how to reference your brother's and mother's behavior.

I don't think you'll "win" here. It's either pay for childcare all days and have reliability and possibly slightly less intrusion/judgement into where you spend your money - or suck it all up for the childcare - and possible have to scrabble for last minute childcare if they suddenly have a change of heart.

NatMoz · 18/01/2023 15:18

OhMonDieux · 18/01/2023 14:40

Maybe your parents are just fed up with being tied to this arrangement.

I have friends in their 60s who are grandparents. They are happy to do the odd day of childminding, when essential, but none of them want to commit to the same day each week.

It's a big commitment when you are retired.

They are clearly very well off with an annual pension of around £50K a year ( £4K a month) so maybe they would like to be enjoying themselves and not be tied to this arrangement.

I don't understand the situation with your brother.
Can't he afford to move out and rent/buy?
Why is your retired father picking him up from the station every day?
I know it will save money, but your brother must be in his 30s and need a push to leave home.

He has his own house, mortgage free and is rented off but it is cheaper to live rent free at my parents than pay electric/broadband etc. Also it's easier as my mum cooks/cleans for him and my dad picks him up from the station/sorts out his car MOT etc. Why give that up?

Yes he is 30.

Extra planning is required to make sure he's fed etc for my mum on the childcare day which i get.

OP posts:
GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 18/01/2023 15:13

Sort out proper paid childcare. Your parents are not obligated to give you free childcare. It sounds like it is causing them stress and you stress.

GloomyDarkness · 18/01/2023 15:07

Your option is be beholding to them or use nursery.....

This really.

I do think some GP are well meaning and then get hit with the reality.

I had to listen to my IL - who never did any childcare - moan about DH uncle and aunt finding two days a week childcare challenging as they'd love to see more of their GC (news to us ) and then next breath complain their friends can't do things with them for certain days as the provide childcare for their kids - and why can't they miss a week - I think there's a lot of woolly thinking around it.

You may also find what ever you do you are in the wrong - so I'd prioritized reliable childcare so work ins't impacted.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 18/01/2023 15:03

mewkins · 18/01/2023 14:58

Hmmm but what if op can afford all bills and has savings and there was never a discussion about doing it in order to save OP money.

Also the op is going on a family holiday with her kids. Not going on spa days and only drinking champagne.

It's weird for a parent to begrudge their kid a holiday.

It simply sounds like op's mum is happy to be doing this and her dad is really not enjoying it so is being an arsehole about it.

With respect, do you discuss the ins and outs of your finances with your parents? I suspect OP has told us more here than she's told her parents. So it's not unreasonable for her parents to be thinking we're saving our daughter X amount of money every week, to the detriment of our health, AND we can't make any plans that day because we have the baby 7-7. And because of our sacrifice she's booked the first holiday abroad we've ever known her take?

It's likely a lot harder than they were expecting. I know it is for my mum who similarly does a day of childcare for my sister.

Coffeeandchocs · 18/01/2023 15:01

I’ve already posted but I think grandparents are more reluctant to help out with childcare these days, and rightly so in my opinion.

Retirement is much later in life now, there’s less time to spend pottering around after your working life is finished. Of course, grandchildren bring joy and fun but it’s less so when you’re obligated. It takes away any opportunity for spontaneity, never being able to just go off camping because the weather is nice or book a holiday when you fancy it, as you always have to take into consideration you look after the GC on Tuesdays.

There’s also the element, I think, that we expect a lot of grandparents but also don’t care for them in the same way that happened generations ago. They might make sacrifices to help you go back to work, but when they become elderly and infirm, would you be in a position to drop to part time work and help care for them for a couple days a week? If the answer to that is no, and for many it would be reasonable to say no, then you can’t expect childcare from them, in my opinion.

Surfsenior · 18/01/2023 15:01

Your dad is being very unfair. I would take him to task on it, together with your mum, and say it seems like it is too much them having the baby one day a week, as they don’t seem happy doing it and making you feel guilty wasn’t part of the bargain

mewkins · 18/01/2023 14:58

2bazookas · 18/01/2023 14:47

Your parents are donating their time free (at some cost to themselves in energy, health risk) so that you can go to work and pay your household bills.

NOT

so you can spend one day a week at the spa drinking wine and having a massage. Or save up for a holiday for YOU.

No wonder they are cross.

Hmmm but what if op can afford all bills and has savings and there was never a discussion about doing it in order to save OP money.

Also the op is going on a family holiday with her kids. Not going on spa days and only drinking champagne.

It's weird for a parent to begrudge their kid a holiday.

It simply sounds like op's mum is happy to be doing this and her dad is really not enjoying it so is being an arsehole about it.

Glittertwins · 18/01/2023 14:49

The OP didn't say that though. She has plenty of funds to manage herself.

ppure · 18/01/2023 14:49

sounds like they don't want to catch anymore nursery child germs to me. don't blame them.

2bazookas · 18/01/2023 14:47

Your parents are donating their time free (at some cost to themselves in energy, health risk) so that you can go to work and pay your household bills.

NOT

so you can spend one day a week at the spa drinking wine and having a massage. Or save up for a holiday for YOU.

No wonder they are cross.

mewkins · 18/01/2023 14:43

LunaBoBuna · 18/01/2023 14:10

I don't think YABU.
My parents helped me out with childcare when I went back to work, otherwise my entire paycheck was going just to childcare and we wouldn't actually benefit from me going back to work. my mum loved it, did ask for a few days off here and there but she did the majority of the work so of course it was fair. She even asked if we had any holidays planned so they could plan too. I am so grateful for her during that time.
My dad on the other hand would always make off hand comments about not knowing how much longer they could keep doing it and generally found it more of a pain then she did.
She told me not to listen to him and she wouldn't have it any other way but it does pile the guilt on to you! It would always be him that made comments, never her.
In the end, COVID happened and I was made redundant so I took on full time childcare and the guilt went away but shortly before it did I was about to sign up to full time nursery because I couldn't deal with the added pressure. It heavily affected my PPD, which didn't come on until I restarted work.
I'm sure that grandparents offer these things and quickly regret it when they remember what it was like having a little child around all day!

I think as well that perhaps that some men didn't really have a hands on relationship with their own kids were little so it is a real shock to be doing that with your grandchildren. My dad was great when he looked after mine as he was a hands on dad and was also very relaxed about things. I feel very lucky that my children were able to spend so much time with him when they were small. He passed away two years ago at a relatively young age but my dc have such happy memories of him.

OhMonDieux · 18/01/2023 14:40

Maybe your parents are just fed up with being tied to this arrangement.

I have friends in their 60s who are grandparents. They are happy to do the odd day of childminding, when essential, but none of them want to commit to the same day each week.

It's a big commitment when you are retired.

They are clearly very well off with an annual pension of around £50K a year ( £4K a month) so maybe they would like to be enjoying themselves and not be tied to this arrangement.

I don't understand the situation with your brother.
Can't he afford to move out and rent/buy?
Why is your retired father picking him up from the station every day?
I know it will save money, but your brother must be in his 30s and need a push to leave home.