Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
AgathaAllAlong · 18/01/2023 13:13

I think the headline is misleading, too. The children WANT to be refered to as the opposite gender. What should teachers say in this climate - no? They would lose their jobs.

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I really hope no one you are close to ever has any gender identity issues.
I didn't help my daughter think there was something wrong with her body, not for one second. I had sleepless nights for years, worrying about it all. It took me a long time to accept it, but if I hadn't of been there for her to talk too, to comfort her, and do so much research with her, she wouldn't be here, male or female. I had counselling myself, as in the beginning I thought I had done something wrong myself to make her feel this way.
People constantly try to be someone they are not, act how they think they should act to fit in with society. Not everyone feels they can 'just be', whether they are child or adult.
My daughter hasn't been let down by medical professionals. She had months and months of counselling before any decisions were made about blockers and hormones later down the line. If they hadn't helped her, she would be dead. I would rather have a transgender daughter than a dead son.
The hard path finished a long time ago. She is happy and healthy and that is all I want for all of my children

MrsOvertonsWindow · 18/01/2023 13:02

MrsOvertonsWindow · 18/01/2023 11:47

"No one can 'register for puberty blockers'"

Gender GP (run by doctors banned in the UK) hand out puberty blockers to children with limited checks:

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/16db5c54-36f3-11eb-861c-b713ee2a0069?shareToken=80bf081d77469f75cf0fe694fa2b4db6.

So pleased to see this discussion happening openly. We all need to question and probe - ourselves, professionals and schools acting with supposed confidence yet zero expertise in this complex area. The stranglehold of #nodebate is over.
It's NOT transphobic to question why the sudden 4,000% increase in teenage girls deciding they hate becoming a woman? It's not transphobic to ask why trans adult groups have been given unquestioning access to schools or maternity care or women's sport to sow the seeds of born in the wrong body and that anything relating women is transphobic and must be changed?
Let's keep talking and fgs, let's centre children in our discussions and whether future sterility, body modification,limited relationship opportunities and life long drug use is the best future for them?

FourTeaFallOut · 18/01/2023 13:01

There's more to being anorexic than stepping on the scale a hundred times a day, but if a teacher enabled the dysmorphia by purchasing scales to only be used at school, out of the way of parents, it's pretty clear to see how affirmative messaging in a small way if terribly damaging - just pronouns, my arse.

sensechec · 18/01/2023 12:59

Wanting to have your healthy working penis cut off is a mental illness.

We just aren't allowed to call it that at the moment.

👏🏻

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 12:59

Referring to a child in their chosen gender identity is surely better than turning them off school and adding to their mental distress, even if you think it's a passing phase/have reservations about trans stuff

and read to the bottom of the article to find how this kid feels today as she’s realising that this was just a passing phase and she isn’t really a boy but how on earth does she back out of this in front of the entire school? She is starting to feel embarrassed about her decision, as many kids do when they look back at certain things they did when younger.

The difference now is that she is trapped by her earlier decision and reminded of it every day. Now that’s really tough.

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 12:58

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 12:33

I don't see the harm in schools allowing children to be called by the name and gender they identify with at that time?

Dr Cass saw the harm, and so do Transgender Trend. The links are upthread.

And it's not about "allowing" anything - it's about insisting that every teacher and every other child uses the new name etc, and deliberately hiding it from the parents. Meanwhile the parents have no chance to understand, to learn, to adapt, to even know what their child is thinking and doing.

Defaulting to secrecy over pronouns reinforces the message that children cannot trust their parents about gender.

It doesn't necessarily mean they will transition fully, but if they did would it not be better for the children to know their parent loves them and supports them no matter what?

Parents don't always support our children by giving them what they want right away.

The kids that ask school to keep it secret must feel like their parents wouldn't accept them as who they are, and that is dangerous

"Accept them as they are" is begging rather a big question - what are they? A loving parent can accept that their child is questioning their gender without agreeing that they need social transition right now.

There is more to social transitioning than using a different name and pronouns. As it is only happening in school I wouldn't even class it as a social transition.
From the article it seems like all the school are doing is calling the child by their preferred name and pronouns, I think they are only looking out for the wellbeing of the child. I do think it ridiculous that they called social services, and I think they should have informed the parents. But I do think the parent is being controlling and trying to stop the child exploring who they are.
I am obviously going to have a differnet view as a parent of a transgender woman. But I have seen first hand the distress felt by my daughter, since she was very young. I also know of two other children who suffered from gender dysphoria as young children/teenagers who didn't go beyond changing their name and pronouns with friends and family who have now gone back to their usual names and pronouns to match the sex they were born with. All I'm trying to say is I think its important for children, whether they have autism or other needs or not, to be able to explore their gender identity if it is something they feel they want to do. With regard to supporting children by giving them what they want straight away, It's not the same as a child pestering for an xbox and not being allowed to get one just because it's what they want, saying no to an xbox is not the same as saying no you can't express your self by using a different name and pronouns.

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 12:57

And no responsibility for the long term outcome either, it's worth adding.

Very true

StephanieSuperpowers · 18/01/2023 12:56

Overseen by teachers who have no expertise in this area whatsoever

And no responsibility for the long term outcome either, it's worth adding. If it all falls apart, it will fall to the appalling transphobes to deal with the fallout of a process that was hidden from them. These teachers will go on their merry way, socially transitioning the next kid without a care in the world.

DoggyDwelling · 18/01/2023 12:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 12:54

No, you don't know that girl. At least not in England.

Because in England she'd have had a massive wait to get into the Tavistock, which has been the only gender clinic for children (and they don't prescribe cross sex hormones for children).

I really do know that girl and everything I say is true.

You are completely wrong about the Tavistock being the only gender clinic in England, I am looking at the website for this gender clinic that is not the Tavistock and is part if an NHS Trust.

Funny how you’ll unquestioningly believe the illogical, yet refuse to believe actual fact.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 12:53

littlelid · 18/01/2023 12:45

I want to understand it I just feel like everytime I want to ask a question I might upset someone if I ask it in the wrong way.

I can absolutely understand that.
That's why if you don't follow the party line, you get shouted at and called a transphobe (see upthread for a live-action version).

The best thing you can do is ask questions and do research. Be wary of who is telling you something and why. Why don't they talk about the downsides of transition? Why are detransitioners banished? Why are parents being kept out of the loop and kids told that everyone hates them? Why are the studies that are relied on to show something usually not show that at all? Why do you think the pharmaceutical industry is so strongly behind most of this? (££$$)

None of it makes sense and you're not allowed to talk about it without abuse.

Join the feminism board if you want to know more, and be prepared for finding out more than you ever wished to know about how deep this goes.

Here's a good book about it - Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality by Helen Joyce

Good luck.

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 12:53

This has parallels to a gay child coming out to a teacher, and asking them not to inform their homophobic parents at home. Here, a child comes out as trans, and asks the school not to inform their transphobic parents at home.

No. As has been explained many times already, it's not just 'coming out' but beginning a process of Social Transition, which the Cass report highlights is not a neutral act and may have many serious and unintended consequences.

Overseen by teachers who have no expertise in this area whatsoever

lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 12:52

What is a transphobic home environment?

How do you define trans?

Is a transphobic home environment one where the adult says it's impossible to change sex and there is no wrong way to be a boy or a girl and you are perfect just as you are?

StephanieSuperpowers · 18/01/2023 12:50

So you think going along with something which is literally untrue and can never be true, is not harmful?

I really struggle with parents doing this. How are kids supposed to cope with the world where they are encouraged to believe something that isn't true and see anyone who isn't colluding in that belief as an enemy who wants to destroy them? Surely we should be trying to help children who feel this way achieve a measure of acceptance of the reality that you are the sex you are but for most purposes, you can live as you choose. But no, if you were born male you won't be able to give birth no matter what you believe or do, and if you were born female you will never be able to produce sperm, regardless of whether you might like to.

I feel bad talking in this way, I might add. I know the poster who told her story is speaking in good faith but since she volunteered the information and associated assumptions/attitudes/beliefs, I suppose it's OK to tease it out.

sensechec · 18/01/2023 12:50

fUNNYfACE36 · 18/01/2023 08:56

Yabu.The school are going along with using the name and pronouns the child prefers.Do you not think they should do this?

No!

HandScreen · 18/01/2023 12:49

DFSsale · 18/01/2023 09:08

I would be furious if a school hid something so important about my child. Surely parents have to take the lead on how to manage gender distress in their own children?
Schools should be supportive of the family not going against them.

This has parallels to a gay child coming out to a teacher, and asking them not to inform their homophobic parents at home. Here, a child comes out as trans, and asks the school not to inform their transphobic parents at home.

Having a homophobic or transphobic home environment can be very dangerous for a gay or trans child, and they deserve to have a safe place/a safe adult a school to confide in.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 12:49

No paperwork, from Stonewall, Mermaids or anyone else claims they can.

So you’ve inspected every single resource provided by the numerous trans organisations that have embedded themselves into schools have you? Their relationship with the truth is rather shaken so I wouldn’t be so sure.

Oddly, many schools are very secretive about the materials they buy in from these organisations and won’t share them with the parents. Rather odd for a school that normally wants to involve parents in everything. Our school used to offer maths lessons and all sorts of demonstrations but on this topic they refuse to let parents even see what they are teaching the kids. A bit of a red flag.

In your inspection you must have seen some very ‘interesting’ materials. Did you come across the infamous ‘dice game’ where kids roll a dice with body parts including genitals listed and then have to come up with ‘activities’ you can do with the various body parts, like anus and mouth? That was a doozy.

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 12:49

Mermaids, by it's own testimony in court, has no medical expertise.

So quite who these experts are I don't know.

There's a lot of misplaced trust here.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 12:48

lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 12:46

Did you miss the part where this poster explained how she approached the appropriate professionals for support?

The problem here is who are the appropriate professionals?

Tavistock has been closed down for good reason.

Mermaids and Stonewall promote acceptance without exception.

Sorry posted too soon.

Schools and other bodies including the NHS have bought into this ideology.

No one has defined any terms.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/01/2023 12:48

Meaningofthesea · 18/01/2023 12:43

Did you miss the part where this poster explained how she approached the appropriate professionals for support?

No, why would you think that? The point is that accepting that you can be born in the wrong body does away with the need for seeking out professional help, doesn't it? It was the best solution for her child to become a trans woman and make the most of a life lived with dysmorphia - but that shouldn't be the starting point.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 12:46

Did you miss the part where this poster explained how she approached the appropriate professionals for support?

The problem here is who are the appropriate professionals?

Tavistock has been closed down for good reason.

Mermaids and Stonewall promote acceptance without exception.

CampervanKween · 18/01/2023 12:46

I can't find where to vote but YANBU

No child is born in the wrong body.

No human has ever changed sex.

nothingcomestonothing · 18/01/2023 12:46

Too slow sorry , FourTea said it better and quicker than me!

littlelid · 18/01/2023 12:45

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 12:40

And people who say the wrong thing are threatened. So it not surprising that people get scared of discussing it.

I want to understand it I just feel like everytime I want to ask a question I might upset someone if I ask it in the wrong way.