Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 13:57

I love when these threads come to light. Because it shuts down those who continually state 'only a minority would say this is wrong', 'the majority of the UK are fully supportive of Stonewall and Mermaids' and 'you are all old and going to die out soon'.

Which have been used to have threads moved to the 'feminist' board, or deleted or just used to tell posters to STFU.

But there are so many people who are now becoming aware of the issues and are wanting to discuss it. So that they understand what is happening and how it has got so far. I was leafletting the other day to raise awareness of this petition (which is so very important as it will force the discussion about strengthening the language around the equality act) and the number of people who told me all about it, and that they were not feminists but were now well aware of different aspects was very heartening.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4722618-petition-to-update-the-equality-act-thread-2?reply=123188586

This also included men - young and old. Not just women. The UK population is becoming more and more aware of the conflicts that some of the demands from a particular group of the population.

I know of two families where the schools transitioned their daughters when the parents had no idea that the school had done so. One was explicitly against the recommendation of one daughter's mental health clinician.

This is happening despite the numerous posters who have come onto these threads and denied it, and the numerous posters who will in the future.

It is happening, just as that article highlights and parents are right to be very concerned.

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 13:57

Sex Reassignment Surgery Market size was worth more than USD 623 million in 2022 and is projected to register over 11.5% CAGR between 2023 to 2032.

I get that the money aspect is playing a role, of course.

But it seems to me there's more at play than that. The silencing of debate, the capture of key organisations, the coaching of children online.

It feels like something bigger.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 13:56

@Mumof3daughters16 I hope I have not laid into you, even if I have disagreed with you about schools. People have different experiences and there are still real disagreements about how best to manage this for young people. We are all doing our best!

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 13:53

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 13:34

I had no idea about a video. But my daughter is in her late 20s now. By the time she started on hormones she was 21. She had 2 suicide attempts at the age of 12 and 13, before telling me. It was terrifying.
Thank you for being kind, some people seem to have laid into me a bit. It's as if they think I was happy to have a child in crisis. I most definitely was not! But it wasn't my body, or my decisions to make.
We did so much research on everything before hand. I did express my anxieties about the hormones, and the surgery. I had severe anxiety about what could go wrong.

I'm sorry you've had to go through that. It sounds horrifying. I can completely understand why parents go along with anything their child wants after finding out that they're suicidal, it's a parent's worst nightmare. I've got a 5-year-old boy that wants to wear pink and play with girls (which is obviously all fine with me, I've bought him a very fetching pink hat and scarf to wear to school) and it's terrifying that he might be influenced by well-meaning teachers.

Out of curiosity, how did your child find out that being trans was a thing? Because obviously 15 years ago it wasn't everywhere like it is now.
Do you think it may have had a link to being on the autistic spectrum (if they are) or being same-sex attracted? Did it come out before or after puberty? Were they "very online"?
Because in the recent past, the main people that transitioned were gay men and I'm wondering if that was true for you. Nowadays it's mostly girls that transition and not always for the same reasons as the previous cohort.
Ignore me if you don't feel comfortable sharing.

CountZacular · 18/01/2023 13:52

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 13:47

a political agenda.

And who is driving it, is the question we should all be asking? And why?

Sex Reassignment Surgery Market size was worth more than USD 623 million in 2022 and is projected to register over 11.5% CAGR between 2023 to 2032.

www.gminsights.com/industry-analysis/sex-reassignment-surgery-market/amp

That’s without the medical interventions and psychotherapy that goes along with it.

Lilavanblue · 18/01/2023 13:52

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 11:11

Except there is zero evidence that this is what's happening.

The numbers don't support it - given what we know about the adult trans population, it follows since all trans adults were once children that a similar proportion of children are trans. So why are we shocked that more of them are realising that at a time when there is much more visibility of trans issues?

The evidence doesn't support it - given that the only study claiming this phenomenon is absolute nonsense that relies entirely on parents self-reporting that their child's gender dysphoria came out of the blue (as if parents of queer kids haven't been unaware of their children's struggles for centuries).

The numbers don’t support it?
The teenage daughter of a friend said there were several girls who identified as nonbinary or trans in her form group - way more than the 0.5 % mentioned on this thread.
I‘ve also seen several threads/ comments on this forum here whole groups of school mates identified out of their gender/ biological sex.

Meaningofthesea · 18/01/2023 13:51

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 13:34

I had no idea about a video. But my daughter is in her late 20s now. By the time she started on hormones she was 21. She had 2 suicide attempts at the age of 12 and 13, before telling me. It was terrifying.
Thank you for being kind, some people seem to have laid into me a bit. It's as if they think I was happy to have a child in crisis. I most definitely was not! But it wasn't my body, or my decisions to make.
We did so much research on everything before hand. I did express my anxieties about the hormones, and the surgery. I had severe anxiety about what could go wrong.

I think you've been courageous in sharing your experience in this thread. Good wishes to you and your family

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 13:47

a political agenda.

And who is driving it, is the question we should all be asking? And why?

GPS · 18/01/2023 13:45

I find it so reassuring to read intelligent, sane responses on this thread. We are being coerced into silence on this subject, as I believe our children are being coerced into questioning their gender. More parents, people, should not be afraid to call this madness what it is - a political agenda.

whereaw · 18/01/2023 13:43

@Mumof3daughters16 that must have been an awful thing to go through.

Do you worry that more and more children will go through similar the more we push the trans idea?

Redbushteaforme · 18/01/2023 13:41

YANBU OP. It is terrible how teenage girls are being encouraged to think they are in the wrong body when, in my experience, a lot of the problems stem from difficulties accepting their body changes due to puberty and/or the fact that teenage girls are subjected to awful pressure in terms of body image and the effects of porn and/or because they are autistic and think that changing their gender is the answer to the problem of them feeling that they "don't fit in". The trend is there for teenage boys too.

I accept that there may be a vanishingly small number of teenagers for whom transitioning, after thorough professional investigation, may be appropriate but we are actually seeing much higher numbers at the moment which is truly frightening in terms of future implications for them.

They need proper support, not to be swept along by the latest trend of telling them that they are indeed in the wrong body without any proper medical or psychological investigation. Unfortunately, I'm in Scotland and if it wasn't for the intervention of the UK Government, it would now be legal for teenagers of 16 years and older to change gender by self-IDing, with no professional or parental involvement or consent. The SNP and Greens have a great deal to answer to on this, and I speak as a former SNP activist and SNP/Green voter.

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 13:34

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 13:18

I would rather have a transgender daughter than a dead son.

And that line right there is why parents are terrified to question anything to do with trans.

Did you realise that children are being coached online to say that they're suicidal? I can't find it now but there's a video of a doctor in America or Canada that literally tells kids to say they're suicidal to convince their parents to do what they want.

I'm glad that your child is happy with their choices but you don't know that they wouldn't have come out the other side anyway.
I hope you and they are aware of the side effects of the drugs and surgery they've had.

I had no idea about a video. But my daughter is in her late 20s now. By the time she started on hormones she was 21. She had 2 suicide attempts at the age of 12 and 13, before telling me. It was terrifying.
Thank you for being kind, some people seem to have laid into me a bit. It's as if they think I was happy to have a child in crisis. I most definitely was not! But it wasn't my body, or my decisions to make.
We did so much research on everything before hand. I did express my anxieties about the hormones, and the surgery. I had severe anxiety about what could go wrong.

CountZacular · 18/01/2023 13:34

This has parallels to a gay child coming out to a teacher, and asking them not to inform their homophobic parents at home. Here, a child comes out as trans, and asks the school not to inform their transphobic parents at home.

Aside from the fact that it really isn’t the case (where in the UK is this happening exactly?), if a child expresses that their parents might hurt them because of any reason the school has a safeguarding responsibility to inform appropriate services. Not just quietly affirm.

What if the child confided their parents would be abusive if they found out their grades were low and asked the teacher not to say anything? Should the teacher just shrug their shoulders and no longer send out reports? Why would one case be a clear cut teacher says nothing and just affirms the child’s wishes and the other not raise serious red flags?

And then where there is a real irreversible risk to the child (as is the case with trans). What if the teacher found out that a 14 year old girl was having regular unprotected sex. Again, just affirm the decision, keep quiet and let the consequences play out without notifying parents or authorities?

FOJN · 18/01/2023 13:32

But if a child tells you they feel like they are the opposite sex, and want to be called a different name and pronouns, and you tell them it's stupid, wrong, or you don't believe them, that can cause harm to them.

It's not a choice between unquestioning affirmation or telling a gender questioning child they are stupid, wrong and you don't believe them. Both of these approaches would fail a child.

nothingcomestonothing · 18/01/2023 13:31

If they hadn't helped her, she would be dead. I would rather have a transgender daughter than a dead son.

This is a line pushed by some vested interests which is not supported by evidence. Young people who are struggling with their gender identity are not at higher risk of suicide. I am truly sorry that you and your DC were in so much distress. I am truly sorry that the people and agencies which are there to help and support us when we struggle, are captured by a damaging ideology. I wish you both well.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 13:27

I don't have a male child anymore. She is a woman.

To be honest, all things being equal I would rather have a physically intact and healthy child of either sex, but there's mental health to consider and anyway it's not entirely our choice, especially as our kids become adults. And none of us parents have a blueprint for this.

I have mixed feelings about "trusting the professionals", they don't all agree with each other for starters. Plus new knowledge is coming in all the time, what seemed like the best way to do things five years ago may look different now, and different again in five years time when the outcome data starts to arrive from young transitioners now.

But hey ho, we parents can only do our best with the knowledge we have at the time. And getting the best possible professional help for your child can't have been easy. I'm glad she is doing well now. Flowers

DoggyDwelling · 18/01/2023 13:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AgathaAllAlong · 18/01/2023 13:25

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 13:17

Children might ‘want’ all sorts of things that may cause them harm - we don’t usually agree and let them crack on. It is our job as parents to look after our children and these schools are removing that parental right.

In agreeing that a girl is really a bit, what message is the school sending to that child? See the many other excellent comments explaining why use of pronouns is part if a process of social transition that is not harmless.

The children in that article had all hit puberty. And actually yeah, at that age, I think that social experimenting with self expression is fine. Loads of people change their names - I did, but this was way back before gender ideology, I just changed it to something I though was cooler.

But my point wasn't actually that affirming gender ideology is fine, my point was that the geneder ideology cat is out of the bag and kids have already latched onto it. It is a structural problem - teachers and schools would make the news and fired for being transphobic if they refused. We cannot as parents demand that teachers call Esme by her name, if she wants to be called Lex. I understand why teachers use the name the student likes, and not the name that parents insist on using just because they chose it. Probably a better solution would be to provide kids with easier 'outs' so that they can identify back with their real sex after the phase is over. Banning self chosen names and pronouns from school will not achieve this, though.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/01/2023 13:23

Yes, one of the things Richard Bell said was that children presenting at the Tavistock started to arrive with a rehearsed script accessed from online groups and delivered to get what they wanted rather than what they needed.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 13:18

I would rather have a transgender daughter than a dead son.

And that line right there is why parents are terrified to question anything to do with trans.

Did you realise that children are being coached online to say that they're suicidal? I can't find it now but there's a video of a doctor in America or Canada that literally tells kids to say they're suicidal to convince their parents to do what they want.

I'm glad that your child is happy with their choices but you don't know that they wouldn't have come out the other side anyway.
I hope you and they are aware of the side effects of the drugs and surgery they've had.

StephanieSuperpowers · 18/01/2023 13:17

It is very concerning to see people going along with the idea that if you don't affirm someone thinking that they are a different sex to the one they are born, they will definitely commit suicide. It's a very manipulative statement. It may be true in some cases, but is definitely not true in all, although I gather many kids are encouraged to present it in this way to their parents in order to compel compliance.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 13:17

AgathaAllAlong · 18/01/2023 13:13

I think the headline is misleading, too. The children WANT to be refered to as the opposite gender. What should teachers say in this climate - no? They would lose their jobs.

Children might ‘want’ all sorts of things that may cause them harm - we don’t usually agree and let them crack on. It is our job as parents to look after our children and these schools are removing that parental right.

In agreeing that a girl is really a bit, what message is the school sending to that child? See the many other excellent comments explaining why use of pronouns is part if a process of social transition that is not harmless.

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 13:16

YANBU OP

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 13:14

If they hadn't helped her, she would be dead. I would rather have a transgender daughter than a dead son.

Jesus but Susie Green has a lot to answer for. Isn't this parroted directly from her words?

Anyway, I'm sorry you fell for this, which isn't true. Transitioning may or may not work out for your child in the longer run. I hope they will not suffer long term effects from any treatment they've had.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 13:14

So pleased to see this discussion happening openly. We all need to question and probe - ourselves, professionals and schools acting with supposed confidence yet zero expertise in this complex area. The stranglehold of #nodebate is over.

Hear hear.

Just to expand on some facts about a misconception that a previous commenter had. The Tavistock was not the only NHS gender clinic in the country, there are actually 8.

There may be waiting lists for some but the person I know got a first appointment within a couple of months of having the initial wondering that she might be trans and then was on cross sex hormones a month later. This wasn’t very long ago.

Maybe it is a bit of a postcode lottery but let’s not assume that all gender distressed young people have to wait years for an appointment because they don’t.

There are also three new major clinics being built as I understand and apparently a hospital that will focus on trans surgery particularly phalloplasty which has an extremely high (something like 70/80%) complication and failure rate.

There is also the Gendergp, a private clinic (there are a number of other private clinics as well) that I think is still operating despite being owned by two GPs that were either struck off or long term suspended for giving puberty blockers and cross sex hormones to kids without proper assessment or monitoring.