Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 14:49

When a child tells us that they are unsafe at home, we should believe them.

By applying appropriate safeguarding protocols, not secretly transitioning them

HandScreen · 18/01/2023 14:47

StephanieSuperpowers · 18/01/2023 09:59

I find it pretty offensive that policies are based on the assumption that children need protection from ‘abusive’ parents

It's extremely offensive. If there are safeguarding concerns around parents that teachers have observed, they need to raise them in the standard way. If that's not the case, they can't just go off on a solo run and socially transition a child on the assumption that the parents are somehow abusive.

When a child tells us that they are unsafe at home, we should believe them.

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 14:47

Thank you x

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 14:46

No not you! I do not take offense to someone having their own opinion!

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 14:44

Meaningofthesea · 18/01/2023 14:32

In the recent census, there were equal numbers of trans men and trans women, which seems at odds with your assertation that 'adult transitioners are mostly male'.

Do you think the census data is accurate? As many trans people were boasting about filling it in incorrectly, using gender rather than sex. Plus there were 48K TW, 48K TM and 118K who said their gender was different from their sex but didn't expand on that. How can anything of substance be drawn from that without knowing about the other 118K identified? Also, 30K are non-binary so could be male or female.

The census question on gender identity was a voluntary question asked of those aged 16 years and over. The question asked “Is the gender you identify with the same as your sex registered at birth?”.
Overall, 45.7 million (94.0% of the population aged 16 years and over) answered the question.
The question was voluntary and was only asked of people aged 16 years and over. People were asked “Is the gender you identify with the same as your sex registered at birth?”, and had the option of selecting either “Yes”, or selecting “No” and writing in their gender identity.
Across England and Wales, there were responses from 45.7 million people (94.0% of the population aged 16 years and over).
A total of 45.4 million (93.5%) answered “Yes”, indicating that their gender identity was the same as their sex registered at birth.
A total of 262,000 people (0.5%) answered “No”, indicating that their gender identity was different from their sex registered at birth. Within this group:
118,000 (0.24%) answered “No” but did not provide a write-in response
48,000 (0.10%) identified as a trans man
48,000 (0.10%) identified as a trans woman
30,000 (0.06%) identified as non-binary
18,000 (0.04%) wrote in a different gender identity

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 14:43

whereaw · 18/01/2023 13:43

@Mumof3daughters16 that must have been an awful thing to go through.

Do you worry that more and more children will go through similar the more we push the trans idea?

Exactly this.

The well worn line "I would rather have a transgender daughter than a dead son." pushed through the media by Susie Green, the unqualified woman who ran Mermaids - has a lot to answer for.

I hear kids trot versions of this out a lot now. If you are constantly telling kids that one group are going to kill themselves - what do we think is going to happen?

So here is a question - if this is the case - how is it not a mental illness?
No child is born in the wrong body. It may be that someone cannot accept reality to the point where they feel suicidal - but that doesn't mean that a person can change sex. As I child I would often have suicidal feelings because I wasn't white like my classmates who were bullying me. It didn't make me white on the inside.

The NHS should not be putting healthy children on puberty blockers. The schools should not be socially transitioning children. Adults should not be affirming the identities of children who can't cope with reality.

Gender identity is what exactly - still no one can define it.

OP posts:
StephanieSuperpowers · 18/01/2023 14:43

Younger girls do it because it's a mask.

I think this is why so many older women are the ones talking about this. We all had female puberty to live through, we know it's so, so hard and can see that, from the point of view of enduring the reaction to your changing body, it's infinitely harder now than it was. I wouldn't like to be a young girl now and I can fully imagine wanting to identify out of the porn soaked hellscape that it appears to be.

Meaningofthesea · 18/01/2023 14:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Nonsense

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 14:40

@FatGirlSwim thank you x

YouJustDoYou · 18/01/2023 14:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 14:38

@whereaw it was awful, and at times very dark.
I've never really thought of it like that, pushing the trans idea, so you've kind of made me think!
I do think more children are aware of gender identity now than 12/13 years ago. And I do think for a lot of them it is maybe just an exploration, or possibly trying to fit in. My youngest is 13, and in her year at school there are several children who identify as the opposite gender, or non binary. There are also lots of children who say they are gay, lesbian, bisexual, pansexual, the list goes on. When my oldest was at school, she was the only one that she or we knew off, and non binary wasn't ever mentioned. She didn't want anyone at school knowing, and this was quite distressing for her as she felt she had to join in with the typical male activities, and pretending to like things like football when all she really wanted to do was go clothes shopping and putting on make up. As being transgender at the time was very rare, the thought of it as a phase was never mentioned.
I can't think of the right word, but it seems that being transgender or non-binary is becoming more 'something', not cool or popular, but something that a lot of children are seeing as normal to be, and making it harder for parents and health professionals to tell if it's a phase or a genuine crisis. And because its almost become normal for children, they are not afraid to use a different name and pronouns. So yes, I can see that side of the debate, and I think more children will think/say they are transgender, but not necessarily go through the process.
I'm wondering how I would feel if it was like this back then, would I have seen it as a phase, as so many children now are saying they are transgender, and gender identity is talked about constantly?

Meaningofthesea · 18/01/2023 14:32

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 14:30

Instead, referrals in the most recent year were in the region of 3000. About one child out of every five thousand. And of course only a very small proportion of those (it was about 6% in 2018 iirc) are prescribed puberty blockers.

if those numbers are correct (and we know how tricky the numbers are), can you explain why there is a vast increase in the number of girls identifying as trans compared with the number of boys?

Previously there was a very small number of young people being referred to gender clinics and they were mostly boys. Older adult transitioners are mostly male, so a huge increase in young females that is not mirrored by an increase in older females indicates a huge change in the proportion of each sex that are trans identifying.

Why would that be? It doesn’t support the ‘greater awareness and acceptance’ argument.

In the recent census, there were equal numbers of trans men and trans women, which seems at odds with your assertation that 'adult transitioners are mostly male'.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 14:30

Instead, referrals in the most recent year were in the region of 3000. About one child out of every five thousand. And of course only a very small proportion of those (it was about 6% in 2018 iirc) are prescribed puberty blockers.

if those numbers are correct (and we know how tricky the numbers are), can you explain why there is a vast increase in the number of girls identifying as trans compared with the number of boys?

Previously there was a very small number of young people being referred to gender clinics and they were mostly boys. Older adult transitioners are mostly male, so a huge increase in young females that is not mirrored by an increase in older females indicates a huge change in the proportion of each sex that are trans identifying.

Why would that be? It doesn’t support the ‘greater awareness and acceptance’ argument.

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 14:24

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 14:21

This is a very good question. It feels like there is something big and powerful at play here.

So many governments have been persuaded to set aside logic and women’s concerns and actual harm to women and children and bring in laws to perpetuate this. But why? There seems to be an unusual amount of influence compared to any other group.

The medical market is huge which will play a part but is not the whole story. There are £millions being made available for LGBTQ organisations which is another part but it still feels like there is more to it.

This is something we need to find out more about.

Have you considered that maybe it’s the tin foil industry looking to increase sales to milliners?

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 14:23

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 14:13

You know the plural of anecdote isn't data right?

Look at the number of referrals to gender clinics. It is no where near to 0.5% of all children. If it were, you'd be talking somewhere in the region of 75,000 children.

Instead, referrals in the most recent year were in the region of 3000. About one child out of every five thousand. And of course only a very small proportion of those (it was about 6% in 2018 iirc) are prescribed puberty blockers.

So you believe that only those who are registered at gender clinics are those to be considered at risk of harm?

Is that what you are saying? That it is quite ok because the tip of the iceberg is small at the moment?

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 14:21

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 13:57

Sex Reassignment Surgery Market size was worth more than USD 623 million in 2022 and is projected to register over 11.5% CAGR between 2023 to 2032.

I get that the money aspect is playing a role, of course.

But it seems to me there's more at play than that. The silencing of debate, the capture of key organisations, the coaching of children online.

It feels like something bigger.

This is a very good question. It feels like there is something big and powerful at play here.

So many governments have been persuaded to set aside logic and women’s concerns and actual harm to women and children and bring in laws to perpetuate this. But why? There seems to be an unusual amount of influence compared to any other group.

The medical market is huge which will play a part but is not the whole story. There are £millions being made available for LGBTQ organisations which is another part but it still feels like there is more to it.

This is something we need to find out more about.

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 14:13

Lilavanblue · 18/01/2023 13:52

The numbers don’t support it?
The teenage daughter of a friend said there were several girls who identified as nonbinary or trans in her form group - way more than the 0.5 % mentioned on this thread.
I‘ve also seen several threads/ comments on this forum here whole groups of school mates identified out of their gender/ biological sex.

You know the plural of anecdote isn't data right?

Look at the number of referrals to gender clinics. It is no where near to 0.5% of all children. If it were, you'd be talking somewhere in the region of 75,000 children.

Instead, referrals in the most recent year were in the region of 3000. About one child out of every five thousand. And of course only a very small proportion of those (it was about 6% in 2018 iirc) are prescribed puberty blockers.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 14:10

As it is only happening in school I wouldn't even class it as a social transition.

Well, that's your view as a parent, but as an expert paediatritian Dr Cass did not agree.

And also think bout the wider context. The name (etc) change is imposed not just on the staff but on all the other children too. If you had not been told, are other children expected to keep secrets from you too? What about their own parents? Unless your child has no friends secrecy spreads beyond school.

It's not the same as a child pestering for an xbox and not being allowed to get one just because it's what they want

Well no, it is not the same. It is much more risky and complex, and not a decision that a school should override you to make. You're the parent. You felt it was best to let your children to experiment with names. Great! But what if the school had referred your children behind your back, on the assumption that you were pushing your other children towards transition?

FatGirlSwim · 18/01/2023 14:09

mumof3daughters16 I’m so sorry that people have been so prejudiced and patronising towards you on this thread.

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 14:08

Lilavanblue · 18/01/2023 13:52

The numbers don’t support it?
The teenage daughter of a friend said there were several girls who identified as nonbinary or trans in her form group - way more than the 0.5 % mentioned on this thread.
I‘ve also seen several threads/ comments on this forum here whole groups of school mates identified out of their gender/ biological sex.

In my own teen's group of friends there were 5 out of the 7 friends that had declared trans identities by age 14. Two girls had convinced other friends to be the delivery point for their binders.

I also have another friend with a daughter who went to the same school but was not part of that group who declared a trans identity.

That does not include the other friends and colleagues with daughters with trans identities. (People who I was friends and colleagues with before their children declared trans identities).

The numbers never quite stack up the way some posters wish them to be perceived. Because the issues are most of the teens I know that have declared trans identities are lesbian females with significant mental health co-morbities.

When you start looking at the rate in this segment, you begin to understand the concern. And you also then ask questions about just why research into this segment has been either non-existent or very slow in even admitting there was indeed an issue.

Even the authors of the Dutch Protocol recognised there is a significant issue here and that their treatment plan is not necessarily going to work for this segment. And by the way, the Dutch Protocol which was seen as the best treatment plan has been misapplied significantly in the current treatment plans which are constantly pushing 'affirming only' treatment. Something that needs to be discussed in the coming 'conversion therapy' bill that was resurrected this week.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4722645-kemi-to-write-to-all-tory-mps-to-insist-that-a-ban-on-trans-conversion-therapy-must-not-criminalise-parents

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 14:05

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 13:14

So pleased to see this discussion happening openly. We all need to question and probe - ourselves, professionals and schools acting with supposed confidence yet zero expertise in this complex area. The stranglehold of #nodebate is over.

Hear hear.

Just to expand on some facts about a misconception that a previous commenter had. The Tavistock was not the only NHS gender clinic in the country, there are actually 8.

There may be waiting lists for some but the person I know got a first appointment within a couple of months of having the initial wondering that she might be trans and then was on cross sex hormones a month later. This wasn’t very long ago.

Maybe it is a bit of a postcode lottery but let’s not assume that all gender distressed young people have to wait years for an appointment because they don’t.

There are also three new major clinics being built as I understand and apparently a hospital that will focus on trans surgery particularly phalloplasty which has an extremely high (something like 70/80%) complication and failure rate.

There is also the Gendergp, a private clinic (there are a number of other private clinics as well) that I think is still operating despite being owned by two GPs that were either struck off or long term suspended for giving puberty blockers and cross sex hormones to kids without proper assessment or monitoring.

The only NHS gender clinic for children was the Tavistock. It had a site in London and in Leeds. That's it.

I think you may be confused with gender clinics for adults.

Lilavanblue · 18/01/2023 14:04

FrostyFifi · 18/01/2023 11:14

Of course what's going on amongst young people at present is social contagion. This literally wasn't a thing previously, what else could it be?

And of course dysphoria is a mental illness, again what else could you call such extreme levels of mental distress about your own healthy functioning body?

And many transsexuals acknowledge this and clearly state that they know they are not the opposite sex and that they undertake risky and painful surgeries to attempt to alleviate this distress. (I dont necessarily agree with this as its imo no different from people who are distressed at not being amputees but there it is.)

TRAs and straight middle aged fetishists have created a whole new thing which is causing massive damage to women's rights, genuine transsexuals and putting children in danger.

Agree with this.
From my own school years, I remember a couple of openly gay kids, I remember gender non-conforming kids, sensitive boys and girls who were into football.
I also remember the discomfort caused by my own body beginning to change (earlier than my peers‘). I remember some other girls developing eating disorders.
I do wonder if any of those teenagers thought they were in the wrong body when it came to their biological sex.

FatGirlSwim · 18/01/2023 14:03

Mumof3daughters16 · 18/01/2023 13:10

I really hope no one you are close to ever has any gender identity issues.
I didn't help my daughter think there was something wrong with her body, not for one second. I had sleepless nights for years, worrying about it all. It took me a long time to accept it, but if I hadn't of been there for her to talk too, to comfort her, and do so much research with her, she wouldn't be here, male or female. I had counselling myself, as in the beginning I thought I had done something wrong myself to make her feel this way.
People constantly try to be someone they are not, act how they think they should act to fit in with society. Not everyone feels they can 'just be', whether they are child or adult.
My daughter hasn't been let down by medical professionals. She had months and months of counselling before any decisions were made about blockers and hormones later down the line. If they hadn't helped her, she would be dead. I would rather have a transgender daughter than a dead son.
The hard path finished a long time ago. She is happy and healthy and that is all I want for all of my children

You are a wonderful parent and your daughter is very lucky. I’m so pleased she is thriving. I imagine I would find it very difficult and be unsure what to do if I had a trans child, but I hope I would be half as accepting and supportive as you have been. I’m sure that’s been instrumental in the positive outcome for your daughter.

CountZacular · 18/01/2023 14:01

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 13:57

Sex Reassignment Surgery Market size was worth more than USD 623 million in 2022 and is projected to register over 11.5% CAGR between 2023 to 2032.

I get that the money aspect is playing a role, of course.

But it seems to me there's more at play than that. The silencing of debate, the capture of key organisations, the coaching of children online.

It feels like something bigger.

I agree there’s probably something else (and I worry something rather sinister) but I do think the money aspect is responsible for the speed in the way this has expanded. I watched Dopesick last year and I couldn’t help note the parallels of getting patients hooked on lifelong drugs to make money.

However I do suspect big-pharma have piggybacked on this rather than caused it.

onyttig · 18/01/2023 13:59

FatGirlSwim · 18/01/2023 12:24

I would want them to redirect confidentiality for a child who is Gillick competent, as they absolutely should. Children have the right to see a counsellor without parents knowing etc.

Being autistic doesn’t mean that someone lacks capacity, either.

Are schools set up to (a) assess this and (b) make the decisions about what should and should not be shared in relation to gender identity?

Counsellors have different professional expertise and skill sets to teachers. Miss Smith, drama teacher and form teacher to 9F should not be socially transitioning a child. No matter how well meaning she might be. Neither should the SENCO. Or the HoY. Or even the school nurse. The school nurse should be contacting the child’s GP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread