Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 17:24

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 14:10

As it is only happening in school I wouldn't even class it as a social transition.

Well, that's your view as a parent, but as an expert paediatritian Dr Cass did not agree.

And also think bout the wider context. The name (etc) change is imposed not just on the staff but on all the other children too. If you had not been told, are other children expected to keep secrets from you too? What about their own parents? Unless your child has no friends secrecy spreads beyond school.

It's not the same as a child pestering for an xbox and not being allowed to get one just because it's what they want

Well no, it is not the same. It is much more risky and complex, and not a decision that a school should override you to make. You're the parent. You felt it was best to let your children to experiment with names. Great! But what if the school had referred your children behind your back, on the assumption that you were pushing your other children towards transition?

"And also think bout the wider context. The name (etc) change is imposed not just on the staff but on all the other children too. If you had not been told, are other children expected to keep secrets from you too? What about their own parents? Unless your child has no friends secrecy spreads beyond school."

Yes, this is very important. My teen's girlfriend was NB and had transitioned at school (not school records) but had not told their parents. Who absolutely loved and supported their daughter.

It is not just the individual's friends, it becomes everyone's issue.

"Well, that's your view as a parent, but as an expert paediatritian Dr Cass did not agree."

And Dr Cass is right. By socially transitioning a child, that may lock them into a future that for so many reasons, that child or young person feels unable to change course from.

We have even seen this happening in adults. Ritchie, a male detransitioner has reported that the clinic would have discharged him if he did not go through surgery as they felt they had done all they could for him. He was a very vulnerable patient and ended up feeling pressured down a course of treatment that wasn't right for him.

There are so many unknowns. And a cohort of young female teenaged transitioners that need urgent research and care that is tailored to them. NOT treatment plans designed for males and ones that may be shaped by mature aged males and what they say their needs were for children and teens. I question even this because why are so many mature males seeking to put into place such harmful treatments for young children and teens?

There are so many questions that need to be asked. And I thank every parent that is asking these questions. Uncomfortable questions though they may be.

There should never be a situation where the school transitions any person without their parent's approval, and if there is abuse issues, they need to be referred onto the appropriate people.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 18/01/2023 17:12

littlelid · 18/01/2023 09:37

Is there a section for trans hate?!

This is an issue of child safeguarding, not 'hate' toward either that child or anyone else.

It's no super-human feat of ingenuity to figure out why encouraging children to keep secrets from their parents - and for schools to collude with this - is a bad and dangerous idea.

This isn't just a question of sexuality, or the child wearing what they want, or even getting a tattoo, which although leaving a permanent mark on the body is likely to do little else. It's about a situation which can lead to a medicalized pathway, potentially leaving that child with sexual issues, lack of ability to experience orgasm, infertility, and possibly major health issues, some of which we might not even know about yet. And it's irreversible. This is forever.

The child is ASD, and there's a recognised correlation between young people on the spectrum and F2M transition. There is also no evidence that said transition even alleviates their distress. What is becoming evident is that numbers of detransitioners are growing exponentially.

You're questioning mothers who are afraid for their children and don't want that for them, or are concerned that transition is being jumped on as a first resort and without their consent? Really? Why?

IcakethereforeIam · 18/01/2023 17:02

Upthread, someone confidently asserted that transitioning wouldn't be more acceptable to bigoted families than having a gay child! I'll spare their blushes.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 18/01/2023 17:02

They never give an intelligent answer to any questions either - it’s just “tra la-la, get back in your box you evil bigot”. Deflect, deflect, deflect - every single time

Yep. They can't answer the most basic of questions or give clear definitions because it's all illogical, completely contradictory, ever changing nonsense.

So all they can do is go on the attack and call us big meanies for having the audacity to point out the huge gaping holes in their feelings based ideology.

Get back in your box ladies. The emperor is stunning and brave. #beeeeekind.

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 17:02

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 15:16

The majority of women in the UK support trans rights.

We do, which includes the rights to evidence-based suppport and to safeguarding. Secretly transitioning children at school - even socially - is not safeguarding.

So much of this debate is about others trying to shut down discussion and debate.

The reality is that there is such a lack of evidence for the current push for affirming only and it is of great concern. And the safeguarding issues become very clear however, the lack of safeguarding is hidden beside 'it is transphobic to question it'. Like that trans swimming session that was a hot topic of discussion. Where parents expressing concern that young people and children were going to be in a swimming pool with much older people and those young people and children could not have a parent with them poolside was considered the very height of transphobia.

Yet, just after that thread finished, we discovered this report.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/oversight-of-out-of-school-settings-lessons-learnt-from-the-dfe-funded-pilot

Right at the end it lists the most common complaints for out of school activities and Grooming/sexual abuse and Child Exploitation was the second highest risk that the study found was the basis for complaints, third was General safeguarding concerns, fourth was Extremism/radicialisation, fifth was more general safeguarding concerns followed by 'lack of appropriate boundaries' in regards to safeguarding young people.

The reality is that trans people need to be held up to the very same standard of safeguarding protocols for their sex (not their gender) as every one. No exemptions based on 'gender' for safeguarding.

No trans person deserves to have lesser quality of health treatment or lesser quality of safeguarding because some people are ideologically driven.

And you MumOfYoungTransAdult have hit the point very squarely.

"Secretly transitioning children at school - even socially - is not safeguarding."

Yeahrightthen · 18/01/2023 16:50

The right to self-identify. I have no problem with trans people in sports or single-sex spaces.

Nor do most people - so long as they are competing in sports and entering single sex spaces according to the sex they actually are (the one they were registered at birth), not the one they have decided they are.
Luckily the powers above seem to feel the same way as per yesterday in the administering of section 35 to block the proposals of the SNP.

It seems on these threads there is always one side - the vast majority - who give facts, have common sense and engage in intelligent conversation regarding the matter - and the other side who resort to swearing, name calling and trying to bully anyone with an opposing view into a dark corner of the internet where no one can be upset by their discussion of the facts and the reality of what the trans-ideology is doing in regards to safeguarding children and women.

They never give an intelligent answer to any questions either - it’s just “tra la-la, get back in your box you evil bigot”. Deflect, deflect, deflect - every single time.

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 16:45

HandScreen · 18/01/2023 15:49

Yes

Fuck! That is something to see.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 12:52
What is a transphobic home environment?

How do you define trans?

Is a transphobic home environment one where the adult says it's impossible to change sex and there is no wrong way to be a boy or a girl and you are perfect just as you are?

To which

HandScreen Today 15:49 posts

Yes

HandScreen, do you believe that you speak for trans people on this thread?

Whatsnewpussyhat · 18/01/2023 16:43

Still no actual answer to the questions

What is trans?

A clear definition that covers everyone who claims to have one.

What is gender identity?

Without using sex role stereotypes or feelings......

People can self identify as whatever they want. It doesn't change their sex though or entitle males who 'identify as' women access to female only anything.

To identify as something means you know you are not the thing you identity as, so why should everyone else agree you are actually that thing?

It also should not require everyone else to use nonsense language or pretend words like women and lesbian now include male people.

Why do those who want to self identify as having a gender identity need to change their sex marker if sex and gender are two different things?

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 16:40

Well there you have it folks. It's transphobic to state biological fact and to tell your children they are perfect just as they are.

if that's what it means, I'm very happy to own it.

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 16:37

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 18/01/2023 16:23

YABVU for posting here and not in the GC section and extra U for your wildly biased YABU = rainbows are magic. You blatantly don't think you are being U, you don't want to discuss or engage, you are not going to listen to anyone who disagrees with you, you just want to pontificate and those are always the most boring of AIBU posts.

We are all here and ready to read your own opinions on whether schools should or should not be socially transitioning children without their parents expressed consent.

Or are you just going to take the opportunity to shame posters that you disagree with for posting on AIBU where you could have just scrolled on past, but needed to come onto the thread to post this?

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 16:33

IcakethereforeIam · 18/01/2023 16:18

I think the people so quick to level accusations of bigotry, really need to think about the meaning of that word and then think about who the bigots actually are.

Indeed cake. It is just like a poster recently who declared that males screaming slurs and abuse at women who are speaking words in a public space and sometimes those male go further and assault those women, often spitting is also involved these days, is practising 'democracy'. Or to deplatform them. Or to drown out their words so people cannot hear them.

When in reality it is totalitarian to attempt to silence someone you disagree with in this way. Democracy would be to debate and put forth points that show the errors and the faults in the arguments. And then let everyone make their own choices. Just because protesting is legal, using it to silence women's voices in this way does not make it 'democratic' as such. It just means it is not illegal.

And sometimes it is the posters who will try to shame others posting here with name calling and other tactics who declare themselves the most tolerant in society, are actually the most intolerant of all.

Because all they have is emotional manipulation.

All they have is the name calling and pointing that glorious finger of shame.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 16:32

HandScreen · 18/01/2023 15:49

Yes

For anyone lurking, take a long look at this and see what kind of person is trying to advise your kids.

You have to pretend to believe people can change sex or your transphobic.

You can't tell your child they're perfect as they are or you're transphobic.

At this point, everything is transphobic and you'll never get it right without complete capitulation to the mob.

Keep an eye on who your kids are taking to, it could be a person like this that will try and turn them against you. The sort that would whisper in their ear that if your parents don't go along with what you want, they are a hateful bigot.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 16:30

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 18/01/2023 16:23

YABVU for posting here and not in the GC section and extra U for your wildly biased YABU = rainbows are magic. You blatantly don't think you are being U, you don't want to discuss or engage, you are not going to listen to anyone who disagrees with you, you just want to pontificate and those are always the most boring of AIBU posts.

Make some points then?
Why do you think it's ok to socially transition kids at school.
I'll listen.
But I will reply and it may not agree with you.
For a start you think this post should be hidden away. Why is that?

OP posts:
RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 16:28

In the recent census, there were equal numbers of trans men and trans women, which seems at odds with your assertation that 'adult transitioners are mostly male'.

In the recent census it didn’t show the age distribution. There are far more older male transitioners than female

IcakethereforeIam · 18/01/2023 16:28

Attractive as they are, rainbows aren't magic.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 16:26

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 18/01/2023 16:23

YABVU for posting here and not in the GC section and extra U for your wildly biased YABU = rainbows are magic. You blatantly don't think you are being U, you don't want to discuss or engage, you are not going to listen to anyone who disagrees with you, you just want to pontificate and those are always the most boring of AIBU posts.

Who held a gun to your head and made you read it?

What are your thoughts on schools socially transitioning children and keeping it a secret from their parents?
Or did you just come here to whine about people finding out about this sort of stuff when it manages to escape from the naughty corner?

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 16:26

YABVU for posting here and not in the GC section

Why do you want to hide posts about child safeguarding in dark corners where minimal people will see them? 🤔

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 16:26

HandScreen · 18/01/2023 16:00

The right to self-identify. I have no problem with trans people in sports or single-sex spaces.

Out of interest, do you understand the argument is not 'banning' trans people from sport? Do you understand that no trans person is 'banned' from playing sport unless they are taking performance enhancing drugs? Which is testosterone for females, of course.

If you are fully supportive of males playing in the category based on sex that is what the female sports categories are, what other categories in sport are you happy for people to be able access when they are not eligible?

Age? Are you happy for a 25 year old to compete against under 12 year olds? What about that 25 year old competing against an 85 year old in the masters category? Happy with that?

Ability? Are you happy for someone who has no disability to compete in a category set up for a specific group with specific needs? Such as someone with full vision to compete in a group for visually impaired people? Happy with that?

What about for a person who is a professional in that sport to compete in the novice category for that sport? Happy with that?

What about a person who is not from a country or region to take the place of a person from that country or region? Happy with that?

What about allowing a cyclist with an electric engine to compete in the Tour de France? Happy with that?

What other categories do you want to get rid of ?

Because it is getting rid of the category set up for females to allow any male person to compete in that category. Just because that male is 'weakened' in some way doesn't mean they should be eligible to compete in a category that was set up to protect the competitive needs of females.

Should all weakened males get to compete in the female category?

Or is this just because some people have taken a special label for themselves. And because some sports have been referred to in the past as 'women's' categories rather than the 'female' category.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 16:24

"The right to self-identify. I have no problem with trans people in sports or single-sex spaces."

Nice for you.

You don't get to decide whether my teen daughter has to share bathrooms with 50 year old men with a sexual fetish for wearing women's clothing.

There's a word for people who think this is ok.

OP posts:
sunshineandstrawberryjam · 18/01/2023 16:23

YABVU for posting here and not in the GC section and extra U for your wildly biased YABU = rainbows are magic. You blatantly don't think you are being U, you don't want to discuss or engage, you are not going to listen to anyone who disagrees with you, you just want to pontificate and those are always the most boring of AIBU posts.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 16:21

@HandScreen keep swearing at the big girls talking. 😂😂😂😂

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 16:19

@HandScreen

"The right to self-identify. I have no problem with trans people in sports or single-sex spaces."

Trans people can do whatever sports they want to do. No one is making them stay at home.

Single sex spaces - now are you sure you want to open this particular changing room door? Because once we start posting examples of men who are appropriating gender identities in order to prey on the bodies of women and children it gets really inconvenient, really fast.

OP posts:
DoggyDwelling · 18/01/2023 16:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

StephanieSuperpowers · 18/01/2023 16:19

Murdoch1949 · 18/01/2023 16:17

For under 18s the school should inform the parents/guardians what has been requested. Fine to go along with choice, but parents are the legal guardians and need to know. They're told of a playground cut or bruise, but not this?

Yes, it's curiously the most important thing in the world, so important that it is necessary to act immediately and also so trivial that it merits less consultation with home than a misplaced copy.

IcakethereforeIam · 18/01/2023 16:18

I think the people so quick to level accusations of bigotry, really need to think about the meaning of that word and then think about who the bigots actually are.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?