Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 09:38

Aethelthryth · 18/01/2023 09:34

YANBU. Affirming mental illness is not going to end well, as the Cass report has pointed out. It is the opposite of hatred to want to protect children from this. There is no such thing as "being born in the wrong body" and the co-morbidity with other mental conditions should give serious pause for thought

Being trans isn't a mental illness though.

littlelid · 18/01/2023 09:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Is there a section for trans hate?!

MMAMPWGHAP · 18/01/2023 09:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Would it be OK if we restrict discussions on racism to the Black Mumsnetters board?

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 09:37

Given that about 0.5% of the population are trans, it should not surprise us if about 0.5% of children will grow up to be trans.

How many of that 0.5% will figure it out while they are children, and tell people, versus how many will either not figure it out until they are older, or keep it to themselves out of fear and shame etc, is another matter - but it makes sense that as trans issues become more discussed and visible, more kids may come out as trans.

This is really not all that different to kids realising they are gay. If, say, 5% of adults are gay, then it follows that about 5% of kids will grow up to be gay. Some will realise at an early age and some will not. Of those who do realise, some will come out early and some will not.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/01/2023 09:36

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 09:35

This

Stop talking women, it makes it very hard to pretend that everyone is on board with this.

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 09:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This

Aethelthryth · 18/01/2023 09:34

YANBU. Affirming mental illness is not going to end well, as the Cass report has pointed out. It is the opposite of hatred to want to protect children from this. There is no such thing as "being born in the wrong body" and the co-morbidity with other mental conditions should give serious pause for thought

PoIIyPandemonium · 18/01/2023 09:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 18/01/2023 09:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 09:32

BaileySharp · 18/01/2023 09:23

I don't agree with keeping it a secret from parents, but at the same time I can see the concern if they think some parents would be abusive over it. Surely most wouldn't be though? The problem is with trans issues anything but affirmation can be seen as abusive which I disagree with. If school thought DD was trans I would want to know and would disagree. I wouldn't be unkind but I would explore her feelings and explain the limitations of "changing sex" and encourage her to understand being female doesn't mean conforming to female stereotypes

This is a good point but if the school genuinely thought that the parents were abusive there are specific safeguarding processes they have to undertake.

Facilitating a child keeping secrets from their parents is against all safeguarding rules and undermines the parent/child relationship in an unacceptable way.

If they suspected the child was anorexic or self harming they would have to involve the parents as standard as they have a legal parental responsibility for the welfare if their child. Why is this different?

Patineur · 18/01/2023 09:31

That's a very typical Mail article - lots of allegations designed to get their readers frothing at the mouth, zero attempt to get or quote the schools' viewpoint in any of the cases concerned, and of course they are taking advantage of the fact that the schools are hamstrung in what they can say about pupils' personal information anyway. YABU to take the report at face value.

MarshaBradyo · 18/01/2023 09:31

Yanbu

Imicola · 18/01/2023 09:30

YADNBU - there is no such thing as the wrong body, just the body you are born with. You may like it, or not, it makes no odds to whether it is the right or wrong body - it is just your body.

Normalising extreme medical routes is totally bonkers. Our bodies have evolved to be the way they are, for a reason.

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 09:30

Worth reading this thread to understand where social transitioning has the potential to lead.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4721731-complications-from-trans-surgery?page=21&reply=123180505

Lolapusht · 18/01/2023 09:29

Yeah OP, go skulk over there in the putrid Feminist corner and stop speaking and having opinions. How very dare you!!!!

YADNBU.

Children cannot be trans. They can be convinced they’ve been born in the wrong body and that by becoming the opposite sex all their problems will be solved. As they will never obtain the thing they’ve pinned all their hopes on (ie changing sex), they are being set up to fail and have their fragile self-worth shattered.

But…transphobia…bigot…hateful.

LightHousePanda · 18/01/2023 09:26

I think it's worrying that teachers are making decisions like this and keeping it from the parents. How are they qualified? I remember reading about a teacher who noticed a boy was always avoiding going to the toilet when other boys were there and using the single toilet. She thought he was trans and started showing him videos about being trans etc. Turns out he just wanted privacy as he had a medical issue like irritable bowel. There are so many unqualified people interfering in children's lives - perhaps with good intentions but that can still mess a child up.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 09:25

onyttig · 18/01/2023 09:08

Are people happy for schools to decide that their vegetarian children should eat meat? And to lie to the parents about it. To collude with the child against their family?

Because that would actually be a far less worrying form off school overreach. But they’d be condemned on MN.

Yet transitioning your child seems to be totally fine for some people.

That’s a really good analogy. Or a school persuading a child to ignore their religious beliefs or cultural background.

The fact that schools are prepared to override parental wishes and recommendations from an actual qualified psychiatrist is horrifying.

Would anyone be happy for their school to diagnose their child with any other chronic psychiatric condition and hide it from the parents?

This is in addition to the obvious safeguarding issues of these schools also allowing young teenagers to use the opposite sex changing rooms and even sleeping arrangements on a school trip.

There was an article a while ago about a young girl who identified as trans being allowed to sleep in the boys dorm on a trip and was raped. We keep make and female teenagers apart at certain times for a very good reason. That reason hasn’t changed.

Toomanywaterwipes · 18/01/2023 09:25

FatGirlSwim · 18/01/2023 09:13

Would you want schools to contact homophobic parents to inform them that their child is gay? Doctors to inform parents that a teenage girl is using contraception? To inform religious parents that a teenager is breaking their religious rules? Potentially putting that child at risk?

It's not the same sort of thing at all. Your analogiy doesn't hold up.

The OP's complaint isn't about schools not telling parents that their child is trans, but that they are actively involved in the social transition of minors (by using names and pronouns of a different sex). This is not a neutral act the Cass report has told us.

BaileySharp · 18/01/2023 09:23

I don't agree with keeping it a secret from parents, but at the same time I can see the concern if they think some parents would be abusive over it. Surely most wouldn't be though? The problem is with trans issues anything but affirmation can be seen as abusive which I disagree with. If school thought DD was trans I would want to know and would disagree. I wouldn't be unkind but I would explore her feelings and explain the limitations of "changing sex" and encourage her to understand being female doesn't mean conforming to female stereotypes

NoWrecksToday · 18/01/2023 09:22

A diversity and inclusion policy for schools should cover the protected characteristics as they apply to children.

Cementing gender stereotypes by socially transitioning children that don’t ‘fit in’ for any reason, falls well outside D&I imho. Huge overreach by the school.

PoIIyPandemonium · 18/01/2023 09:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WarmWinterSun · 18/01/2023 09:21

YANBU

whereaw · 18/01/2023 09:19

YANBU
Sex doesn't define us (what we like, how we act, what we wear).

But it is a biological fact. Sex is more than body parts or hormones.

Denying reality doesn't make it any less real.

Sex and gender are not the same thing!

Gay people have fought for years to erode the distinctions of gender, to be who you want and love who you want.
And now we have built them all back up again.

In the name of what?

Honest question. Are gender neutral people anti trans?

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 09:18

FatGirlSwim · 18/01/2023 09:13

Would you want schools to contact homophobic parents to inform them that their child is gay? Doctors to inform parents that a teenage girl is using contraception? To inform religious parents that a teenager is breaking their religious rules? Potentially putting that child at risk?

Would you want the school to hide that a child is self harming or that a child is anorexic?

OP posts:
NettleTea · 18/01/2023 09:17

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 09:13

Bear in mind that I'm some parts of the world (some states in AUS, possibly US and Canada), if a parent questions their child's desire to transition, social services can remove the child from their care.

Do we want to get to that point?

Again, whose interests are being served?

this is what is being proposed in Scotland.