Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
LemonBounce · 18/01/2023 10:53

I've read the article in detail and the substance of it does not match your alarmist claims:

  • the school is simply respecting the young person's choice it's not the school transitioning young people off their own bat
-one person at CAHMS said there was some young people with autism who were also trans there is no reference to evidence showing any link, this is anecdotal. This is the daily mail somehow if there was any evidence of a real link I think they would have splashed that on the front page! There is clearly not

It's the kind of attitudes expressed here on this board which presumably the school is trying to guard against - is it the schools role to force young people to come out to their parents - who may hold anti trans views, that could put their child at risk?
A young person comes out as trans to their parents and is told it's 'self-harm' or 'a safeguarding issue' just to be themselves?
There is a much higher rate of depression, anxiety and mental health issues for trans young people - they have a right to their identity, equal treatment and an end to discrimination. When is discrimination more damaging than from your own parents?

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 10:52

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 09:48

It's almost like you don't understand social contagion amongst young people.

It's almost like that is an entirely made up concept popularised by homophobes over many decades who imagined that gay people coming out at younger ages must be because of 'contagion' and now co-opted, as with so many other arguments, by transphobes.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 10:50

Being trans isn't a mental illness though.

So what is 'being trans'? Please explain? Is it not conforming to stereotypes, or is it something else? I think given the impact on children, especially vulnerable ones, it is very important to at least understand terms.

InstaJam · 18/01/2023 10:50

It says a lot about our attitude towards mental illness that we would prefer to chop bits off our children's bodies and give them hormones that stop them having orgasms in future and stop them having children, rather than at least question whether their symptoms are related to some kind of mental illness

NoWrecksToday · 18/01/2023 10:48

For all those who are saying changing pronouns and names etc is just being kind. You should know that unfortunately it is the case that homophobic families can push a child who is gay (same sex attracted) into ‘transitioning’ as this is seen as a more acceptable option. The whistleblowers at the Tavistock reported numerous cases of this.

Sadly there are other reasons for some families and carers to want the child to stay childlike and move to blockers. I won’t go in to detail here but again, well reported in relation to Tavistock.

The precise reason we (should) have watertight safeguards that apply equally to all children. No exceptions. Shouting transphobia cuts no ice with me I’m afraid.

Meaningofthesea · 18/01/2023 10:44

FOJN · 18/01/2023 10:40

Re:Cass review. she also states that 'doing nothing' is also not a neutral action. Point 5.20 (see image)

Watchful waiting is supportive, it's not "doing nothing" and usually results in the resolution of gender distress/confusion. Many of the children who experience gender dysphoria grow up to be same sex attracted adults. We shouldn't be in such a rush to "trans the gay away", it's just a different form of conversion therapy.

What is the difference between watchful waiting and doing nothing?

TicketBoo23 · 18/01/2023 10:41

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 09:02

Hide the issues.
I get it.

Maybe you should get off MN totally - like the women who highlighted the safe guarding issues with Stone Wall & Mermaids..... And have been proven to be completely correct.

Toomanywaterwipes · 18/01/2023 10:40

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 10:01

You responded to the shut up woman comment. That didn't copy !

@maddy68
Your accusation of mysogeny upthread does not make sense.

The pp was not telling you to shut up.
She was pointing out that you and the person you quoted were telling other women to shut up, to be quiet, to keep their concerns tucked away where few would hear them.
HTH

FOJN · 18/01/2023 10:40

Re:Cass review. she also states that 'doing nothing' is also not a neutral action. Point 5.20 (see image)

Watchful waiting is supportive, it's not "doing nothing" and usually results in the resolution of gender distress/confusion. Many of the children who experience gender dysphoria grow up to be same sex attracted adults. We shouldn't be in such a rush to "trans the gay away", it's just a different form of conversion therapy.

InstaJam · 18/01/2023 10:38

FatGirlSwim · 18/01/2023 09:13

Would you want schools to contact homophobic parents to inform them that their child is gay? Doctors to inform parents that a teenage girl is using contraception? To inform religious parents that a teenager is breaking their religious rules? Potentially putting that child at risk?

Potentially that child could be saying they are trans precisely because their parents are homophobic and changing their gender seems an easier way out than accepting that they are gay. So simply because they are gay you want to be complicit in removing their body parts and subjecting them to a life of dependency on drugs amd medical procedures. I think that's a very concerning position for you to be taking.

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 10:38

Re:Cass review. she also states that 'doing nothing' is also not a neutral action. Point 5.20 (see image)

I don't think anyone is advocating doing nothing.

Rather that counselling should be the go to.

Intransigentcat · 18/01/2023 10:32

MaureenSowerbuttsCardi · 18/01/2023 09:53

Sinister. Women know your place!

Exactly! Incredibly sinister. Banish the feminists, those uppity women who campaigned for women to enjoy basic freedoms like the right to vote and so many other issues affecting women. Who abhor the patriarchy and try to better the lot of women daily in the face of this kind of misogynistic hatred.

God forbid women speak.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 10:31

Given that about 0.5% of the population are trans, it should not surprise us if about 0.5% of children will grow up to be trans.

But now far more than 0.5% of kids are doing this. We don't know how they will grow up. And they really are being encouraged to see themselves as T with all that entails. Many of them may end up as LGB adults or gender nonconforming adults or even pretty ordinary and straight. But not before they have done themselves a mischief believing that they are T and that transition will make them feel better.

Nousernamesleftatall · 18/01/2023 10:30

Yanbu. This is crazy.

Meaningofthesea · 18/01/2023 10:30

I'd love to hear these events from the perspectives of the young people (from skimming the article, they are now young adults and continue to identify as trans). I wonder if there were reasons they specifically asked school staff not to share social transition with parents.

Re:Cass review. she also states that 'doing nothing' is also not a neutral action. Point 5.20 (see image)

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?
Jazzy21 · 18/01/2023 10:29

YANBU

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 10:28

Lockheart · 18/01/2023 10:16

I think the words "social transitioning" are doing a lot of heavy lifting here. As far as I can see from the article all the school are doing is using a requested nickname. The child's actual name hasn't been changed.

What do you think social transitioning is?

Name change
Sex on records changed and notes made to not tell parents so that letters home still go out in the "deadname"
Allowed to use opposite-sex toilets and changing facilities (remember this would be for overnight trips too, your daughter is in with the boys overnight, still OK?)
I've read of children being given the opposite sex uniform to use and then changing before leaving for home

Do you not think parents have any right to know about any of these? What on earth gives the right to unqualified teachers to allow any of this without parents' knowledge?

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 10:27

Lockheart · 18/01/2023 10:16

I think the words "social transitioning" are doing a lot of heavy lifting here. As far as I can see from the article all the school are doing is using a requested nickname. The child's actual name hasn't been changed.

Could I suggest you read the full article? They are promoting puberty blockers to autistic 14 yr olds, going against psychiatric advice and threatening parents with social services, referring to girls as ‘he’ (and therefore encouraging all other students to do so) and changing students registered names (which I think is against the rules).

The first girl referred to, Esme, has her name and pronouns changed so the whole school uses them. She is now indicating that she wants to revert to her old name and being a girl but it is now very hard and embarrassing to go back which is hampering her.

I know a girl who did this, although with parental knowledge. She changed her name on the register and issued new pronouns to much fanfare. A year later she now is embarrassed about 13 yr old her’s decisions and wants to forget the whole thing, except that the school are not so willing to alter the register again so she is reminded of her teenage decision every day. That is not helping.

InstaJam · 18/01/2023 10:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

There are 2 issues here, which you seem to be confusing.

  1. Should people who are trans be treated with respect and given appropriate treatment? (I think most people would argue yes)
  1. Should children who have symptoms of being trans but actually these symptoms are the result of some other cause, be incorrectly treated and given life altering and irreversible surgery or hormones?
(I think most people would argue no)

The question is how do you know whether the 1000 per cent increase in girls saying they are boys are actually trans or not? That is a massive increase, and the question at least needs to be asked if these girls are actually trans or not. That answer may be yes, but any responsible adult involved with the child should be open to the answer being "no, there are other reasons why they are presenting with these symptoms".

If your child presents at the hospital with symptoms of a broken leg, they will xray your child to find out if they actually do have a broken leg and decide how best to treat it. They don't just pop any old sore leg into a plaster cast without proper investigation. And they will always tell the parents what they are doing because the parents need to be there to support their child.

Just as a general rule, anyone who is encouraging a child to keep secrets from their parents has to be viewed with suspicion, even if that suspicion is later allayed.

Spambod · 18/01/2023 10:18

I believe that specific department of education guidance for schools prohibits them from telling children that they are in the wrong body.
it came out a couple of years ago I think and at the time I was shocked that this guidance had to be given to schools in the first place.
I don’t like the way trans ideology targets children via schools. It is clearly a child safeguarding issue to dismantle children barriers and the adult gatekeepers around them.

FOJN · 18/01/2023 10:17

I take the quotes from Transgender Trend pretty seriously

Absolutely, Transgender Trend are a very credible organisation made up of knowledgeable and well educated parents who put child welfare at the center of everything they do.

Lockheart · 18/01/2023 10:16

I think the words "social transitioning" are doing a lot of heavy lifting here. As far as I can see from the article all the school are doing is using a requested nickname. The child's actual name hasn't been changed.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 10:14

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 10:02

Anyone who thinks a daily mail article is factual is bonkers.

Maybe you could actually read the article and consider testimonies from parents like this:

But when a nurse at school had a chat with Harry about puberty, he came skipping home through the door with paperwork about how to register for puberty blockers. I was shocked. He was only 14.

Please ask yourself why it is appropriate for the school to give this child information that bypasses any psychological evaluation or actual diagnosis of gender dysphoria and jumps straight to medication as a solution for his distress?

Most children experiencing distress with puberty or their identity will settle down once the huge brain development that occurs has kicked in. Encouraging a child to jump straight to a self diagnosis of trans and need for heavy lifelong medication is extremely harmful.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 10:12

I take the quotes from Transgender Trend pretty seriously, they are a grassroots support group for parents and these are parents who have been through the mill. And the article is consistent with what I've seen described as good practice by schools in Scotland.

Yes the DM love this stuff. Doesn't mean it's not true, sadly.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 10:09

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 10:02

Anyone who thinks a daily mail article is factual is bonkers.

I'm pretty sure at least one of the mothers in the article already posts about this on the feminism board. If not, the story is almost exactly the same.

Just because something is reported in the DM doesn't mean that it's not true and it's lazy to imply it is.

If you're all on board with everything trans-related, why can't it be talked about on the main boards here, rather than hidden away? What is there to hide?